Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MN makes me feel bad

136 replies

wilkoqueen · 28/11/2024 08:11

About everything.
My diet, my drinking habits, the screen time I allow my dc. I could go on. I take a lot of advice from here but I also try to remember that it's literally a bunch of strangers on the internet and anyone can say anything,
How reflective do you think MN is of real life? By MN standards I suspect I am a slovenly, unhealthy sub standard parent.

OP posts:
Berlinlover · 28/11/2024 09:50

Mumsnet has a major issue with age gap relationships especially when the male is older. My partner is 21 years older than me and I usually end up hiding most of the age gap related threads because the replies are so awful.

Flumoxed · 28/11/2024 09:46

I think there tends to be 2 types if people on mumsnet - the people who are struggling (with money, relationships, time management, motherhood...) and the people who want to brag about their perfect life and perfect morals. I think it is reflective of real life because both of those sets of people exist, but I would say that the vasy majority of people fall somewhere in the middle and slide up and down the scale on a daily basis depending on what else is going on in our lives. Sometimes we struggle with things, sometimes we manage. We all have things we do well and things we would rather other people sort out. Something easy to one person is hard for another and vice versa.

VegTrug · 28/11/2024 09:46

AwfulAmount · 28/11/2024 08:24

But you are the Queen of Wilko so you are winning. 👸

MN used to be less anonymous and therefore more supportive generally. Now you post something quite ordinary and people are attacking from all sides. It's crazy. But you are right, you don't know them. I know an influencer whose life is completely fabricated. It's total bollocks.

What sort of things does the influencer fabricate out of interest? Obviously not asking who she/he is I'm just fascinated as I'd always suspected that they do this

Ilovelurchers · 28/11/2024 09:39

Some.parts of the site are brilliant, which is why I come on. But it is very right wing and very middle class - obviously working class women who post on here get a very hard time.

I also notice that if anybody has slightly dodgy literacy or uses slang, they are picked on quite a bit.

So I would take it all with an enormous lump of salt if I were you OP.

Do you know anyone in real life who never gives their toddlers any screen time? I don't.

I had LOADS of screen time when I was little - loved it - and I still went on to do very well academically - went to Oxford University in fact (and I am from a fairly working class background so that wasn't easy)

My daughter had quite a lot of screen time and has grown up to be a high academic achiever and the loveliest person I ever met.

Some people just like to make their own lives harder, and their children's lives miserable. Let them crack on - and "tonight thank God it's them, instead of you."

Flumoxed · 28/11/2024 09:37

TheWorminLabyrinth · 28/11/2024 08:16

It's anonymous...people can, and do, say anything they like! I take everything on here with a truckload of salt. Isn't it something like only 4% of British adults earn this MN legendary 6 figure salary? Yet they're all on here, posting all day...

I often wonder the same thing! When do they earn their money? They are answering threads 8 hours a day!

WinterBones · 28/11/2024 09:35

Bogginsthe3rd · 28/11/2024 08:36

As a high earner, I agree three year olds shouldn't be having screen time.

good for you, would you like a cookie?

CharlotteRumpling · 28/11/2024 09:34

I think a lot of posters are ridiculously anxious and paranoid.

pooballs · 28/11/2024 09:31

No it doesn’t reflect RL for me, many mumsnet users seem weirdly uptight and wanting to take the moral high ground all the time. I’ve posted before that it can full of contradictions as well depending on the topic. Eg. if someone posts about going out and about with a cold you will get lots of stern and angry replies ‘So selfish spreading germs. I ensure to stay away from anyone until I’m not infectious!’ But then if someone posts about being off work with sickness it’s ‘I have never taken a single day sick leave in fifteen years. I would be seriously unimpressed at an absence like this. You can work with a mild cold!’

There are so many posters who just sound insufferable (but there is also nice, normal sounding people and good advice which is why I stay !)

LadyKenya · 28/11/2024 09:30

GretchenWienersHair · 28/11/2024 08:28

How reflective do you think MN is of real life?

I think it’s reflective of white, wealthy middle class women from wealthy middle class backgrounds in the south east. If, like me, you’re not all of those things, it’s probably not reflective of your real life.

This. I have been on MN for years, under a different username. I have periods where I have stepped back because the tone of the site has taken a dive imo. I would not log on here if it is affecting you too much OP.

SJM1988 · 28/11/2024 09:30

wilkoqueen · 28/11/2024 08:21

There is a thread at the moment about screen time for toddlers which I agree isn't ideal but my dd is currently to glued to Blippi while I attempt to have a coffee and get some washing done. People are saying 3 year olds should have no screen time and I just compare that with my own reality and feel like I'm doing things wrong somehow. That's just one example.

It regularly makes me feel like I'm doing life wrong. And yes I realise people might be lying but surely not everyone is. There is quite often some useful advice here so it would be nice to think most people are genuine.

I commented on that post as it felt so bias towards no screen time when in reality I know no one who has a no screen time policy for their 3 year olds!

I feel regularly I am doing things wrong but remind myself most people will only post the good stuff and online exaggerate alot of that. I try to comment on those sort of posts to make sure the OP does see there are also people doing things the way they are.

I once got roasted on a post for saying I took my DH surname when got married and because it was what I wanted....apparently that wasn't the right answer to some people.

Tireddadplus · 28/11/2024 09:29

It’s really handy for specific questions that I’m struggling with. Was a life saver during the first couple of years with a new baby! But I was also surprised at the perfectness of all the other parents as no one I see in real life is that good!

i felt like the worst parent ever after my DD at some tissue and I got 24 hours of hate. DD seems fine now 3 years down the line! Who knew.

CharlotteRumpling · 28/11/2024 09:27

Also never post in AIBU. Use other forums.

Darkmodette · 28/11/2024 09:27

Mumsnet was horrible during Covid. I was the worst side of people then. It was revolting

WinterBones · 28/11/2024 09:26

wilkoqueen · 28/11/2024 08:11

About everything.
My diet, my drinking habits, the screen time I allow my dc. I could go on. I take a lot of advice from here but I also try to remember that it's literally a bunch of strangers on the internet and anyone can say anything,
How reflective do you think MN is of real life? By MN standards I suspect I am a slovenly, unhealthy sub standard parent.

best piece of advice i ever had with regards to advice was 'take what serves, leave what doesn't'

Everyone has a different life, different circumstances, different health, different children with different needs... not everyone's thoughts or advice will suit you or work for you.

As a disabled parent with a disabled kid i have to take a lot of peoples thoughts about house work, hygiene, child rearing, appropriate amount to spend on the kids at christmas..etc with a pinch of salt because if i took it al to heart, i'd just give up.

Darkmodette · 28/11/2024 09:26

Anonymity brings out the worst in people. I wish there was a way around this

CharlotteRumpling · 28/11/2024 09:25

I don't take parenting advice from MN, generally. I am only here for entertainment and diversion. I took parenting advice from my mum.

Oganesson118 · 28/11/2024 09:23

My friend and I regularly comment on things we've said or done with "MN would hate it"

cloudydays2 · 28/11/2024 09:23

You need to take what people say online with a pinch of salt! Anyone can lie online, i'm sure their words don't reflect their lifestyle at all.

Lampzade · 28/11/2024 09:21

wilkoqueen · 28/11/2024 08:21

There is a thread at the moment about screen time for toddlers which I agree isn't ideal but my dd is currently to glued to Blippi while I attempt to have a coffee and get some washing done. People are saying 3 year olds should have no screen time and I just compare that with my own reality and feel like I'm doing things wrong somehow. That's just one example.

It regularly makes me feel like I'm doing life wrong. And yes I realise people might be lying but surely not everyone is. There is quite often some useful advice here so it would be nice to think most people are genuine.

My three spent an inordinate amount of time in front of the tv when they were toddlers.
Nickelodeon and the Cartoon Network were their unpaid babysitters
i didn’t cook from scratch daily, oven chips and nuggets were usually the order of the day.

They are all teens/ early twenties now and are lovely , sensible and well rounded .

Some people on MN are genuine. However, I take most of what is said on here with a pinch of salt

BarbaraHoward · 28/11/2024 09:21

wilkoqueen · 28/11/2024 08:21

There is a thread at the moment about screen time for toddlers which I agree isn't ideal but my dd is currently to glued to Blippi while I attempt to have a coffee and get some washing done. People are saying 3 year olds should have no screen time and I just compare that with my own reality and feel like I'm doing things wrong somehow. That's just one example.

It regularly makes me feel like I'm doing life wrong. And yes I realise people might be lying but surely not everyone is. There is quite often some useful advice here so it would be nice to think most people are genuine.

I'm on that thread saying the OP should just go cold turkey during the week, but that's because it isn't working for her or her DC. I have one that could have the TV on all day and be grand, and one that really struggles with it going off, especially on busy weekdays.

If Blippi lets you get a coffee, then you savour that coffee. And tune out Blippi, because I'm not familiar but I'm betting it's hella annoying. Grin

I don't think MN is representative. IRL everyone I know opens the door when it rings, no matter if they're expecting anyone. Wink

Take what's useful from it and ignore the rest, and if it's getting under your skin just leave and enjoy your life. Smile

PixieTrance89 · 28/11/2024 09:18

I don't care what people think of me as a parent, I do what I need to do to stay sane and get things done, my 4 month old baby is currently sat watching nursery rhymes so I could wash up and get laundry done without her screaming, some people would probably have something to say about that but I don't care, in my opinion it's better for her to be happily entertained by some cartoon animals than getting upset and screaming because I'm not in the room

Ceeceele · 28/11/2024 09:14

GretchenWienersHair · 28/11/2024 08:28

How reflective do you think MN is of real life?

I think it’s reflective of white, wealthy middle class women from wealthy middle class backgrounds in the south east. If, like me, you’re not all of those things, it’s probably not reflective of your real life.

I don’t even think it’s reflective of that - I think it’s reflective of people online pretending to be that.

FOJN · 28/11/2024 09:11

....but I never realised how chilled out I am until I came on here. There are so many people on here stressing about nothing, unhappy and judgemental and unable to connect with other humans.

Me too. I've never described myself as laid back but compared to some posters on MN I'm horizontal. I wonder how some people get through the day with the amount of things they worry about and get irritated by.

You're doing fine OP, be grateful you don't get worked up over largely inconsequential matters.

Wishimaywishimight · 28/11/2024 09:11

I read MN like it's a problem page of a magazine. Back in my youth I always skipped to the problem pages first (anyone remember 'Cathy and Clare'?)

erihskreb · 28/11/2024 09:09

Most people have it together in a couple of areas but not all of them, and that doesn’t come across very strongly on a forum with thousands of different posters. So for example a poster might say that they don’t use screens for their DC and clean their home to a high standard but what they don’t say is that they don’t work. Or someone might say that they’re a high earner but not mention that they don’t have time for a healthy lifestyle. But reading those posts together gives the impression that everyone has everything together.

And sometimes people might be saying what they think the best thing to do is regardless of whether they actually do it - I think limiting screen time under 3 is a WHO recommendation but saying that doesn’t tell you about my own approach.

Swipe left for the next trending thread