Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

(CW Child abuse) Why do mothers not protect their children from abusive boyfriends

364 replies

OutWithTheMule · 14/12/2024 00:43

There has been another horrific child abuse death and I have noticed in the majority of these cases the mothers boyfriend has been abusing the child, and the mother is aware and allows it to happen, and usually protects them by trying to cover it up from the police after the fact.

In the awful case that has been in the news today the mother had only been with her boyfriend for 36 days. She allowed the abuse to continue because she didn't want him to leave her. How the fuck can you choose someone you have known 36 days over your own child!?

I just can't understand why these women choose their boyfriends over their children, if anyone laid a finger on my daughter I would flay them!! Even if you wouldn't physically intervene you would take your child and leave surely? If the boyfriend isn't the child's father they have no access to them if you just take them somewhere else. I know women are sometimes scared to leave abusive partners but often in these stories the partner is not abusing the mother, they are only abusing the child and the mother either passively allows it or sometimes joins in.

I understand that the fault lies with the boyfriends obviously, they are monsters and there is no excusing their actions, it's horrific. But it makes sense, violent men abuse children, it's straightforward as disgusting as it is. What I cannot understand for the life of me is why a mother would allow a boyfriend to harm their child or actively choose a boyfriend over their child. It just doesn't make any sense to me. Can anyone shed any light on these women's behaviour?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
kitteninabasket · 14/12/2024 10:51

Porcuporpoise · 14/12/2024 08:43

There's a bit of a myth that women are passive onlookers in these tragic cases. But actually a good number are active participants in the abuse.

Yes. It tends to be that when a woman abuses her child it’s assumed she’s a victim of some sort, that a man must have coerced her to do it. Or she’s vulnerable. Or she’s experienced trauma. Do the same people who make these assumptions speculate whether a man who abuses children is vulnerable or has experienced some kind of trauma?

Women are capable of abusing children of their own volition just as men are. Women shouldn’t be treated more sympathetically when it comes to abuse just because they’re women. Sexual abuse where the perpetrator is female is barely acknowledged, and if it is it tends to be perceived by the public as a much lesser crime.

TeenLifeMum · 14/12/2024 10:48

Women are so desperate to no be alone they’ll prioritise awful boyfriends and ignore all the red flags. My friend is a family court solicitor and her experience is that many women do not put their dc first in these situations.

everychildmatters · 14/12/2024 10:41

@Dweetfidilove It's hard. Because of severe financial abuse not recognised by anyone (as well as psychological abuse and coercive control), I lost so much when I left a decade ago.
My ex-husband lives in a huge house complete with swimming pool and hottub whilst we still live in privately rented a decade on. My sons live with him the majority. Life financially remains doable. Just.
I have had counselling recently and for the first time ever I do not blame myself for the "selfish" decision to leave.
As my counsellor said, better to have a loving mum a little of the time than no loving mum at all.
I'm still fucking angry though.

MrsSethGecko · 14/12/2024 10:40

@WindyRedAlert I'm not sure. We certainly did get physical abuse but it was never extreme, it wasn't done where it could be seen.
The neglect and emotional abuse was much worse.
I don't know why you don't read about it as often, other than at home it was drummed into us that we absolutely do not talk about what happens in the family, and when I got up the nerve to tell a teacher she laughed and told me not to make up stories, everyone knew my parents weren't like that.

turkeymuffin · 14/12/2024 10:37

Lurkingandlearning · 14/12/2024 08:43

I think the women who allow their children to be abused are just as much a monster as the man hurting them. These women may have reasons for being what they are, terrible, sad reasons, but those reasons do not make them any less a monster.

This.
Worse in some ways as biologically they should be hardwired to protect the child in a way the men aren't.
Something is seriously wrong with society and many many individuals within it.

Goody2ShoesAndTheFilthyBeast · 14/12/2024 10:35

cock is king.

you see it all the time.

as pp have said how many times on here do you read about dreadful, dreadful men and then have to read the next sentence which is about how good he is with the kids or how much he loves them or the kids love him and how great he is apart from when he's drinking / doing drugs / screaming at them / hurling abuse / kicking them round the kitchen.

You are not responsible for someone else's behaviour but you sure as shit are responsible for yours. The adult has a choice, the child has no choice.

Dweetfidilove · 14/12/2024 10:34

everychildmatters · 14/12/2024 10:27

@Dweetfidilove I agree; there are many women who prioritise lifestyle (and probably not having to work) over everything else. But the issue is often exacerbated by the fact that these women have happily become entirely financially dependent in the first place.

If nothing else inspires you to fix that lackadaisical attitude to independence, protecting your children should.
Then again, some folks believe keeping their children in these situations is protecting them from poverty and judgement.
I just pity the children raised in these unhealthy and unsafe environments; often to grow up and repeat the cycle.

Msmoonpie · 14/12/2024 10:33

There was a thread on here last night about a woman who was heavily pregnant to a volume man with severe MH issues pleading for advice how to “get” social services understand that he was a great father after he’d assaulted her again.

They care more about having a partner than the child.

NigelHarmansNewWife · 14/12/2024 10:30

I was once on a jury where it was apparent one of the reasons the complainant's abuser was not stopped years before the complainant was old enough to be able to stop it herself was because when she tried to tell someone the mother mistakenly thought she was accusing mum's boyfriend.

The stupid mother put her own relationship above her daughter's safety and wellbeing and although the authorities were involved it was brushed off as made up because they focussed on the wrong person. Just appalling.

My mum was a safeguarding lead for many years and has told me that it is not uncommon for women to protect men who abuse their children because they don't want to be alone.

everychildmatters · 14/12/2024 10:29

@OutWithTheMule It is, insofar as biological parents are not always safe either.
The "professionals" are often failing children by simply not identifying abuse.

unsync · 14/12/2024 10:29

There are a lot of very damaged people out there. There is very little help and support available. Certain types of men prey on these damaged, vulnerable women. It creates generations of damaged, traumatised and abused and/or abusive people. Unless you've been abused, it's hard to understand, especially trauma bonding. For some people, it's a case of better the devil you know. It overrides everything we know about decency and behaviour.

OutWithTheMule · 14/12/2024 10:27

everychildmatters · 14/12/2024 10:17

@OutWithTheMule It wasn't for Sara Sharif. Her own father killed her, after being awarded custody despite a huge amount of evidence that he was a violent man.
The "Father's rights at all costs" is an incredible dangerous rhetoric.

But that's not relevant to mothers allowing boyfriends to harm their children.

OP posts:
everychildmatters · 14/12/2024 10:27

@Dweetfidilove I agree; there are many women who prioritise lifestyle (and probably not having to work) over everything else. But the issue is often exacerbated by the fact that these women have happily become entirely financially dependent in the first place.

Dweetfidilove · 14/12/2024 10:26

JadedVeryJaded · 14/12/2024 09:29

I’ve never understood why mums move new boyfriends in so easily and quickly. It’s a recipe for disaster. The DC feel resentful and pushed out, and if he has children from a previous marriage it creates so many problems.

Of course the bigger question is why are some men abusive, dangerous, violent arseholes?

Apparently it's easier, as you can't leave the children to go on dates, etc. It's also nice to have someone to cuddle and watch the telly with as evenings are otherwise lonely - said I colleague who was having her 4 boyfriend in less than 2 years. She was something else all together.

mindutopia · 14/12/2024 10:25

Because they are insecure and desperate. My mother chose a convicted paedophile over me and her grandchildren (who she also exposed to the risk of abuse). Thankfully, I don’t believe my children were ever harmed, but I think they would have been if I hadn’t stepped in and cut her off. He abused another child in his family before they met, which he pled guilty to, and other (not related) children since they have been together (not caught but my mum told me it happened).

It’s because she is insecure and desperate and it’s easier to live in a fantasy world believing you have the ‘perfect man’ and the ‘perfect life’ than to live in reality. For her, it’s very #blessed and very social media glossy, which belies what is really going on behind closed doors. For some people, that’s worth more than family and genuine connection.

I cannot even begin to fathom throwing my own children away for a man. Even if Dh - who is the loveliest man ever - did something horrible to either of them, he’d be straight in the bin. I think some people are so messed up though that their attachments are so surface. They will happily discard a child they claimed to love because something new and shiny came along. They feel so bad about themselves that they chase anything that gives them a little hit of self worth. Absolutely pathetic really.

Dweetfidilove · 14/12/2024 10:22

MrsSethGecko · 14/12/2024 08:52

My mother kept us with our violent and alcoholic father because "we wouldn't have been able to live in that big house with the lovely garden if I left. We'd be in some horrible council house. What would people think."

So basically, for her, appearances and what other people thought was more important than stopping her children being abused and beaten.

Women like her are a dime and dozen on this forum. It doesn't matter what advice they get, even from children who were raised in said circumstance, they will not be moved. So sad ☹️.

WindyRedAlert · 14/12/2024 10:21

MrsSethGecko · 14/12/2024 10:16

@WindyRedAlert they do, my parents were both middle class in very good jobs, both well respected.
Which meant that nobody believed it when I tried to tell them.

Would you say with middle class parents it's more likely to be verbal and emotional abuse rather than physical abuse and that's why you rarely read about such cases ?

YIP · 14/12/2024 10:19

MammaKel · 14/12/2024 02:22

I guess the easiest answer is that the mothers are just an evil piece of shit like their pathetic boyfriends.

Other reasons can be quite complex, such as mental health illness, trauma, being neurodivergent, the complexity of domestic violence, vulnerability, etc. Some men are very good at finding women like this for the sole purpose of abusing children..

Personally, I'll never understand it. If DH and I broke up, I probably wouldn't date again until my children were a lot older as I couldn't risk anything happening them.

The last paragraph makes no sense if you’re a well adjust woman - I assume you are. It wasn’t going on in secret.

Surely you would trust your own instincts as to whether a guy you’re dating is decent or not. There are red flags more often than not, but for some reason they are often ignored and like clockwork things get worse and worse.

These monster mothers aren’t oblivious to what’s going on, they know it’s happening! They don’t do anything to stop it. They are culprits of their child’s suffering. The vast majority of mothers would do anything to protect their children.

(I’m not talking about the case of little Sara as it was her monster of a dad)

everychildmatters · 14/12/2024 10:17

@OutWithTheMule It wasn't for Sara Sharif. Her own father killed her, after being awarded custody despite a huge amount of evidence that he was a violent man.
The "Father's rights at all costs" is an incredible dangerous rhetoric.

MrsSethGecko · 14/12/2024 10:16

@WindyRedAlert they do, my parents were both middle class in very good jobs, both well respected.
Which meant that nobody believed it when I tried to tell them.

WindyRedAlert · 14/12/2024 10:14

Boomer55 · 14/12/2024 07:46

Inadequate parents come in either gender. Thry put their own needs above the protection of their children. 😞

They come in all social classes too . It seems to be the working / under class abuse cases that make the headlines though.

WindyRedAlert · 14/12/2024 10:11

MyPithyPoster · 14/12/2024 07:12

Again, I’ve met plenty of Nursery workers I wouldn’t leave children with… another rather uncomfortable truth

Edited

Add carers to that.

PuppiesProzacProsecco · 14/12/2024 10:08

I'm neuro divergent, I have complex trauma, I was emotionally neglected by my narc mother (occasional v mild physical abuse too - eg "accidentally" slamming a door on my fingers), I've been sexually assaulted and had some not great relationships. I'm medicated but still struggle with anxiety, depression and low self esteem. I'm an ex self harmer and have addiction issues.

I, and many, many women like me, would lay down my life for my kids and would never in a million years allow anyone, male or female, to hurt my children.

There is simply no excuse - women who do this should be sterilised.

cunoyerjudowel · 14/12/2024 10:02

Some people are just crap abusive parents and they have lots of children who grow up yearning for a family of their own to heal their trauma so have a lot of children very young and the cycle repeats and repeats.

WinterMorn · 14/12/2024 10:00

PoissonOfTheChrist · 14/12/2024 02:34

Some women truly do value having a partner over the wellbeing of their children. You see it on here all the time-an idiot woman deciding to move some man into her child's home when they've been together a matter of weeks or months. Relationship is usually a piece of shit but still the women cling to the dick. They just simply love being fucked more than they love their own chidren.

These women are not helped by enablers that give excuses such as the women must've suffered trauma or be ND or whatever other nonsense.

Nailed it. We talk about trauma, dysfunction and vulnerability, but an awful lot of these woman are selfish individuals who prioritize their own wants above that of their children. They are not vulnerable - they re inconsiderate and neglectful and thoughtless.