Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mil issue?

38 replies

Firsttimedad1989 · 16/11/2024 19:40

Hi new dad and new poster here , I saw a post last week I think it was and it was very similar problem to what I have but I never got a chance to see the results and I think it went offline.

I have an issue with my mil and it drives me mad!

Our daughter is 3months old for context

My mil is constantly saying “nana” to our baby I mean constantly!! So much so that I have started counting.. I know it’s sad but I thought I was going insane as my wife didn’t hear it. In a 4 hour visit it was said way over the 100 times! Probably closer to 150! Its nearly every other word! It’s very irritating and I find it really inappropriate.

we say “mummy” “daddy” as all parents do.. but a tiny fraction compared to my MIL. I’m finding I’m having to say mumma and dadda way more than what feels comfortable because of it.

I personally feel she’s doing it to get one of her first words to be nana, i would be upset if nana comes before mumma.

My mil is quite interfering and she’s often said she sees our daughter as her child. when she does come over or we visit her she does seem to take over and almost mother her. I do feel quite self conscious as she doesn’t take her eyes off our daughter and wants to grab her at any possible moment. Which is annoying.

I know it sounds silly but the way my mil says “nana” is completely unnatural, it’s only said to drum that word into my daughter, she will say 3/4 times in a row.. that isn’t normal to say.

A i being unreasonable?

OP posts:
5128gap · 16/11/2024 20:13

"MiL don't keep saying nana to DD because I'm worried it will be her first word. Yeah, I know if I'd done my research I'd know how unlikely that would be given they almost all start with something we take to mean dada or baba because that's how speech develops, but y"know I don't wanna take the risk"...?

Kaleidoscopic101 · 16/11/2024 20:12

Argh how self flatulating! Agree with @P1550FF 👆 ... The fair thing would be to have a tactful word ...then you can be satisfied you've given her a chance to change her behaviour. Unfortunately some relatives have a narcissistic tendency to think the baby is their right and exists to fill some sort of emotional or egotistical hole. On the other hand it's early days and perhaps the novelty will wear off...as soon as baby starts being patient zero for illnesses, it's surprising how effective it is for warding off interfering relatives!

P1550FF · 16/11/2024 20:12

I think you’re dealing with a bit of a narcissist here, she’s making it all about me, me, moi.
Honestly, kids are not stupid. As they get a bit older they start to see things for what they are and the desperation and fakery of this woman will become obvious.
Just enjoy being a Dad as much as you can. If it helps, I think most grandparents step back a bit after the early baby stage once they realise that the parents have got this. She’ll soon realise that she’s surplus to requirements.

Firsttimedad1989 · 16/11/2024 20:08

LivingLaVidaBabyShower · 16/11/2024 19:54

Honestly I’d just lightheartedly say dada dada dada all the time OR join in with the nana nana naaaanaaaa

making fun is a non tense way to communicate how annoying she is…

she sounds bloody annoying though

I have tried bringing it up in a jokey manner, she just said “but I want her know who I am”

OP posts:
P1550FF · 16/11/2024 19:59

She is overstepping the mark and passive aggressively being dominating and controlling. You’re very vulnerable as a new parent and it doesn’t help when grandparents make it all about themselves.
She probably has never been put in her place by your partner/wife. Speak to her and share your concerns. Tell her how much it is irritating you and can she have a word with her mum.
Don’t worry though, you’re still mum and dad and the most important people to your baby.
Nanna needs some boundaries and she needs to learn some respect.

Firsttimedad1989 · 16/11/2024 19:56

AnnaDelvorkina · 16/11/2024 19:51

better if your wife speaks to her mother about this, I think, but YANBU.

Most babies make the dada sound first, regardless of whether that’s a word they’re heard or that exists in their language, it’s how speech develops.

Unfortunately my wife won’t talk to her about it because she doesn’t want to upset her,

im aware it won’t be her first word but could be her second third. I wouid just be upset if she’s close to sounding “m” and my mil interpreting it as an “n” sounding word and repeats nana instead of mumma, if that makes sense

OP posts:
PrimalOwl10 · 16/11/2024 19:55

Why have you done another thread about your mil?

FairFuming · 16/11/2024 19:55

She's massively over stepping but does your wife mind? I don't think you can really raise it too much if she doesn't. My now ex MIL did this with Gran or Gaga and my daughter ended up calling her Nin (no idea why) id be repeating Mama or Dada while baby looks at you a lot until the first words come out but I'm petty 😂 and it does work.
Eventually this will just be another mad thing she did but I can see why it's annoying you.

LivingLaVidaBabyShower · 16/11/2024 19:54

Honestly I’d just lightheartedly say dada dada dada all the time OR join in with the nana nana naaaanaaaa

making fun is a non tense way to communicate how annoying she is…

she sounds bloody annoying though

Firsttimedad1989 · 16/11/2024 19:54

Searchingforthelight · 16/11/2024 19:49

Sounds really annoying, it would do my head in!

It drives me mad. The way it’s said as well in a really annoying baby voice

OP posts:
AnnaDelvorkina · 16/11/2024 19:51

better if your wife speaks to her mother about this, I think, but YANBU.

Most babies make the dada sound first, regardless of whether that’s a word they’re heard or that exists in their language, it’s how speech develops.

Searchingforthelight · 16/11/2024 19:49

Sounds really annoying, it would do my head in!

Firsttimedad1989 · 16/11/2024 19:45

As in am I being unreasonable to ask my mil to ease up on saying nana

OP posts: