Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to feel this was odd and dismissive?

81 replies

JensenButtonsBellyButton · 27/11/2024 23:01

This happened a while ago but it comes into my mind occasionally so wanting some outside perspective.

DH, 2 kids and I were attending DH’s uncle’s funeral at other end of country so long drive. On arrival at aunt’s house found that she wanted DH and his brother ( her nephews) to be in funeral cars. I was a bit taken aback as we’d come as a family, but ok. So SIL and I drove our cars ( with our kids) to the funeral.
On arrival we discovered that main funeral party ( aunt, her kids and their partners, DH, BIL and my MIL) were of course sat in front two rows. But, and here’s where I’m not sure if I’m being unreasonable, there was nowhere for us to sit. They hadn’t kept any seats for me, SIL and our kids. It was full so we had to stand at the back.

AIBU to think this was…odd?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
devongirl12 · 07/12/2024 15:39

No, it wasn't odd.

No, it wasn't dismissive.

It wasn't about you.

Funerals are not the time for this. You turned up, that's it, job done. There is nothing more to it.

Onceachunkymonkey · 07/12/2024 15:23

I think something is lost here, as I can’t believe for one moment you actually thought you should be in the funeral cars and reserved seating up front. Surely not.

housethatbuiltme · 07/12/2024 15:20

JensenButtonsBellyButton · 07/12/2024 00:56

You have made a huge amount of insulting assumptions here.
Of course it’s not about me.
It was a huge loss to my DH- the family is incredibly close. Why do you assume I barely knew him? Isn’t it natural to want to sit with him?

Isn’t it natural to want to sit with him?

also once again MASSIVELY telling, how are you making the death of someone elses family member all about what YOU want. What you want really doesn't matter one ounce because as said before its not about you.

housethatbuiltme · 07/12/2024 15:14

JensenButtonsBellyButton · 07/12/2024 00:56

You have made a huge amount of insulting assumptions here.
Of course it’s not about me.
It was a huge loss to my DH- the family is incredibly close. Why do you assume I barely knew him? Isn’t it natural to want to sit with him?

well one just factually you lived at opposite ends of the country so highly unlikely to have a really involved relationship where you are active parts of each other lives.

And two, and this is the key one... your whole attitude told on you. If you lost someone you where close you would NOT be thinking of yourself and then dwelling on it all this time later way you would be busy dealing with grief instead.

Ellie1015 · 07/12/2024 09:10

JensenButtonsBellyButton · 07/12/2024 00:56

You have made a huge amount of insulting assumptions here.
Of course it’s not about me.
It was a huge loss to my DH- the family is incredibly close. Why do you assume I barely knew him? Isn’t it natural to want to sit with him?

If course you want to he there for dh. And also perfectly natural he prioritised being there for his aunt/parents over needing support himself.

They arrived, there was no space for you, did you want dh to come stand with you? Did you want aunt to ask those who arrived earlier to move? Did you expect aunt when planning funeral to more accurately estimate the number of rows to be reserved? That is not easy, and i expect funeral direcors kept 2 rows which is pretty standard. Unfortunately thst wasnt enough but it isnt odd or rude to you or sil.

Nolegusta · 07/12/2024 07:01

No, not odd at all.

User820825 · 07/12/2024 07:00

Isn’t it natural to want to sit with him?

Sure but that didn't work out on the day.

You didn't end up sitting with him. That doesn't make it 'odd'. You've already said that the other relatives were the main funeral party.

You wanted them to keep seats at a funeral. In my experience, people expect close family to sit in the first couple of rows as you describe and that's what happened.

Other than that, people don't 'keep seats' like lunch in an American teen movie. I honestly can't imagine shuffling in to a row at a funeral and someone saying 'actually, we are keeping those seats for Dave's nephews wife and children who live at the other end of the country.'

CRD67 · 07/12/2024 01:55

Whi take kids to a funeral? Too young to understand and upsetting for them. The deceased won't mind.

JensenButtonsBellyButton · 07/12/2024 00:56

housethatbuiltme · 05/12/2024 16:20

I think you need to remember its not about you.

This isn't your family at all and is at best distant family of your kids who I'm guessing they had little relationship with. Obviously your DH is much closer to this family member and/or those grieving him.

Being upset you weren't honored enough at someone you barely knows funeral is really quite tactless.

People comparing it to their or DH PARENT dying are missing that this is a long distance UNCLE. OP is not the persons DIL, she is not supporting her DH through great loss, this is not her DC grandparents. Her DH is their to support his parents/aunt through their big loss. OP attendance means little to nothing and is just for social appearance.

You have made a huge amount of insulting assumptions here.
Of course it’s not about me.
It was a huge loss to my DH- the family is incredibly close. Why do you assume I barely knew him? Isn’t it natural to want to sit with him?

OP posts:
MoonWoman69 · 07/12/2024 00:47

That's perfectly normal. From my experience of the many funerals I've been to and the couple I've had to organise.
What I don't find normal is that after all this time, you're still stewing over it?! That's rather odd to me!
We can be put out about a lot of things, but we shrug and move on. As long as Uncle had a good send off, that's all that matters surely? Not the seating arrangements, which were the norm as funeral etiquette dictates.

sunshinestar1986 · 07/12/2024 00:11

I mean, why not say, funeral is for principles mourners only, so they could just stay home?
Why bother ask/expect them to come at all?

Ellie1015 · 06/12/2024 21:01

I dont think nephews wives and great neices/nephews are close family. I expect Aunt thought of her own children/grandchildren her partners siblings and partners. Likely nephews were last minute decison which is nice, not an insult to you.

Sillyname63 · 06/12/2024 20:30

Usually the funeral directors keep seats for the family and extended family but if they were not told you were attending they would not know, perhaps Your DH' s Aunt didn't know you would be attending. I personally wouldn't have taken children to a funeral.

beautifuldaytosavelives · 06/12/2024 20:00

Weird. Family before friends in the seating, and outrageous to split nuclear families up.

AllyArty · 06/12/2024 19:32

I think the row behind the chief mourners should have been kept for you & sil and all your children.

H0210zero · 06/12/2024 19:32

I think this is perfectly normal, I've been outside the crematorium watching on a screen from.outside with other family members for relatives closer than his uncle so to you. I think you need to get over yourself. A man has died show a bit of respect and pay your respects and move on. Surely you aren't so daft to understand that your not a priority his immediate family is. Clearly his aunt wanted her nephews there which is her choice. But she's hardly going to make room for you and the kids if it's not a tiny funeral. I've known funerals where there has been siblings and cousins stood outside because of lack of room. Both crematorium funerals and church funerals/burials etc.

Bugbabe1970 · 06/12/2024 19:04

Family in the first few rows then friends!

Calloja23 · 06/12/2024 19:03

Normally at funerals the person. Person has n cusrge asks for a certain number of pews/seats to be reserved for family having discussed with next of kin. I do find it odd that you had to stand atbthe back as family, and that is not the norm. However, unless exceptionally close and directly related, depending on age, I don’t think it’s a place for children, if young especially. It’s not like a wedding or a party is it?

independentfriend · 06/12/2024 18:02

Somebody underestimated how many people would come, which gives you the 'great turnout' line at the expense of sufficient seating for you and your sister in law and children:-/

Not everybody can stand reasonably still, comfortably, for an hour. Venue staff ought to have found some folding chairs / have an overflow room so you didn't have to stand.

LadyTiredWinterBottom2 · 06/12/2024 09:01

No it's not odd. It was bust, they had other priorities over saving seats. Saving seats is odd.

Bollocksmorelike · 06/12/2024 08:58

Sounds perfectly normal to me. Front row is for the primary mourners. Everyone else is expected to act appropriately and just sit/stand wherever.

Calamitousness · 06/12/2024 06:07

YABU op. This is totally normal. Seats for direct family in front rows only. You should have gone ahead to get seats at the back not followed funeral cars. I can’t believe you continue to think about this.

RosieLeaf · 06/12/2024 05:46

All normal.

User820825 · 06/12/2024 05:36

OP should have been warned there would be no seats for her (or kept for her) so she could decide to stay home.

People don't know how many mourners will be at a funeral.

Someone had to stand. It's just something that happened. Why should it not be the op? I just don't understand how anyone could be so put out by standing at a funeral of driving to it without their spouse.

Itissunnysomewhere · 05/12/2024 23:15

Makes sense for children to be near the back I think