Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want a way to label the reasonable fear of the variety of Islam that wishes to impose Sharia law?

492 replies

Oodiks · 22/11/2024 19:40

I understand that there are different sects within Islam and that while some pose no concerns, others do. I am horrified at the type of Sharia law imposed in Iran, Saudi Arabia, and Afghanistan, which denies women human rights, but it's hard to talk about those reasonable fears without being labelled Islamophobic. It's not unreasonable to fear a religion that imposes such harsh lives on women.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Womblingmerrily · 22/11/2024 21:04

This is Stacey Dooley's visit back to her home town in Luton.

I think this demonstrates that there is something to fear from fundamentalist Islam in the UK.

I fear it. It really depends where you live, but if you live in an area that has a large and growing population of people who believe in a fundamentalist form of Islam then I think this represents a danger to some women in that area who are seen in a negative way and can be subject to insults and intimidation particularly from young men and women who have been taught they are trash, as seen in this video where Stacey is insulted and intimidated by individuals.

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z_wgOHuY-vM

Completelyjo · 22/11/2024 21:03

Tabitabtab · 22/11/2024 20:57

It genuinely could be by divine decree. I've been on my own spiritual journey for a few years and there are times I genuinely do believe the Islam may be the truth. I toy between Christianity and Islam.

Your spiritual journey is and should be irrelevant to the law of the land.

Sharia law should have nothing to do with the law in a secular country, neither should the ten commandments or the golden plates of Joseph Smith!

kazzieB · 22/11/2024 21:02

It bothers me that religions enforce rules like headscarves, burqas, etc. Don't fucking tell me what to do. See also women not allowed to become priests and the misogynistic Bible stuff. None of this is divine law handed down from a booming voice in the clouds, it's all just stuff some bloke made up. That's all it is.

Oodiks · 22/11/2024 21:00

Tabitabtab · 22/11/2024 20:48

Sharia Law is just God's law as to how humans and society should behave

Your god, maybe; I’m an atheist.

OP posts:
okright · 22/11/2024 21:00

I dislike and fearful of the unfeminist elements of it. I hate to see women fully covered. I despair for women living in extreme regimes.

Tabitabtab · 22/11/2024 20:57

XmasMarkets · 22/11/2024 20:50

So made up then.

It genuinely could be by divine decree. I've been on my own spiritual journey for a few years and there are times I genuinely do believe the Islam may be the truth. I toy between Christianity and Islam.

Precipice · 22/11/2024 20:55

Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · 22/11/2024 20:17

If you live in the UK it's not a reasonable fear at all.

If you live in the US, it'd be reasonable to fear Christanity being weaponised against women in a very similar way to what happens in Muslim countries.

If you just identified as 'feminist' it would be very clear to most people that you were opposed to any legal framework that treated women as second class citizens, whatever religious beliefs are being used as an excuse to create that system. But please don't use that word if you aren't actually prepared to let women who live in places like Iran, Afghanistan and Saudi Arabia tell you what they want their lives to be like.

What is it that you mean with your last sentence?

If even the majority of women in (whatever country) were to freely express that they wanted to be subject to restrictions by law and custom that their male peers are not, it does not follow that feminists should be in agreement. Feminism is not about women's choices, alone or for the majority. Feminism is about the social and legal liberation of women.

username8348 · 22/11/2024 20:54

Tabitabtab · 22/11/2024 20:48

Sharia Law is just God's law as to how humans and society should behave

I'm an atheist.

Kwiaenrker · 22/11/2024 20:51

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Don't be so ridiculous

Completelyjo · 22/11/2024 20:50

Sometimeswinning · 22/11/2024 20:43

Really? You don’t think there are any Sharia councils in the uk? Hint: There are.

Like someone said above though I’m way beyond anyone accusing me of any isms. I really don’t care. Op can ask a question and if you’re offended make sure your defence isn’t completely ignorant of facts.

That’s got nothing to do with “law” though.
There’s a Sharia council a handful of minutes from me, if an Islamic couple want them to deal with their divorce that’s on them, it doesn’t infringe in my rights in any way.
Do I disagree with it? To an extent yes because I come from another part of the UK where women would also have to seek advice from the church and the church encouraged them to stay in shitty situations.
Ultimately people are free to take part in a religion of their choosing though whether or not any of us think it’s valid.

Mumblechum0 · 22/11/2024 20:50

Sharia law is very much a thing in the UK. I’m a willwriter and several prospective clients have requested Sharia wills, whereby sons get twice as much inheritance as daughters.

ive always turned down the work as it goes against my ethics but plenty of firms will happily do them.

XmasMarkets · 22/11/2024 20:50

Tabitabtab · 22/11/2024 20:48

Sharia Law is just God's law as to how humans and society should behave

So made up then.

hazelnutvanillalatte · 22/11/2024 20:49

headstone · 22/11/2024 20:45

You’re right hazelnutvanillalatte Saudi Arabia was a place full of naice white people until they started letting Muslims in, now look at it.

Islam isn't a race. HTH

JaneJeffer · 22/11/2024 20:49

this is also seen in hardline Christmas groups
Santanists?

Tabitabtab · 22/11/2024 20:48

Sharia Law is just God's law as to how humans and society should behave

Silvan · 22/11/2024 20:48

I would add it's really important to be able to say what you do and don't like about some religions or cultures. It's also fine to be unhappy about the rapid social or cultural change that sometimes goes alongside mass immigration.

What (obviously) isn't fine is hostility towards individuals, sneering or disgust towards a particular group, calling for violence or discrimination and so on.

JaneJeffer · 22/11/2024 20:47

soupfiend · 22/11/2024 20:04

Actually people have said that criticism of Hamas comes from Islamophobia. So it does get misused and bandied about. Apparently if you highlight that Hamas are terrorists and just as violent and unhinged as the current Israeli strategy, you're racist and Islamophobic. Read any thread here about it.

Much like being labelled antisemitic for criticising the Israeli government

T4phage · 22/11/2024 20:45

I think climate change will increase the numbers of muslim migrants coming here and at some point the balance will tip towards a change of governance in the country in order to reflect the needs and wants of its citizens.

headstone · 22/11/2024 20:45

You’re right hazelnutvanillalatte Saudi Arabia was a place full of naice white people until they started letting Muslims in, now look at it.

Sometimeswinning · 22/11/2024 20:43

Batmanisaplaceinturkey · 22/11/2024 20:05

Oh here we go again, another thread about Islam, how Muslims want to impose Sharia law blah blah yawn.

Really? You don’t think there are any Sharia councils in the uk? Hint: There are.

Like someone said above though I’m way beyond anyone accusing me of any isms. I really don’t care. Op can ask a question and if you’re offended make sure your defence isn’t completely ignorant of facts.

hazelnutvanillalatte · 22/11/2024 20:40

They would justifiably call you Islamophobic for saying 'We'll end up under Sharia law if we keep letting in people from Muslim countries'.

History is Islamophobic then

Completelyjo · 22/11/2024 20:40

I am horrified at the type of Sharia law imposed in Iran, Saudi Arabia, and Afghanistan, which denies women human rights, but it's hard to talk about those reasonable fears without being labelled Islamophobic

Really? You’ve discussed being horrified at the regime in Iran and Saudi and people label it as Islamophobic? Somehow I doubt that.

There are some extremist Muslims in the UK who hide behind Islam to be homophobic, misogynistic and patriarchal limiting the rights of women, this is also seen in hardline Christmas groups and Hasidic Jews.

I think fearing sharia law will be placed on all UK citizens is crazy and unfounded though.

Silvan · 22/11/2024 20:39

Echobelly · 22/11/2024 19:59

I've never seen it this used for anyone expressing a reasonable fear of extremism. No one would call anyone Islamophobic for saying 'The Taliban are horrific'. They would justifiably call you Islamophobic for saying 'We'll end up under Sharia law if we keep letting in people from Muslim countries'.

There is a difference between criticising/fearing that (which as PPs have said, has parallels in Christian extremism, which is also awful) and between talking about all Islam as though it's all extremism, or as though respecting Islam is a slippery slope to extreme Sharia law, which too many people do. See American right wingers who rant about Sadiq Khan as though he is an extremist for literally no other reason than his is Muslim.

"'We'll end up under Sharia law if we keep letting in people from Muslim countries'."

I'm interested that you say this statement is Islamophobic, since it does haven some factual basis to it: polling has shown around 40% of British Muslims would like some form of Sharia law to apply in communities in the UK. Obviously that doesn't mean they want everyone living under Sharia law, but it does mean that if the number of British Muslims continues to grow, Sharia law in this country is a real possibility.

LoremIpsumCici · 22/11/2024 20:39

It’s not religion, it’s certain usually male leaders abusing religion as a tool to control a population. So your fear is of theocrats or of a theocracy.

Theocrats are akin to autocrats or dictators.

username8348 · 22/11/2024 20:35

We do have Sharia law in the UK, I think we have 30 councils who mainly deal with financial and family matters.

They're not legally binding and can't do anything against UK law. Like any religious council, they're sexist and mainly run by men.

I don't want any religious councils in the UK and believe people should abide by Western values irrespective of their religion or culture.

Islamic Sharia Council - Wikipedia

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islamic_Sharia_Council#:~:text=The%20Islamic%20Sharia%20Council%20(ISC,lesser%20extent%2C%20business%20and%20finance.