Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be Concerned about husband's reaction to Xmas planning making it about race

393 replies

anonymousxmasposter · 17/11/2024 23:06

I'm a British Asian woman married to a white man, and I'm currently pregnant with our first child. I need some advice about a situation that's really bothering me.

I suggested hosting Christmas this year but separately for our families - mainly because of logistics. My family is quite large (10 people), younger (mostly teens and twenty-somethings), and celebrates with music, games, and a lively atmosphere. His family is small (4 people), much older (60s-80s), more traditional, and quieter. His father has dementia and hearing difficulties, which makes large gatherings challenging for him.

When I suggested hosting our families separately to make everyone more comfortable, my husband immediately accused me of wanting an "Asian-only Christmas where we just do our own Asian thing." I was shocked because it had nothing to do with race - I was thinking about space, comfort levels, and very different celebration styles. My sisters boyfriend is white too, so it wasn't about excluding anyone based on race.

I ended up feeling so guilty that I changed my plans to invite his family, but I'm deeply troubled by his response and how quickly he turned a practical concern into a racial accusation. This isn't the first time he's done something like this - any discussion involving race tends to end badly.

I'm especially worried as we're expecting a child. What if our child had heard that comment?

Im also keen to hear from people in same race relationships, for Xmas if you were hosting at your home, do you also blend families - was it weird of me to say I didn't want to do that?

Whether you have or haven't what the hell do I do with this as feel really alone with this and could use some advice as I have no one I can talk to about this without judgement.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Shhhthedogssleeping · 20/11/2024 23:36

How I got through living with an emotionally unavailable person with no insight into his own or anyone else’s feelings or behaviour was to feel lonely, depressed, unheard and sad. For 23 years. I did eventually get the strength to leave. My biggest regret is wasting so many years feeling less than and having my confidence and self-esteem worn away to a wafer thin, fragile shell. Once I was away from him, I built up my life from scratch in my mid-40s. For 20 years I’ve grown in strength, in my ability to be able to cope with life on my own, to have made wonderful friends and to feel happy and at peace . I wish I’d done it when my DC were small. His influence in their lives has been negative and a very bad role model regarding what a healthy, mutual partnership should be.

pikkumyy77 · 20/11/2024 22:00

You understand your cage and your keeper really well. That is something you have worked hard and faithfully to do. But understanding that the bars are irin and the keeper is sad doesn’t make the cage tolerable. You are on a journey to understanding what life you have to sacrifice to pretend everything is ok. He will accept nothing less than total capitulation to his whims and unreasonable thoughts and actions. His hostility must be respected or you myst collude with him when he insists it was just a joke. His moods are righteous and reasonable and yours are signs of disease—you are crazy, mental, sulky, abusive.

It is going to take you a while, perhaps, to accept what we are saying. A while and a lot if pain. Because he is going to keep hurting you as long as you stay.

Experience is a dear teacher. But men will have no other. —Ben Franklin

ThatTealViewer · 20/11/2024 21:15

anonymousxmasposter · 20/11/2024 20:43

@ThatTealViewer I started reason to thank you but it's a full on novel! It will take time

It’s a book, yes. A few relevant excerpts.

To be Concerned about husband's reaction to Xmas planning making it about race
To be Concerned about husband's reaction to Xmas planning making it about race
To be Concerned about husband's reaction to Xmas planning making it about race
To be Concerned about husband's reaction to Xmas planning making it about race
Codlingmoths · 20/11/2024 20:51

anonymousxmasposter · 20/11/2024 20:46

@Shhhthedogssleeping thank you out talking to my mom is just going to ruin the relationship she has with him. I really don't see the point.

I've considered speaking to his mom about it but she's so placid and conflict avoidance that it'll never work. She will just say something like we just get on with it.

I also think these are learned behaviours he has, he is adamant his parents are happy but whenever his mom wants to bring anything to his dad she says she didn't because he will get cross. Even things in his best interest.

So the point is, he sees happiness as putting up and accepting people for who they are. Because that's what he's been shown

But he’s not doing that, he’s not accepting you one bit.

anonymousxmasposter · 20/11/2024 20:46

@Shhhthedogssleeping thank you out talking to my mom is just going to ruin the relationship she has with him. I really don't see the point.

I've considered speaking to his mom about it but she's so placid and conflict avoidance that it'll never work. She will just say something like we just get on with it.

I also think these are learned behaviours he has, he is adamant his parents are happy but whenever his mom wants to bring anything to his dad she says she didn't because he will get cross. Even things in his best interest.

So the point is, he sees happiness as putting up and accepting people for who they are. Because that's what he's been shown

OP posts:
anonymousxmasposter · 20/11/2024 20:43

@ThatTealViewer I started reason to thank you but it's a full on novel! It will take time

OP posts:
ThatTealViewer · 20/11/2024 20:41

anonymousxmasposter · 20/11/2024 20:36

@CovertPiggery there's defo good people around but they will start to resent him for hurting me and it won't help which is why I don't wish to involve any friends or family

When you say it won’t help, what do you mean, though? As I suspect you mean it won’t help you because you want to stay with your husband, whatever happens. You have family that actually loves and respects you, go to them and let them help you.

People who love you SHOULD resent someone who hurts you. YOU should resent someone who hurts you. It’s really worrying that you don’t.

I posted a link to ‘Why Does He Fo That?’ a few times, yesterday. Are you willing to read it?

anonymousxmasposter · 20/11/2024 20:36

@CovertPiggery there's defo good people around but they will start to resent him for hurting me and it won't help which is why I don't wish to involve any friends or family

OP posts:
CovertPiggery · 20/11/2024 20:30

anonymousxmasposter · 20/11/2024 19:54

@CovertPiggery I agree but he's given me an ultimatum and right now being pregnant feeling awful amount all other things - leaving I just don't have the strength for.

I appreciate Mumsnet have said this throughout the thread but if anyone has advice aside from leaving and has perhaps been in a similar situation I'd love to hear

I do understand where you're coming from.

I reacted the same way when I was given the same advice. All I wanted was for people to say it was my fault and all I needed to do was X, Y, Z and everything would be ok. Leaving is scary. I can only imagine how much harder it seems when you're pregnant.

I think most people saying to think about leaving have been in a similar situation and that's why they are saying that.

I do know it's not easy and I hope you can reach out to your friends/family for support. It sounds like you have good people around you who would listen to you.

anonymousxmasposter · 20/11/2024 20:15

@OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon February

OP posts:
OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 20/11/2024 20:14

so you are going to sit and be sad miserable and lonely in silence.

when is baby due ?

anonymousxmasposter · 20/11/2024 19:58

@pikkumyy77 I explained to him yesterday I don't feel like he loves me and I feel stupid, lacking confidence, undervalued and dismissed. He didn't reply, we were both angry. He just said this has to stop as it's not healthy and if it happens again he will go away somewhere.

I haven't bought it up again I'll just wait to speak to counsellor now

OP posts:
anonymousxmasposter · 20/11/2024 19:56

@5128gap honestly his family as sweet and kind to me, I have nothing against them.

I just don't want to put my family in a position of making their Xmas awkward. I know my family well and I know 100% they'd prefer it to be just them.

I've also had family feel his dad is sometimes off with them and this is usually because his dad is poor socially unless had a drink. He won't be drinking as he'll be driving so I'm worried about that too.

OP posts:
anonymousxmasposter · 20/11/2024 19:54

@CovertPiggery I agree but he's given me an ultimatum and right now being pregnant feeling awful amount all other things - leaving I just don't have the strength for.

I appreciate Mumsnet have said this throughout the thread but if anyone has advice aside from leaving and has perhaps been in a similar situation I'd love to hear

OP posts:
MarkingBad · 20/11/2024 17:09

With the best will in the world, your DH is not going to change. Stop trying to make him understand, he simply doesn't want to and he won't however much you keep on at him. He has told you this quite plainly from what you have said

The only way you will get change is if you make it yourself. How you do that is entirely up to you of course and depends on whether you want to remain is this dreadful situation or if you want to give yourself and your baby the best chance in life.

You can't psychoanalyise him out of this, no amount of therapy speak will work.

Shhhthedogssleeping · 20/11/2024 16:20

Codlingmoths. I’d be leaving him and going to my DPs for 2 weeks (at least). I’d be telling him why and then let him see if he realises he needs to shape up or you will be reconsidering this relationship. How he reacts to being left to ‘think’ will be revealing . How much is he prepared to fight to improve his marriage and commitment and involvement to his baby, once they have been born. OP needs to show that she will not put up with this.

LivingLaVidaBabyShower · 20/11/2024 10:00

This evening he said he is going to take a break for two weeks if this happens again where I drag something out because it's not healthy.

this is totally unacceptable and if you don’t react to it you are basically giving him a green light to continue this bullshit.
i would be telling him to get out of your house and take the 2 weeks now.
i would be talking this through at length with your councillor as when are you due and this behaviour will escalate and l ramp up land you will be much more vulnerable

Lampzade · 20/11/2024 08:43

The truth is that your dh is not ready to be the father to a mixed child with a different culture.
My cousin is married to a lady of Nigerian origin.
Before they married they had extensive discussions about how they were going to navigate an interracial relationship particularly in terms of bringing up the children.
They discussed the wedding, naming the children ( as cousin’s wife wanted her kids to have a Nigerian middle name) .
My cousin understood that his mixed children would not have the same experience as he had ( him being a white male) and would likely experience racism.
My cousin and his wife are happily married

Op’s dh wants to leave the ‘race’ issue.to his wife . I pity those kids

Codlingmoths · 20/11/2024 08:30

Please listen to me op. He is trying to bully you into compliance and never challenging him. You must challenge this now. You need to say I am about to have our baby, this is a challenging and emotional time for a woman learning to look after a new baby while physically recovering from giving birth. I had expected to have your support during it, but here you are telling me you will leave if I am upset about something. I want you to leave now- take those two weeks. I won’t bring up a baby with the man who said that to me, I won’t have the world believe I’m supported as a new mum while my husband tells me if I’m unhappy I need to hide it. If this is you our marriage will not survive a new baby and I am far better off setting up my own home now so I have a plan to cope. If you won’t leave I will, I will move home for two weeks.

and do leave. Let him realise marriages are fragile, they die if you don’t care for them, and women giving birth need support not abuse.

Lampzade · 20/11/2024 08:28

5Bagatelles · 20/11/2024 07:12

As someone in an interracial marriage with an often-defensive husband, let me break down what's happening for you:

He senses his family's discomfort around your family, your culture and your food. He's hoping you haven't noticed but in case you have, he's launching a pre-emptive strike that portrays you and your family as the problem, rather than his. If you ever point out his family's discomfort, he will accuse you of making everything about race. He will tell you that that's just how they are. This is 100% toxic.

But two things can be true at once.

Now, a question for you: how do you really feel about his family dynamic? Yours is younger, larger and less traditional- it sounds more fun and warmer. You are probably (understandably) more drawn to spending time with your family. Do you visibly have more fun with them than with his family? Are you less relaxed around his family? However you feel about his family dynamic, he has probably picked up on that too and likely feels hurt by it. He can't change his family and needs you to be a good sport. Not all the time. Just often enough that he realises you're on the same team. That might encourage him to make an effort to see things from your perspective too.

Problems like this tend to get worse once babies arrive so nip it in the bud while you can. Host a joint Christmas. It is a beautiful thing when two families from different cultures can come together, no matter how different you think they are. I could have written your post a few years ago (our families are very very different) but now our parents visit each other without us (and they live in different countries!).

Good luck! Your marriage will be fine! :)

Edited

i agree with most of this. However, I am not sure that the marriage will be fine

CovertPiggery · 20/11/2024 08:28

HollyKnight · 19/11/2024 23:58

You are dismissing all the explanations because you don't like them. But that doesn't mean they aren't true. And asking him/MN the same thing over and over isn't going to get you a more palpable answer.

You don't correct people who think you've spent the past 8 Christmases with just his family (maybe because you think it will undermine your argument?) You've presented the situation here in a way that makes your husband sound like a bullying racist so of course people are going to tell you to leave him. They can only go on what you are telling them in the way you are telling it.

He gave you his reason for saying what he said. You don't like it because it says something negative about you. You keep hounding him because you want him to give you a different answer. But if he actually genuinely believes he was making a joke and that your decision to leave his family out is selfish he's not going to give you a different answer. He is just going to get more annoyed, blunt, and dismissive with you which people will continually to tell you is because he's abusive.

Maybe he is racist or maybe he is just fed up of a pattern of you misinterpreting him and beating him with it. Who knows. It's something you need to work through with a therapist. They are better trained at getting you to focus your thoughts, instead of this relentless circular spiraling you're putting yourself through. It's not good for you.

The difficulty is, OP knows it wasn't a joke. Her Husband knows it wasn't a joke.

Everyone knows the difference when someone says something spitefully to hurt them and when it's a joke.

Jokes aren't said angrily or spitefully.

I really don't think OP should just pretend to believe it was a joke when she knows it wasn't.

CovertPiggery · 20/11/2024 08:24

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 19/11/2024 23:58

so you dear husband has now informed you that he is going to leave you for 2 weeks if you cause a row with him again ?

This is not how good people treat their spouses OP.

He's trying everything he can to silence you.

He's spiteful to you to deliberately upset you when you disagree with him, then he lies about it, pretends it's a joke and gets annoyed at you for being upset.

He then gives a half-hearted apology, but also with more accusations that it was basically your fault and if you don't immediately crush your (valid) emotions he'll leave you for 2 weeks.

It's not right.

5Bagatelles · 20/11/2024 07:12

As someone in an interracial marriage with an often-defensive husband, let me break down what's happening for you:

He senses his family's discomfort around your family, your culture and your food. He's hoping you haven't noticed but in case you have, he's launching a pre-emptive strike that portrays you and your family as the problem, rather than his. If you ever point out his family's discomfort, he will accuse you of making everything about race. He will tell you that that's just how they are. This is 100% toxic.

But two things can be true at once.

Now, a question for you: how do you really feel about his family dynamic? Yours is younger, larger and less traditional- it sounds more fun and warmer. You are probably (understandably) more drawn to spending time with your family. Do you visibly have more fun with them than with his family? Are you less relaxed around his family? However you feel about his family dynamic, he has probably picked up on that too and likely feels hurt by it. He can't change his family and needs you to be a good sport. Not all the time. Just often enough that he realises you're on the same team. That might encourage him to make an effort to see things from your perspective too.

Problems like this tend to get worse once babies arrive so nip it in the bud while you can. Host a joint Christmas. It is a beautiful thing when two families from different cultures can come together, no matter how different you think they are. I could have written your post a few years ago (our families are very very different) but now our parents visit each other without us (and they live in different countries!).

Good luck! Your marriage will be fine! :)

Lampzade · 20/11/2024 06:01

pikkumyy77 · 20/11/2024 00:51

I am one if the many posters who have identified your husband as a lazy, selfish, racist, abuser. I did that on the strength of your reports of what he habitually says and how he treats you. For your information I am the product of a happy marriage of 70 years, and have been very happily married myself for 30. I am also a licensed therapist in the US and have given couples therapy (although it isn’t my specialty).

Your situation is really bad but you don’t seem to know it. That is actually one of the warning signs that you are in a toxic relationship: you come out of fairly routine and minor disagreements with your husband feeling confused, shamed, attacked, misunderstood, silenced, and mor unhappy than when you started.

Your husband is work shy when it comes to your future child. He routinely attacks and demeans you verbally, accuses you of being irrational, drags in random “friends “ to give him a spurious authority, and threatens to escalate conflict by punishing you/leaving you for the crime of not giving in fast enough or cravenly enough for him.

This is completely improper behavior in what is supposed to be a love match. Do you think this is what love looks like? Brcause I don’t. Nothing should be too good for his pregnant wife. He should be eager to pitch in with his own child. He should be concerned about their experience as a mixed race child and eager to learn how to raise them successfully. He should be appreciative of all you have offered to do for his family and eager to return the favour.

He’s basically not much of a good human. I wouldn’t take him off your hands for any price. Why waste your life with someone sho doesn’t adore you? The world is hard enough without giving yourself to this wanker.

All of this

pikkumyy77 · 20/11/2024 00:51

I am one if the many posters who have identified your husband as a lazy, selfish, racist, abuser. I did that on the strength of your reports of what he habitually says and how he treats you. For your information I am the product of a happy marriage of 70 years, and have been very happily married myself for 30. I am also a licensed therapist in the US and have given couples therapy (although it isn’t my specialty).

Your situation is really bad but you don’t seem to know it. That is actually one of the warning signs that you are in a toxic relationship: you come out of fairly routine and minor disagreements with your husband feeling confused, shamed, attacked, misunderstood, silenced, and mor unhappy than when you started.

Your husband is work shy when it comes to your future child. He routinely attacks and demeans you verbally, accuses you of being irrational, drags in random “friends “ to give him a spurious authority, and threatens to escalate conflict by punishing you/leaving you for the crime of not giving in fast enough or cravenly enough for him.

This is completely improper behavior in what is supposed to be a love match. Do you think this is what love looks like? Brcause I don’t. Nothing should be too good for his pregnant wife. He should be eager to pitch in with his own child. He should be concerned about their experience as a mixed race child and eager to learn how to raise them successfully. He should be appreciative of all you have offered to do for his family and eager to return the favour.

He’s basically not much of a good human. I wouldn’t take him off your hands for any price. Why waste your life with someone sho doesn’t adore you? The world is hard enough without giving yourself to this wanker.

Swipe left for the next trending thread