Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Partner spending Christmas with ex-wife/kids/friends.

211 replies

melissajreyes · 23/12/2024 02:10

My partner is spending Christmas with his ex-wife and kids. Kids are 17 and 13. They divorced in 2020. Every Christmas is spent together. I don't have kids. His argument is that Christmas together is for the kids and that's fine.

Last night, he told me his longtime friends invited him to bring his kids over to their place on Christmas Day - this would be post family time/post opening gifts etc... He said he would like to take his kids over to their (the friends) place. These are family friends, to be clear. So their kids would get to spend time with his kids etc... I don't know why, but I thought it would be just him taking his kids over - because of the way he phrased it.

Today, while we were talking he tells me he has to text his ex-wife and tell her that 'we are invited to A and B's house for Christmas Day'.

By 'we' he meant he and his ex-wife, that is.

I'm not invited to this, so basically it'd be two sets of families hanging out together. I've decided to spend Christmas Day with my parents - and then friends in the evening as a result.

AIBU to think this isn't normal? I've put up with a lot that isn't 'normal' since he has kids and I don't, but at some point, it's a piss-take.

He's admitted that his situation isn't 'normal' but that it is all in the name of his kids - and that's fine to a degree - but I don't see anything ever changing.

OP posts:
loveawineloveacrisp · 23/12/2024 08:45

KeeKees · 23/12/2024 02:55

I think you're getting some shitty replies here. I dont think many people would be happy with what he's doing here. It's not about the kids at all, it's the relationship he still has with the ex. Fucking your plans off because he got a better offer? That's shite. If the co-parenting relationship was so healthy why can't you be part of the plans and part of the invite too?

Agree with this. From someone who married a man with kids, he has never cancelled his Christmas plans with me to spend it with the ex. He'd be a goner if he had.

ChristmasFluff · 23/12/2024 08:44

He isn't free to have a relationship because he's still tangled up with his (ex) wife.

I've said it before, and I'll say it again, when people are truly amicable, they don't confuse the children by playing happy families. Or rather, when they do, new partners are there too (I am amicable with my ex-husband).

It's never really 'for the children'. It's because at least one of them is hoping for reconciliation, and the other partner is either there reluctantly (having fallen for the lie), or is a player who wants to keep alive the hopes of their ex.

But whatever, he has amply demonstrated he has no room for you in his life in any meaningful way. His willingness to be aorund his ex and his lack of care for your plans would suggest to me that he is a player, and is now messing with your head.

Centralperky · 23/12/2024 08:35

OP I could have written this post myself 10 years ago, but the kids were 17 & 23!

I found it really hard, I was much younger than him and had no kids of my own. It became clear that we would never be a family in the sense that I understood family to be, and we ultimately broke up. He had his family, and I wasn’t part of it.

Coconutter24 · 23/12/2024 08:28

melissajreyes · 23/12/2024 02:37

I don't mind him spending time with his children - obviously. He acknowledges how 'unfair' it is to me sometimes.

But we had plans, that he cancelled on - yes, on Christmas evening. We've been together 3 years. It's not really one day in the year as they spend Thanksgiving, Easter, every (Euro Summer) vacation together as well as skiing etc... If that makes me petty and jealous, ok. But yes, perhaps we aren't compatible.

I wouldn’t be with him tbh. He's maintaining a life with his ex wife and I know people will say it’s for the kids but the kids are 13 and 17 and plenty old enough to understand that their parents are divorced and live separate lives. He could still take them on holidays etc just him and the kids so he gets time with them. Of course there’s no reason they can’t be friends given they’re prepared to spend all this time together but it’s cross I g boundaries I couldn’t deal with, that’s not their problem if their happy with the set up it’s mine so for that reason I’d have to walk away

MonaLisaDoesntSmile · 23/12/2024 08:17

Inmydreams88 · 23/12/2024 07:34

He has kids. He is putting those kids first at Christmas. Divorce doesn't have to be fighting, name calling and not speaking to each other. They seem civil, they are both putting their childrens needs first. Good on them.

But they also travel together and go out together, as OP sits on her own. Good for them, not so good for her. tyhey could be civil but also he could spend time with his actual partner rather than changing plans last minute to spend more time with his wife (who do not seem to be an ex after all)

MonaLisaDoesntSmile · 23/12/2024 08:15

ForFunAmberDeer · 23/12/2024 02:46

You 'don't mind' him spending time with his children on Christmas day???

You aren't compatible. You need a man with no children or adult children. You don't seem to have any relationship with his children, who are clearly very important to him. Which is odd 3 years in. Essentially for you to get what you need he has to disappoint his children and rightly he isn't going to do that. I would move on tbh.

This is such a crappy response and quoting out of context, nitpicking.

OP has nothing against partner spending time with kids. But that also means she is left on her own and this is also not pleasant.

OP sorry nit read the whole thread, but I think I would leave. Your DP is a bit shitty to you saying 'oh it must be hard' but then he is clealry still with his (ex?) wife and this may not change for many years to come, in which you will be always the third wheel and he will never commit. He has his cake and eats it having his family and then oyu on the side when he is nto with them, and his 'sorry' does not change it for you.

Honeycrisp · 23/12/2024 08:12

OrigamiOwls · 23/12/2024 08:08

Of course his kids should be the top priority. But he's shown you where you are on the pecking order - below the kids (fine), below the ex-wife and below his friend (less fine).

I would be starting to consider whether this relationship is for you, as you have very different priorities. He wants to play happy families with the ex, but also keep you hanging for when it's convenient for him. Are you willing to settle for the scraps he's offering you?

Three years is enough time to get the lay of the land in the relationship. He's getting his cake and eating it too. Just depends if you are happy with that?

Agree. It's fine for him to have a priority list, it's also fine for OP as one of the lower ranked not to be up for that. Sometimes people are just incompatible.

SoInLuv · 23/12/2024 08:10

notbythehaironmychinnychin · 23/12/2024 07:09

'It's for the kids' is a line that is always trotted out to stop partners from challenging inappropriate boundaries between ex partners. They're either together or they aren't. If they were so bothered about everything being 'for the kids' they would have stayed together in the first place and not disrupted their children by putting them through a divorce. But they did. Shit happens, life goes on. He can't have it both ways. I actually disagree that spending Christmas Day and holidays with divorced mum and dad is healthy for children as it sends so many mixed messages, I would have hated this and felt so confused. He is treating you like some shameful side piece and I would leave the relationship.

I agree 💯

OrigamiOwls · 23/12/2024 08:08

Of course his kids should be the top priority. But he's shown you where you are on the pecking order - below the kids (fine), below the ex-wife and below his friend (less fine).

I would be starting to consider whether this relationship is for you, as you have very different priorities. He wants to play happy families with the ex, but also keep you hanging for when it's convenient for him. Are you willing to settle for the scraps he's offering you?

Three years is enough time to get the lay of the land in the relationship. He's getting his cake and eating it too. Just depends if you are happy with that?

VaddaABeetch · 23/12/2024 08:08

ThatKhakiMoose · 23/12/2024 05:51

Sometimes I really feel that divorced dads and single women mix like oil and water, especially if she wants her own family as well.

Not sure how old you are, OP, or if you want your own husband and kids, but if you do, and you're still relatively young, I would find a fresh one. Much nicer to start your own marriage and family with someone who doesn't have an ex-wife and kids with another woman. There are always going to be divided loyalties, and all the firsts for you, like marriage, pregnancy, newborn etc are all things he's already done with someone else. Nah. Get a nice new one for yourself.

My thoughts too. If he has a 17 year old I’m guessing he’s mid 40s ? If you’re 8 years younger you’re late 30s?

Do you want your own kids? If so I’d get rid of this one. He’s getting the girlfriend experience with you but one he can pick up or leave down as he feels like it.

Freeasabird76 · 23/12/2024 08:03

I can understand the upset about night plans changing and that's unfair but until 13 yr old is 18 I'd assume christmas day will not be spent together.

12purplepencils · 23/12/2024 08:02

I too think it’s nice they’re spending Christmas Day together.

But it would have been nice for him to see you too in the evening and can see why you’d be hurt that he’s cancelled that.

Whatsitreallylike · 23/12/2024 08:01

Are you invited to the friends house after? It sounds very civilised, everyone getting along for everyone’s sake… so why aren’t you going?

Olliequick · 23/12/2024 08:00

A lot saying it’s great he wants to spend Christmas time with the kids, but it’s not that it’s a full day of married life. Then add in the holidays, no thanks not for me.

I would have to end this one and wonder how you coped for so long.

rstare786 · 23/12/2024 08:00

I also disagree with children always come first. You are the children's role model for their future relationship. A relationship is of equal importance.

twentysevendresses · 23/12/2024 07:58

OCDmama · 23/12/2024 07:50

3 years is barely anything. Christmas is for his children.

Are you serious? 🧐🤦‍♀️ 3 years is a very significant investment in a relationship! And yes, Christmas is for the kids...it's NOT, however, for the ex and their 'ex couple' friends!

twentysevendresses · 23/12/2024 07:56

Wow, there are some weird replies on this thread! I'd love to see how some of the posters would actually react if they were in your position OP!

Prioritising children...absolutely 💯

Prioritising your ex wife and your 'couples friends' from you ex relationship!?!? No way!

Your DP is being very manipulative OP, telling you how he 'understands' how difficult it all must be for you, and then continuing to make it difficult! This is shit behaviour, and he's trying to make it so that YOU will be the 'unreasonable' one if you complain, as he's been 'oh so nice and understanding' by saying that he 'understands'. Really, really manipulative!

You are so far down on his priority list you've fallen off it!

I'd bet money he's still sleeping with his ex on those many holidays they take 'as a family' and one (or both) of them are holding out for a reconciliation.

Raise your bar and dump his arse! He doesn't respect you at all.

LadyChilli · 23/12/2024 07:54

KeeKees · 23/12/2024 02:55

I think you're getting some shitty replies here. I dont think many people would be happy with what he's doing here. It's not about the kids at all, it's the relationship he still has with the ex. Fucking your plans off because he got a better offer? That's shite. If the co-parenting relationship was so healthy why can't you be part of the plans and part of the invite too?

It took a while for some common sense to arrive here! Of course his kids come first and of course it's great that he maintains a civil relationship with his ex for the sake of the kids. This doesn't make it ok for him to make plans with OP and then cancel them in favour of more time with the ex and kids (previously it wasn't either or, he was seeing the kids too). Leaving someone at a loose end at relatively short notice at Christmas is not fair.

rstare786 · 23/12/2024 07:53

I disagree. 3 years is a significant amount of time for a relationship. Has he even asked his children if that's what they want. I know my children would find it awkward.

OCDmama · 23/12/2024 07:50

3 years is barely anything. Christmas is for his children.

MeridianB · 23/12/2024 07:42

One person’s ’unusual’ is another person’s ’unnecessary’.

Either way, his actions put you at the bottom of a big pecking order after (understandably) his two children, then ex, then the friends. Three years in I’d expect an invitation to the friends or at least for him to want to spend some time with you, perhaps the evening.

It would be interesting to understand how many years he plans to do this for.

rstare786 · 23/12/2024 07:38

The children are 17 and 13 so not young. He's not doing it for the children. They might think they're doing it for the children but they're giving them mixed messages of what a relationship is and blurred boundaries. Would he like his children's future partner to leave them at Christmas to spend it with the ex. This doing it for the children is rubbish.

AmberAlert86 · 23/12/2024 07:36

Have you posted before? Only asking as I remember reading a post and situation was identical.
It's great that he spends plenty of time with his kids, but why can't you be included more? I'm not sure it's healthy to spend every single holiday with his ex and kids. Why is it not him and kids, and some trips with you included? Have you had a holiday with him and his kids ever?
It's totally reasonable to finish the relationship with this man if that's what you want. Don't want to upset you but ulyou seem quite low in his priority list. I don't think anything will change anytime soon. Don't waste your time.

Spirallingdownwards · 23/12/2024 07:34

ForFunAmberDeer · 23/12/2024 02:33

I think I would feel pretty bad about taking a father away from his children on Christmas day. If I were a parent and my pretty recent partner, presumably less than 4 years, was unhappy about it I would really be questioning our compatibility. It's one day in the year. I have to say I think you are being petty and sound jealous. Maybe don't date a man with children because the children shd always come first

@melissajreyes you do not sound petty nor jealous.

"normal" is for parents to have kids alternate Christmases once divorced but obviously not every split family has to choose to do what the majority do if it suits them.

If their "normal" has been them for the day and you for the evening then I would sat rhat you are disappointed that he has changed the plans you had together but maybe arrange something special for Boxing Day instead.

I would set out your expectations going forward and maybe even have the discussion that if next year you are still around the split has been long enough and the kids well used to the situation for Christmases to alternate or split days between their divorced parents as is more common in such situations.

Inmydreams88 · 23/12/2024 07:34

He has kids. He is putting those kids first at Christmas. Divorce doesn't have to be fighting, name calling and not speaking to each other. They seem civil, they are both putting their childrens needs first. Good on them.