Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be a bit annoyed to be told to ‘be the parent’?

167 replies

givemeaminuteplease · 29/11/2024 12:25

I know that people will read the title and jump to an immediate YABU but hear me out.

18 month old DD is at that stage where she’s not happy about the pushchair. Obviously she sometimes has to go in it and she will tolerate it for short periods then starts wanting to get out.

Discussing a local event with a friend we went to last year and I said quite light heartedly I would give it as miss this year as it was so busy and DD would not be happy about the pushchair. She got quite arsey and said I needed to ‘be the parent’ and DD would have to go in it.

But the whole point of the event is that it’s for children / a family day and if we don’t enjoy it because we’ve got a whining toddler arching her back and trying to escape then what’s the point? Surely that isn’t ’not being a parent’ it’s just common sense? Or AIBU?

OP posts:
Goldenbear · 29/11/2024 13:43

HMW1906 · 29/11/2024 13:31

My son is 21 months, he hates his pram but he doesn’t get a choice about whether he wants to go in it. He has an older brother and I’m not having him miss out on doing things because of his younger brother not liking the pram. I get him out of the pram at intervals for a break but he goes back in when I need him to. Maybe if he was an only child I’d just not bother going to stuff (although I doubt it).

My friend also have a 18 month old who hates the pram, they use a backpack carrier for her as she tolerates that better but again they don’t miss out on stuff just because she won’t go in the pram (but also have a older child so again they don’t want the eldest to miss out).

Yes but your youngest's needs should also be considered and spoken about with your eldest, it shouldn't just be one way, like the baby is an irritation, the eldest needs to emphasise with them and understand that it isn't all about them as otherwise they will acquire a Little Lord complex!

givemeaminuteplease · 29/11/2024 13:42

It is a bit strange though, how we have gone from ‘well, this event will be jam packed, DD will be crying and straining to get out of her pram, won’t be any fun for anyone, let’s give it a miss this year’ to ‘your child will never be on time for school.’

I mean, I work three days a week and we’ve yet to be late for work, nursery or preschool. Some stuff just has to be done, but stressing and losing our minds at a Christmas even isn’t one of them!

OP posts:
Lookingatthesunset · 29/11/2024 13:42

Ablondiebutagoody · 29/11/2024 12:54

The DD behaviour is dictating which family activities are suitable. That's a terrible state of affairs. She's the boss.......she just doesn't know it yet. Gonna be a nightmare when she realises.

That's just stupid. She won't always be 18 months old. It's a pragmatic and entirely reasonable decision to take!

Just avoid situations that you know will be challenging but be resolute when she acts up in ones you can't!

givemeaminuteplease · 29/11/2024 13:40

SisterAgatha · 29/11/2024 13:38

Hahah school… if she can’t get them in a pushchair she won’t be certainly won’t be getting them in to school 🤣

Her friend is a teacher, she probably sees parents like this shooing a child along at 9.25 every morning and then complaining they “just can’t get in on time”

Ask me what I do Wink

OP posts:
givemeaminuteplease · 29/11/2024 13:39

@HMW1906 i think there’s a compromise to be had.

I don’t stop DS doing things if DD might not enjoy it but equally - his life doesn’t revolve around her and hers doesn’t revolve around his.

As with most things there is a happy medium I suppose.

OP posts:
Allthehorsesintheworld · 29/11/2024 13:39

Any transition period with a toddler is challenging. When they hate the pushchair, when they go into a bed and find what fun it is to get in and out and in and out and when they give up the afternoon nap ( which is the worst imo)

The person who suggested the pull along cart - brilliant idea. I see lots of kids in these at car boots and there’s never one whining. Perhaps you could borrow one to try out?

SisterAgatha · 29/11/2024 13:38

WhimsicalGubbins76 · 29/11/2024 13:36

“I don’t like your tone”

Where do you think we are? School?? 🤣

Hahah school… if she can’t get them in a pushchair she won’t be certainly won’t be getting them in to school 🤣

Her friend is a teacher, she probably sees parents like this shooing a child along at 9.25 every morning and then complaining they “just can’t get in on time”

givemeaminuteplease · 29/11/2024 13:38

SisterAgatha · 29/11/2024 13:36

You realise those two three year olds and a four year old were also once 18 months and some people still managed to go out then.

You have options which accomodate you and the child

Let them walk
Get a side carrying sling
Pick them up
Dont go

And learn that just because some people have different experiences to you doesn’t mean they are boasting or trying to out do you.

Your tone is shitty anyway, I’m with your mate 🤣

Of course I realise that. But the poster was replying present tense. And I suspect being economical with the truth!

We get out and about absolutely loads, I just don’t tend to do activities that involve my children sitting in pushchairs for long periods. It’s not brilliant for their development anyway, although obviously sometimes you have to.

OP posts:
historyrepeatz · 29/11/2024 13:38

Is she being arsey about it because she wants you there and doesn't see your reason as ok. Would she still have a problem if you said you don't fancy it yourself this year?

WhimsicalGubbins76 · 29/11/2024 13:36

SisterAgatha · 29/11/2024 13:23

I posted in answer to you saying age changes things.

I don’t like your tone if I’m honest so - no worries, stay home and cry in to your cornflakes because you can’t work a pushchair then, no need to be rude.

It’s not my fault I lived in central London and still went out. I’m saying don’t go if you don’t want to. And FYI you can’t name change once you’ve posted once already.

“I don’t like your tone”

Where do you think we are? School?? 🤣

SisterAgatha · 29/11/2024 13:36

You realise those two three year olds and a four year old were also once 18 months and some people still managed to go out then.

You have options which accomodate you and the child

Let them walk
Get a side carrying sling
Pick them up
Dont go

And learn that just because some people have different experiences to you doesn’t mean they are boasting or trying to out do you.

Your tone is shitty anyway, I’m with your mate 🤣

damebarbaracartlandsbiggestfan · 29/11/2024 13:32

I had one of each OP! My eldest loved sitting looking out of the car windows on long drives, loved going in a backpack carrier on walks, and would happily sit in a high chair whilst we had leisurely lunches. My second spoke early and I think their spoken first phrase was 'want to get out'!😁

HMW1906 · 29/11/2024 13:31

My son is 21 months, he hates his pram but he doesn’t get a choice about whether he wants to go in it. He has an older brother and I’m not having him miss out on doing things because of his younger brother not liking the pram. I get him out of the pram at intervals for a break but he goes back in when I need him to. Maybe if he was an only child I’d just not bother going to stuff (although I doubt it).

My friend also have a 18 month old who hates the pram, they use a backpack carrier for her as she tolerates that better but again they don’t miss out on stuff just because she won’t go in the pram (but also have a older child so again they don’t want the eldest to miss out).

Toastghost · 29/11/2024 13:31

Not unreasonsble

although your friend is right, you just have to be the parent a lot of the time because you have no choice, if it’s supposed to be a nice day out and you know your toddler is going to miserable for two hours straight then why bother. I think some people don’t believe a kid can keep up a tantrum for that long. My first really, really hated the car seat and she used to scream her head off. She could keep it up for a really long time. I didn’t rush to travel anywhere I didn’t need to, for months until she grew out of that.

Unihorn · 29/11/2024 13:29

Mine both hated pushchairs, car seats, cots etc. so I adapted accordingly by not putting us all through the stress of certain days out unless I knew we'd enjoy them. They're both very well-behaved primary aged children now who are most definitely not the bosses in our house 😂

I agree with choosing your battles. Too many parents force young children to attend (often "Instagram-worthy") overblown and expensive events at this time of year when everyone's just having a crap time.

givemeaminuteplease · 29/11/2024 13:29

Sigh.

No, I’m not ‘rounding on someone who manages multiples.’ I’m pointing out that two three year olds and a four year old is not even remotely comparable to a toddler of around 18 months. Not even slightly.

I don’t have a tiny age gap or twins (my age gap is two and a half years almost to the day) but I do know that Ds, aged almost four, is not a toddler!

OP posts:
BunnyLake · 29/11/2024 13:28

Whether she’s right or wrong I wouldn’t appreciate a friend speaking to me like that.

PotteryOne · 29/11/2024 13:27

You ignore whinging etc and just get on with the day there, children learn very quickly if they have a parent that never gives in to them for an easy life

Or, you teach them that mummy and daddy don’t care about their feelings and preferences. You must know some super smart 18 month olds that can cry to manipulate a situation and stop when they realise their plans aren’t working. 18 month old DS2 must be stupid. If he’s crying he doesn’t stop until he’s comforted.

SisterAgatha · 29/11/2024 13:26

SisterAgatha · 29/11/2024 13:05

Id consider - is the gain worth the loss?

so will you get more out of being at the event than you will lose by spending time getting her in to the pushchair? Does the outcome outweigh the inconvenience.

If it does, YABU because sometimes you have to do hard things for long term gain. If not then YANBU because what’s the point. And be honest with yourself here, think of the gain to your child, not just the gain to you. You’d be doing her a disservice to not take her if she would actually benefit from it, just because it’s effort to you. You don’t have to go to everything but sometimes it’s worth it.

I wrote this first, then commented again because you seemed to round on like @Ladyj84 who can manage multiples.

i was showing you options like slings and letting the kid walk once in a while.

BogRollBOGOF · 29/11/2024 13:25

givemeaminuteplease · 29/11/2024 13:16

She’s normally pretty calm and chilled (applicable to both DD and friend to be fair!) but DD is my second and neither of my children have liked pushchairs or high chairs; high chairs have been a nightmare for them both, they just keep trying to escape.

It is fine, but i do inwardly marvel at people who sit in cafes and restaurants for long periods with a toddler in a high chair quite happy!

I still don't have that type a decade later. They like going out to eat... they don't see the point in pfolonged lingering especially after finishing eating. As a result we are selective about where we go to places with a faster turn around.
We stopped eating out with DS1 between 18m to about 3. Well to anywhere more ambitious than a cafe.

There are ND/ sensory issues in our equation but the point remains at why do something non-essential if it won't be pleasurable.

If it's something like an extended family catch-up, they cope better because of the cousin entertainment factor, so they meet what is required of them, and we're not suffering because we keep in a comfort zone of the likes of Nandos or carveries that is their comfort zone when it's just immediate family.

givemeaminuteplease · 29/11/2024 13:25

I didn’t explicitly say age changes things. I pointed out the poster answering me as if she has a comparable situation hasn’t - her three children are more than double the age of my youngest. I also have a three, very nearly four year old and it wouldn’t even occur to me to put him in a pushchair because he isn’t a toddler.

OP posts:
Hannahandlucy · 29/11/2024 13:25

Thepeopleversuswork · 29/11/2024 12:36

I mean technically she's probably right but its a very annoying and up yourself phrase and it would irritate me too. I just wouldn't presume to tell anyone how to parent.

Best answer

johnd2 · 29/11/2024 13:24

She's trying to be a motivational poster or something!
Honestly it's up to you so as the parent you decide what's best for your family as a whole. No two families are the same so as long as you're being the best version of yourself then that's job done.
However if it's stressing you out that you're missing out on all the things you want to do because of this, maybe it's time to get more forceful, but the misapprehension I had was that weekends were for going out and doing proper things with the kids, but actually they are for doing whatever suits us even if it's sitting at home recovering!
Take care and trust yourself.

SisterAgatha · 29/11/2024 13:23

I posted in answer to you saying age changes things.

I don’t like your tone if I’m honest so - no worries, stay home and cry in to your cornflakes because you can’t work a pushchair then, no need to be rude.

It’s not my fault I lived in central London and still went out. I’m saying don’t go if you don’t want to. And FYI you can’t name change once you’ve posted once already.

Franjipanl8r · 29/11/2024 13:23

Completely depends on the child and at 18 months most people have no idea if their child is neurotypical or not. You do what suits you and your child and ignore the snide comments.

Swipe left for the next trending thread