Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

AIBU to be having nightmares over friends visit?

584 replies

Allinarow48 · 10/12/2024 21:43

Having nightmares over old friends visit.

One of my closest friends is coming to visit over Christmas, after 10 years living abroad with only ocassional visits I should be excited but I’m actually terrified.

I was best mates with “Jane” since we were kids, we lived together during college and were absolutely inseparable. We really, really loved each other for years and went through a lot together. She is also good friends with my DH and my DD loves her.

During her time abroad she has met a lovely man, had a beautiful son (age 2) and started her own business.

She’s always suffered badly with depression and anxiety and her mental health has been fragile. Although in her new country she found some excellent therapists who really helped her. However lately she seems to be spiralling .

It started during Covid, I think she got very deep into social media. She’s always been very politically active and since she had her son the plight of children in Gaza has been a huge focus for her.

She’s always been very vehemently anti Israel since I’ve known her (We’re Irish and that’s very normal here).

She began to post pro-Hamas stuff just after the 7/11 attacks on Israel and immediately shared Hamas videos of the attacks ( the murder of Israelis and desecration of corpses etc.) With added commentary “This is beautiful to me.” “This is how freedom is gained.” Etc. A lot of Irish people are still quite pro-IRA and once again the support of Hamas isn’t that unusual but actually sharing the videos was extreme.

She then started posting videos of dead Gazan children pretty much continuously. Due to the time difference I can see most of her posting is done at night. I think she posts while feeding her son. Videos accompanied by “This is me.” “This is my son.” “I am Palestine.” kind of stuff. She said in one post that her ability to care for her son has been affected by the secondary trauma of what happening in Gaza.

Then recently she began to go from “Death to Israel” to “Death to the Jews.” She posted in Arabic and I translated it. It was an insta story and then disappeared. And since then she’s pretty much transitioned from anti-Israel to Anti-western and fairly drastic Antisemetic stuff “They didn’t gas enough of you” that kind of thing.

Then she went on to say recently that anyone who doesn’t agree with her should kill themselves or be killed and burn in hell etc…

Now here’s the thing: I’m Jewish, non practicing, I have relatives in Israel and lost a friend to the Hamas attacks. I’m disgusted by the Israeli government at the moment and have a lot of sympathy for the Gazan people but I don’t hate the Israeli people either. I am actually quite middle of the road politically.

Being Irish, Jewishness is is not something I have ever advertised and I’m actually not sure I’ve I ever told her. If she’s aware and doesn’t care or has forgotten and doesn’t mind me seeing her posts.

My mistake is that I never responded to any of her posts and never argued with her. She seems to think we’re totally cool. So she contacted me wanting to see me over Christmas for a day or 2.

I’ve been having nightmares about it. I’m scared I’ll say something or do something that upsets her and she freaks out, or something I do or don’t say triggers her mental heath problems and she hurts herself. I also feel bad that my dishonesty caused this situation. If I has said something last year she would probably have ditched me and never wanted to see me again.

I would like some advice on how to proceed.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
Allinarow48 · 11/12/2024 10:16

emailnonse · 11/12/2024 06:19

wait you do have children Op?

Parent the hell up FGS

I wouldn’t want this woman within a ten mile radius of my children and here you are…. potentially having her stay with you.

FGS OP you admit to being a coward, but for the sake of your children…. parent up

She wanted to possibly have a hotel break,not stay with me. I wouldn't bring the kids.

OP posts:
Daradarina · 11/12/2024 10:10

ACatNamedRobin · 11/12/2024 09:55

@the7Vabo @Rowen32 @Daradarina and all...

""Daradarina · Today 08:40

"The social pressure to be anti Jews, pro[] Hamas, and so forth is immense. Disagreeing makes you a social pariah and ostracized."

This is not true."

I don't know what to tell you.

As I said I'm an immigrant from Europe, and I can assure that each of my small group of Russian and Ukrainian friends would testify to exactly this.

This is what we've all seen from Irish people, in private and in public.

I've been here over 20 years, my Russian friends about 10, the Ukrainian girls obviously less (having come due to the war).

It's actually made the Ukrainian girls really sad, and sadly cynical, about Ireland and Irish people, who've otherwise treated them very nicely.

I am sorry you have misunderstood the situation then.

Maybe question people more directly about what they mean instead of extrapolating from what you’ve heard elsewhere? There is a lot of ‘the Irish are anti-Jewish’ rhetoric about at the moment unfortunately - mostly spread by people with their own agenda - and perhaps it is easy to be swayed by this.

I’ve been here a lot longer than 20 years and I could not be surer that you are wrong.

I caveat that by saying there are dickheads everywhere and we have our fair share!

Allinarow48 · 11/12/2024 10:07

Namechange908 · 11/12/2024 05:29

I find it really shocking and disturbing that so many Irish people posting here are calling the OPs comments about some Irish people supporting the IRA “disgusting” yet have absolutely nothing to say about her friend describing the murder of innocent civilians beautiful and calling for the genocide of all Jews.

Seriously, if that’s the part of this post that disgusted you, you need to look in a mirror.

And they wonder why I don't advertise my Jewish heritage.

OP posts:
Allinarow48 · 11/12/2024 10:03

AmberAlert86 · 11/12/2024 04:49

You are better, more empathetic person than I am. I would cut ties with her and im not Jewish. I wouldn't want someone glorifying violence in my home or near my family. I feel sorry for your friends little child. Also if your friend is mentally unwell I hope her family will notice and encourage her to get help.
If you don't mind me asking, why did you have to hide that you are Jewish? Are Irish antisemitic?
I'm nit from Ireland myself, just being curious how come being German was better than being Jewish....

Ireland isn't any more antisemetic than anywhere else (although a Nazi sympathyser did publish all our school textbooks apparently.) I know a few other Jewish people in the same situation. We were already bullied for being "foreigners " because our parents weren't born here and there was a strong feeling that being 'different' in other ways would make the situation worse. My brother mentioned it once and was mobbed at school with "you killed jesus" remarks. Then as we grew up the line between anti-Israel and antisemitism was sometimes blurry. It was just obvious not to advertise it.

OP posts:
ACatNamedRobin · 11/12/2024 09:55

@the7Vabo @Rowen32 @Daradarina and all...

""Daradarina · Today 08:40

"The social pressure to be anti Jews, pro[] Hamas, and so forth is immense. Disagreeing makes you a social pariah and ostracized."

This is not true."

I don't know what to tell you.

As I said I'm an immigrant from Europe, and I can assure that each of my small group of Russian and Ukrainian friends would testify to exactly this.

This is what we've all seen from Irish people, in private and in public.

I've been here over 20 years, my Russian friends about 10, the Ukrainian girls obviously less (having come due to the war).

It's actually made the Ukrainian girls really sad, and sadly cynical, about Ireland and Irish people, who've otherwise treated them very nicely.

TunnocksOrDeath · 11/12/2024 09:53

Wellshellsbells · 10/12/2024 23:21

I’m Irish and I agree with the basic principles of ira ideals ,which are that Ireland should be a 32 county country and it shouldn’t be part of England.i don’t agree with the bombing etc but I think op means the basic principle not the violence.lots of people I know think the same and everyone knows some rebel songs.

I'm 100% behind the right of the Northern Irish to determine whether they are part of The Republic of Ireland or of the UK, but please get the name of the country right... it would be both politically and geographically impossible for any part of Ireland to be part of England, Scotland or Wales.

Allinarow48 · 11/12/2024 09:49

Username2532 · 11/12/2024 02:17

It is breeding hate and condescending to say if someone hasn’t ‘lived it don’t see’ can’t comprehend, have you lived it? Or indeed op
@Lavender14 it’s quite clear you have the same views as @Allinarow48 who believes ‘most’ Irish people support the IRA, or as you said a lot, that is not a true representation, which is only what many have conveyed on this thread.

I never said "Most" read my post again.

OP posts:
OpheliaWasntMad · 11/12/2024 09:47

Daradarina · 11/12/2024 09:13

It’s very, very far from the majority position in Ireland. Please don’t think it is.

Apologies- I expressed myself badly

Rowen32 · 11/12/2024 09:44

Daradarina · 11/12/2024 08:40

The social pressure to be anti Jews, probably Hamas, and so forth is immense. Disagreeing makes you a social pariah and ostracized.

This is not true.
Ireland is anti what Israel is doing in Gaza, not anti-Jewish, not pro Hamas.

I think you must have misunderstood the nuances of conversation (most probably in a language that is not your first?) to think what you do.
Or perhaps you want to misunderstand?
I don’t know. Either way you are mistaken in what you say above.

You are right in that you are not aligned with the majority of Irish people’s views if you think Israel has no other choice but to destroy Gaza.

This thread is baffling to me, first with the IRA, now you're a social pariah unless you're anti Jew. That is such utter bs and I never use that word but I'm actually angry there's such narratives being put forth, omg.

fashionqueen0123 · 11/12/2024 09:42

Allinarow48 · 10/12/2024 23:16

I've only met him once. I've talked to her mother about it but she claims to have no knowlege of it and doesn't use socials.

We all saw what happened to people posting awful stuff online about the riots a couple of months back. She could end up in serious trouble.

HopeMumsnet · 11/12/2024 09:37

Hi all,
We've been through this thread and deleted several personal attacks and an astonishing amount of troll hunting. Please can we remind you that it is against our guidelines to troll hunt as it derails threads and causes strife and bad feeling, upsetting genuine OPs and delighting those who do happen to be trolls.
In future we expect that you will report any posts that concern you, and we take this opportunity to remind everyone that our patience is not endless when it comes to persistent guideline-breaching behaviour.

Happiestwhen · 11/12/2024 09:37

the7Vabo · 11/12/2024 09:13

There is a difference between history and the current IRA which are classed as a terrorist organisation.

Yes that's exactly my point , I was replying to the loyalist .

YesHesAPlonker · 11/12/2024 09:29

Allinarow48 · 11/12/2024 00:25

Thank you! I was always told not to tell people by my parents and I understand why!

I understand why as well, particular if you are in rural Kerry.

Antisemitism is a deep rooted prejudice, when it erupts it's volcanic - history has shown us that. The brutality of the Hamas attacks on ordinary people just living their lives, kids at a festival, people in their homes, has uncorked it in so many people. A normal human response to that brutality should be horror, not jubilation. Being a non practicing Jew, an anti Zionist Jew, an atheist Jew, did not, and will not, protect anyone. I'm not Jewish but I used to teach ABOUT AntiSemitism and its history. Like an idiot I thought it was largely a historical problem. I was very wrong. I have seen unhinged glorification of Hamas from people on the left, who I know and thought were pretty normal, I have pulled away from a number of people recently. My question to them was "If you are devastated and heartbroken at the death of children in Gaza are you also devastated and heartbroken at the death of children in Israel on Oct 7th? If not why not?"

Sadly being in Australia will be a factor, they have a huge Antisemitism problem ATM, the Australian Jewish community is feeling very much under siege, a Synagogue in Melbourne was destroyed in an arson attack last week, the attack has now been designated a terrorist attack and Australia has launched an Antisemitism task force.

Having a mental health issue, particularly if it involves any kind of psychosis, will make her very vulnerable to clinging onto beliefs which are unhinged. It doesn't necessarily mean she always was antisemitic, it just means that antisemitism now slots into her new world view, a world view which is disordered and she has no control over.

Sad though it is you cannot reason with anyone in that kind of mental state. For your own sanity and safety please just withdraw from the friendship, block her on social media.

ChessorBuckaroo · 11/12/2024 09:28

PurpleThistle7 · 11/12/2024 08:45

I'm Jewish. And I live in Scotland so I'm regularly the only Jewish person people have met. My young daughter has been pushed in the hall, had children yell horrible things in her face - and we had to get the police involved. She's never even been to Israel and is being associated with it just because she's Jewish. I'm anxious all the time. Every single day.

I'd never have that person anywhere around my children as who knows what would trigger her and what could happen. Generations of trauma have made most Jewish people pretty paranoid and unfortunately lately for good reason. The conflation of 'Jewish' and 'Zionist' is nonstop and the difference too subtle for many angry people to understand.

I work at a university so am surrounded by anti Israel sentiment that often drifts into antisemitism chants and such. It's everywhere and I have avoided work often as it's super triggering.

I'm sorry you feel you need to keep this secret but generations of Jewish people would empathise. Just remember that you're Jewish so your children are too and your 'friend' cannot be trusted. If you do meet her to try to help her, stay in public and be careful as she knows where you live.

Sorry you have had to go through this. That's awful that some ignoramuses would conflate the two things (Jews and Israel).

Many of the most passionate anti zionist (anti settler colonialism) speakers are Jewish. None better than Norman Finkelstein.

All settler colonialism is abhorrent wherever it takes place. What's amusing is OP's 'disgusted with Israel" friend lives in Australia...another white settler colonial hotbed. You would think if she is so outraged she would not be living in a land where the indigenous people, the Aboriginal people, were systematically reduced in number by being bred out of existence by mixing with the white settlers; this included removing aboriginal children from their families. The other major white settler entity, the kingpin of settler entities, america, it too would split up families (enslaved Africans) though for reasons other than whitening the skin colour...there's was just to buy a slave, regardless how old they were. One of the most harrowing examples being 9 year old Ashley who was separated from her mother after she was sold to her new slavemaster.

"Ashley's sack is a mid-1800s cloth sack featuring an embroidered text that recounts the slave sale of a nine-year-old girl named Ashley and the parting gift of the sack by her mother, Rose. Rose filled the sack with a dress, braid of her hair, pecans and "my love always".

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ashley%27s_sack

Ashley's sack - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ashley's_sack

Gettingbysomehow · 11/12/2024 09:16

I wouldn't tolerate someone with those views in my home. Let alone inflict them on my family. Tell her you are busy.

the7Vabo · 11/12/2024 09:16

AnxiousRose · 11/12/2024 09:15

As an Irish person living in Ireland for over 40 years I have NEVER met anybody who has openly stated that they are anti Jewish or pro Hamas.

Yes, there is lots of sympathy for Palestine and yes people are against what the Israeli government are doing in Gaza. But people are not anti Jewish or pro Hamas. Violence on every side is condemned.

To state that many Irish people support terrorist organisations such as the IRA and Hamas is untrue.

Thank you!

AnxiousRose · 11/12/2024 09:15

As an Irish person living in Ireland for over 40 years I have NEVER met anybody who has openly stated that they are anti Jewish or pro Hamas.

Yes, there is lots of sympathy for Palestine and yes people are against what the Israeli government are doing in Gaza. But people are not anti Jewish or pro Hamas. Violence on every side is condemned.

To state that many Irish people support terrorist organisations such as the IRA and Hamas is untrue.

the7Vabo · 11/12/2024 09:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Well there is on this thread anyways.

Do people do have the ability to understand that the views expressed in border towns and small rural communities are not universal?

To understand that being anti what Israel is currently doing in Gaza is not the same as being anti Jewish.

the7Vabo · 11/12/2024 09:13

Happiestwhen · 11/12/2024 09:10

Like it or not we wouldn't have a Republic if it wasn't for the old IRA so yes most of the country are proud that they stood up to a big nation and fought for their land and rights. Michael Collins is a hero in West Cork. He was part of the IRA.

There is a difference between history and the current IRA which are classed as a terrorist organisation.

Daradarina · 11/12/2024 09:13

OpheliaWasntMad · 11/12/2024 09:07

I think that’s very sad to hear.
I can see how it is hard to disagree with the majority view in Ireland . It does lead to being ostracised.
That might explain why the OP lacks the confidence to be more open in her own views
But that doesn’t explain why this “friend” has views that are so extreme and hateful.

It’s very, very far from the majority position in Ireland. Please don’t think it is.

BarbaraHoward · 11/12/2024 09:13

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

the7Vabo · 11/12/2024 09:12

OpheliaWasntMad · 11/12/2024 09:11

Sorry - I meant pro Palestinian ( which is a majority view)
I definitely didn’t mean to imply that the horrific anti semitism was a mainstream view.

Ok fair enough.

Sidebeforeself · 11/12/2024 09:11

Can whoever has asked every single person in Ireland their views on this please join this thread? Cos thats the only person who with any accuracy can say what the majority of Ireland think !

the7Vabo · 11/12/2024 09:11

Daradarina · 11/12/2024 09:08

But you have misunderstood I’m afraid.

You said

The social pressure to be anti Jews, probably Hamas, and so forth is immense. Disagreeing makes you a social pariah and ostracized.

and that is simply untrue.

If you believe it you are wrong, sorry.

I am talking about the majority position, so like OP it is probably true within certain small social groupings, but you are misrepresenting Ireland and Irish people as a whole.

I don’t think one has to list all that is wrong in the world to call out a situation as unacceptable either.
That’s ridiculous and clearly just an excuse not to listen.

This is so horrific to me that anyone considers in acceptable to mass generalise about Irish people.

OpheliaWasntMad · 11/12/2024 09:11

the7Vabo · 11/12/2024 09:09

It is NOT the majority view in Ireland.

Sorry - I meant pro Palestinian ( which is a majority view)
I definitely didn’t mean to imply that the horrific anti semitism was a mainstream view.

Swipe left for the next trending thread