Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be fed up of "you're daughter is nothing like you" comments from MIL

62 replies

DiaperDutyDiva · 01/12/2024 17:14

My MIL has this ongoing habit of constantly pointing out how much our daughter looks and acts like my husband. She calls her his “twin” and makes it clear she sees no resemblance between my daughter and me. This isn’t just a rare comment—it’s every single time she visits (which is 1-2 full days per month), whenever a photo is shared in our group chat, or even when she randomly sends us baby pictures of my husband with captions like, “Isn’t she the spitting image of her daddy?”

I’m not exaggerating when I say I hear some version of “You are nothing like her” at least a few times a week. My MIL will even say things directly to my toddler like, “You’re nothing like your mummy, are you? All daddy!” My husband brushes it off, saying she doesn’t mean any harm, but honestly, it’s exhausting and hurtful.

It’s not just about looks either. If our daughter does something clever or cute, like solving a puzzle or climbing well, my MIL will say things like, “That’s some clever genes from your daddy,” or “You’ve got good genes from your daddy.” It’s as if any positive trait she displays must come from him, never from me.

Objectively, my daughter has my hair color, my eye color, and a mix of features from both of us. She’s petite like I was as a child, while my husband was a chunky toddler. Yes, she resembles him, but she also looks a lot like me.

It’s reached a point where the comments feel less like innocent observations and more like constant jabs.

OP posts:
Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 01/12/2024 18:00

Point out to her that your daughter has a major difference from her son, and that that difference is going to become more marked as she grows…..

EvilsElsasPetSnowman · 01/12/2024 18:00

Grapewrath · 01/12/2024 17:59

my mil was the same and in the end id make comments like
’yea she’s so like her Dad, but then he’s like his Dad too- weird that neither dd or dh look nothing like you’

I love this.

EvilsElsasPetSnowman · 01/12/2024 18:00

I’d find this hurtful. And odd. Rebuff every time. Every. single. Time.

heres a non prescriptive list of retorts:

”It’s so weird you say that because literally everyone else says the opposite”
”Really because I think she looks like the milkman, haha”
”I see lots of her in me as does DH”
”She’s very much like me, thank god!”
”What does it matter?”

Also try and find a baby picture of you where you look like her and make a point of putting in the group “Look what I just found! Isn’t she my mini-me”

Grapewrath · 01/12/2024 17:59

my mil was the same and in the end id make comments like
’yea she’s so like her Dad, but then he’s like his Dad too- weird that neither dd or dh look nothing like you’

ohwhataluvverly · 01/12/2024 17:56

I think you are being a bit over sensitive. People see different things. Most children and adult have people saying they look more like one parent than the other and most will have had saying that about both parents at different times.

Besides it is well known that very young children and babies facially tend to resemble the father - it has a biological purpose to encourage bonding between father and child. In days of yore before DNA testing, the only way a father could tell this was his baby and not the baby of the caveman next door was by a resemblance - so it is very normal for babies and children to favour the father in looks but in many cases it lessens as they grow. Not alway obviously but in other words almost all babies look like their father but not true of almost all adults

DiaperDutyDiva · 01/12/2024 17:31

roseymoira · 01/12/2024 17:23

Stop inviting her, and don't share pictures in the group chat. She sounds nasty and spiteful, passive aggressive

I don't invite her, my husband insists that his mum must come 1-2 times a month - understandable because I also want my parents to see DC regularly.

I don't share pictures, DH does or sometimes SIL and BIL if they come visit, and I guess I can't stop them.

OP posts:
toomuchfaff · 01/12/2024 17:24

Delay your response: Toxic people may like to see an immediate reaction, so try to add distance between what they said and when you respond.

Explain that their words hurt: Calmly explain that their words were hurtful and that you don't appreciate being spoken to/about that way.

she knows what she is doing. I'd make a point to say that the comments are hurtful, just the once, then when she said something again ask her if she means to be hurtful, push it back to her to give her a chance to respond. She's in a no win there, she either admits to doing it to be hurtful, or she will come out with some other typical narc comment like "you're too sensitive "

Then at least you know what you're dealing with

Papergang · 01/12/2024 17:23

Yep you are absolutely not unreasonable OP, I think it’s a clumsy attempt to feel closer to her granddaughter by linking her to her side of the family and distancing her from yours. I reckon jealousy based and needs calling out if it’s upsetting you, or clap back with return comments about how much she’s like you/your mum then maybe she’ll get the hint

roseymoira · 01/12/2024 17:23

Stop inviting her, and don't share pictures in the group chat. She sounds nasty and spiteful, passive aggressive

LadyGabriella · 01/12/2024 17:18

God she sounds insufferable. Not sure what to advise. I’d stop engaging with her.

TheRainItRaineth · 01/12/2024 17:17

YANBU. It sounds miserable and exhausting.

Wildywondrous · 01/12/2024 17:16

Next time your husband does or says something nice or kind tell him he's nothing like his Mum.