Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is husband expecting too much 4 months PP or AIBU

264 replies

LaurenOX · 19/12/2024 10:59

Gave birth to our second son 4 weeks ago via c section. First son has just turned 4. Husband is back in work (wfh 1 day a week).

Last night husband took off on me for the house being “untidy”. To give context, husband hates clutter and his definition of untidy is things being left around the house (shoes by the door, parcels being left on the island, a chopping board in the sink and eldest son’s toys left out). Despite the clutter, the bathrooms had been cleaned and the floors hoovered/mopped and a duster had been thrown around. A wash load had been dried and put away with another wash just finished. I explained that the only time I had to do any housework was 2 hours in the afternoon due to taking my son to a play group he attends weekly and having to get the bus due to not being able to drive. Husband still accused me of not doing enough around the house.

I am EBF and son feeds every 2-3 hours all day/night. Of an evening he cluster feeds from about 8 until 12. Husband has been sleeping in with my eldest son who can still wake in the night but certainly not to the extent of our newborn. He may wake 1 or 2 times and will fall straight back asleep after some reassurance. Husband has taken on responsibilities for eldest son, he does bath time of an evening and gets him ready of a morning for pre-school (jobs which I used to do before baby’s arrival) I told my husband I appreciate he is doing more, but I am exhausted I have a baby on my boob constantly and he is being unreasonable to expect any more from me this early on. He suggested that I’m never too exhausted to do any of the fun things (I went the Christmas market with my son and my friend and her son one afternoon this week). We went to bed on an argument and this morning the last thing he said before leaving for work was “have a productive day”.

So question is, is he being an inconsiderate A* AIBU to think he is being wholly unreasonable?

OP posts:
PiperLeo · 19/12/2024 13:29

LaurenOX · 19/12/2024 10:59

Gave birth to our second son 4 weeks ago via c section. First son has just turned 4. Husband is back in work (wfh 1 day a week).

Last night husband took off on me for the house being “untidy”. To give context, husband hates clutter and his definition of untidy is things being left around the house (shoes by the door, parcels being left on the island, a chopping board in the sink and eldest son’s toys left out). Despite the clutter, the bathrooms had been cleaned and the floors hoovered/mopped and a duster had been thrown around. A wash load had been dried and put away with another wash just finished. I explained that the only time I had to do any housework was 2 hours in the afternoon due to taking my son to a play group he attends weekly and having to get the bus due to not being able to drive. Husband still accused me of not doing enough around the house.

I am EBF and son feeds every 2-3 hours all day/night. Of an evening he cluster feeds from about 8 until 12. Husband has been sleeping in with my eldest son who can still wake in the night but certainly not to the extent of our newborn. He may wake 1 or 2 times and will fall straight back asleep after some reassurance. Husband has taken on responsibilities for eldest son, he does bath time of an evening and gets him ready of a morning for pre-school (jobs which I used to do before baby’s arrival) I told my husband I appreciate he is doing more, but I am exhausted I have a baby on my boob constantly and he is being unreasonable to expect any more from me this early on. He suggested that I’m never too exhausted to do any of the fun things (I went the Christmas market with my son and my friend and her son one afternoon this week). We went to bed on an argument and this morning the last thing he said before leaving for work was “have a productive day”.

So question is, is he being an inconsiderate A* AIBU to think he is being wholly unreasonable?

Aren't you supposed to rest for 6-8 weeks after a C-section?

Either way he is being very unreasonable. If my husband tried that shit, he wouldn't be eating from clean plates or have any clean clothes out of spite.

Prick!

LookItsMeAgain · 19/12/2024 13:20

He is being entirely completely and utterly unreasonable.

When you have the strength to deal with this, I'd make it very clear to him that while I might be a housewife, I'm not a servant and at the very least I deserve a level of respect that he clearly isn't able to muster. You will have a long hard think about whether you want your children to grow up in a household where the wife and mother is seen as little more than a baby producing factory and a skivvy and he would do well to remember that!

He probably shouldn't have had kids if what he's looking for in his abode is a clean and tidy house. Kids are messy. They get messier as they get bigger.

He's really insensitive and I don't even remember what I was doing at 4 weeks post partum as I was going around in a haze. You're doing exceptionally well!

MrsSunshine2b · 19/12/2024 13:18

LaurenOX · 19/12/2024 13:11

Thank you for pointing this out, it is something I worry about.

I try and maintain the bond with my first and do feel like I am doing so but I worry my husband isn’t bonding with our second as he did our first.

He had made comments about the baby not liking him or being redundant and I do worry that he is struggling to bond with him as our first was very ill at birth so he spent a lot of time at his bedside in NICU and helped tube feed and then bottle feed him.

As I say, I didn’t do this post to slate him he is amazing and I love him dearly he just has this controlling/obsessive streak over the house (which I think comes from growing up in a house which is cluttered and unkept). Reading the harsh words said about him has been tough but I needed to know I wasn’t being ridiculous to feel annoyed/upset.

I think we are both exhausted and the transition of 1-2 has been hard on us both but possibly more so on him if he is struggling to bond with our newest family member.

He thinks a 4 week old baby "doesn't like him"? Do you not see how it's not acceptable for him to be "amazing" but also "controlling"?

You are in recovery from a serious operation with a tiny baby who is completely reliant on you and are already doing way more than you should be doing post C-section. A loving husband would be protecting you and your recovery, telling you to sit down and rest. He's putting his own selfish obsession with the house above the health and wellbeing of his wife and baby.

I can well understand why you don't want to leave him when you are a few weeks post-partum but I would be letting him read this thread and having a serious talk about how he plans to improve himself and be a better husband in future.

Takeoutyourhen · 19/12/2024 13:17

Congratulations on your new arrival!
What I have noticed with posts which ask for advice on whether they are BU is that the OP gets shocked by the reactions (often rightly warranted) and then get defensive about their partner. Only you know him properly, but the overwhelming consensus is that lots of posters are galled by his attitude which you are too. You say he has issues with clutter, fine, he can help with that but to talk to you like that is really out of order, whether he is a good husband or a good dad.
Plan a chat with him soon.

Fern95 · 19/12/2024 13:17

We have a 5 month old and a 5 year old. My husband has a 70 hour work week until Christmas day. He'd never say anything like that especially at this time of year! A home is supposed to be a cosy and welcoming place, not sterile and spotless.

101Nutella · 19/12/2024 13:13

YANBU
I mean the doctor and HV specifically said no hoovering or mopping at all for 6 weeks post C section due to the movements damaging your back as your stomach muscles haven’t switched on properly. It was even in the leaflet from the hospital.

id focus on your recovery and the fact you’re doing childcare. He can get a cleaner if he’s not happy.

BriannaCranston · 19/12/2024 13:11

As far as I'm concerned the whole point of maternity leave is to look after the baby. That is currently your FT job in the same way that your husband's job is his job. So while he is at his job, you are at your job. Then when he is not at his job you both share the parental and domestic load for your family. You should not be running ragged 24/7 while he gets to work at most 10 hours a day and then takes it easy. Remind him that being on maternity leave does not make you his maid or domestic servant. You are doing your job already, and when he is home you look after the house, the children, and each other together.

Twat.

LaurenOX · 19/12/2024 13:11

Thank you for pointing this out, it is something I worry about.

I try and maintain the bond with my first and do feel like I am doing so but I worry my husband isn’t bonding with our second as he did our first.

He had made comments about the baby not liking him or being redundant and I do worry that he is struggling to bond with him as our first was very ill at birth so he spent a lot of time at his bedside in NICU and helped tube feed and then bottle feed him.

As I say, I didn’t do this post to slate him he is amazing and I love him dearly he just has this controlling/obsessive streak over the house (which I think comes from growing up in a house which is cluttered and unkept). Reading the harsh words said about him has been tough but I needed to know I wasn’t being ridiculous to feel annoyed/upset.

I think we are both exhausted and the transition of 1-2 has been hard on us both but possibly more so on him if he is struggling to bond with our newest family member.

OP posts:
WhatMe123 · 19/12/2024 13:10

Just scrolled down and your actually 4 weeks pp, aagh even worse . Why can't he tidy up 🤯 if men had babies I feel the system would be set up very different.......has he tried having a baby on his boob on and off all day and then tried to clean the house, no so he has no idea if tidying the house is possible or not. Totally out of order

MrsSunshine2b · 19/12/2024 13:08

"Have a productive day", what you mean like sustaining an entire human life that you created from your body? Ask him how many people his body has provided a complete food source for today.

WhatMe123 · 19/12/2024 13:08

Ffs awful awful man. Your doing just fine op 💐

Sleepysleepycoffeecoffee · 19/12/2024 13:07

He sounds like a complete arsehole. Go on strike and don’t do any housework except anything that benefits you and the children, ie yours and their washing, dinner for you and son

Mumlaplomb · 19/12/2024 13:06

Oh OP. I am 5 years post partum and my house is still a shit tip. You’re not his maid. Sounds like you are coping really well and doing too much already. He needs a kick up the arse.

MadinMarch · 19/12/2024 13:05

EuclidianGeometryFan · 19/12/2024 12:54

Slightly off topic:

Don't fall into the trap of him always looking after the eldest while you look after the baby.
He needs to take the baby frequently, so that he can bond with his second child whilst you maintain your relationship with your first.

I wholeheartedly agree with this.
A relative did this and was only bonded to the firstborn child who became the golden child to him. He pretty much ignored the subsequent children throughout their childhoods. It was awful for them and his wife and they eventually divorced- with this being a big factor in it.

AshCrapp · 19/12/2024 13:04

“have a productive day”

He's a total cunt

MrsSunshine2b · 19/12/2024 13:01

He's being massively unreasonable. There's a reason it's called MATERNITY leave, not maid leave.

Your job is feeding your baby, which in the first year is more hours than a full time job, anything else is a bonus.

Next time he says it's untidy, I'd come back with, "Yes, and to be truthful it's quite lazy of you to let it get like this. Please tidy up so I can focus on your child."

MadinMarch · 19/12/2024 13:01

Maray1967 · 19/12/2024 11:24

Don’t get hurt, get angry. If he’s normally a decent bloke, he needs a burst of anger in his direction and a warning. He is totally out of order. And yes, we all know that couldn’t get much done if he was in your position.

This!

Foreigners88 · 19/12/2024 12:59

This is a bad sign. When I was with the baby few months in and trying to do everything, one day I realised I am so underslept that I fell on the floor. The husband came back and I told him what is done and what needs doing.

He tried to moan a bit but I declared it then and there that he start doing what he wants doing or see needs doing. A decade later, I have a properly developped house-husband who is able to do even more than 50% housework than me if the need will arise.

Tough love dear until they get it or leave
Life is short and I before I married ( which was late) already had enough time to have a practice run with another and decide what I DONT WANT from a man and what I want.

Katemax82 · 19/12/2024 12:57

Sorry but he's being an absolute cunt

Deathraystare · 19/12/2024 12:55

"Yes Daring, very productive. Sign these divorce papers".

EuclidianGeometryFan · 19/12/2024 12:54

Slightly off topic:

Don't fall into the trap of him always looking after the eldest while you look after the baby.
He needs to take the baby frequently, so that he can bond with his second child whilst you maintain your relationship with your first.

lovelydayIhave · 19/12/2024 12:52

What an asshole!
Tell him to get real...what an idiot, I'm raging for you op.🌷🌷

MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking · 19/12/2024 12:50

Four weeks post CS!!! He is a gold star twat of the highest order. "Have a productive day" indeed, yes, your day is productive - keeping your young baby ALIVE AND WELL. That is what your maternity leave is for, not to fucking well keep house!

If he wants a spotless house, he can bloody well pay for a cleaner. He has 2 kids for goodness sake. Wait till they're 6 and 2, he'll have the shock of his life if he thinks he'll manage a clutter free show home then!

Redoubchair · 19/12/2024 12:50

LaurenOX · 19/12/2024 11:20

I worry I’ve made him out to sound like he doesn’t do anything which is far from the case!

He does his fair share of house work, he does all DIY he does have a stressful job which takes up some evenings of his time but he is still very much a hands on dad who is idolised by our eldest. This wasn’t to shame him for not doing anything because that is far from the truth, it was to find out if I was being unreasonable to be hurt by his behaviour.

Everyone is different and heals differently. 4 weeks post C-section, I wasn't really doing much to be honest. And my husband was looking after our older child. I'd have been extremely unimpressed if he mentioned anything about the house not being tidy enough

LittleBitAlexisLaLaLaLaLa · 19/12/2024 12:50

Your husband is a cunt.

I’m coming up to 3 months pp and if my husband started pointing out all the stuff I’m personally not getting done he’d be told to crack on and do it himself. That goes for when I’m back at work too. Yeah he’s been at work all day but it doesn’t take much to say to his older child “come on kiddo let’s pick up all the toys off the floor”. Or just wash up the chopping board and put it away. Take less time to do it yourself than it would to point out it’s not been done.

Swipe left for the next trending thread