Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

…to ask what to do about my former employer trying to ruin my life any way they can for their own amusement?

280 replies

Renegader · 22/11/2024 21:37

Hi MNers,

Unfortunately back in September I was dismissed from my job due to failure of probation. This was the next working day after I took a few hours off which I requested TOIL to go the vet to seek an update on the cat I rescued from outside my workplace. My manager whom was very controlling and acted angrily to any kind of challenging of his ‘authority’ used this as a reason to fail my probation and dismiss me immediately. I sought legal advice and was told as I was in probation there’s not much I can do, even though I wasn’t even on a warning nor did I commit any kind of misconduct.

My weasel of a manager calls me after the charity manager dismisses me saying he was having a stressful day and didn’t think his boss would actually fire me even though he blew the cat situation out of proportion and knows she is very harsh. He said to give him as a reference for any future jobs and that he is so sorry about everything, so that’s what I did.

Fast forward to today and I get an email from a job I was due to start in a few weeks saying they are withdrawing the job offer as my former manager would only provide a basic reference thus raising a red flag for them. This was when he said he would give me a positive reference. I was good at my job and my clients I supported were very happy with me.

I have been in tears for most of the day, feeling completely powerless and hopeless about my future. Am I going to be blacklisted from this sector because I did a good deed and stood my ground about it? I need a job, this cat is expensive and I feel like my former manager and employer are trying to ruin my life. Because of their inept Payroll team I am also having my Universal Credit slashed by 20% as my employer took a Direct Earnings Attachment from my salary for a previous DWP advance then appear to not have actually sent the monies to HMRC as DWP told me they have no record of it despite the deductions being on my payslips. So, in conclusion, they sabotaged my employment with them, my benefits whilst out of work and now my future employment prospects. The most laughable thing is they are supposed to be a mental health charity but are doing everything in their power to push me to despair! Any advice on how to overcome this would be much appreciated, thanks in advance.

OP posts:
ItTook9Years · 23/11/2024 12:08

Juno86 · 23/11/2024 11:50

And to be honest if the new place is seeing a bog standard reference as a “safeguarding issue” then I wouldn’t want to work for them anyway.

Edited

please read the posts about safer recruitment.

I’m pretty sure you don’t want an unreliable nurse or carer with professional incompetencies looking after you and your loved ones.

pinkdelight · 23/11/2024 12:02

Something else to consider is your TOIL. Was the hours officially banked? In lots of workplaces, there is an expectation to complete work within the agreed hours. Regularly working additional hours can be a sign that either the employee has too much work or isn't managing their workload. It would be usual for the employee and line manager to discuss it. From the pov of the employer, an excess of additional hours to be taken back can be a red flag in itself.

This is a good point. And coupled with the 'few weeks off', it makes me wonder if it wasn't so much that you'd done lots of extra hours so we're owed TOIL, but maybe you weren't managing to get all your work done as you'd been off so much. That may not be the case, but it's an odd combination to be off so much and yet still have time owed during probation. All adds to the picture of this not being the right workplace for you anyway. I also agree that if the new co asked virtually any further questions about your reasons for leaving, your manager wouldn't be able to impart that info positively regardless of ego. The bottom line is that you were let go because of your own actions, so better to own that, get help with your MH and start over, not including this role on your cv.

Juno86 · 23/11/2024 11:50

And to be honest if the new place is seeing a bog standard reference as a “safeguarding issue” then I wouldn’t want to work for them anyway.

CallMeFlo · 23/11/2024 11:50

Whether you agree with why I needed TOIL or not, it is wrong that my employer are still trying to sabotage my future employment just because of ego or to make a point

Jeez you're over dramatic. Between this & the thread title.

That's not what's happening. Your ex employer has, as about a dozen folk have already said, given a standard reference. For some reason the other employer seems to want more. The issue is with them if it's with anyone.

Your previous employer isn't sabotaging anything

Juno86 · 23/11/2024 11:48

So you’ve just lost your job over this cat. This cat is expensive and adding to your financial stresses.

I mean maybe you just…don’t let this cat ruin your life?

Citrusandginger · 23/11/2024 11:30

I did call and text, they weren’t replying and my OCD was going into overdrive about how it would be all my fault if the cat was dying and I was just sat at home working in a job where I was treated like shit constantly.

@Renegader, along with others I hope you are able to get support for your health. I think you would have made different decisions if you had been well.

Safer recruitment has been mentioned - in health it's often known as fit and proper persons rules. For some roles, employers have a regulatory responsibility to confirm the reason for leaving a job. You might want to look for jobs with less strict recruitment requirements for a time so that you can rebuild your CV.

Something else to consider is your TOIL. Was the hours officially banked? In lots of workplaces, there is an expectation to complete work within the agreed hours. Regularly working additional hours can be a sign that either the employee has too much work or isn't managing their workload. It would be usual for the employee and line manager to discuss it. From the pov of the employer, an excess of additional hours to be taken back can be a red flag in itself.

Wimberry · 23/11/2024 11:06

Op you have lots of good advice and information on this thread, just to mention about your point of 'safeguarding ' and being made to feel like a 'pervert' - in this context it's much more likely that by 'safeguarding' the prospective employer is using it in the context of not being able to take a risk on someone who has failed probation at another job. They have vulnerable clients and need to protect them by having consistent, reliable staff. There are other considerations for charities; recruiting is expensive, managing staff through HR/disciplinary type issues is difficult and expensive and they don't want to take the risk.
I'm sorry but they are well within their rights to decline your job offer on the basis of a failed probation and your sickness record, so you don't have any scope to 'prove' that your last employer was unfair. They have enough factual information to rescind the offer.

Please focus on your mental health, perhaps look at low pressure ways to build up your CV again and I'm sure you'll be able to get something in future

ItTook9Years · 23/11/2024 11:00

AIBU really is the worst place for employment advice.

ItTook9Years · 23/11/2024 11:00

Sorry - wrong post quoted. (Not had caffeine yet!)

ItTook9Years · 23/11/2024 10:59

Type2whattodo · 23/11/2024 10:53

I hire people and only ask 4 questions in a reference check:

  1. Dates of employment
  2. Job title
  3. Reason for leaving
  4. Would you rehire the person?

For you, the reason for leaving would be given as failed probation. The answer to 4 would therefore be no automatically.
I'd fail probation for more than 1 absence/3 days in a 6 month period unless extreme circumstances.
Probation is you on your best behaviour so if you are already questionable on probation, a manager will assume that you will be a nightmare to manage once employment rights kick in.
I assume you are quite young and I don't feel that society is setting young people up for success.

You go to work, arrive and leave on time. Dress and behave appropriately. Your boss is not your mum. Don't tell them all your personal details.
Why does a boss of such a short period know you have debt and all the other personal things about your life?
Save it for friends and family.

So you aren’t employing client facing staff in a mental health setting like the OP’s employer then……….

🙄

OP is clearly an employment liability at the moment and somehow that message has got through to the new employer.

OP needs to take some responsibility and learn from this in readiness for the challenges of whatever she does next.

twentysevendresses · 23/11/2024 10:57

Oh lord OP, you seem to have your priorities very mixed up! You didn't 'have to' physically go to the vets to 'check up' on a stray cat. That could have waited until you did not have paid work commitments!

You don't seem to have any idea at all how the real world of adults works 🤷‍♀️ Time to grow up.

Type2whattodo · 23/11/2024 10:53

I hire people and only ask 4 questions in a reference check:

  1. Dates of employment
  2. Job title
  3. Reason for leaving
  4. Would you rehire the person?

For you, the reason for leaving would be given as failed probation. The answer to 4 would therefore be no automatically.
I'd fail probation for more than 1 absence/3 days in a 6 month period unless extreme circumstances.
Probation is you on your best behaviour so if you are already questionable on probation, a manager will assume that you will be a nightmare to manage once employment rights kick in.
I assume you are quite young and I don't feel that society is setting young people up for success.

You go to work, arrive and leave on time. Dress and behave appropriately. Your boss is not your mum. Don't tell them all your personal details.
Why does a boss of such a short period know you have debt and all the other personal things about your life?
Save it for friends and family.

ItTook9Years · 23/11/2024 10:51

Silvertulips · 23/11/2024 00:40

How long was probation and at what point did they ask you to leave?

probation is a red herring. No employment rights re unfair dismissal (unless on grounds of a protected characteristic) for 2 years. The OP went AWOL.

snotathing · 23/11/2024 10:43

I think you need to accept responsibility yourself for not getting this job. You didn't get the job because of how you conducted yourself in your last job. That's how references work. If your last employer was asked specific questions about your non attendance or attitude to authority and employment, they couldn't lie.

You took a lot of sick leave, you left work without permission, you wasted work time fretting about a cat, you shared information about your relative's MH problems and your financial struggles. These are all things you have admitted you did. No employer would have accepted all this during probation.

You need to leave this job off your CV next time.

Westofeasttoday · 23/11/2024 10:33

EssentiallyItsTrue · 23/11/2024 00:58

You mentioned having a few weeks off for illness. Might that have been the real problem.

I think so too and this is somewhat being overlooked. A few weeks off in 7 months is a lot and then suddenly leaving (it’s sudden if only a half hour notice) without it being approved.

In probation you are looking for how well a new employee performs but also their dedication, fit into the team and overall fit, attitude etc. Too much absence, leaving suddenly, catastrophising language (sabotaging my life, bullying manager, etc) are all serious red flags.

What strikes me most about this post is the amount of people who have basically all
said the same thing to the OP and she still doesn’t understand it’s on her. The reason she failed her probation, the standard reference response and Continued excuses and justifications but no real responsibility taken.

I do really hope the stops for a second and starts to understand her part in this and not blame everyone else.

TheKeatingFive · 23/11/2024 10:18

Basic references are normal, seems absolutely extraordinary to withdraw a job offer on the basis of one.

Be mad at this new company, your old employers have done nothing wrong.

MyrtleStrumpet · 23/11/2024 10:04

MyrtleStrumpet · 23/11/2024 10:03

I downloaded the Safer Recruitment toolkit and here are some screenshots about thee content of references.

It includes the duty on your former employer to comment on suitability to work with those at risk. Sickness should be included and reason for leaving.

It also says reasons for failing probation should be included. If your former employer didnt include that information, they may have been justified in withdrawing your offer of employment.

And a fourth screenshot

…to ask what to do about my former employer trying to ruin my life any way they can for their own amusement?
MyrtleStrumpet · 23/11/2024 10:03

ItTook9Years · 23/11/2024 00:32

I’ve only read your posts, OP.

I’m in HR and have worked across several sectors, including voluntary.

Is the role you’ve applied for covered by “safer recruitment”? If so that is why a basic reference has raised alarm bells. It’s also possible that they called the manager who said a lot more over the phone, which you could never prove.

I downloaded the Safer Recruitment toolkit and here are some screenshots about thee content of references.

It includes the duty on your former employer to comment on suitability to work with those at risk. Sickness should be included and reason for leaving.

It also says reasons for failing probation should be included. If your former employer didnt include that information, they may have been justified in withdrawing your offer of employment.

…to ask what to do about my former employer trying to ruin my life any way they can for their own amusement?
…to ask what to do about my former employer trying to ruin my life any way they can for their own amusement?
…to ask what to do about my former employer trying to ruin my life any way they can for their own amusement?
Wolfpa · 23/11/2024 09:49

It’s time for you to take responsibility for yourself and stop blaming others.

You took unauthorised leave from work to visit a cat that wasn’t yours.

A lot of companies only give basic references and if they gave an enhanced truthful reference there will have been huge red flags raised.

once you take accountability for your actions life will get easier

Isatis · 23/11/2024 09:48

pinkdelight · 23/11/2024 06:25

I did have a few weeks sick leave spread across the 7 months so I accept this was an issue

OP was on probation. This latest cat incident sounds like it was the final straw. She also cited lots of reasons from her side why it wasn't good fit and she had a lot of issues with the place and people. So ultimately it's best that she's out of there.

OP, my main takeaway here is that you're not very well and everything is framed through your illness whether it's anxiety or OCD, from the plight of this cat to the paranoia about your career sabotage. Try to focus on getting help for that rather than feeding this feeling of persecution about the manager. Until you find ways to get your thinking in check, things will spiral. It's good that you're on a waiting list but don't just wait. There are good books and online resources which will help and as you've worked in the sector you just be aware of how to access other support. When you're out the other side of this you'll be able to see that this wasn't a good time for you and things got warped and out of perspective, but right now it's hard to hear and easier to fixate on this manager having it in for you, which will only exacerbate your 'devastation'. Take care and get yourself well again.

This post is so sensible, please pay attention to it OP.

Isatis · 23/11/2024 09:39

Renegader · 22/11/2024 22:40

So there is no such thing as denying a leave request without a valid reason? Surely this then gives managers with a tendency to be bullies or overly controlling carte blanche to dismiss someone for something someone else with a different manager would simply get authorised in many cases?

Edited

You were employed to work full time, that's valid reason enough for refusing a leave request which itself doesn't have a valid reason underlying it.. If an employee wants time off suddenly at no notice, it is the employee who needs a valid reason. Wanting to visit a vet to find out something they could have checked on by phone doesn't qualify.

BobbleHatsRule · 23/11/2024 09:25

OP you've had lots of feedback about your own attitude to being an employee. The world does not owe you a living.

Your best bet is to take some time to consider what employment can provide you with what you need (flexibility, nurturing, empathy, sympathy, no rules, no authority and time off at the drop of a hat) and seek that.

Or change your attitude to employment and think about what an employer needs: reliability, presence, able to follow instruction, able to work without supervision. You'll have a wider pool of jobs with the 2nd option

StressedLP1 · 23/11/2024 09:20

What you do in this situation is leave that employer off your cv.

You took several weeks sick leave during a short period and unauthorised absence to visit in person a cat that wasn’t yours. This was during your probation period where most people would be expecting to see you deliver your very best.

With that in mind the most you can hope for is a neutral reference, which is what they gave you. At your next job don’t make the same mistakes and actually turn up to work.

Elderflower14 · 23/11/2024 08:47

You took time off when you were refused and wonder why you were sacked? As others have said you should have waited till the end of the day! YABU.

Zanatdy · 23/11/2024 08:44

To be honest, a few weeks sick leave is more than enough to fail probation, without going AWOL. In my work, it’s 2 days sick leave in the 6 months probation that you can take. They should have addressed that and failed the probation. So even without the cat situation, I can see why you failed. I do agree that in a small sector it’s likely a phone call took place, or perhaps the old manager refused to answer some questions. In the past when i’ve been given as a reference there’s been some questions posed like ‘what was their time keeping like’. If someone declined to answer then yes it would make me think there’s a problem.

Sympathise about the cat, as a huge animal lover i’d have probably helped the cat too. But you cannot go AWOL in a job, its not acceptable.

Swipe left for the next trending thread