Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed at being told to be considerate of disabled people

693 replies

DefendingPan · 13/12/2024 13:48

This sign was in the disabled toilet in a restaurant (which is also the only baby change in the restaurant).

What’s the point of this sign? What might parents be doing that they will stop after reading this?

To be annoyed at being told to be considerate of disabled people
OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Manara · 13/12/2024 18:17

DefendingPan · 13/12/2024 18:13

It never occurred to me people would be feeding their babies in a toilet. I guess conventions vary by culture and local but here women breastfeed pretty much everywhere. I’d hate to think of my wife and baby having to hide in a grotty toilet!

If it is about putting the table back up they should have been way more specific!

Just be considerate. It’s not hard.

FionaSkates · 13/12/2024 18:16

DefendingPan · 13/12/2024 18:13

It never occurred to me people would be feeding their babies in a toilet. I guess conventions vary by culture and local but here women breastfeed pretty much everywhere. I’d hate to think of my wife and baby having to hide in a grotty toilet!

If it is about putting the table back up they should have been way more specific!

Having read all the replies, are you still annoyed at being ‘told’ to show consideration for disabled people?

DefendingPan · 13/12/2024 18:13

Workingclasslass · 13/12/2024 15:07

Is this a farmhouse inn because I frequent one a few times and they have a disabled toilet but it’s a baby changing one as well the point is what they’re saying is don’t take the piss. Don’t take too long that’s unnecessary because disabled people are waiting for the toilet, I do remember once this happened to me and I was waiting and waiting and waiting. I did say to the manager I said I think this is ridiculous. Why don’t you have two separate places? I don’t understand why they don’t have it in the women’s toilets where they could have a separate place there but they don’t and it can be frustrating when you’re waiting to go to the toilet.

Edited

KFC

OP posts:
DefendingPan · 13/12/2024 18:13

It never occurred to me people would be feeding their babies in a toilet. I guess conventions vary by culture and local but here women breastfeed pretty much everywhere. I’d hate to think of my wife and baby having to hide in a grotty toilet!

If it is about putting the table back up they should have been way more specific!

OP posts:
FionaSkates · 13/12/2024 18:10

FOJN · 13/12/2024 17:49

Why do people take signs like that personally?

There have clearly been complaints that some parents have not been as considerate of other peoples needs as they could have been.

If you are not one of them then the sign isn't directed at you so stop making it about you.

I think some people are just desperate to be offended as often as possible, and then complain about it as loudly as possible!

yipyipyop · 13/12/2024 18:09

Twilight7777 · 13/12/2024 17:43

As a disabled lady, I am very pleased that sign is there, having seen so many people think oh I’ll use the disabled loo cos it’s nearest. I’ve seen a mum with a baby in a pram and a toddler all go into the loo, presumably for safety of the toddler whilst they change the baby. I was waiting for the loo as someone with a hidden disability. They took 20 minutes so presumably they’ve changed the baby and both the mother and toddler have used the loo. I was just grateful I didn’t have incontinence or bowel problems and was able to wait.

20 minutes is ridiculous but what do you propose the parent does with a toddler when she needs to change a baby alone? It's the establishments fault for not providing separate toilets. I do avoid changing/disabled toilets when all possible as public toilets are usually pretty disgusting anyway but sometimes you have to use them.

Squeekey · 13/12/2024 18:07

Simonjt · 13/12/2024 17:48

Babies can easily be changed on your lap, theres nothing stopping an able bodied parent sitting on the loo and changing their child. There is also nothing stopping a parent choosing a sensible pushchair rather than a tank on wheels. If an able bodied parent can’t manage to change their own babies nappy without using the disabled toilet I’d be concerned about other basic tasks their brain can’t manage.

A small baby and a wee, sure.
But you can change a poonami baby on your lap whilst sitting on the loo? Good for you. Most can't.

Equally, guess hows changing a 3 year olds pooey pull up going on your lap?

I've changed many a nappy on my lap. I've used the boot of the car, pushchair, the floor, all sorts. But in the above situations, no I couldn't have done it on my legs.

Also, I was pretty good at lap changing for my second baby, but not my first, especially when they were tiny.

Rosscameasdoody · 13/12/2024 18:04

renoleno · 13/12/2024 16:59

It was in response to a poster with a lack of perspective outside their own issues, taking an innocent explanation someone made on why joint facilities exist in small businesses, and seeing it as a campaign against disabled people. Being disabled doesn't preclude people from being inconsiderate or selfish - always assuming the worst intentions in the most innocuous actions and comments, or refusing to understand a different perspective is ignorant and offensive BS too.

I understand why joint facilities exist in small businesses. But the fact is they shouldn’t. And from next year new legislation will stop it wherever possible. Oh, and I understand a different perspective all right. Been disabled all my life and have watched as ignorant and entitled people have tried to shoehorn themselves into benefits and concessions meant for the genuinely disabled. I’ve been a disabilty outreach worker for many years and have seen disabled people subjected to disgusting treatment, for no other reason than disability. That’s what colours the outlook of disabled people. It’s not a ‘chip on the shoulder’ or anything else able bodied people like to explain it away with. It’s watching the constant erosion of the rights that we’ve fought long and hard for by entitled people who want it for themselves, whether they’re entitled or not.

SaagAloopa · 13/12/2024 17:58

EmmaMaria · 13/12/2024 15:45

Before disability I used to think that equality laws and so on had made improvements in the way people with disabilities were treated. And in some ways they have. But what I now feel is that some of the progress made is actually begrudged by some able-bodied people. We see it on here all the time. Despite evidence showing that people with disabilities are disproportionately in the poorest segments of society, we all apparently live on benefits, have six foreign holidays a year and own mansions. Pushing someone in a wheelchair out of the way is the thin edge of the wedge. I regularly have the door slammed in my face by people who hold it for the next (able-bodied) person but then see that I am slow and have both hands using sticks or other walking aids, so they let it go to slam in my face! And I mean that it's rare a week goes by without that happening.

Fucking hell

user1471516498 · 13/12/2024 17:54

I have a hidden disability (a stoma) and I am also a parent. I am aware that sometimes I annoy people by taking a long time in the bathroom particularly if I have to change a nappy and empty my bag at the same time. I do everything I can to be as quick as possible, but usually manage to piss off both other disabled people and other parents because I look fine. While I am on maternity leave I am avoiding unnecessary trips out when my stoma is being active, but thats about all I can do

Healingsfall · 13/12/2024 17:54

You can buy travel changing mats too so surely that's an easier option for parents?

Bakedpotatoes · 13/12/2024 17:53

bandicoot99 · 13/12/2024 14:25

I've had plenty of times when nappy changes were urgent (leaking or exploding nappies) and I wouldn't have appreciated anyone jumping the queue in those circumstances, nor would I have offered, sorry. Not every disabled person needing to use the toilet is going to need it urgently either. If specifically asked and if my nappy change wasn't urgent then I'd accommodate.

I've taken my own changing mat and spare clothes so I can change wherever needed and can change the baby if required. This is so selfish, you'd make a disabled person wait and potentially soil themselves than change your child's clothes after an accident (which as a seasoned parent I'd assume you'd have).

Squeekey · 13/12/2024 17:51

FestiveFruitloop · 13/12/2024 17:37

You do realise this is breathtakingly entitled?

For a while the only baby changing rooms in the city centre was one in a shopping centre, in a disabled cubicle. It was locked with a radar key, with a sign saying to get the key, go to the office. That involved going the other side of the shopping centre, into the multistorey, up to the top floor and to the office in the far corner. And back again afterwards 😂

I changed baby in a corner instead.
If I'd come to town more I may well have bought a key for that specific loo to avoid a 10m traipse each way. That's different from just using it all radar loos because they are convenient.

As it happens, I now have a disabled child who I often use the disabled loos with (whether we need to use them depends on how she is, what w need the bathroom for, how big the regular cubicles are etc). I'm in the small minority that find combined ones useful because sometimes the table is useful, but she's too old to feel comfortable in the baby change.

FOJN · 13/12/2024 17:49

Why do people take signs like that personally?

There have clearly been complaints that some parents have not been as considerate of other peoples needs as they could have been.

If you are not one of them then the sign isn't directed at you so stop making it about you.

Simonjt · 13/12/2024 17:48

Babies can easily be changed on your lap, theres nothing stopping an able bodied parent sitting on the loo and changing their child. There is also nothing stopping a parent choosing a sensible pushchair rather than a tank on wheels. If an able bodied parent can’t manage to change their own babies nappy without using the disabled toilet I’d be concerned about other basic tasks their brain can’t manage.

sloecat · 13/12/2024 17:45

MerryMaker · 13/12/2024 17:44

@sloecat But it is impossible to do that. Take buses. We have buses that have a wheelchair space plus space for two buggies. Still there are parents who do not want to vacate the wheelchair space for the wheelchair user. I read parents locally saying that more seats should be removed to make more spaces. But during the day buses are mainly used by older people, some of whom can not manage stairs on a moving bus, they need the seats downstairs. How big do they expect buses to be!!

I’m not saying it is easy or straightforward.

MerryMaker · 13/12/2024 17:44

@sloecat But it is impossible to do that. Take buses. We have buses that have a wheelchair space plus space for two buggies. Still there are parents who do not want to vacate the wheelchair space for the wheelchair user. I read parents locally saying that more seats should be removed to make more spaces. But during the day buses are mainly used by older people, some of whom can not manage stairs on a moving bus, they need the seats downstairs. How big do they expect buses to be!!

SavingTheBestTillLast · 13/12/2024 17:43

FestiveFruitloop · 13/12/2024 17:37

You do realise this is breathtakingly entitled?

@IVFmumoftwo
a lot of providers don’t like toilets in stand alone baby changing rooms because - - they don’t want to encourage people using them just as toilets
or they don’t want the extra cleaning hassle
or they don’t want to pay for the plumbing ( I know! )
or they just don’t realise what a pain it is for people needing both
or they are men who’ve never experienced the dilemma

speaking as a women architect who can’t even get male bosses to realise a sanitary bin can’t fit in next to a wc if it’s centrally spaced. I’ve had years of this nonsense.

Twilight7777 · 13/12/2024 17:43

As a disabled lady, I am very pleased that sign is there, having seen so many people think oh I’ll use the disabled loo cos it’s nearest. I’ve seen a mum with a baby in a pram and a toddler all go into the loo, presumably for safety of the toddler whilst they change the baby. I was waiting for the loo as someone with a hidden disability. They took 20 minutes so presumably they’ve changed the baby and both the mother and toddler have used the loo. I was just grateful I didn’t have incontinence or bowel problems and was able to wait.

sloecat · 13/12/2024 17:41

Waitinggame42023 · 13/12/2024 16:58

Reading these comments I'm certain I'll be flamed for this, but as a new parent they make for depressing reading. I'm surprised to see such a lack of understanding that facilities for babies are often woefully inadequate, only the constant 'disabled needs trump anyone and everything' mantras.
No one is disputing that. And I'm absolutely not suggesting disabled facilities should be sacrificed for baby-related spaces, but that doesn't mean I think it's right that infants and new mothers/pregnant women are always pushed to the back of the queue and seemingly never have suitable provision.

My sister (who's 30 weeks pregnant) recently had to board a train with my 15 month old niece, in a pram and with a weekend bag. It was a 2 hour journey but no stops between where she got on and where she was alighting. The only place she ccould sit with the pram was in the only wheelvhair spot on a 10 carriage train (no wheelchair user on board). She was told to move- which meant trying to find a home for her bag, collapsing the pram and storing it all while juggling a toddler, and then wrestling with her on her lap for 90 minutes. This is despite no wheelchair user needing that space.

So whilst I appreciate that disabled person's do have needs that should always be treated with consideration, it's a shame that so many people don't see how inconsiderately we treat young children and their parents and how often they're made to feel unwelcome. It's not a race to the bottom.

From what I’ve read here, many of us think that parents should have a dedicated changing space and also on trains and in any other public shared space. It is a struggle to juggle a baby/small child and all the paraphernalia they need. Things are easier for parents than they used to be. I’m old so I remember the days when you had to fold up the pushchair to get on the bus while struggling with the children and shopping. It’s wrong that the two groups are pitted against one another in shared spaces for their needs to be met. That’s what needs to change in my view.

Rosscameasdoody · 13/12/2024 17:40

renoleno · 13/12/2024 16:31

Oh come on! My friend has a baby and will carefully research places that have baby change facilities and are breastfeeding friendly. I will check to only visit places that have multiple cubicles because of my IBS. It's entitled to expect the entire world to cater for you when it doesn't cater completely to any group of people, disabled or non disabled.

But apparently entitled to expect that the entire world cater for you as a parent. The point you are missing here is that there is disability legislation that requires establishments to cater for disabled people. Many don’t. There are no consequences because the legislation isn’t enforced to any great degree. How would you feel as a disabled person knowing that legislation is there to provide for you but if people can’t be arsed enforcing it, then no biggie ?

SaagAloopa · 13/12/2024 17:39

Workingclasslass · 13/12/2024 15:07

Is this a farmhouse inn because I frequent one a few times and they have a disabled toilet but it’s a baby changing one as well the point is what they’re saying is don’t take the piss. Don’t take too long that’s unnecessary because disabled people are waiting for the toilet, I do remember once this happened to me and I was waiting and waiting and waiting. I did say to the manager I said I think this is ridiculous. Why don’t you have two separate places? I don’t understand why they don’t have it in the women’s toilets where they could have a separate place there but they don’t and it can be frustrating when you’re waiting to go to the toilet.

Edited

Because they can't be arsed to put one in the women's and men's toilets for some reason so bung it in the accessible changing room

FestiveFruitloop · 13/12/2024 17:37

IVFmumoftwo · 13/12/2024 17:23

I am aware of that so we need baby change areas with a toilet with room for a pram. I wouldn't actually use a disabled toilet that requires a key but I can see why some people purchase a key and use it. I have seen some toilets like I mention but very few and far between.

You do realise this is breathtakingly entitled?

SoNiceToComeHomeTo · 13/12/2024 17:36

You only get a sign like that once there has been an incident. Probably for reasons pp have suggested: nappy change taking too long, parents feeding the baby at the same time etc.

SavingTheBestTillLast · 13/12/2024 17:33

Rosscameasdoody · 13/12/2024 17:31

I suggest you go online and access the regulations. Accessible toilets are meant for use by anyone who needs them. Stand alone toilet rooms are not designated as accessible toilets. They are exclusively for the use of disabled people and their carers.

I’m an architect
I design them in all the time and overall calculations count accessible toilets in with all others
Like I said, no one’s breaking any laws using them.
The only law is that they are provided when required as part of the Equalities Act