Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Exhausted with current situation - money issue

361 replies

Dreambow · 21/11/2024 01:28

I don’t really know what to expect from this but please be kind.

We are a married couple both in professional jobs (doctor and DH works in the city - not a banker).
I have been contracting the last few years as NHS salary doesn’t cover enough outgoings.
We have a 2.5 year old and a 8 week old.

All we do is work work work. The cost of everything is eating up everything and we have several credit cards (interest free). We live frugally as we can but our outgoings are huge and have increased so much over the past two years. I am so worried that this is going to get worse over the next few years.

We have a large mortgage as live in London for DH work - since the rate of interest has gone up we are now paying £1200 per month extra. Still better off in the long run than rent and we are grateful for this.

Nursery fees were £1050 per month in Jan 2022 and now £1600 (£550 per month increase) for full time. This is for one child (not eligible for government help). Absolutely dreading when the second one starts nursery and when they go up again next year. This is for a cheap nursery - most are £2000 per month for one child full time.

On top of this energy bills and food bills all increased. We have a Victorian house and it’s freezing cold (apart from the ground floor which has underfloor heating). Currently 10 degrees in the house (not ground floor). No insulation (apart from loft) and heating bills are huge so try and turn off as much as possible but harder with children.

We never go out, no date nights (babysitter plus cost of going out would be too much. No coffees out, no meals out, no cinema. No holidays. Clothes from Vinted.

Our living costs have increased by around £2000 per month including increased mortgage £1200 month, increased nursery fees £550 month, energy and food bills etc

For the past two years I worked every weekend (apart from Christmas and Easter) and 2-4 days in the week. Some of my work is adhoc so unpredictable with childcare and have to put DC in nursery for full time.

I feel like we are working a lot harder but wages are not going up. Our outgoings have increased by £2000 month over the last two years but our lifestyles are much much worse.

We used to be able to go out for coffee/ meals/ cinema dates comfortably. We used to go on holiday a lot. We were able to buy high street clothes without thinking twice. House is currently freezing cold and on top of it all we also have a mouse problem (coming in from next door).

I know we are in a better position than some but I feel pretty down-beaten and exhausted with it all. I think inflation will back up again next year and I am not sure how we will financially and mentally manage it all.

To expect to have a better quality of life, working full time and working hard?

OP posts:
TrixieMixie · 22/11/2024 22:46

Move up north and role reverse. You work as a doctor, DH can get another job of some sort or be a stay at home dad and save on childcare - you could live well in the north east on just your consultant salary.

Mamabearsmile · 22/11/2024 22:43

Maybe it's time to consider a relocation for a better, more economically eased way of life? I know that sounds radical but there is no need to continue in such misery. Maybe the universe (and the cost of living) is giving you an opportunity to consider something different, more qualitative and affordable. I hate the fact that you're working so hard and seeing so little for your efforts. Sometimes an about turn can be perfect but you really do have to choose it. I wish you well with it in any case, concentrate on getting joy and time back into your life.

2Old2BABPpresenter · 22/11/2024 21:36

It’s tough and I really feel for you but everyone is squeezed, try and get out of London. Lots of places are commutable to London and you and your children will have a better quality of life.

Crikeyalmighty · 22/11/2024 21:28

@Completelyjo yep I agree- but no one forced them to buy a 1.5 mill house- and have such a massive mortgage- I have every understanding as to why they might have wanted to buy in London and don't disagree with doing that - but back in 2020 when they bought they could have bought a perfectly nice 4 bed family home in many decent areas for £900k or so - they had a big deposit - nor why last year the OP was debating whether it was worth buying the £30k kitchen etc - the OP clearly has flash tastes without the millionaire bank account and it's bitten them on the arse - it's not jealousy by the way- I don't like the idea of the OP or her kids living in a cold house with no money to do even basic fun things- I think she needs to look sideways -

Crikeyalmighty · 22/11/2024 21:20

@Winter2020 - thank you for explaining- I can see that's pointless- she either needs to flog it then and downgrade a bit - or use the basement for a live in nanny or rent the basement flat out

Justthistime1234 · 22/11/2024 21:13

We had kids who are now 18 and 20 and honestly even then the cost up to school age was unbelievable. So many mums stopped working for the 4-5 years and then found it hard to get back in. We both worked full time and in the end had a nanny for 2 of the years - which was insane with taxes too. Honestly though when the the first was at school and the second hit 2 we brought in an au pair and nursery for one and suddenly we were fine again. You potentially have 2 more years to go. You can do it x

Pixiedust88 · 22/11/2024 20:37

Completelyjo · 22/11/2024 19:58

To be fair being able to afford your bills and childcare for date nights while having your grandson isn’t remotely comparable to the OP’s situation.
As out of touch as she is for moaning that she can’t afford a coffee so are you for suggesting that the financial situation between a young family with less equity at the start of their mortgage is remotely similar to someone looking after their grandchildren.

I can afford all my bills but the reality is despite us both working FT with two children in nursery we cannot justify the £100 for a babysitter on top the cost of a meal so we certainly aren’t able to have regular date nights and certainly wouldn’t be able to do it on one of us working 2 days.

we don’t just look after him, he lives with us full time and we have to pay for everything for him as his mom and dad don’t contribute at all. We don’t go out for food, just a couple of drinks and we’re lucky enough to have my MIL living round the corner and she will watch him the two hours we’re out for.

what I’m trying to get at is OP is complaining about not having any money when she’s a doctor who contracts out to the NHS and her husband earns a fairly decent wage for them to live in the house they do in London where prices are sky high and wages are more when there’s people who work FT out of London scraping by on food parcels because they can’t afford not to work because of the COL

Winter2020 · 22/11/2024 20:26

A few people have suggested the OP should rent her house out. The OP seems to be aware of this being not viable due to the tax implications but to explain to others...

The OP would need to do a self assessment for the income from letting her property.

To use some round figures to illustrate the tax due: imagine OP's mortgage is 4k each month and 2k is mortgage interest and 2k is reducing the capital owed. Imagine the house rented out for 4k each month covering the mortgage exactly.

The OP and her husband would need to pay 40% tax (as higher rate tax payers) on the 2k each month reducing her mortgage capital owing so that's £800 each month.

Then they would owe 20% tax on the mortgage interest paid (40% tax and then 20% credited back) so £400 each month.

= tax due of £1200 each month or £14,400 each year even if the rent only covered the mortgage. It would be slightly less after the deduction of insurance/gas safety check/maintenance from profit but still a hefty chunk of cash to find for someone struggling with cash flow and likely cancelling out any benefit of renting somewhere cheaper themselves.

Completelyjo · 22/11/2024 19:58

Pixiedust88 · 22/11/2024 19:48

I still can’t get my head around you complaining about not being able to afford things with you being a doctor and your husband having a good job leaving you ineligible for the free nursery hours. COL is high everywhere not just London but other people manage to live on what they have coming in. My husband works for the NHS (band 2) and so did I (also band 2) until I was forced to give up work due to having to care for our grandson full time. We manage to pay all our bills, have date nights once a month AND pay for childcare (not eligible for 30’hours free as baby 10 months and 15 hours doesn’t kick in until January) on one FT salary, me working two days a week and a tiny top up from universal credit. Maybe think about downsizing if you can’t afford your mortgage and utility bills instead of complaining on here expecting sympathy

To be fair being able to afford your bills and childcare for date nights while having your grandson isn’t remotely comparable to the OP’s situation.
As out of touch as she is for moaning that she can’t afford a coffee so are you for suggesting that the financial situation between a young family with less equity at the start of their mortgage is remotely similar to someone looking after their grandchildren.

I can afford all my bills but the reality is despite us both working FT with two children in nursery we cannot justify the £100 for a babysitter on top the cost of a meal so we certainly aren’t able to have regular date nights and certainly wouldn’t be able to do it on one of us working 2 days.

BlueFlowers5 · 22/11/2024 19:57

This is the most challenging time financially with young family and childcare fees. When I went through this OP, it was awful. All I could do was head down, work hard and get through it.
A quick coffee at lunchtime, hopefully with an entertaining colleague.
Planned date nights at home. Lights off, popcorn etc.
This too shall pass. When your lovely children hit school, then big school, things will gradually ease up.

Good luck.

TheKeatingFive · 22/11/2024 19:51

MattBerningerstrophywife · 22/11/2024 13:06

I’m finding all the people saying that the OP should move out of London and either work elsewhere or commute in.

If a doctor cannot afford to live and work in London then God help us. London needs doctors

Hardly anyone can afford to live in London. What about all the teachers, nurses, police, social workers, etc? They all live outside and commute.

Pixiedust88 · 22/11/2024 19:48

I still can’t get my head around you complaining about not being able to afford things with you being a doctor and your husband having a good job leaving you ineligible for the free nursery hours. COL is high everywhere not just London but other people manage to live on what they have coming in. My husband works for the NHS (band 2) and so did I (also band 2) until I was forced to give up work due to having to care for our grandson full time. We manage to pay all our bills, have date nights once a month AND pay for childcare (not eligible for 30’hours free as baby 10 months and 15 hours doesn’t kick in until January) on one FT salary, me working two days a week and a tiny top up from universal credit. Maybe think about downsizing if you can’t afford your mortgage and utility bills instead of complaining on here expecting sympathy

Yourcatisnotsorry · 22/11/2024 19:44
  1. If you pay into your pension so that your take home is under 100k. This means you qualify for the funded childcare so both look at doing that.
  2. Cancel nursery while you are on mat leave. Yes you might lose the place but you will probably be better off with a nanny anyway with 2 so save yourself 15k and spend more time with your toddler.
  3. Husband look at other jobs. I work in the city and mostly wfh. This will also help with school runs etc.
  4. Arrange your work to have fixed days, this reduces your waste spending money on childcare when you aren’t working.
  5. Find things you and the kids enjoy which are free/low cost. Take picnics and have lovely days out and feel joy.
Sillyname63 · 22/11/2024 19:30

Would a nanny work out cheaper than nursery fees for 2? This would leave you free to accept shifts at short notice and you might even be able to have an occasional night out. You said it's a large house would you have the room to accommodate another adult?

Yoonimum · 22/11/2024 19:28

Dreambow · 21/11/2024 05:58

Thank you all for your useful replies and for being kind.

As I was contracting I am on maternity allowance which is not much but better than nothing. This is temporary so above is situation prior to maternity leave.

We have looked into moving out but DH and I do long hours (unable to compress). He has to go into the office and WFH is not encouraged so it would make nursery and later potentially school drop offs and pick ups viable if in London. I don’t think we could make it work out of London unfortunately as trains are too unreliable (and very costly).
Also I tend to work outside of London and need to travel really early to get there so being in London gives me the opportunity to do my job. If I lived out of London it would make by job unviable as I wouldn’t be able to make the hours work due to increased commute times.

We unfortunately do not have family close by - nearest in Wales but would not be in a position to help with childcare.

Really looked into a lodger as I think this would be really helpful but the cost of the energy bills needed to heat up house would outweigh the cost of a lodger in the colder months, which is crazy. Our house is very energy inefficient. Spoke to neighbours about coldness in house and they are similar and rack up huge heating bills over winter months/ heat up less rooms etc
We have insulated loft and blocked up fireplaces with chimney sheeps but I think it’s the external walls that are inefficient. The cost to insulate these would be crazy when I looked into it. Double glazed windows which has made some difference but not a lot. We probably should have replaced window boxes but couldn’t afford it. Our old house was Victorian but never had these problems and easier to heat.

Do you need to rethink on a bigger scale? You will find work wherever you go. If you move somewhere cheaper your husband could take a lower paid job and/or retrain. There is absolutely no point living in London in misery if you could be happier living on less elsewhere.

laraitopbanana · 22/11/2024 19:12

It is tough op.

I am sorry things are really not looking like things will get cheaper anytime soon…

It is probably not something to lightly consider but could you get some help from your parents? Financially? Or his? Maybe they can spare a few each months to get you through?

If not, I am afraid it is just like everyone else and to wait out the dreadful nursery years… it gets better after these.

Good luck op 🌺

Redburnett · 22/11/2024 19:02

OP you bought an expensive do-er upper house a few years ago and have apparently spent a fortune doing it up, at the same time as starting a family. Your current problems are the result of those decisions and not COL. That is not to blame you, we all make decisions that turn out to be unwise.
You are in the short term 'massive child care costs' phase of your life, but it should get better in the long run.
Please don't let the financial crap or comparisons with consultant colleagues prevent you from enjoying baby no.2. You are a high earner and it will come good int he end.

RosesAndHellebores · 22/11/2024 18:58

It isn't a government issue it's a cyclical issue. The market was long overdue an adjustment when the op bought.

I bought in 1981. Bottom of the marker.
Silly move in 1986 and broke even in 1993.

In 1993 bought a finished renovation when the builders went bankrupt. It was in an area under development and we took a risk. It came off. BUT it was finished because we were starting a family. I had a substantive job, DH was self employed. We had 50% equity and options if anything happened health or work wise. We had taken incremental steps and had headroom if two incomes dropped to one.

The op and dh made a choice. They now have to deal with the consequences and cut their cloth and/or their losses.

nationalsausagefund · 22/11/2024 18:49

ForSillyPinkPeer · 22/11/2024 18:02

I think it's a nightmare for everybody, and this government is just making it a whole lot worse! Ideology and resentment envy this government has only made me sad.

I lived through the 60's 70's and 80s that were bad, with power cuts, three day weeks, etc, but you could see a way out.

I saw this ideology we are now being dragged into without choice and no manifesto. In 1978, I went to Russia during the Cold War behind the iron curtain. I went there shortly before Kier Starmer went to Czechoslovakia. There were the ELITE who wanted for nothing, then the masses scratching around for an existence with almost nothing. They were living in fear of having an opinion or stepping out of line. This is his ideology Kier Starmers' government is heading for. He's going to destroy the uk by the time he is finished.

I actually don't see a way out for four years until the next election. By then, there will be so much damage we may never recover!

I feel sorry for my grandchildren and your children. What life will this be? We can only sweat it out!

Hang on, you’re blaming OP’s predicament on the government that’s been in power for less than six months, but not on the last lot who merrily fucked us all for 14 years?

RosesAndHellebores · 22/11/2024 18:37

The trouble is the op bought at the top. Things have changed dramatically and they now have a semi complete renovation project that is not ready to sell in a falling market. It's an issue of misjudgement. Many did the same in 1989 and suffered. One would have thought that two very intelligent people might have done a better risk analysis.

angela1952 · 22/11/2024 18:26

Dreambow · 21/11/2024 11:31

@OrlandointheWilderness i agree - one life only and don’t want to waste it. My DH puts his head in the sand a lot and we are often too busy to sit down and go through options but we need to.

@hettie his job is very London centric. When I looked at the numbers we could move to commuter areas but the cost is now similar to London plus unreliable costly trains in the mix.

@hattie43 this. It does make me think the UK is tanking. I think inflation will go up again a lot next year and this make me worried. We are working to pay bills and keep afloat. I will think if two people are working full time there has to be rewards in life, not just surviving.

@Dreambow "his job is very London centric. When I looked at the numbers we could move to commuter areas but the cost is now similar to London plus unreliable costly trains in the mix".

It all depends on where your DH works. You'd be surprised by how much cheaper it is to live in, say, Kent or parts of Surrey such as Epsom; many places have excellent, reliable, fast trainlines. I know people who have successfully moved to both areas in the past few years.

Now that the Elizabeth Line is working there are far more other options too: Twyford to Farringdon just under an hour for example

I'm older and can absolutely see why you'd prefer to stay in London - that's what we did because of my DH's job in central London and his need to be near Heathrow for overseas travel. But it was always a real struggle as we earned less than you and lack of any nurseries in those days meant that I either paid for more expensive childcare or didn't work until the children were at full-time school. Today I think that we'd probably have moved further out.

Perhaps you could take a longer look at options for bearable commuting for your DH? Presumably you would still get a good salary in any large hospital so could avoid the commute yourself.

My DD and DIL had horrendous nursery costs, they just sucked it up because they knew that it wouldn't last forever.

Artistbythewater · 22/11/2024 18:22

You have massively overextended.

fetchacloth · 22/11/2024 18:05

username358 · 21/11/2024 05:01

If you're living beyond your means then move somewhere cheaper and commute like other people.

This really OP. To be honest if you want to improve your lives you'll have to consider moving to a cheaper area.

ForSillyPinkPeer · 22/11/2024 18:02

I think it's a nightmare for everybody, and this government is just making it a whole lot worse! Ideology and resentment envy this government has only made me sad.

I lived through the 60's 70's and 80s that were bad, with power cuts, three day weeks, etc, but you could see a way out.

I saw this ideology we are now being dragged into without choice and no manifesto. In 1978, I went to Russia during the Cold War behind the iron curtain. I went there shortly before Kier Starmer went to Czechoslovakia. There were the ELITE who wanted for nothing, then the masses scratching around for an existence with almost nothing. They were living in fear of having an opinion or stepping out of line. This is his ideology Kier Starmers' government is heading for. He's going to destroy the uk by the time he is finished.

I actually don't see a way out for four years until the next election. By then, there will be so much damage we may never recover!

I feel sorry for my grandchildren and your children. What life will this be? We can only sweat it out!

Completelyjo · 22/11/2024 17:31

Also if you can’t afford a coffee while you’ve still been on 90% maternity leave and likely enhanced leave anyway if you’re in a role earning well over 100k then how do you think you’re going to have 1.5k spare a month for nursery in however many months?
Either your issue is you don’t feel as well off as you thought you would by the time you earned X salary or you can’t actually afford to heat your home, buy the odd coffee or the occasional weekly £10 baby class. Two very different problems, if it’s the first I think everyone sympathises. Through a mixture of COL, kids and therefore essential expenses increasing I definitely have less spare cash for frivolities compared to when my wage was less than half it is now.
Or you’re in a 1.6M house not being able to “afford” to pay into a pension on a 150k+ salary or the occasional £4 a week coffee, in which case you really need to evaluate your lifestyle and choices.

Swipe left for the next trending thread