Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No snowboarding on school ski trip

231 replies

Gentillie · 28/11/2024 18:30

This is so frivolous I know!

My DD is Y8 she has two very close friends and they are all going on the school ski trip in January. Today one of the friends dad has complained in our group chat non stop about how they aren’t allowing his daughter to do any Snowboarding, he claims he’s offered to send her with equipment etc.
Now when it comes to it, it’s because his daughter is better at snowboarding, she’s been going on a trip with her dad every half term since she was a child and always doing private snowboarding lessons. He keeps making it clear she can ski but isn’t as advanced.
He’s now asked a slightly larger group chat of parents 7 kids worth, to join him in complaining to the school as it’s unfair she won’t get to snowboard.
One of the parents has pointed out that it will be because for lessons they will split into ability groups and even if they made a snowboard group she’d probably be too advanced as it would be a small minority who would pick it.
Others have agreed it’s very unfair and will be joining him in complaining.

AIBU to think he’s being very precious and his DD can ski with everyone else for 5 days? Is this normal in your kids school or do they let them ski or snowboard.

OP posts:
Scottishskifun · 29/11/2024 08:16

Sounds like the school doesn't have a teacher who snowboards and can keep up with the group bur if the letter was clear then he doesn't have any complaints to make.

Either she goes or doesn't sounds like he is foot stomping because that's the type of person he is!

Quite a lot of schools in our area have stopped doing snowboarding on the ski trip as too many were getting injured

AllstarFacilier · 29/11/2024 06:33

He had no reason to think snowboarding was included, even if it had in previous years, as the letter clearly stated it wasn’t. The trips have ratios of staff to students, and if there isn’t anyone to staff to advanced snowboarding group as he seems to want, it then the activity can’t go ahead. If all the parents complaining are doing so because they want their kids to snowboard too, then there could maybe be a shuffle in the groups. But if she’s the only one, or if the others are all going to be in the beginners group, I doubt they’d all be willing to pay the extra for another member of staff (plus possibly their supply cover) for her to be able to do it. He probably thinks he can take her himself and will expect her to still be involved in the activities with her friends despite not being part of the trip.

schmeler · 29/11/2024 06:27

Margzarita · 28/11/2024 23:17

There is a massive difference between. Having snowboarding lessons in England and going boarding in the mountains.

Oh there is no one was on about the difference. It was about the money and that if they didn't snowboard on the trip then they are missing out of an opportunity they would never get....bull, if they can afford such a high cost trip then they could afford a high cost activity was the point you missed.

StormingNorman · 29/11/2024 00:39

Saschka · 29/11/2024 00:31

Honestly the appeal for me (aside from boarding being much easier Grin) is that I don’t injure myself boarding, despite riding a lot harder than I ski.

When I skied regularly and not just pootling about on blue runs with DS after ski school, I used to twist my knee at least once per trip and need a few days laid up icing it.

Those sorts of injuries just don’t happen on a board (because your legs are tied together). Your joints are so much more protected on a snowboard.

I love to ski but the ease of walking in snowboard boots always tempts me. That and the feeling of falling through the air on the turns rather than fiddling about with poles! But overall skiing wins.

Saschka · 29/11/2024 00:31

Margzarita · 28/11/2024 20:25

That's interesting. I haven't been for a while and am going this year with the kids for the first time so it will be interesting to see if there are less boarders.

I agree that flats are harder to traverse on a board and certainly button lift are much harder to negotiate. But there are so many advantages, much more comfortable boots, easier to of piste due to the surface area and it is easier so a lot less likely to find your self on a run and out of your depth.

I respectfully disagree skiing is a better experience. When I worked a season we started with 5 boarders and 6 skiiers we ended with 9 boarders and 2 skiiers. Pre kids I started skiing with a group of 8 skiiers that is now 4 boarders, 3 skiiers and one does neither. I love snowboarding so much so I am going to sell my skis as I can't imagine I will ever go back to it.

Honestly the appeal for me (aside from boarding being much easier Grin) is that I don’t injure myself boarding, despite riding a lot harder than I ski.

When I skied regularly and not just pootling about on blue runs with DS after ski school, I used to twist my knee at least once per trip and need a few days laid up icing it.

Those sorts of injuries just don’t happen on a board (because your legs are tied together). Your joints are so much more protected on a snowboard.

GargoylesofBeelzebub · 29/11/2024 00:29

Ooooooh get YOU!! Skiing AND snowboarding. 😂😂😂😂 👜

StormingNorman · 29/11/2024 00:25

GargoylesofBeelzebub · 29/11/2024 00:16

Oh I'm very friendly pet. Also a very experienced skier who understands this is a school ski trip and not a family holiday. HTH

You don’t sound friendly hun. I understand the difference between a school trip and a holiday (obviously) but lots of posters were unsure how one might assume a ski trip would include snowboarding. As you’ll see from OP’s later posts, the ski trip had actually included snowboarding in past years. So, not an entirely outrageous assumption for the dad to make.

He can be criticised for behaving like a cunt, but not for starting from the assumption he did.

Congrats on being able to ski. I ski and snowboard. See you in Elevenereife next summer.

GargoylesofBeelzebub · 29/11/2024 00:16

Oh I'm very friendly pet. Also a very experienced skier who understands this is a school ski trip and not a family holiday. HTH

StormingNorman · 29/11/2024 00:11

GargoylesofBeelzebub · 29/11/2024 00:08

It's a school ski trip. Not a family holiday. Do you not understand the difference?

Aren’t you friendly? 😂😂😂

GargoylesofBeelzebub · 29/11/2024 00:08

StormingNorman · 28/11/2024 19:12

I grew up skiing and a ski holiday has always meant skiing and snowboarding. Within the ski holiday industry a ski holiday can mean skiing or snowboarding. Follow the link for an example…

It is not at all obvious to an experienced skier that a ski holiday does not include snowboarding. In fact it would be quite unusual. The usual assumption is that you could do either.

https://www.neilson.co.uk/ski?gadsource=1&gclid=CjwKCAiAxqC6BhBcEiwAlXp459gMJMx7w4TjDwnJ3Ion3B4d3tEPVvNr0EMfFZFABfVner4CjlT4xoCB2MQAvDBwE

Edited

It's a school ski trip. Not a family holiday. Do you not understand the difference?

GargoylesofBeelzebub · 29/11/2024 00:06

Cowboycorgi · 28/11/2024 18:49

I don't think he's being that ridiculous. Snowboarding is pretty standard. We live near the mountains & my kids go on ski days with school pretty regularly & and snowboarding, snow showing & tubing are the norm alongside sking. Maybe that's what he's used to?.

Talk about missing the point.

Margzarita · 28/11/2024 23:17

schmeler · 28/11/2024 22:44

If you can afford the ski trip and want to snowboard then your parents surely should put the money towards lessons at home not a big trip. There is no restrictions as the money is there so needs to be spent more wisely then!

There is a massive difference between. Having snowboarding lessons in England and going boarding in the mountains.

WinterSunshineBright · 28/11/2024 22:51

DanielaDressen · 28/11/2024 18:37

He's a twat. Don't book on a ski trip if you don't want to ski. Simple.

I feel sorry for teachers, it's a lot of work and stress organising such a trip and then they have to put up with this sort of shit.

This!

schmeler · 28/11/2024 22:44

Margzarita · 28/11/2024 19:49

OK I understand if a teacher has to accompany the lessons and they have no snowboarding teacher. It is a shame though as it means that children who would are trying it for the first time are having a restricted experience. I suppose as someone who can both ski and snowboard I wonder why the default offering is always skiing. Especially when snowboarding is so much easier and more fun.

If you can afford the ski trip and want to snowboard then your parents surely should put the money towards lessons at home not a big trip. There is no restrictions as the money is there so needs to be spent more wisely then!

Pipconkermash · 28/11/2024 22:35

“If she’s not very good at skiing yet, won’t she get better on a week’s trip?” innocent face

He sounds unbearable. He’s one of those people who’s obsessed with a hobby he perceives as ‘cool’ and ‘unusual’ enough to set him apart from others. He probably came to it late himself. And he’s being weirdly posturing and territorial about it. Just laugh at him.

Another2Cats · 28/11/2024 22:05

LaPalmaLlama · 28/11/2024 20:45

You're definitely right on the boots!! DS (140 is only a boarder, DD (12) can do both but prefers skiing and DH and I are firmly skiers so we ski as a mixed group. Possibly I'm scarred by having to tow DS across the flats and waiting for him to clip in in blizzard conditions Grin . If you go to France I guarantee you'll notice far fewer boarders than in the early naughties and more slanted towards Brits vs locals. I think one thing is that a lot of people my (then) age started boarding in the late nineties/ early naughties because "skiing is for the olds" and now that's sort of changed because middle aged people now board, so boarding is more of a personal preference vs. a "cool thing to do" IYSWIM. I wonder if generally deteriorating snow conditions have also impacted the choice to an extent- as in, is it easier to ski bad snow than board it? Not sure.

Thank you, this reply makes much more sense.

Like @Margzarita, I disagreed with your original comment; my own experience has been that boarding is generally easier/more fun and is still equally popular.

"...and now that's sort of changed because middle aged people now board, so boarding is more of a personal preference"

This did make me smile. I am very definitively a "grey on a tray" nowadays. I've just turned 59 and it's nice to know that I still count as one of the "middle aged people" who "now board"! I first went snowboarding when I was 29 back in the 1990s.

But, thinking about things, it has been several years since we've been snowboarding in Europe. We've been going to the USA and Canada in the last few years. The whole vibe there is very different indeed to a French or Swiss ski chalet.

btw, if you're ever concerned about lack of snow, then look to Japan. Especially the northern island of Hokkaido. They typically have 15 metres (yes, metres) of snow every year. Even the lower lying cities get around 5 metres a year.

LivinInYourBigGlassHouseWithAView · 28/11/2024 21:41

Snowboarding isn't part of the trip this year.

It's really that simple.

Can see why he's divorced. How awful for his poor ex wife and son.

Dad is showing himself to be an utter arse, absolutely full of himself, and he's busy ensuring everyone knows it.

Shame, really, as his daughter is likely to grow up just like him by the sound of it.

Onlyvisiting · 28/11/2024 21:29

'Never mind, I'm sure if she practices hard she will soon be able to manage 2 skis instead of one' 🤣

Of course I wouldn't say that as he is the twat, not his daughter.
But unless it is a winter sports trip I would point put that snowboarding and skiing are separate sports. Perhaps he should think about working on his reading and comprehension skill......

Idratherbepaddleboarding · 28/11/2024 21:18

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

Morefunhere · 28/11/2024 21:15

Are skiing and snowboarding rated equally for the safety? From my Skiing days I assume Staff Ratios and locality of runs are important factors.

another1bitestheduck · 28/11/2024 21:15

On this years letter it clearly stated that due to staffing no snowboarding would be offered.

This is the only important and relevant information.

It doesn't matter what happened in previous years. I'm sure there were lots of differences - wouldn't be surprised if the cost has increased for one thing. The school made it clear it was only skiing, his dd signed up on that basis, he doesn't have a leg to stand on. Doesn't matter if his (I'm assuming ex) was the one who actually received the letter, he obviously knew enough about it to agree to her going, whether her mum discussed all the details with him is nothing to do with the school!

Not only could the school fine him for taking his dd out during term time but surely he's also liable for the full school trip payment as well?
His poor dd is going to have a bit of a shock when she goes to uni and nobody cares how amazing she is (and when she is surrounded by others better than her!)

Cakeandusername · 28/11/2024 21:08

So they don’t now have a teacher who can accompany snowboarding group and made it clear on booking. He can’t want his dc alone unsupervised in a foreign country and I’m sure his dc would prefer to be with her friends.
I’m a volunteer girl guiding leader who goes on trips and it’s a definite trend that some parents only think of their child and fail to understand how different caring for a group and children that aren’t your own is.
Had a brownie mum complaining her dd hadn’t been allowed to buy a fizzy drink. Leader explained about how we couldn’t let a 7 yr old go to a bar alone in public bowling alley. Mum didn’t mean that - she meant leave the other kids unsupervised and take her child.

RawBloomers · 28/11/2024 21:05

Gentillie · 28/11/2024 19:23

Because I know what this dad is like.
His daughter has to be the best at everything especially sports and academia. His very musical and creative son may as well not exist though!

Him being a braggart doesn’t mean that this isn’t down to his DD really wanting to snowboard, though. However, if the letter said just skiing, it’s far too late for him to be kicking up a fuss now and it does make him look like a tit.

Are the parents separated? Some of the detail you’ve given sounds like it might be a bit of a tiff between the mum and dad playing out, too.

DaniMontyRae · 28/11/2024 21:02

katepilar · 28/11/2024 20:26

I personally would assume that a ski trip means both skiing and snowboarding, or a choice between the two.
Dont understand why people are saying it would make it more expensive, or need more staff.
I would also expect clear info from the school at the start as to how its going to be organised. Or better still, a discussion or a questionaire etc. to find out what is actually wanted.

It was clear from the start. The school's letter about the trip said it would be skiing only and that snowboarding was not on offer this year.

katepilar · 28/11/2024 21:01

ErrolTheDragon · 28/11/2024 20:31

Dont understand why people are saying it would make it more expensive, or need more staff.

This school has a teacher with each group. They do not have one now who snowboards.

People said that long before OP revealed that info about the snowboarding teacher gone.