Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

His new hobby and female friend - be cool?

189 replies

EvieR · 10/12/2024 23:18

My boyfriend has recently started a musical hobby at his job. He played piano as a child but dropped it long ago. Suddenly he announced he wanted to get back into it.

Around the same time he started talking about violins then his colleague Rachel played violin. Other things she said. I was detecting a bit of mentionitis.

It turns out they have met once a week for a month between classes (both teachers) to play together. Now he's talking passionately about this hobby but not about her anymore. They practice together just the two of them.

As for our relationship, it feels stronger than ever and he told me how happy he is the other day. Outside of this I have no concerns.

Should my reaction to this new hobby and friend just be 'have fun'? Truth is I am a bit jealous. I love him and don't want to lose him.

OP posts:
OnlySlightly · 11/12/2024 10:23

user1492757084 · 11/12/2024 10:09

It's thoroughly cute.
I would enjoy that so much. Be sure to listen to them sometimes. Do they play for functions?

Book them to play for your home at Christmas.

I do think the conversation about him watching out for if the relationship could ever be heading down the inappropriate path is wise. You can never (and he can never) be sure of what his friend is feeling.
As teachers they would be well educated to never find themselves in a small science back room etc alone with a student. That is best practise so he will understand your concern. Do they welcome other musicians into their space?
I would hope so.

Edited

But the OP’s husband and his colleagues are two adult members of the teaching staff, not school children. Adults aren’t left alone with individual children in private spaces because of potential risk to the child in a situation with considerable power differential. None of that is relevant to two adult colleagues using a free period to play music together. Even if people are characterising the OP’s DH as a deluded innocent liable to be pounced upon by his cougar fortysomething fellow-teacher while he’s trying to work out a tricky bit of Rachmaninov.

user1492757084 · 11/12/2024 10:19

Definitely meet her.
They must sound so good together by now.

Invite her around to play and have nibbles for Chritmas cheer.
I don't think you will feel jealous but more so very proud of the musical talent your DH is developing.

Maybe you'd like to invite him out to a Christmas Carols in a beautiful cathedral. They are amazing with pipe organs and choirs.

GivingitToGod · 11/12/2024 10:16

EvieR · 10/12/2024 23:30

It all just sounds a bit romantic! The two of them going off to play music together.

I personally don't entertain new one on one friendships with men but no doubt I'm a minority.

This
The fact that he isn't a piano or violin player would worry me

EvieR · 11/12/2024 10:15

He's practicing with her right now. I'm fine. 😅

OP posts:
EvieR · 11/12/2024 10:14

@EauNeu I know. I just fear he might be a bit naive and end up going down an unintended path.

I can't control the outcome. And by raising it and looking jealous I also risk looking unsupportive if he is just enjoying his new hobby.

But if they become closer I think I'd want to meet her.

OP posts:
gannett · 11/12/2024 10:13

Fireworknight · 11/12/2024 09:54

Is there any evidence of increased communication outside of school? Texting her? Making more of an effort on practise days etc?

Could you take the bull by the horn and suggest getting him violin/piano lessons for him? Or for you as well? Ie. Take ownership of this , and make it a hobby you can do together? (It may be telling if he bats this idea down, if he only wants to do it with teacher friend).

Also, can you go with him in the practice session? Invite yourself along, as a couple?

Spoiler alert, he would not rather play music with his non-musician wife than with a competent musician colleague. The idea is nuts.

Also two musicians practising or jamming or doing improv or making music together are not going to want someone in the room who's just observing them. That's anathema to any creative person.

EvieR · 11/12/2024 10:12

@user1492757084 I don't know if they welcome other musicians into their space. For all I know they could be, or it's just them.

He did say another colleague was thinking about joining them but that it probably wouldn't happen. I remember thinking he doesn't seem to want it to!

OP posts:
user1492757084 · 11/12/2024 10:09

It's thoroughly cute.
I would enjoy that so much. Be sure to listen to them sometimes. Do they play for functions?

Book them to play for your home at Christmas.

I do think the conversation about him watching out for if the relationship could ever be heading down the inappropriate path is wise. You can never (and he can never) be sure of what his friend is feeling.
As teachers they would be well educated to never find themselves in a small science back room etc alone with a student. That is best practise so he will understand your concern. Do they welcome other musicians into their space?
I would hope so.

Edingril · 11/12/2024 10:05

EvieR · 10/12/2024 23:30

Also he has a type (redheads=me). So is this woman.

I know I'm likely being ridiculous.

Yes you are, if my husband (or bf) was this jealous, they would be shown the door

Zae134 · 11/12/2024 10:05

I think I'd be blunt but not unkind about it, I'd say I feel a little jealous of the time he's spending with someone else and see how he responds.
Also, I can only speak for the music practice rooms in my secondary school, they are usually cupboards with windows on a main corridor- so it's possible that it's a much less romantic scenario than you're picturing haha

whatnow5 · 11/12/2024 10:02

Fireworknight · 11/12/2024 09:54

Is there any evidence of increased communication outside of school? Texting her? Making more of an effort on practise days etc?

Could you take the bull by the horn and suggest getting him violin/piano lessons for him? Or for you as well? Ie. Take ownership of this , and make it a hobby you can do together? (It may be telling if he bats this idea down, if he only wants to do it with teacher friend).

Also, can you go with him in the practice session? Invite yourself along, as a couple?

That’s not a bad idea actually. Tell him you’ve been delighted for his newfound interest and get him some lessons for Christmas 😂😂😂 He may ramp up the practice time though to support the lessons

EauNeu · 11/12/2024 10:01

There's nothing you can do about it really. If you trust him you trust him. If you don't, the relationship is probably not going to work.

EvieR · 11/12/2024 10:00

@Tumbler2121 he was excited that day but only cited the music as the reason.

@Fireworknight I know where you're coming from but I resent the idea of taking up a hobby he likes as a means of protecting the relationship from this. I have my own hobbies. I'm not saying a definite no.

I haven't noticed him being on his phone more at all. In fact as a couple we've been spending a lot of time together and he doesn't look at it. I assume he must check it briefly before bed or similar.

OP posts:
whatnow5 · 11/12/2024 09:59

EvieR · 11/12/2024 01:56

@Ratisshortforratthew I agree that individual pursuits are important. When he told me I was outwardly supportive but felt a bit worried. I want to support him too.

I actually do understand because I also used to play piano.

He isn't practising at home at all so far.

Yes at the moment it is just playing between lessons but she has invited him and another colleague over to her place so definitely scope for this to grow outside of work. Not inherently an issue if just friendship.

Why don’t you ask him to show you what he’s learned? If he’s hopeless, you’ll know he hasn’t been spending the practice time practicing!

I’m only joking but OP I think it’s normal (and exciting at the beginning) to find someone with a common interest. You said she’s a professional? She has probably talked about it in a really engaging way and spurred your husband on to take it up again. She is probably helping him improve and likes having someone at work she can talk to about her interest. I wouldn’t worry about him going to her house with another colleague (her suggesting that actually makes it sound like she is deliberately avoiding anything inappropriate) but if it’s just him and her and you feel uncomfortable I think it’s fair enough to mention it.

Comedycook · 11/12/2024 09:56

This is how affairs start. I wouldn't be happy at all.

Fireworknight · 11/12/2024 09:54

Is there any evidence of increased communication outside of school? Texting her? Making more of an effort on practise days etc?

Could you take the bull by the horn and suggest getting him violin/piano lessons for him? Or for you as well? Ie. Take ownership of this , and make it a hobby you can do together? (It may be telling if he bats this idea down, if he only wants to do it with teacher friend).

Also, can you go with him in the practice session? Invite yourself along, as a couple?

Tumbler2121 · 11/12/2024 09:49

the the that would have got me is that he didn’t come home all excited that he had come across someone to practice music with, and at school!

also, the going round to her house with one other person there … really?

expect the best prepare for the worst, I’d make sure that she met me, so she could see we were a couple in case he’s been diminishing your relationship to her.

from someone 100% trusting whose EXH is now married to a good friend and colleague!

LurkyLuke · 11/12/2024 09:47

It turns out they have met once a week for a month between classes (both teachers) to play together.

Were you aware of this or was it happenning without your knowledge?

I don't think you are being ridiculous at all. Emotional affairs happen, and sometimes they are more obvious to the ones on the outside.

ThatTealViewer · 11/12/2024 09:41

OnlySlightly · 11/12/2024 09:39

Yes, I’m 52, and clearly my sexual life is a dim and distant memory. I have long since hung up a ‘CLOSED DOWN IN PERPETUITY’ sign with an arrow pointing downwards on my belt. 🙄😀

🤣🤣🤣

OnlySlightly · 11/12/2024 09:39

ThatTealViewer · 11/12/2024 09:26

if she’s 40s wouldn’t she already have a family or be past that whole thing?

I don’t think OP has anything to worry about, but the ridiculousness of this sentence made me CACKLE! 🤣

Yes, I’m 52, and clearly my sexual life is a dim and distant memory. I have long since hung up a ‘CLOSED DOWN IN PERPETUITY’ sign with an arrow pointing downwards on my belt. 🙄😀

ThatTealViewer · 11/12/2024 09:26

PlopSofa · 11/12/2024 09:03

if he was quite good before then it’s often just the pleasure of playing with someone else.

if she’s 40s wouldn’t she already have a family or be past that whole thing? Not to say it couldn’t happen but it’s not as likely?

I can see your worry though. Strange things can happen.

does he love music? What grade did he get to?

I guess it’s adult activity in an otherwise pretty mundane day. It’s probably quite exciting because it’s for his enjoyment not anyone else’s.

if she’s 40s wouldn’t she already have a family or be past that whole thing?

I don’t think OP has anything to worry about, but the ridiculousness of this sentence made me CACKLE! 🤣

MereDintofPandiculation · 11/12/2024 09:12

I’ve had three separate men at my house playing duets, one man at a time, no safety in numbers. Never occurred to me that there might be 3 jealous women sat back at home.

Mind, one was a vicar.

PlopSofa · 11/12/2024 09:03

if he was quite good before then it’s often just the pleasure of playing with someone else.

if she’s 40s wouldn’t she already have a family or be past that whole thing? Not to say it couldn’t happen but it’s not as likely?

I can see your worry though. Strange things can happen.

does he love music? What grade did he get to?

I guess it’s adult activity in an otherwise pretty mundane day. It’s probably quite exciting because it’s for his enjoyment not anyone else’s.

404ErrorCode · 11/12/2024 08:58

It turns out they have met once a week for a month between classes (both teachers) to play together

This is probably where you started to get a bit bothered - he should have told you he was meeting up with this woman, just the two of them at the time it began. Finding out after, makes it seem like he was hiding it, even if he was (most probably) doing nothing wrong.

Why are you only finding out now?

EvieR · 11/12/2024 08:57

OnlySlightly · 11/12/2024 08:53

I love this suggestion. The DH and his violinist colleague are working away at Messiaen’s Theme and Variations for Violin and Piano and the OP is sitting in, repeatedly hitting middle C on her little Casio, like Mr Bean at the 2012 Olympics opening ceremony, and glaring.

This made me laugh out loud. Thank you!

The funny thing is I actually do have a keyboard but I barely play it. So the scene would be exactly like this.

OP posts: