Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand adult food vs kids food?

317 replies

SofandaCox · 22/11/2024 11:37

I meet up occasionally with my old baby group. Our babies are 3 now. We met up yesterday for lunch and there’s a few in the group that are firmly in the adult foods are separate to kids food camp and I find it so bizarre. They make really weird comments like “why would you give that to a child” “my child would never eat that” “I wouldn’t waste that on a child” etc. my child has a long list of allergies and I’ve had gastric surgery so can’t much so we usually share a meal. The offending meal? Calamari. Basically chicken nuggets but wish squid. They acted like I had just purchased my toddler a fillet mignon with champagne and lobster tail. Which, again, don’t see the issue if that’s what he wanted! Has anyone experienced this? And also just to be so rude as to sit there and actually make comments about it. I’ve had judgey thoughts about them feeding their 3 year old jarred baby food but I’ve kept that to myself. It’s making me not want to meet up with them anymore but it would be a shame for my son as he enjoys spending time with the others toddlers.

OP posts:
HooMoo · 22/11/2024 12:49

Yanbu! Our 10 month old eats the exact same food as us.

justasking111 · 22/11/2024 12:49

Mine loved calamari, moules marinere, curry, Colman's English mustard, pate, etc. they did have chicken nuggets, fish fingers as well.

We let them try everything.

SmalllChange · 22/11/2024 12:48

jaimelesoleil · 22/11/2024 12:42

It’s calamari not bloody caviar. What stone do you live under 😂

Are you new to Mumsnet?

There are loads of MNetters who think their kids are the bee's knees, due to having a wider pallet than some other kids.

Weird, but it's always been 'thing' that little Johnny and Jemima are requesting Japanese food on takeaway night, and screaming for hummus and quinoa in the middle of Waitrose before they're old enough shit alone.

pooballs · 22/11/2024 12:47

My uncle is a ‘child of the 70s’ and will only eat a really, really small selection of foods. My grandma eventually gave up with the take it or leave it approach (because he literally just would not eat) and just made him a separate cheese sandwich or sausages and chips. She always says it’s her fault that he’s fussy now as an adult. He has very clear autistic traits (not that she would ever agree with this) and the stories of him as a child are soo similar to my own son with ASD. Things like ARFID 100% did exist back then.

Fridgetapas · 22/11/2024 12:46

DreamyDreamy · 22/11/2024 12:34

This!
I always wonder why parents would give junk food / sweet drinks / ketchup / ultra processed food / candy etc etc to toddler who would be perfectly happy with a piece of fruit or veg and water because that’s all they know.

Agree with the sweets and sweet drinks but I guess my 3 year old has had some ketchup and a bit of junk food like oven chips/nuggets because sometimes we have it as adults.

But we also ninety percent of the time do home cooked meals, lots of veg, model balance so I hope we are teaching about moderation.

I guess there are always different levels of what we approve of disapprove of as an adult. I’m privately quite judgey about my friends who allow their children squash and biscuits but I think my dentist friend probably judges me for letting mine have the occasional smoothie or bit of cake.

Wheresthebeach · 22/11/2024 12:45

Yeah it's pretty common, and people wonder why we have issues with kids eating crap all the time. Kids should eat the same as adults, but smaller portions. My DD had allergies, and reflux. She ordered off the adult menu and people sometimes commented. I tended to respond with 'I don't agree with kids menu's'. If asked 'why' the answer was 'because it's usually junk food, or very simple and I want DD to develop broad tastes and not get stuck on crap food like chicken nuggets'.

x2boys · 22/11/2024 12:45

jaimelesoleil · 22/11/2024 12:42

It’s calamari not bloody caviar. What stone do you live under 😂

Calamari is very chewy and nothing like chicken nugget I doubt many three year olds well apart from mumsnet three year old would eat it.

Iceache · 22/11/2024 12:42

It isn’t a ‘British’ thing as none of my friends are like this and nor are we. Ours both went through a slightly fussy stage but now they eat what we eat. Last night it was king prawn jambalaya, the night before it was chilli chicken udon and tonight my eldest is making us stuffed crust pizzas. We eat our food VERY spicy and I don’t adjust the heat at all for them. They used to pick out the veg but don’t at all now.

They do love chicken nuggets though 🤣

We never really did kids’ menus either; we just ordered from the adult menu and they’d share ours or share an adult meal between them. I do miss those days a lot as now it costs a fortune eating out buying four adult portions

Squeezetheday · 22/11/2024 12:42

They are odd IMO for feeding their 3 year old jars…3 year olds should be eating proper food.

I find kids menus so dull, just the same old chicken nuggets and fish fingers everywhere you go like people assume that’s all children eat! My DD isn’t particularly adventurous but we try to encourage her to try things from the normal menu or share with us and we all eat the same meals at home.

jaimelesoleil · 22/11/2024 12:42

randomchap · 22/11/2024 12:22

Of course you understand it. You're just showing off that your child will eat calamari and more adult foods

Was the faux naivety needed?

It’s calamari not bloody caviar. What stone do you live under 😂

GiveMeVodkaPlease · 22/11/2024 12:41

boulevardofbrokendreamss · 22/11/2024 11:42

My kids have never really eaten 'kids food'. Of course they'll eat chicken nuggets etc but more often than not they used to choose a starter when we were eating out. (now they have three courses and eating out is bloody expensive!).

If you see them again I'd start commenting on feeding a 3 yo jarred baby food.

Yes, because that going to really help 🙄

OP, just shrug and say "I guess everyone does things differently". And stop judging them for the jars.

It's pointless and harmful to start thinking that your way of raising a baby is the "right" way, and anyone who does it differently is "wrong". Everyone has different circumstances.

Notjustabrunette · 22/11/2024 12:40

Hmmm, my kids ate everything at 3. Now at 10 and 7 they have become more picky. For example, both would eat salmon as toddlers, but won’t touch it now unless I make it into a fish cake.
Also, I find often the kids menu just offer a smaller portion than on the main menu. I found on holiday in Italy this summer a lot of the kids food was wasted as the adult size portions were too big for them.

Cosyblankets · 22/11/2024 12:39

DreamyDreamy · 22/11/2024 12:34

This!
I always wonder why parents would give junk food / sweet drinks / ketchup / ultra processed food / candy etc etc to toddler who would be perfectly happy with a piece of fruit or veg and water because that’s all they know.

Child of the 70s here. We were just given our meal and we ate it. No questions asked. Obviously there were things we weren't keen on. We grew up with meat and two veg type meals, some of the veg was home grown. My parents had neither the money, nor the opportunity to give us choices. Neither of us have grown up with any issues around food.

ediepop · 22/11/2024 12:38

This has been going on for decades. My mother is a particularly amazing domestic cook and an early adopter of Elizabeth David, Jane Grigson, Fay Maschler et al. So my siblings and I were exposed to a wide range of delicious foods pretty much from the word go and as a result grew up eating anything. My friends parents were regularly astonished at my breadth of taste (1980s) whereas my mother was appalled when we hosted, at how many of my friends were revolted at the sight of a tomato or whatever. She was born in 1935, so bloody grateful for easy access to tomatoes.
The cycle repeats - I've brought up my children the same way. They do love a classic spag bog, and are equally keen on fish curry, but I've learnt to stick to sausages/fish fingers when they have friends round for tea, as serving other people's 8 year olds ratatouille seldom ends well.

SmalllChange · 22/11/2024 12:38

DrZaraCarmichael · 22/11/2024 12:33

Another "i don't understand" thread where the OP clearly DOES understand, just disapproves.

Thinking about it yes, this makes more sense than claiming they don't want to meet up anymore, because the other mums commented on her feeding her kid deep fried beige food.

I think my eyes have rolled right out of my head.

RabbitsEatPancakes · 22/11/2024 12:37

Is it where you live?

No one I know feeds their kids chips and nuggets on the regular- that's more emergency freezer food.

There's a few fussy kids but pretty sure you get that everywhere. We have always just fed ours what we eat although toned down the chilli level.

I would consider calamari a very basic food, yummy but I'd expect every kid to eat it. Its just like, nuggest, scampi, fish fingers etc.

I'm not sure it's just a British thing though, I had a Spanish waiter get very worried at 8month DD eating a chicken leg, he was quite sure babies only ate soup until 2! We had similar in Brazil and Portugal- babies should have fruit and soup.

Jarred baby food for a 3yr old! Some people like to baby their kids- you see dummies and bottles on walking toddlers all the time.

PerditaLaChien · 22/11/2024 12:34

Breastfed babies often prefer sweeter food. Childrens have twice as many taste buds as adults and so things like bitter or strong flavours can basically taste worse to them.

Ive noticed in some countries that claim children "eat what grown ups do", plenty of children fill up from the plainer options served & eat little of the spicy sauce or the bitter brassicas. Eg they'll eat lots of the breads, rices, dairy components, snacky bites of this and that.

In Britain we don't have a culture of central serving dishes where childrencan get away with simply filling up on preferred/easy foods. Children are given their own portion with a mix of foods, and we don't like waste so over time this leads to children being given blander/palatable foods they are more likely to eat.

DreamyDreamy · 22/11/2024 12:34

Gogogo12345 · 22/11/2024 12:23

Might be a strange question but how do kids even KNOW about " beige" food if they've never been given it?

This!
I always wonder why parents would give junk food / sweet drinks / ketchup / ultra processed food / candy etc etc to toddler who would be perfectly happy with a piece of fruit or veg and water because that’s all they know.

DrZaraCarmichael · 22/11/2024 12:33

Another "i don't understand" thread where the OP clearly DOES understand, just disapproves.

Mummyoflittledragon · 22/11/2024 12:31

x2boys · 22/11/2024 12:02

Some kids will only eat beige food ,my son is 18 now and has just discovered a love for curries, and chilli etc, but wouldn't have entertained them when he was younger
Maybe people need to stop judging whst other people feed their kids and concentrate on their own kids ?

Agreed. My dd has ARFID tendencies. She did from before she was a 1 year old.

Neodymium · 22/11/2024 12:31

My kids always eat what we eat. Even as babies I would puree up our food for them. They are varying degrees of fussy. My daughter is the worst but she will still eat just complain about picking put mushrooms. My boys eat everything and love spicy food and love cooking.

but yes I recall playgroup mums always being surprised at my kids. Like they would eat multigrain bread. Still do. Cause that’s all I buy.

Elisabeth3468 · 22/11/2024 12:31

Yeah that is weird. My son (3 years old) eats what we have, there are a few exceptions because he genuinely doesn't like them like curry , fajitas. I don't even buy kiddie yoghurts though, he just has Greek yoghurt or whatever adults I buy in that week.

Buddhistcauliflower · 22/11/2024 12:28

School usually. School dinners are appalling, even where they claim to make everything fresh and on site it's awful.

TheNinkyNonkyIsATardis · 22/11/2024 12:28

We add a side or two when we eat out, and divvy up bits from each of us for our one year old.

So sometimes he has a bit of curry and a bit of roast on his plate, then some fruit and return to gravy etc.

momager1 · 22/11/2024 12:28

ByHardyRubyEagle · 22/11/2024 12:10

My 3 year old loves calamari. We don’t just buy for him either we eat it as a family. He loves tempura prawns too. What does that make us? Should I be giving him chicken nuggets shaped like dinosaurs?

the tempura prawns, omg memories. My daughter loves all shrimp. She would buy the cooked shrimp rings with sauce and also from costco the tempura ones. My grandson hated shrimp, but those "tempura chicken tails" he loved. I have a video of him eating some and my daughter offering him a shrimp from her shrimp cocktail, him saying ewwwww no I don't like shrimp (with a tempura that he was happily munching on) and his sister (one year older saying "are you suuuuurrreee) one of my fav memories from when they were little. My grandaughter knew "chicken tails" were shrimp and she was told to not tell him lol.