Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think separated parents have the best of both worlds?

241 replies

Adventurebayholiday · 16/11/2024 12:10

I know - sounds like a goady title and I don’t intend it to.

I am specifically talking about parents who have split and one parent had the children for at least some of the time.

I don’t catch a break. I’m either working, caring for children or on the very rare occasion I am not doing either I’m doing household tasks and they really do need doing no matter how low you make your standards. Life is relentless and if I am honest pretty horrendous.

I know DH should be doing more but I can’t get through to him. We’ve had any number of conversations and they just end in sniping and bad feelings. Please don’t tell me to talk to him; you can’t and it just wastes everybody’s time.

One or my friends has split from her partner and she gets a day every weekend (child goes on the Saturday evening so she gets that ‘off’) and she collects him Sunday evening. Sleeping through one day a week and a lie in the next day with a full day to yourself feels like untold luxury to me at the moment. And she has an evening free in the week too.

I know people will say to do it then if it’s that easy and I have thought about it. But it obviously is a massive thing to break up a family and I don’t think it would make the children happy, just me and in many ways I’m the least important one.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CheekyHobson · 17/11/2024 21:17

Men in these communities may hide their laziness behind their female partners' hard work when in relationships but, if those relationships end, they have nowhere to go and actually many of them do maniacally start transforming themselves into 'super-dads' and posting about all the cool trips and long bike rides they're doing with the kids, if only to spite their exes.

A line I hear quite often from separated friends and acquaintances is "He never did any of that with the kids when we lived together".

This is very much my experience… my ex veers between leaving the kids on devices all day and feeding them takeaways, and taking them out to adventure parks and on shopping sprees so he look like a Disney Dad to his workmates (doesn’t have friends).

Mitre · 17/11/2024 14:39

50/50 parenting was probably the best time for me as a parent. The kids got more attention when I had them as they did at their dads. We still got on well and so no animosity and on my days without the kids I was able to be me again. That involved travel, pampering, going out with friends and spending hours in bed with my various lovers. Good memories to be honest.

Undecided45 · 17/11/2024 14:31

I don’t catch a break. I’m either working, caring for children or on the very rare occasion I am not doing either I’m doing household tasks and they really do need doing no matter how low you make your standards. Life is relentless and if I am honest pretty horrendous.

Separated parent here.... This literally describes my life right now. It was easier when we were a family unit.

CrispieCake · 17/11/2024 14:04

@FuckILookLike . I can see where the OP is coming from too. There are some men who won't step up if there's a handy female around that they can push their responsibilities onto. If that female exits the picture, some may throw in the towel altogether and never see or bother with their kids. But others may finally be forced to take responsibility.

I think sadly it differs depending on sector of society and (to an extent) socio-economic status. There are some communities where it appears if not fine, at least accepted, for men essentially to abandon their children on a relationship breakdown and try their best to evade their financial responsibilities. But there are other communities and professions where being a feckless father is very much frowned upon and the expectation is that men will be involved fathers in some ways. Men in these communities may hide their laziness behind their female partners' hard work when in relationships but, if those relationships end, they have nowhere to go and actually many of them do maniacally start transforming themselves into 'super-dads' and posting about all the cool trips and long bike rides they're doing with the kids, if only to spite their exes.

A line I hear quite often from separated friends and acquaintances is "He never did any of that with the kids when we lived together".

FuckILookLike · 17/11/2024 09:26

Interesting post. I see where you’re coming from OP.

I have two children, both have disabilities. I have my children from Monday - Friday (morning) and their dad has them from Friday afternoon until Sunday. It can be difficult to do the school run and manage medical appointments for one child who has a severe disability but at the same time, I know I’ll have a break at the end of the week.

I’m thoroughly supported by UC as a single parent who’s also a carer and have no financial worries at all. I also manage to work part time but that probably won’t be foreseeable for the future as my child’s needs are increasing all the time.

I’m often out for cocktails with my friends or we’ll do a fun activity like bingo or something! It’s difficult as a single parent but their dad pulls his weight and I get a lot of free time. Something that many parents don’t really get

Phineyj · 17/11/2024 08:30

I think the mistake is waiting for a selfish/oblivious person to offer to do something like get up at night. They're not going to.

We had a rota when DC was small.

I mean yes an entirely selfish person will ignore a rota too but it doesn't half shine a light on what they're doing.

Colourfulduvets · 16/11/2024 23:19

Adventurebayholiday · 16/11/2024 21:13

I know you don’t get it. It’s obvious. All day you’ve been not getting it and then getting insulting when you don’t get it. Give it a rest.

I just read my own posts through and they don't insult you but they don't pander to your nonsense either which is probably why I have annoyed you so much.

Santasbigredbobblehat · 16/11/2024 22:35

Can you get them into nursery for one extra day? Give yourself a break.

litepop · 16/11/2024 22:33

Adventurebayholiday · 16/11/2024 12:37

@Colourfulduvets i am not saying that they are ‘having the best time.’

Ive answered your second paragraph in my OP and again subsequently. I do think that for me splitting would be beneficial, at least in the short term. I’d have some life back. It wouldn’t however benefit anybody else and I do have to think about everybody else.

If your DH is as useless as you say (and I'm not doubting he is), it's highly unlikely he'd suddenly step up and co-parent well to give you the 'me' time you're hoping for

CheekyHobson · 16/11/2024 21:49

I’m probably in the situation you dream of @Adventurebayholiday, so it is possible. My ex has the children four days a fortnight, so I get what feels like a really decent break, but I also don’t have to be away from my kids too much. I am a pretty high earner so although it’s definitely tight running a household on one income, as my ex was a massive spender, over time I’ve actually become more financially secure than I was when in a relationship with him.

It’s not all roses though. The kids are affected to some degree. My daughter does not love going back and forth between houses and she misses me a lot when she is with her Dad. My life has to be run as a very tight ship time-wise and I would struggle if I didn’t have a flexible employer.

The kids’ dad does now have to take genuine responsibility for them when he has them, instead of being “present but absent” like he was when we were together, but he is not a great dad. My kids are tweens and are starting to see it for themselves. At some point I imagine they will be back with me full time by their own choice. I feel sad knowing he largely leaves them on devices and feeds them takeaways when they are with him, but nothing about the way he parents would reach a threshold for formal neglect so there’s not much I can do about it.

If you are actually considering separating at some level, I would suggest to wait until the kids are a bit bigger and you have high earning capacity and a solid financial backstop.

My ex was emotionally and financially abusive and a liar (among other issues) so I had a very clear reason to leave and my life is unquestionably miles better and happier now. Overall I think it’s better for the kids to have one happy and attentive home where they mostly live (even if the other home is only materially comfortable, not emotionally nourishing) rather than living full time in a loveless and anxious household with parents who fight a lot. But your calculus may be different.

Sugarflub · 16/11/2024 21:38

Adventurebayholiday · 16/11/2024 20:40

I’ve plenty of self respect, but more than that, I’ve got pragmatism. I recognise that much as it would be lovely to be cherished for my beautiful looks and sparkling personality, the reality is that I am an ordinary woman, pleasant enough to look at but nothing remarkable, like hundreds of other women. I am nice enough to be around (well, I was, not sure about now!) passingly intelligent and good at cooking, childcare and housework.

Like hundreds if not thousands of other women. If DH hadn’t met and married me, he’d have met and married someone very similar to me, and I’d probably have met and married someone similar to him.

Marriage may be a romantic concept in modern times but it traditionally was a legal contract and it still is. Squawking at me to ‘have some self respect’ is faintly amusing if only because that’s exactly what marriage is, it’s literally a sexual and financial contract.

You don't have self respect, you're happy to drive yourself to depression and are looking rosily out at being a single parent because you evidently feel like you don't deserve better than this lazy man who doesn't respect you one iota.

Plastictrees · 16/11/2024 21:32

Adventurebayholiday · 16/11/2024 20:54

@Plastictrees you possibly missed my saying that I do think I am quite depressed at the moment. I can see things objectively if you like and recognise they won’t be like this forever but ‘long enough’ is my feeling.

I work Mondays, Tuesdays and Fridays. Mondays and Tuesdays and Fridays I get up, get the children ready, teeth brushed, dressed, out of the door and to nursery. It’s always a rush but in many ways that’s the easy part, they are fed and cared for there. I then go onto work myself, it’s a frantic job with no breaks to speak of, finish work, back to collect children, home, they are tired, fretful, squabbly, clingy, whiny. Bath time and out of bath, pyjamas, teeth, stories, a thousand squabbles, finally in bed around half seven, and down I come to the carnage that is my house, I also have work to do myself in that time, collapse exhausted into bed, then the night shift starts.

And then it starts again.

I gave a hit of help on Friday, usually, and I know I should not call it help, but I don’t know what else to say. DH usually works from home. Wednesdays and Thursdays should be theoretically a break and yes it’s nice not having to charge out of the house, we do groups and little activities they enjoy and I’m not a monster, of course I enjoy seeing them having fun and they are adorable and loving and loved. But it’s relentless. They take toys off each other, scream, slap one another, tell tales ‘DD pushed me … DD hit me …’ it goes quiet and I find them both immersed in the cupboard under the stairs trashing it or they are in a bedroom being adorable listening to the tonie box and I’m thinking how sweet then someone cries or wails or there is a thud of doom. Even if I start something I can’t finish it. I have absolutely no time for me. I do get that I wouldn’t have much but no time to read, be still and calm, breathe, none.

I’d probably be OK with that but I’m so tired and I think that’s why I’m a bit depressed. She slept through a few times last week after some sleep training (only gentle before anyone annihilates me) and I thought I’d cracked it but she’s waking up again, I’m not sure what to do really. Most nights I only get 4-5 hours and it’s broken. I look grey and washed out, circles under my eyes, I’m snappy and emotional and quick to be offended and upset which is a complete antithesis of the person I was before. I was always chilled, laid back, shrug it off. But the years of bad sleep have taken their toll.

so this is partly depression talking. I know, objectively, soon I’ll have two school age children, I’ll have time, I’ll have a bit more peace, I’ll have an easier time of things, nappies, pushchairs, high chairs and sippy cups will be gone, never to return, my head knows this. My heart - not so much.

I did miss that. It is really hard! It’s no wonder you feel the way you do. I can also relate as I’m in a very similar position to you - I also work 3 days a week with very young DC. It is exhausting but your DH doesn’t seem to be helping as much as he should. He could do more to help even the load, particularly as you are struggling. Does he know how you feel? He at least needs to look after DC so you can get a decent nights sleep a few nights a week. The lack of sleep will be making everything worse. In your situation I would honestly book a nice hotel for a couple of nights and leave DH to it, you can rest and sleep. Don’t get pulled into the trap of having to do everything for everyone, he’s a parent too and should be able to look after his children in his own. It might be hard for you to relinquish some control but you may need to. I hope things improve for you soon and you can get a break.

Gogogo12345 · 16/11/2024 21:23

ClosetChroll · 16/11/2024 20:59

Parents who stay together have the best of all worlds. Splitting is bad.

Even if one is beating the shit out of the other? Or constantly drunk? Or addicted to drugs?

Adventurebayholiday · 16/11/2024 21:21

DH isn’t a bad man. In years to come, when we’re out of the trenches, I’ll probably remember why I married him. The big thing for me is that he lets me do the nights, not once has he said look, you sleep, I’ll go to DS/DD. He just doesn’t see what he doesn’t want to see.

OP posts:
Bornnotbourne · 16/11/2024 21:14

I’m at the age where my friends have started getting divorced and from what I’ve observed is that spilts roughly fit into 3 categories.

  1. He has an affair, she’s devastated we all saw it coming
  2. He’s becomes more and more lazy, she requests help. She gets a sickness. He leaves.
  3. she hit 40, decides she can no longer be his mother and leaves him. Much wailing and crying from man-child.
I think personally there are men who will push you till you leave them because they don’t want to be the bad guy. It is cowardice tbh
Adventurebayholiday · 16/11/2024 21:13

I know you don’t get it. It’s obvious. All day you’ve been not getting it and then getting insulting when you don’t get it. Give it a rest.

OP posts:
Colourfulduvets · 16/11/2024 21:11

No I absolutely don't get you at all.
This whole thread is baffling to be honest & I made the mistake of not unwatching it. Off to click that button now.

And my posts to you were not all unpleasant at all. Yes, at the beginning I definitely took offence to your glib comment that your separated friend has it made. But then I tried to offer advice based on my own experience so it seems you have misunderstood me at times too.

I honestly wish you luck with whatever it is you want or are looking for. It seems you don't know but if you do choose to leave I hope it works out and that you enjoy your child free time and your weekend lie ins

Adventurebayholiday · 16/11/2024 21:09

We only have two children, @ThatIsNotMyNameSoWhyAreYouCallingMeThat . Although it does sometimes feel like more!

OP posts:
ThatIsNotMyNameSoWhyAreYouCallingMeThat · 16/11/2024 21:06

SnowflakeSmasher86 · 16/11/2024 17:01

Yeah, that’s a bit horse/stable door though isn’t it. It sounds like OP’s husband definitely isn’t that type. So where to go from where she actually is? A Time Machine to choose a more involved husband isn’t really an option at this point.

Presumably it was obvious after baby 1 though. Or 2 at a push.

Adventurebayholiday · 16/11/2024 21:02

@Colourfulduvets I honestly think you really have completely misunderstood what the threads about. It isn’t me looking for the nirvana of being a separated parent at all. You seem convinced I’m debating the pros and cons of me leaving, despite me saying over and over that I am not. And then when I point this out to you, you become personally insulting. It is tedious to be honest, really it is. I did a wee search - twelve posts, all of them poking at me, complaining at me, insulting me. Give it a rest Hmm

OP posts:
ClosetChroll · 16/11/2024 20:59

Parents who stay together have the best of all worlds. Splitting is bad.

Colourfulduvets · 16/11/2024 20:58

Adventurebayholiday · 16/11/2024 20:17

Ah, you’re back.

Much as I don’t want to bite, what in the above for me isn’t good?

I don’t mind living somewhere less affluent, I’m not going to school, I don’t mind working full time, my ‘days off’ are far harder and more exhausting than my working days.

So what is it you’re poking at now?

You really are quite an unpleasant person.
I hope you find whatever it is you are looking for and that the nirvana of being a separated parent is everything you think it will be.

Adventurebayholiday · 16/11/2024 20:54

@Plastictrees you possibly missed my saying that I do think I am quite depressed at the moment. I can see things objectively if you like and recognise they won’t be like this forever but ‘long enough’ is my feeling.

I work Mondays, Tuesdays and Fridays. Mondays and Tuesdays and Fridays I get up, get the children ready, teeth brushed, dressed, out of the door and to nursery. It’s always a rush but in many ways that’s the easy part, they are fed and cared for there. I then go onto work myself, it’s a frantic job with no breaks to speak of, finish work, back to collect children, home, they are tired, fretful, squabbly, clingy, whiny. Bath time and out of bath, pyjamas, teeth, stories, a thousand squabbles, finally in bed around half seven, and down I come to the carnage that is my house, I also have work to do myself in that time, collapse exhausted into bed, then the night shift starts.

And then it starts again.

I gave a hit of help on Friday, usually, and I know I should not call it help, but I don’t know what else to say. DH usually works from home. Wednesdays and Thursdays should be theoretically a break and yes it’s nice not having to charge out of the house, we do groups and little activities they enjoy and I’m not a monster, of course I enjoy seeing them having fun and they are adorable and loving and loved. But it’s relentless. They take toys off each other, scream, slap one another, tell tales ‘DD pushed me … DD hit me …’ it goes quiet and I find them both immersed in the cupboard under the stairs trashing it or they are in a bedroom being adorable listening to the tonie box and I’m thinking how sweet then someone cries or wails or there is a thud of doom. Even if I start something I can’t finish it. I have absolutely no time for me. I do get that I wouldn’t have much but no time to read, be still and calm, breathe, none.

I’d probably be OK with that but I’m so tired and I think that’s why I’m a bit depressed. She slept through a few times last week after some sleep training (only gentle before anyone annihilates me) and I thought I’d cracked it but she’s waking up again, I’m not sure what to do really. Most nights I only get 4-5 hours and it’s broken. I look grey and washed out, circles under my eyes, I’m snappy and emotional and quick to be offended and upset which is a complete antithesis of the person I was before. I was always chilled, laid back, shrug it off. But the years of bad sleep have taken their toll.

so this is partly depression talking. I know, objectively, soon I’ll have two school age children, I’ll have time, I’ll have a bit more peace, I’ll have an easier time of things, nappies, pushchairs, high chairs and sippy cups will be gone, never to return, my head knows this. My heart - not so much.

OP posts:
Plastictrees · 16/11/2024 20:47

Marriage is not a sexual contract. We don’t live in the Middle Ages. Plenty of people - normal, ordinary people - manage to have marriages that are happy and equal. It is hard when children are young and you have to work at it, but your DH is patently not pulling his weight here. Where is his regard for your feelings? What would happen if you showed him this thread, or just voiced your feelings honestly as you have here?

I think you are normalising his learned ineptness/ weaponised incompetence by telling yourself that wanting more is some sort of silly fairytale. It isn’t. You don’t sound pragmatic, you sound despondent.

Adventurebayholiday · 16/11/2024 20:40

I’ve plenty of self respect, but more than that, I’ve got pragmatism. I recognise that much as it would be lovely to be cherished for my beautiful looks and sparkling personality, the reality is that I am an ordinary woman, pleasant enough to look at but nothing remarkable, like hundreds of other women. I am nice enough to be around (well, I was, not sure about now!) passingly intelligent and good at cooking, childcare and housework.

Like hundreds if not thousands of other women. If DH hadn’t met and married me, he’d have met and married someone very similar to me, and I’d probably have met and married someone similar to him.

Marriage may be a romantic concept in modern times but it traditionally was a legal contract and it still is. Squawking at me to ‘have some self respect’ is faintly amusing if only because that’s exactly what marriage is, it’s literally a sexual and financial contract.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread