Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sister annoyed with me

33 replies

NoForwardingAddress · 21/11/2024 10:50

I end up hosting every year at Christmas. I don't enjoy it. Up until now, the reason has been that my husband's elderly mother and very elderly grandad came to us. Both frail and would otherwise have a bleak Christmas alone, so obviously we've willingly had them round ours. At times, my husband's sibling (who lives abroad) has come too.

Sadly, Mil and GFil both died this year. We will obviously miss their presence, especially my kids who naturally associate Christmas day with them being here. However, I do have to say that I was looking forward to not hosting for the first time in over 20 years. We were thinking of going to a restaurant so I wouldn't even have to cook and could spend my day relaxing and being with my kids.

However, my brother then said he'd love to join us with husband's wife and 3 kids. To stress, I obviously would love to see him at Christmas as usually he's with his inlaws at the other end of the country. And our kids all adore each other, very close in age etc, so it will be lovely for them and for me to see my nieces and nephew.

My sister is now annoyed that she's been left out 😩 every year, she goes to her inlaws and is doing the same this year. I assumed happily, but maybe not. Regardless, I can't stand the thought of cooking Christmas dinner and hosting my 4, my brother's 5, plus my sister's 6 (three adult children, one with fiancé). It's insanity. From past experience, my brother will contribute to the cost and help cook. My sister will not.

I've already offered to host everyone at mine at some point during brother's visit and do a buffet, possibly on boxing day.

Every single time my brother visits, I host everyone at mine and cook for everyone (something easy to bulk cook, like curry or chilli). My sister has never once hosted or invited me to do anything, I've never even been inside her house because she's weirdly private about it. Even when I've asked the address to drop (for example) her birthday gift off, she won't reply to me and just turns up on my doorstep!

I honestly feel like I do the most to facilitate everyone being together, she does the least, yet I'm a selfish cow for leaving her out.

I can't justify myself by saying that I didn't actually invite my brother, he invited himself, because that is mean to my brother and implies I don't want him here (not the case). I refuse to cook and host for that many so I'm not willing to extend the invite to her for Christmas dinner. Although she's welcome (as she's done most years previously) to come over for prosecco and croissants late morning to exchange gifts).

What's the solution here? I'm most annoyed that instead of saying directly that she upset with me, she's told the rest of the family that I've left her out and always do! Urgh.

Suggestions?

OP posts:
Whothefuckdoesthat · 21/11/2024 11:10

You could ignore it and just roll your eyes when anyone mentions her feeling left out.

You could contact her and tell her you’ll all be going to hers at Christmas, seeing as it’s clearly now so important to her.

You could message her and tell her to stop being silly, of course she’s welcome, her share is £££, which you’ll need before you go shopping and what job would she like to do?

You could have everyone at yours but go out for dinner, with everyone paying for themselves, so you’re not stuck in the kitchen all day.

You could push everything back a day, or bring it forward a day, so you have turkey with just your family on Christmas Eve or Boxing Day, and do a bulk chilli/curry on Christmas Day.

I’d like to think I’d go for one of the last two options. I admit I’d probably just do the ignoring and eye rolling thing one though.

Onlyvisiting · 21/11/2024 11:03

Just tell her sorry, that's too many to host on Xmas, love to have her family for s meal another day.

FlightofWind · 21/11/2024 11:01

Would your brother be ok with you all going out for meal on Xmas day? Or maybe plan that for next year so you know it will happen?

FlightofWind · 21/11/2024 11:01

Sounds like your sister might have some issues with her mental health given her unusual stance.

In your situation, I would do what you want and leave any feelings your sister has about that with her. Easier said than done I know! But it sounds as though the current plan works well for you so I’d leave it as is and just accept she’s a bit unhappy about it.

GiraffeTree · 21/11/2024 10:59

Don't feel guilty OP. You are doing a lot and you can't keep everyone happy!

AndrewPreview · 21/11/2024 10:59

Well, seeing as she hasn't actually said directly to you that she's annoyed I'd just ignore it.

(I'm not the type that get swayed by passive aggressive games).

Skybluepinky · 21/11/2024 10:57

Just say no, u r going out for dinner.

Icanttakethisanymore · 21/11/2024 10:54

I would contact her and say "I hear you are upset about us not all getting together at Christmas I agree that would be great - can we come to yours on X day?"

Swipe left for the next trending thread