Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this gift giving situation unusual or am I a total Scrooge?

36 replies

helptodecide · 19/12/2024 23:25

Perfectly willing to be told that I’m being unreasonable here. Genuinely unsure what the situation is in most large families.

DP is part of a large family and as a result we have multiple nieces and nephews (6 total). Me and DP are the only ones out of all his siblings who don’t have any kids, everyone else has at least 1. At Christmas we buy individual presents for all of our nieces and nephews, and this totals around £150, often a bit more. Everyone else in the family has their own children, so as well as buying gifts for everyone else’s kids they’re all getting presents for their child in return. A big present exchange is done every year on Christmas Morning, and we obviously don’t get anything from anyone as we don’t have children. For context the kids are all between 0 and 4.

Now I know you don’t give to receive, and obviously I don’t expect the kids to get me anything, which makes me think I’m being entirely unreasonable here. However it is a lot of money each year now there are so many of them! Would I be unreasonable to say look there are too many of them now for them all to get a present each, and maybe rejoin the huge gift giving exchange if/when we have our own?

Kind of theoretical as I know in reality we will probably keep buying them all presents come what may, just interested re what other people do in this situation?

OP posts:
JingleB · 19/12/2024 23:42

First of all, 6 isn’t that many nieces and nephews really.

Secondly, yes, total and complete Scrooge to think you shouldn’t have to buy for them because you chose not to have children (yet).

It’s not a game of tit for tat.

I’m sure someone in your life, when you were a child, bought gifts for you without reciprocity.Now you’re paying it forward.

A budget of £15 is £90 for all of them. You can get plenty of decent gifts for children in the £15 range.

twentysevendresses · 19/12/2024 23:41

You DEFINITELY don't need to spend £25 per niece/nephew!! That's excessive! Cut it down to a book and a selection box each, and that will more than halve what you're spending. Or just stop altogether 🤷‍♀️

Amanitacae · 19/12/2024 23:37

Also, the kids will notice if you stop giving them Christmas presents. How would you explain to them that it’s all transactional?

AhBiscuits · 19/12/2024 23:36

Yeah that's pretty scroogy I'm afraid.

ueberlin2030 · 19/12/2024 23:36

I would set a £5 limit, and agree with the suggestion of a book (fact, fiction, puzzles, stickers etc). Lots of places have cheap books and you can even get pretty much new condition books second hand. It's also a bit off that none of them get you at least a token gift.

Amanitacae · 19/12/2024 23:34

Wow that’s a really odd attitude to buying gifts for children.

Absolutely don’t bankrupt yourself (low budget or homemade treats would be fine). However telling the family ‘we’re not giving these children presents until we can be sure we’re getting a reasonable return’ isn’t really in the spirit.

TwoBlueFish · 19/12/2024 23:34

Why not just reduce your budget, my budget this year for nieces and nephews is around £10-15. As they’re all still little you should easily be able to lower the budget.

i buy for my siblings until they have kids and then just the kids get something.

biscuitsandbooks · 19/12/2024 23:33

Why are you spending so much money?

TMGM · 19/12/2024 23:32

Maybe a sort of secret Santa thing could be a solution? That’s what we did for ours, set a price limit everyone is comfortable with and stick to it. There are even websites now that you can use to organise it.

ArcheryAnnie · 19/12/2024 23:30

You could buy them each a book for a tenner, would more than halve the overall cost, plus you become Christmas Book Aunt, which is a win/win. Kids of that age will already have a ton of toys.

NewName24 · 19/12/2024 23:29

Yes, I think that would be unusual, to say the least.

I bought for nieces and nephews before I had my dc. I bought them things because I loved them, and I wanted to.

I mean, in our family, we don't spend £25 per child, but that's going to depend on budget.

I think it would be reasonable to suggest a smaller budget, but I think IWBU to say you aren't getting them anything because you currently don't have dc (especially if it is on the cards - as you imply - there will be a time in the future where you hope to have dc).

Swipe left for the next trending thread