Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think something has gone wrong in schools? https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cz0m2x30p4eo

364 replies

RebelBabybel · 21/11/2024 17:34

From the BBC : school exclusions have doubled in the last 10 years.

I’ve worked in schools for 30 years : KS1/Early Years.

When I first started I was expected to do : hand written, detailed plans. Assessments. Handwritten reports. I had no TA. I had a blackboard. Children had books. I had to be firm with behaviour, schools had very clear behaviour policies in place, and the head would have an overview, was visible, check classes, be the ‘go to’ person if anything was difficult to manage.

Over the years, particularly in the Early Years things have changed massively.
My latest role has involved a manager who is mostly on the computer and rarely interacts with the children. No planning, no assessment. Resources are put out, but there is an ethos that it’s ‘wrong’ to show the children how to use them. Therefore children don’t use jigsaws as puzzles, they take the pieces out and transport them round the classroom. A doctors role play is set up, but with no input as to what the resources are there are for or how to role play ‘being a doctor’.

There is an expectation, a ‘box’ of what constitutes ‘normal’ behaviour : even with very young children. Any child who is outside this box, is often labelled ‘I think they’ve got autism, I think they’ve got ADHD’ without a formal assessment. These children - rather than getting to know them, or putting clear strategies in place, are quickly labelled as difficult : and fall into a stereotype that causes a negative cycle. There seems to be little ‘fault’ addressed to the teaching style, and the ‘fault??’ is centred on the child, I’d also argue that it is NOT a fault. It’s called being a child.

Children seem to be very readily excluded from schools without the adults fully questioning their teaching style and whether that might be at fault.

To be completely honest, teaching was far easier 30 years ago. Children were better behaved, and there was far better, stronger support from senior management. It felt more like a team, rather than:

an SLT who are in meetings, on a computer, off to conferences, in the staff room, pushing ‘new’ initiatives and criticising their staff.

OP posts:
RebelBabybel · 22/11/2024 07:42

@Superhansrantowindsor

My youngest child has an EHCP. When I sought a reception place, the school tried to say they couldn’t meet his needs before DC had even set foot in the door.
After a battle with the school, DC is doing really well.

And very importantly, DC is in his local area, not having to cope with transport to a school far away - and has made friends in his local area.
I really feel I have had to fight against a rigid mindset. I’ve also had to battle against assumptions before DC was diagnosed (with a speech delay and not ASD as presumed by school).
I’ve also had to battle against egos and SLT who are more determined to prove ‘I was right all along’ rather than admit fault.
At the heart of all this is the child.

That is what seems to have been forgotten over egos, initiatives and pigeon holing children.

OP posts:
DiggetyDog · 22/11/2024 07:40

coxesorangepippin · 21/11/2024 18:32

She was no problem in the classroom, but difficult to manage at home,
^

This is hugely important. Why could she be managed in the classroom, but not at home??

I'm thinking that the adult in charge has something to do with it

This struck me as a very good example of the disconnect between teachers, children and parents that’s going on.

It’s very well know that neurodivergent children often mask in school. Call it the coke bottle effect, the stress bucket, whatever, but I’m appalled afresh that so many teachers have never heard of it.

This is something that will affect the child and their family of many of your pupils. The fact that teachers still use this as a stick to beat parents with is shocking.

It’s so easy for teachers to call out parents in this way (haven’t read the thread beyond this post, but I’m willing to bet my arm that this will feature heavily), but it’s so lazy, and just shows that they’re so up their own egos that they cannot accept that the way schools have changed that sees so many teachers despairing and wanting to leave, is the exact same reason that has children not coping as well.

So short sighted.

Funkybananabread · 22/11/2024 07:40

I’m sorry if this is controversial but I would suggest that you move schools as not all schools are like this!
I am a headteacher and myself and the DH are almost always in classes supporting behaviour. In my previous school it was the same (wasn’t the Head then - just SLT). We just got outstanding ofsted for EYFS and we have children displaying the behaviours mentioned but we put good routines in place to support them, work with parents and seek outside support. I’m not saying it’s easy by any stretch (still have bruises from 2 weeks ago from 1 child biting me) and I completely agree with lots of the posts about parents needing to take accountability for their children’s behaviour and the curriculum being too full to allow teachers to work with children on their behaviour. I’m just suggesting that maybe your school / SLT could be dealing with things in a more positive way.

ImaginaryHorse · 22/11/2024 07:25

User37482 · 22/11/2024 07:13

I do think we need more SEN provision schools, not wothin mainstream. It’s not fair on the kids who need a different approach to have them in mainstream and it’s not fair on mainstream to have class time taken up with meeting significant additional needs.

I think we should have high standards in school, we should accept not everyone should be going to uni and strengthen trades qualifications and apprenticeships. It doesn’t do anyone any favours to make school easier or less demanding to accommodate instead of understanding that different children have different paths and pushing ahead to make sure able children get where they should be going. We need both, we need the carpenters and we need the hospital consultants. We should bring back gifted and talented programmes as well.

I agree with this.

My friends son is 11, he is autistic with ADHD and learning difficulties. He can't really read, can't write anything other than his own name, can't do written down maths at all. Despite years and years of targeted interventions, and her doing everything she can to help him, it just isn't something he's ever going to master. He is however excellent with his hands and can use loads of tools very skilfully already. He can also do pretty good mental arithmetic in a woodwork context. She wants him to study a trade, but there's no pathway for that for him. He has to stay in school and study for GCSEs which he will never pass, and already he is becoming disengaged from education and starting to play up to get out of lessons he can't understand. But he's "too able" for special school placements according to our LA. It's very sad to watch.

User37482 · 22/11/2024 07:13

I do think we need more SEN provision schools, not wothin mainstream. It’s not fair on the kids who need a different approach to have them in mainstream and it’s not fair on mainstream to have class time taken up with meeting significant additional needs.

I think we should have high standards in school, we should accept not everyone should be going to uni and strengthen trades qualifications and apprenticeships. It doesn’t do anyone any favours to make school easier or less demanding to accommodate instead of understanding that different children have different paths and pushing ahead to make sure able children get where they should be going. We need both, we need the carpenters and we need the hospital consultants. We should bring back gifted and talented programmes as well.

User37482 · 22/11/2024 07:09

MineMineMineMineMine · 22/11/2024 06:40

But so many parents must be exhausted. It's not just "feckless". When I was small you could have a parent without a degree working and bring in enough money to support a small family and another parent work a few hours if you wanted to. Now so many parents are both working full on jobs and kids are in nursery or childcare or after school care most of the day and by the time they come home the parents are exhausted. Especially if it's 2 outside the home physical jobs without flexibility. Also when parents are struggling col, depression, unsuitable housing, unsupported kids with additional needs etc then it is hard to be all the things you'd like to be to your kid. It's about surviving.

Its quite different to the work from home flexible jobs you read about on mn.

I don’t know, my parents worked very long hours 6 days a week. We were often home alone at a very early age (think 6ish). We still got good feedback on behaviour and were always on the working in greater depth tables. The expectations start young. A lot of school is being able to sit down, pay attention and not be disruptive. Thats enough to learn something. My own is an extremely active child who struggles to be sitting down too long but she manages fine as long as she can have a run around a few times.

Expectations about behaviour are set way before they get to primary imo. Obviously I’m not talking about children with SEN.

Porcelainpig · 22/11/2024 06:59

coxesorangepippin · 21/11/2024 18:32

She was no problem in the classroom, but difficult to manage at home,
^

This is hugely important. Why could she be managed in the classroom, but not at home??

I'm thinking that the adult in charge has something to do with it

It is well known that some ND children mask at school and then behaviour explodes at home. Not necessarily parenting. Please don't blame parents by default if you don't really have an understanding of ND.

My son used to be fine and now does the same. He literally walks through the door and lets everything out that has built up in the day. He has complex needs, but this happens with higher functioning children too. He is fine after a while, but it wasn't happening before and now has started to happen daily. We haven't changed the way we parent...

Superhansrantowindsor · 22/11/2024 06:48

RebelBabybel · 21/11/2024 18:01

@hellooooooomama

Completely disagree. That’s segregation. Us and them mentality. Placing the fault on all these ‘SEN’ children, it wasn’t like that 30 years ago. There was a feeling of inclusivity - and caring for ALL children.

Sorry but this is rubbish.
In the 25 years I have been in the classroom the range of ability and SEN has increased dramatically. Add in EAL students, those with mental health difficulties and it’s a recipe for disaster. It is not fair on anyone.
There is absolutely nothing wrong with having different types of schools. We already have SEN schools but just not enough of them. When I started teaching I too had a blackboard and no TA. I also only had 25 children on average in a class. One of my classes this year has 8 different languages spoken. There are 32 in every class. All children deserve the best education possibly. Putting them all together in a huge building isn’t the answer. Education needs a radical overhaul with lots of different types of schools.

Pippy2022 · 22/11/2024 06:41

Toomanywars · 22/11/2024 06:38

Toddlers sat in pushchairs on phones whilst parents look at phones. Very little interaction. Older children on Tic toc. Social media is killing communication and watching parents role model behaviour.

Agree.

And everyone is afraid now or dont know what is the right way of punishing children for bad behaviour because parents are told 'do this and you'll traumatise your child'

MineMineMineMineMine · 22/11/2024 06:40

But so many parents must be exhausted. It's not just "feckless". When I was small you could have a parent without a degree working and bring in enough money to support a small family and another parent work a few hours if you wanted to. Now so many parents are both working full on jobs and kids are in nursery or childcare or after school care most of the day and by the time they come home the parents are exhausted. Especially if it's 2 outside the home physical jobs without flexibility. Also when parents are struggling col, depression, unsuitable housing, unsupported kids with additional needs etc then it is hard to be all the things you'd like to be to your kid. It's about surviving.

Its quite different to the work from home flexible jobs you read about on mn.

Toomanywars · 22/11/2024 06:38

Toddlers sat in pushchairs on phones whilst parents look at phones. Very little interaction. Older children on Tic toc. Social media is killing communication and watching parents role model behaviour.

Ytcsghisn · 22/11/2024 06:33

Yeah something is wrong. The feckless parents, raising feral kids.

Lancasterel · 22/11/2024 06:07

Onand · 21/11/2024 23:56

The children and youth of today are utterly screwed, a bad education system with exhausted demoralised teachers, addicted to screens, a broken society, no money, no prospects, no aspirations, no creativity, vapes, terrible diets, a world at war.

Think of them like plants trying to grow in dark rooms with no water. 🥀🍂

A bright future seems like a distant dream.

I tend to agree wirh this too and particularly the rise of screen use over the last 10 years. Children coming to school speaking in American accents because of all the YouTube they’re watching who are plonked in front of a device as soon as they get home because it’s easier 😢

Lancasterel · 22/11/2024 06:00

Sherrystrull · 21/11/2024 20:08

In a class of 30+ it's impossible to consider behaviour as communication for every child in every lesson. What am I supposed to do with 30 children all communicating with me in some way? What I do is try my best but I'm sure it falls woefully short.

Some people suggest methods that work at home in a 1:1 situation and are then surprised a teacher can't do the same in a 1:30 situation.

Totally agree with this. I sometimes think it’d be great for anyone who hasn’t done it to come and observe my classroom for a day - 30 children, most with a need of some kind ranging from EAL to non verbal autism, and 1-2 adults trying to manage behaviour and actually teach something!
I’ve reset my mindset recently and realised that it would be ridiculous to think it was actually possible to meet everyone’s needs in this scenario, so I’m not failing just doing the best I can given the circumstances which are out of my control.

Thisismynewusernamedoyoulikeit · 22/11/2024 05:03

Exasperateddonut · 21/11/2024 23:45

I was in infant school 30 odd years ago and vividly remember the SEN kids. Only they weren’t the SEN kids…. They were just Daniel who had one of us read to him and help him with his cutting. Or Anne who preferred to spend her break times ‘helping’ with playground duty. It was so very much integrated and every child was heard. There was far less academic work and an awful lot of raising decent people.

But you didn't have Jack, who was born at 23 weeks and is doing amazingly from where he started as it was predicted he'd never walk or be able to manipulate objects. He is walking and that's amazing, but he can't run, he can't yet use a pencil, and he only speaks in single words.

You didn't have Hana, who has complex autism and often bangs her head on the table, never sleeps through the night, has no verbal communication and is only just beginning to use intentional pointing or hand-leading.

You didn't have Ilmi, who has down syndrome and associated hearing and visual impairments, difficulties with producing speech sounds, behavioural challenges and physical disabilities.

You would now have the first because they wouldn't have survived the NICU. Medical advances and changes in treatment protocols increased survival rate in babies born at 23 weeks by 12% (4% to 20%) from 1995 to 2006 alone.

You would now have the third because the average life expectancy of a child with down syndrome is now 60 years old. In 1983, that was 25. In 1960, it was 10. Therefore, more of them are alive long enough to go to senior school, and the expectations for what they will be taught have improved because of social change and a desire to better their life chances.

You would now have the second. I don't know why. Perhaps because of environmental factors causing an increase. Perhaps because they previously would have been in a special school, or at home as parents were too embarrassed to send them to school. Not because of increased awareness; that makes no sense. These are not children we would ever have looked at and thought "she's ok." They have complex, pervasive and multiple challenges due to something innate within them.

oakleaffy · 22/11/2024 01:08

LizzieBowesLyon · 21/11/2024 23:50

Inclusion per se is a Good Thing when done properly. Our village school has enhanced funding for severe additional needs so even though it’s a mainstream primary they have hoists and lifts and massive bathrooms and all sorts of equipment. The kids with additional needs are all in with the mainstream. My children wouldn’t have come across severe physical disability in any other sphere but they rarely commented. It just wasn’t a thing.

There was a little girl in my son’s class who had a genetic issue and some deformities of her hands and feet. My son said “Ivy does my spellings and I do her laces.” His learning partner that year was a child who was functionally blind and he chatted to me at home time and said “I’m different to Josh, because I don’t like peas and he likes peas.” Then he and Josh couldn’t breathe they were laughing so hard because one of them said “pea-ness”.

''Pea-ness'' now that is a witty child! I'm laughing at that joke and have woken the dog.

oakleaffy · 22/11/2024 01:02

Ariela · 22/11/2024 00:24

Exactly this. I blame social media.

My friend lives on a very quiet road where much of the fairly new estate cuts through a path to her road & goes for a walk past her front room. We sat watching them a couple of weeks ago while we sipped our coffees.
Lots of babies in prams and pushchairs. Every single mother WITHOUT EXCEPTION had their head buried in their phone as they pushed their offspring past. Now maybe some babies were asleep but surely those that are awake you talk to, point things out like the horses in the field, the leaves falling off the trees?
Children are not learning from their parents because their parents ignore them at a time they could be learning from them. My eldest does a bit of volunteering with kids and was surprised recently that none of the group (primary) could identify common birds such as a blackbird or a magpie - she could identify loads as soon as she could talk (under 2) because we did RSPB Birdwatch every year.

So so true.

I was having coffee at local cafe alone and sitting with dog on the grass, and a darling little toddler was running around with early autumn leaves, catching them and wanting to show them to his Dad {who was old}
The Dad was just oblivious, glued to his phone.

The sweet child tried to get the Dad to look, and then picked up his /her Ball and again tried to get Dad's attention.

The little tot wandered off -I kept an eye on them, and the Dad was head down all the time.

It was so upsetting.

Watch your Kids! interact with them.

Same with dog owners- head down in phone rather than watching dog. {Dogs also check in with owners a lot -or should.}

oakleaffy · 22/11/2024 00:56

RebelBabybel · 21/11/2024 17:49

@Tangledmane

My first 10 years of teaching was in a school in a deprived area. We had a very strong, visible head with a clear behaviour policy. I can’t remember one child who was ever excluded.

Mum when young taught in a very deprived area of London {Poplar} and said the children were lovely.
She managed a class of 30 on her own and with ease.

The children were generally well behaved and the head teacher was wonderful.

Something has gone very awry with society and 'parenting' as a whole- Screens and lack of stories/reading.

Obviously there are parents who do lots of reading and games like puzzles with their children still- but generally iPads and other tech for little kids is bad news.

Littlemissgobby · 22/11/2024 00:32

Is it not because we have loads of academies now . Watched a documentary about off rolling and basically any kid that perhaps had learning difficulties etc that was bringing results down they off rolled which js bloody bad.
Also listening to the radio many teachers tonight on lbc said that parents are siding with kids if teacher says thwy have been naughty etc. So are parents not helping the situation either

Ariela · 22/11/2024 00:24

PerditaLaChien · 21/11/2024 23:16

Part of the issue is parenting

How is a kid appearing at school at 4/5 not knowing how to do a simple jigsaw puzzle, role play doctors, or use scissors?

Children usually just imitate adults, you don't "show them" how to role play doctors. Its experience based. If theyve been in in hospital they might pretend cannulas with a bandaged hand or an oxygen mask etc. If they haven't they'll pretend giving syringes of calpol or GP type activities like looking in ears/throats, or want to stick endless plasters on your arms.

Exactly this. I blame social media.

My friend lives on a very quiet road where much of the fairly new estate cuts through a path to her road & goes for a walk past her front room. We sat watching them a couple of weeks ago while we sipped our coffees.
Lots of babies in prams and pushchairs. Every single mother WITHOUT EXCEPTION had their head buried in their phone as they pushed their offspring past. Now maybe some babies were asleep but surely those that are awake you talk to, point things out like the horses in the field, the leaves falling off the trees?
Children are not learning from their parents because their parents ignore them at a time they could be learning from them. My eldest does a bit of volunteering with kids and was surprised recently that none of the group (primary) could identify common birds such as a blackbird or a magpie - she could identify loads as soon as she could talk (under 2) because we did RSPB Birdwatch every year.

hellooooooomama · 22/11/2024 00:09

JaneyD123 · 21/11/2024 23:58

It’s so depressing. I thank my lucky stars every day that I grew up long before screens and social media. I feel like it’s TikTok that’s been the most destructive coupled with the lockdown it was the worst combination

I agree. Shorts and reels have completely destroyed attention spans.

And yet it's not linked to ADHD?

hellooooooomama · 22/11/2024 00:08

Dramatic · 21/11/2024 23:54

This certainly wasn't true of my infant school experience 30 years ago, we were sat round tables from day dot in reception. In fact I vividly remember my first day of school, we had to copy sums from the board and read flash cards, not something my children did on their first day. I also found one of my school books recently from when I was 5, we wrote weekend reports each Monday and were using full sentences and being corrected on spelling, again not something my daughter is doing yet.

I remember doing weekend write ups too. They don't do that any more because some kids have such miserable lives.

I think it's a great way of getting some insight re safeguarding and for those with ok/happy homes it's nice to document things at a young age as we forget so much.

Macaroni46 · 22/11/2024 00:07

RebelBabybel · 21/11/2024 17:58

@cansu

I’m not so sure. There seems to have been a movement away from planning with children. It seems a lot more lax. With the youngest children, we used to have clear roles for each adult in the classroom.
One adult would play a board game, or teach how to use scissors.
Now these things are put out, but with no guidance. So the board game is distributed around the classroom and pieces lost - while the adults cut out Twinkl signs or are called out to a meeting, leaving one person trying to cope with behaviour.

Edited

I'm sorry OP but I don't recognise this classroom set up and I taught EYFS / KS1 until last year.
It's like others have said. Cuts in support staff and specialist services and the ridiculously too highly pitched and irrelevant, boring, dry curriculum that expects 5 year olds to use question marks and exclamation marks in their writing and year 4 children to add fractions.

JaneyD123 · 21/11/2024 23:58

Onand · 21/11/2024 23:56

The children and youth of today are utterly screwed, a bad education system with exhausted demoralised teachers, addicted to screens, a broken society, no money, no prospects, no aspirations, no creativity, vapes, terrible diets, a world at war.

Think of them like plants trying to grow in dark rooms with no water. 🥀🍂

A bright future seems like a distant dream.

It’s so depressing. I thank my lucky stars every day that I grew up long before screens and social media. I feel like it’s TikTok that’s been the most destructive coupled with the lockdown it was the worst combination

Onand · 21/11/2024 23:56

The children and youth of today are utterly screwed, a bad education system with exhausted demoralised teachers, addicted to screens, a broken society, no money, no prospects, no aspirations, no creativity, vapes, terrible diets, a world at war.

Think of them like plants trying to grow in dark rooms with no water. 🥀🍂

A bright future seems like a distant dream.

Swipe left for the next trending thread