Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Honest opinions ... is a UK 14/16 seen as unattractive for dating as a 50 year old?

309 replies

lemonepisode1 · 13/11/2024 13:13

I'm online dating for a while. My face is decent and I'd consider myself relatively attractive in the looks stakes but it is my body that men seem to dislike.
As above , I'm that size, 5'7', proportioned except for a wide , flabby meno belly.Im 2.5stone overweight on the scales.
I weight train and walk and run over the week.. so I exercise every day. Look after my appearance/ clothes/ grooming etc but I really believe it's my body that turns them off .
Honestly, especially to men on here, is that size and body type unattractive to you on a woman who is 50?
What are your experiences and more so, what do you find attractive out of interest ?
Thanks.
Lemon

OP posts:
BobbyBiscuits · 14/11/2024 11:04

I don't think anyone would choose to date someone who is lacking severely in confidence sexually, or has very low self esteem about their looks. It really is about confidence I'd imagine.
But most 50 yo men probably want a women of similar age but only if she looks like Amanda Holden. Otherwise they want someone in their 30s. Not that they could get that most of the time...

Lastonightadjsavedmylife · 14/11/2024 11:00

LeavesToSweep · 14/11/2024 10:55

They are. She isn’t… not even close.

While I am obviously concerned for her general health, I am not concerned about her weight. Her BMI is within the healthy range.

Edited

I’m sorry that’s hugely unlikely. A size six on a woman above average height is likely to be significantly underweight. And I find it creepy you know her dress size, weight and bmi.

LeavesToSweep · 14/11/2024 10:55

Lastonightadjsavedmylife · 14/11/2024 10:46

If your stats are right, she is likely to be significantly underweight. And as we age, that is hugely promblematic. I’d say if you were married and love her, you should be more concerned about her health than if you fancy her.

They are. She isn’t… not even close.

While I am obviously concerned for her general health, I am not concerned about her weight. Her BMI is within the healthy range.

StMarie4me · 14/11/2024 10:50

elastamum · 13/11/2024 14:07

Sadly this is a thing. My lovely 60 year old friend is constantly messaged by men in their 70s and above looking for a partner. She doesn't want to be a carer so isn't interested.

At 61 this is why I don't bother! I got the same.

Bloody men who all think they can date 20/30 years younger than themselves. Eeeew.

Lastonightadjsavedmylife · 14/11/2024 10:46

LeavesToSweep · 14/11/2024 10:19

Honestly, especially to men on here, is that size and body type unattractive to you on a woman who is 50

I am married to a 50 year old woman. She is slightly above average height and a size 6. Would I find a 50 year old woman that is a size 14/16 attractive? Possibly.

Attractive enough to date? Probably not. I have always preferred slimmer women and that hasn’t changed with age.

My daughter is in her early twenties and frankly the thought of her being with a man in his 40s nauseates her and me tbh

We got together when she was in her 20s and I was in my 40s (just). I guess she must have a strong stomach.

If your stats are right, she is likely to be significantly underweight. And as we age, that is hugely promblematic. I’d say if you were married and love her, you should be more concerned about her health than if you fancy her.

EBearhug · 14/11/2024 10:41

There's quite some difference between 29 & 41 compared with 21 & 49. 12 years and 18. Plenty of larger age gaps do work, though.

There's a huge range of men in their 40s and 50s. Some have never done a day's exercise since they were at school, others have taken more effort. Some have ED, others are up for it frequently with no issues. Women are similarly variable. And that's just physical - intelligence, values, humour, and everything that goes into attraction also adds up. It makes it difficult. But you only need to find the one (needle in a haystack as it might be.)

LeavesToSweep · 14/11/2024 10:19

Honestly, especially to men on here, is that size and body type unattractive to you on a woman who is 50

I am married to a 50 year old woman. She is slightly above average height and a size 6. Would I find a 50 year old woman that is a size 14/16 attractive? Possibly.

Attractive enough to date? Probably not. I have always preferred slimmer women and that hasn’t changed with age.

My daughter is in her early twenties and frankly the thought of her being with a man in his 40s nauseates her and me tbh

We got together when she was in her 20s and I was in my 40s (just). I guess she must have a strong stomach.

DancingLions · 14/11/2024 10:18

Yes it's often not a huge gap, like a man of 50 and a woman of 25. So saying a woman in her 20's wont be interested in someone 20yrs older is missing the point.

But there's no real reason why a woman of 45 would not potentially be interested in a man of 55. Especially if he's got a lot going for him. So when you get Mr 55 yr old on OLD, in decent shape, good job etc he's going to have options. He could set his age range from 40-50 and get dates, meet a partner etc. He's not going to be thinking oh I must date someone exactly the same age as me!

The 55 yr olds who have nothing going for them, well no, they won't get dates with younger women. But no woman of their age is going to want to date them either!

I did OLD between 45 and 48. I was slim then, well put together, could have passed for younger. (It all went to pot in menopause but I'd given up dating by then!). I was looking at 45-50 age group. It was absolutely dire! Hence why I stopped at 48. I decided if I didn't meet someone naturally, then so be it. It's not impossible to meet someone via OLD in your 50's, but it's very hard if you have any kind of standards and don't want to go higher than your own age.

EBearhug · 14/11/2024 09:37

A male friend with whom I have discussed OLD - he's currently 59 (but fit, slim and healthy.) His dating age range was set 20-60. Mine was +/- 5 years of my own age (currently 52.) He wanted a relationship whereas i was more open to seeing how things went. He didn't really want a 20yo, but was much more open to younger women than I was to younger men. His ex-wife was 17 years younger than him. I'm not sure of the age of the woman he's now seeing, but I think she's mid-40s.

I think that's fairly typical of men on OLD. They're fine with women their own age, as long as they're fairly fit, but otherwise, as long as they're adult, that's all good.

5128gap · 14/11/2024 09:03

lemonepisode1 · 14/11/2024 08:49

My daughter is in her early twenties and frankly the thought of her being with a man in his 40s nauseates her and me tbh.
She is regularly harassed sexually through verbals and once through groping, in her part time work and finds them and that age group generally Lecherous and entitled. Not one of her peer group are with men older than late twenties.

This is a significant problem for young women. There was a post yesterday from a 20s woman who is receiving unwanted attention from numerous ex colleagues, all middle aged men. Whenever I see posts on here proclaiming that men in their 50s 'will' be dating young women, I always think, spare a thought for young women before perpetuating this myth, that really has no basis outside of older men's fantasies. They may want young women, it's rarely reciprocated, and every time we assert they 'will' be dating them, it adds to a culture where aging chancers will keep trying their luck and bothering young women.

5128gap · 14/11/2024 08:56

Lastonightadjsavedmylife · 14/11/2024 08:45

No it doesn’t, it just makes you look like you’ve a fat face.

Wow. Big fat faces or haggard? What a way to describe each other. Surely we shouldn't be even debating what type of 50 year old woman is more acceptable to 50 year old men, when it's pretty much guaranteed that fat or thin the majority of us have more to offer than the majority of them. Which is the crux of the problem for women like the OP. Not finding one who will find her attractive, finding a tolerable one from amongst those who do.

lemonepisode1 · 14/11/2024 08:49

My daughter is in her early twenties and frankly the thought of her being with a man in his 40s nauseates her and me tbh.
She is regularly harassed sexually through verbals and once through groping, in her part time work and finds them and that age group generally Lecherous and entitled. Not one of her peer group are with men older than late twenties.

OP posts:
Lastonightadjsavedmylife · 14/11/2024 08:45

Whatwasthiscakeineedtoknow · 14/11/2024 08:30

Holding fat in your face smooths out wrinkles and can keep you looking younger for longer.

No it doesn’t, it just makes you look like you’ve a fat face.

Whatwasthiscakeineedtoknow · 14/11/2024 08:30

Lastonightadjsavedmylife · 14/11/2024 06:49

Huh? Why would she look haggard and older if she was slim. What a silly thought.

Holding fat in your face smooths out wrinkles and can keep you looking younger for longer.

PaterPower · 14/11/2024 07:37

As an early 50s man (who’s with a two years older partner I met online at 38), all I can add is that the thought of dating someone in their 30s or younger is not appealing at all.

As a PP pointed out earlier, none of my cultural references would mean anything to them, they might still want DC (I’m definitely done with that - who’d want to be changing nappies at my age?!) and I’d want to enjoy my not-that-distant-now retirement with someone who wasn’t still, (rightly so for them), grafting and building their career.

My tastes run more to a sense of humour that gels with mine, broad cultural tastes and someone wanting to travel a bit. Size 18+ is probably a bit bigger than I’d prefer, if I was being completely honest, but I’ve dated women of that size when I was younger and personality counts for more.

Lastonightadjsavedmylife · 14/11/2024 06:49

Fizzywizzywoowoo · 13/11/2024 23:53

But if you were a size 10 now you would look haggard and a lot older

Huh? Why would she look haggard and older if she was slim. What a silly thought.

Tulip2478 · 14/11/2024 01:50

potatocakesinprogress · 13/11/2024 17:13

The ones with daddy issues are 26 year olds wanting to date 40 something men.

Single women of 40 or 50 have kids that come first because they got divorced from their husband cheating on them. A man is secondary. But yes they are better than the men.
Single men of 40 or 50 are either the divorced ones that did the cheating or have an online gaming addiction and don't like going outside.

Edited

Not in every situation, I was 24 when i met my 41 year old now husband. I didn't have 'daddy issues' whatever those are.

EBearhug · 14/11/2024 00:41

I'm 52, size 18 at 5'4", don't dye my hair, don't wear makeup. Met a couple of lovely men in their 50s on OLD. (Also a lot of arseholes and some nice guys who I just didn't have a spark with.)

You don't need every man to be looking for you, just one you click with.

TheDeepLemonHelper · 14/11/2024 00:07

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Fizzywizzywoowoo · 13/11/2024 23:53

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

But if you were a size 10 now you would look haggard and a lot older

satonacat · 13/11/2024 23:16

MargoLivebetter · 13/11/2024 16:29

@XxSideshowAuntSallyx honestly, it is not depressing and I say that as someone who internet dated from ages 36-51. I had my best dates towards the end of those years, mostly because I grew in confidence and happiness with myself and then when nearly 52 I met lovely DP.

There is no shortage of anything at all and just like in all aspects of life, there are good people and not so good people to be met. There are plenty of men who want to date similar aged women. I am an ordinary looking middle aged woman (much as I'd love to believe I'm something special) and I had no difficulty dating men my own age at all. I don't live in central London either, before someone lobs that old chestnut in!

I agree.
I've dated some lovely men my age / within a couple of years older & younger.

All nice, decent guys, all dating within their age range.

Not found one for me, and it took too much time and energy sifting through online to get the odd decent date, I'm not one for OLD but the idea that's it's your age or weight holding you back isn't my first thought, more that it's a numbers game and also a lottery. You can be lucky and find someone fairly quickly or it can be a relentless task (I know a Londoner in her 30s who dated for 10 years a couple a week until finding her very handsome same age architect (so to be) DH on there) so it can happen

Opentooffers · 13/11/2024 23:12

I think the most frequent lie I've come across is height, and I'd go to 5ft6 being only 5ft4, but shorter or the same height is obvious on meeting and its so irritating. While your busy castigating your own figure, haven't you found that most single men around 50 are overweight, bald or both. I found the few slimmer ones were mainly smokers or busy taking profile shots of themselves in the gym - the sort that would treat a woman like a sex object.
Chances are the over 50 men you are dating are equally packing a bit of weight and then some, so who gives an F what they think.
If you want a slim fella yourself, you probably do need to be reasonably slim too, but that's kinda fair.

TwistedWonder · 13/11/2024 23:01

IcedPurple · 13/11/2024 22:57

Are these men such a catch that they're going to have much younger women drooling over them?

I doubt it.

Men may be 'interested' in dating hot young women but those women will not be interested in them. Not much of an 'advantage'.

Honestly when I was in my 20’s the thought of a man my dads age trying to pull me would have absolutely repulsed me 🤢 I would have thought they were a sad sleazy old creep

IcedPurple · 13/11/2024 22:57

HRTQueen · 13/11/2024 21:56

It’s your age

a colleague who is in his early 50’s and he likes women of a similar age. The women he has met online are way out of his league he knows that he has the advantage and so many are disappointed that few men that are a similar age are interested in them (his words)

Are these men such a catch that they're going to have much younger women drooling over them?

I doubt it.

Men may be 'interested' in dating hot young women but those women will not be interested in them. Not much of an 'advantage'.

Lucy25 · 13/11/2024 22:01

BillPurchase · 13/11/2024 18:15

Many men like a bit of cushion for the pushing. Many fatties exist at under 50 so don't feel bad, you'll clean up.

🤢