Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why older women constantly ask if I have children, as opposed to if I have a partner?

111 replies

ThisLoudBeaker · 24/11/2024 16:00

I’m single and in my early 30s. Older women who are mums constantly ask me if I have children, as opposed to if I have a partner. This makes no sense to me. One surely comes before the other, so why not ask the appropriate question if you must ask?

These same women also become extremely awkward when you say you don’t have children and follow up with condescending comments like “your time will come,” or if they ask if I have a partner after I say I don’t have kids, they’ll say “give it time/your time will come. No rush.” These comments are so unnecessary.

Most of the women that ask these questions and make these comments don’t even seem content themselves.

OP posts:
nfkl · 24/11/2024 16:44

OP, to quote with a slight edit your latest post

"It’d be so refreshing if people could just accept a [QUESTION] without trying to dissect or challenge it."

Same back to you, 15-love, and all that.

Eyresandgraces · 24/11/2024 16:44

Guess what?
They're making conversation.
Tbf if you were a man they would probably ask what you do for work followed by do you have dc.

Only at job interviews or on dates has anyone said - Tell me about yourself.

Lallydallydune · 24/11/2024 16:42

ThisLoudBeaker · 24/11/2024 16:41

Exactly this! It’s not the question itself that’s the issue - it’s the assumptions and follow-up comments that often come with it. It’s like some people can’t fathom that choosing not to have kids is a valid and fulfilling decision, or that some women simply haven’t had kids yet. I think it makes them uncomfortable because it challenges their own life choices or societal norms they’ve internalised. It’d be so refreshing if people could just accept a no without trying to dissect or challenge it.

They ask everyone.

I used to just shake it off. Some older women are still very old fashioned

DebtinVegas · 24/11/2024 16:42

Ask them.

ThisLoudBeaker · 24/11/2024 16:41

PinkArt · 24/11/2024 16:32

I don't mind being asked if I have kids. I do mind if my answer of no leads to all the 'plenty of time yet' or 'you'll change your mind' kind of replies. Women actively and enthusiastically choosing not to have kids seems to make some people, usually mums in my experience, quite uncomfortable.

Exactly this! It’s not the question itself that’s the issue - it’s the assumptions and follow-up comments that often come with it. It’s like some people can’t fathom that choosing not to have kids is a valid and fulfilling decision, or that some women simply haven’t had kids yet. I think it makes them uncomfortable because it challenges their own life choices or societal norms they’ve internalised. It’d be so refreshing if people could just accept a no without trying to dissect or challenge it.

OP posts:
BreatheAndFocus · 24/11/2024 16:41

It’s a more neutral question to ask about children than partners IMO. These women aren’t judging you and I doubt they care whether you have children or not. They’re just making polite conversation.

Why does this bother you? Is it because they ‘got the order wrong’ and should have asked about a partner first? I don’t get it. Lots of women have children but no partner - for any number of reasons. These women are trying to find topics of conversation. Asking about children is an easy way to start a conversation. It allows the other woman to answer briefly or expand, as she wishes.

SilverBlueRabbit · 24/11/2024 16:40

Fairyliz · 24/11/2024 16:34

To be fair in this instance I wouldn’t bite my tongue if I was you.

Oh and this. I did not meet DH until i was in my 30s and had my first Ds late into my 30s. A friend of my mother's asked me a few years before that what i was doing with myself these days and when I said I'd recently been employed in a very high powered international job she laughed in my face and said' 'Oh you poor fool- you'll never get a husband with that attitude!'. It was said with such contempt like I was less than shit on her shoe.

Lallydallydune · 24/11/2024 16:40

ThisLoudBeaker · 24/11/2024 16:05

These comments usually come from older women I encounter in social settings, work, or even casual conversations - whether it’s at family gatherings, events, or just chatting with acquaintances. It’s not like it happens daily, but it’s often enough to feel noticeable and frustrating. It feels like there’s this assumption that children are the ultimate goal, and if you don’t have them, something must be missing in your life.

I just don’t understand why they jump straight to kids without even asking if I have a partner first - it feels like they’re skipping a step! It’s not malicious, I’m sure, but the condescending follow-up comments make it worse.

It seems to be a passage of life!

I used to get all those comment when I was in my early 30s too.

Now I'm 40, they don't say it to me anymore.

Fire86 · 24/11/2024 16:40

I guess for these “older women”, their kids are, and always will be - the most important people in their lives….and they’re looking to relate to others about that. Ok, so perhaps it’s clumsy, but some people are.

lightsandtunnels · 24/11/2024 16:40

I agree with some pps that have said it's most probably women making conversation. Lots of women have children and families and talking about families is something that people do when they get together and don't know each other that well. You're not usually going to get into a deep and meaningful conversation about politics, war or the natural world when you meet someone briefly. It's kind of common ground, I guess, as we all have a family (of some description) even if it's close friends etc. Better than talking about the weather I guess!
I think we can always find something to be offended about when offense was never intended, if we try hard enough!

Snorlaxo · 24/11/2024 16:39

How much older ?

I started a new job earlier this month and do you have kids is a bonding question. So I told one woman that my dd is at uni and we discussed what she was studying and what her son at uni was studying too. There’s a good chance that someone your age has kids so it’s a common question to ask like “Did you travel far today ?” (Not a dig at people who aren’t local)

The follow up comments like you have plenty of time is rude though. Not everyone wants or can have kids and that assumes that you want kids.

I agree with pp that asking about kids is more interesting than asking about a partner. Half of marriages end in divorce and you don’t want to kill the conversation when you ask someone whose marriage ended in sad circumstances.

SilverBlueRabbit · 24/11/2024 16:37

It's usually because 'partners' come and go but children are forever. And at the end of the day by the time you get to your age OP most partners have proven only to be a bit disappointing.

Fire86 · 24/11/2024 16:37

Sounds like they’re just trying to make conversation.

ThisLoudBeaker · 24/11/2024 16:37

Fairyliz · 24/11/2024 16:30

Could you give us a list of appropriate questions to ask to get to know someone op?
I’m an older woman, don’t want to inadvertently upset someone by actually being interested in them.

It’s not about being interested or asking questions - it’s more about how those questions come across. For example, instead of jumping straight to ‘Do you have kids?’ or assuming it’s a given, a more open question like ‘What keeps you busy these days?’ or ‘Tell me about yourself’ can feel less presumptive. It gives the other person space to share what’s important to them, rather than feeling boxed into specific life milestones.

OP posts:
CurlewKate · 24/11/2024 16:35

@ThisLoudBeaker " But I get what you’re saying, and it’s definitely frustrating no matter who’s doing it."

Not as bloody frustrating that the constant "older women are like this" narrative that abounds.

Fairyliz · 24/11/2024 16:34

ToBeOrNotToBee · 24/11/2024 16:31

I know exactly what you mean.
One friend of a friend particularly, every time I see her it's the same "no kids yet??".
I'm very sorely tempted to reply "no, seeing you so haggard and miserable put me off". Instead I bite my tongue.

To be fair in this instance I wouldn’t bite my tongue if I was you.

PinkArt · 24/11/2024 16:32

I don't mind being asked if I have kids. I do mind if my answer of no leads to all the 'plenty of time yet' or 'you'll change your mind' kind of replies. Women actively and enthusiastically choosing not to have kids seems to make some people, usually mums in my experience, quite uncomfortable.

ToBeOrNotToBee · 24/11/2024 16:31

I know exactly what you mean.
One friend of a friend particularly, every time I see her it's the same "no kids yet??".
I'm very sorely tempted to reply "no, seeing you so haggard and miserable put me off". Instead I bite my tongue.

5128gap · 24/11/2024 16:31

Its because all older women are bitter, jealous, insecure and unhappy with our lives. Our one remaining pleasure being to upset younger women. If we're not MiL with a DiL on tap to annoy, we make do with asking younger women questions designed to annoy them, but cunningly disguised as making conversation. You have clearly seen through our ruse OP, so will be ahead of the game when on your 40th birthday you will required to start annoying younger women yourself.

Fairyliz · 24/11/2024 16:30

Could you give us a list of appropriate questions to ask to get to know someone op?
I’m an older woman, don’t want to inadvertently upset someone by actually being interested in them.

Dilbertian · 24/11/2024 16:28

TBH if I'm interested in you then I'm far more interested in whether you have dc than whether you have a partner. Partners may come and go, but dc are part of you.

But if you said you didn't then I would just accept it (and not bend your ear with stories about mine). None of my business why, and I certainly would not patronise you with 'your time will come' - what a🤮 thing to say!

ForPearlViper · 24/11/2024 16:28

Are all these questioning older women in the room with you right now, OP?

bluebee17 · 24/11/2024 16:27

Just making conversation I imagine sometimes that's all it is doesn't have to a reason behind it.

ThisLoudBeaker · 24/11/2024 16:26

ruethewhirl · 24/11/2024 16:21

Hmm I'm 50/50 on this. As a childfree woman I agree this line of conversation can be frustrating, especially comments like 'there's still time' which assume all women want children. But I'm wishing you hadn't specified older women, because I haven't found this to be specific to older women at all. I'm older myself and I know better than to do this, because I've been badgered so often myself about my reproductive choices - by women of various ages, not just older women. (And to be clear, by 'badgered' I don't mean simply being asked if I have children. I'm talking about the intrusive questioning and commentary that so often accompanies the answer 'no'.)

I totally agree that the intrusive commentary can come from people of all ages - it’s not exclusive to older women. I only mentioned older women because, in my experience, that’s where it’s happened most often. But I get what you’re saying, and it’s definitely frustrating no matter who’s doing it.

OP posts:
Henrythehappypig · 24/11/2024 16:25

I have friends with partners and no children. I have friends with children and no partner. If my DCs came up naturally in the conversation I might ask if someone had kids because there
might then be a shared experience. I don’t think I would ever ask someone if they had a partner as I can’t really think of anything that would be a natural extension to a conversation on that context - unless I was having a moan about something but even then I probably wouldn’t. Maybe because am older and friends have been through some pretty brutal splits.

Swipe left for the next trending thread