Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SAHM + Nanny

334 replies

Namechang3ds · 17/11/2024 14:57

I’d be very grateful for some non judgemental views. I’ll start by saying that where we live in central London - Nannie’s are very popular!

I have two children who have a one year age gap exactly. So I am still in maternity leave with my second. Given the close age gap, we have a lovely nanny who is very much part of our family. She is really lovely and I look forward to seeing her everyday.

She helps me a lot - particularly taking my toddler to tonnes of stay and plays and baby classes and also taking care of them both so I can go to the gym etc.

I am really happy with my arrangement and we financially can afford it. But I went to a friends birthday over the weekend, and people looked at me with shock/confusion that I do not currently work (but I will go back in 6m) and also have a nanny. I didn’t disclose this info to them quickly but when it slipped into conversation it made me feel almost guilty…that I should be doing this with them both myself rather than having someone to help

Sorry for rambling it just got me down. But the way I see it is that she is lovely, it makes my life easier and I am happy! And I can afford it. It just made me feel bad.

OP posts:
FixingStuff · 17/11/2024 17:05

This is a great idea. I wish I had had the same option. Well done to you.

PowerfulLotus · 17/11/2024 17:04

As a fellow woman, I love this for you! If I had the resources and financial means, I would do the same. I say celebrate having the confidence to put yourself first simply because you are deserving. Common myth appears to be that unless we are self-sacrificing as women, we can never be great mothers.

Quitelikeit · 17/11/2024 17:04

Well if the nanny is full time then in my worldly view op you are not a sahm.

You can dress it how you like op 😂😂

You can also crack on with your lovely swimming and daily steams but in the true sense of the word you are not carrying out the role on your own

I mean you literally pay someone to parent whilst you are in the room 😂😂 sounds fab but don’t try to kid yourself that you are a sahm. In reality you do not stay at home you do what you like throughout the days

I am not jealous btw but my pride would never have allowed me to do what you do. I’d never have wanted others to think I couldn’t manage on my own and tbh isn’t it a touch lazy? Is your dh perhaps thinking you could slide into a depression? Does he think you are not capable of going it alone?

I could understand a couple of hours a week here and there so you could get certain things done

Saying others are jealous is a tad ott as there are plenty women who would not want or need the assistance regardless of income.

LostittoBostik · 17/11/2024 17:04

JaneandtheLaundry · 17/11/2024 15:00

So you're actually on mat leave not a SAHM? YANBU if you let her go for months on end she would get another job and there's no guarantee you'd get another of her calibre very quickly!

This is what I would have said to them too.

They're just jealous OP. As am I 😅 If you can afford it, take the help! Don't feel guilty about it

Namechang3ds · 17/11/2024 17:03

Ytcsghisn · 17/11/2024 17:01

Who is paying for the nanny? If you are paying yourself, why is it any of other people’s business. Plenty of people living it large at taxpayer’s expense, those are the ones taking the piss.

Oh my!! Absolutely not living it large at taxpayers expensive. Have never claimed anything! All paid from my own pocket!

OP posts:
Blackfluffycats · 17/11/2024 17:03

Sounds like bliss!

If I could afford one I would and I’m on maternity leave with my second. My toddler goes to preschool 3 days a week and I find the 2 days I have them both so hard!

Namechang3ds · 17/11/2024 17:02

CookieMonster28 · 17/11/2024 16:55

I've just seen update that your nanny is full time. I would judge tbh and not because of jealously! Just not what I would personally do...but as I said before I certainly wouldn't voice it and make you feel shit about it as it's whatever works for you.

May I ask why you would judge?

OP posts:
WigglyVonWaggly · 17/11/2024 17:02

It’s ideal and anyone who says it’s not is bonkers! Its nothing do with them, but if you feel judged then just tell them that she’s so fantastic that she’s a part of the family now and you didn’t want to risk letting her go for such a short time as she’d even be unavailable when you needed her again so have kept her on. That will make them more jealous, but (shrug).

Ytcsghisn · 17/11/2024 17:01

Who is paying for the nanny? If you are paying yourself, why is it any of other people’s business. Plenty of people living it large at taxpayer’s expense, those are the ones taking the piss.

Zen8 · 17/11/2024 17:01

They're just jealous. I think you all get the best of everything this way. Better for the kids. Better for you.

ChampagneLassie · 17/11/2024 17:00

Honestly leave this group. Like you say it’s common in London to have Nannie’s I’m sure there will be other places with more like minded mothers who don’t see it as some sort of competitive martyrdom

readingismycardio · 17/11/2024 16:56

Yeah, because sacrifice is glorified!! So, so sad. Good for you, OP!!!

CookieMonster28 · 17/11/2024 16:55

I've just seen update that your nanny is full time. I would judge tbh and not because of jealously! Just not what I would personally do...but as I said before I certainly wouldn't voice it and make you feel shit about it as it's whatever works for you.

Motherofdragons20 · 17/11/2024 16:55

Well I suppose most SAHM don’t “need” a nanny, but I don’t really need online shopping deliveries, a robot hoover, and a cleaner every week but it makes my life more bearable and we can afford it. Do what you want OP it’s nobody’s business what you and your family do, if it works for you smile and carry on are you are.

Namechang3ds · 17/11/2024 16:53

WitchesCauldron · 17/11/2024 16:46

Take absolutely no notice- they're just jealous. She's nice, you get on. What's not to like!

I guess they implied I was lazy and didn’t take care of my kids!

OP posts:
PlopSofa · 17/11/2024 16:53

I never went back OP by the way. I wanted to spend more time with my children.

PlopSofa · 17/11/2024 16:53

Namechang3ds · 17/11/2024 16:44

Yes. Regularly travels abroad 2-3 days a week and works 13-14h days and evenings!

That's like my DH. It's not changed and kids are much older now.

I really needed the help back then. Don't ever feel guilty about this.

Parker231 · 17/11/2024 16:52

Wishingplenty · 17/11/2024 16:01

God that is truly grim and shocking. That is literally what a mum is for. Why on earth would you have babies if you can't even be bothered to tend to them yourself at night? I can understand needing help day to day with practical stuff, but outsourcing actual mothering, just no!

My DMil flew over to stay when DT’s were born. She was a teacher and luckily they were born just at the start of the long summer school holidays. She did the majority of the night feeds for the DT’s and got them into a good routine. If she hadn’t been able to come over, I would have paid for a night nanny.

BoundaryGirl3939 · 17/11/2024 16:50

Gosh, no. You're giving your family and children as much support as possible. That can't be bad.

Goody2ShoesAndTheFilthyBeast · 17/11/2024 16:48

It's got fuck all to do with anyone else.

It makes your life easier
It's giving someone employment.

win/win as far as I'm concerned.

Nobody's handing out medals for wearing yourself out doing everything. If you can afford help and want help then there's nothing wrong with that.

TheWrongBus · 17/11/2024 16:48

YADNBU, I have a 17 month age gap and was able to survive the first year with both only by keeping my son in nursery 4 days a week. I appreciate that (like you) we were very lucky to be able to afford childcare when I was on mat leave, but I would have really struggled with both full time. I also appreciate that lots of people do have to struggle with 2, 3 or more young children and lots besides and don’t have this luxury, but I’m not suffering for the sake of it or out of some misplaced sense of solidarity with others!

Maria1979 · 17/11/2024 16:47

Sahm here. I wouldn't have liked a nanny (but that's because I really enjoyed being with my children + didn't want anyone else to do it, trustissues) but I would never have judged you. I think I would have been jealous of you being able to trust someone with your baby (which is sane, I'm the loony one with trust issues) to get some time for myself. The thing is people will always judge. I had mums telling me "don't know how you can take care of your children all the time, don't you get bored?". I could have told them that I wouldn't leave my children to a childminder (having 4 children at charge) at 3 months old if I don't have to having seen how a lot of them (not all) talk about children and how it's bordering on neglect when they let them "cry it out" instead of comforting them. You are lucky as you have a motivated lovely nanny who only do your kids. Kids are happy, you are happy and it's really great for all of you. Don't listen to what envious/ignorant people say. You know you are doing what's Best for YOUR family and in the end that's all that matters.

WitchesCauldron · 17/11/2024 16:46

Namechang3ds · 17/11/2024 14:57

I’d be very grateful for some non judgemental views. I’ll start by saying that where we live in central London - Nannie’s are very popular!

I have two children who have a one year age gap exactly. So I am still in maternity leave with my second. Given the close age gap, we have a lovely nanny who is very much part of our family. She is really lovely and I look forward to seeing her everyday.

She helps me a lot - particularly taking my toddler to tonnes of stay and plays and baby classes and also taking care of them both so I can go to the gym etc.

I am really happy with my arrangement and we financially can afford it. But I went to a friends birthday over the weekend, and people looked at me with shock/confusion that I do not currently work (but I will go back in 6m) and also have a nanny. I didn’t disclose this info to them quickly but when it slipped into conversation it made me feel almost guilty…that I should be doing this with them both myself rather than having someone to help

Sorry for rambling it just got me down. But the way I see it is that she is lovely, it makes my life easier and I am happy! And I can afford it. It just made me feel bad.

Take absolutely no notice- they're just jealous. She's nice, you get on. What's not to like!

Namechang3ds · 17/11/2024 16:44

LoveSandbanks · 17/11/2024 16:43

I didn’t have a nanny, we could never have afforded it but I’m going to guess that your husband (and yourself) earns a bloody good salary. Bloody good salaries inevitably come with long hours and he’s probably not much help when he is around and, frankly, he needs to be engaging with the children in the limited time he’s at home. My husband worked away and it was fucking hard. Why out yourself through that shit if you can afford not to??

when I had my 3rd I was a member of a gym that had a crèche and he was in that crèche the very day he turned 6 weeks old (and the staff couldn’t wait to get him)

There are no prizes for doing it all and “managing” mother and children both benefit if mum can look after herself.

when I was in the thick of it I’d have been jealous as hell, no doubt. But that’s my issue, not yours.

Yes. Regularly travels abroad 2-3 days a week and works 13-14h days and evenings!

OP posts:
Apollo365 · 17/11/2024 16:44

Namechang3ds · 17/11/2024 16:30

I have been added to a group with these people and it is non stop comparing of babies (for the 3h I’ve been in the group!) and everyone almost “competing” as to who is sleeping the least and teething the worst. It is exhausting!!

Tbh this is awful and will cause you problems. Leave and find your people elsewhere