Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not mention I have 50/50 custody on my dating profile

169 replies

WillVioletsDad · 12/11/2024 08:58

Hi all. I'm a bloke, but posting here because I'd appreciate a female perspective. I fear the below might read like engagement bait, but it's genuinely the dilemma I have, and I would like to know what people think.

I'm separated (nearly three years now, divorce imminent) with a very good relationship with my ex-wife. We share 50/50 custody of my daughter.

In my profile on dating sites I mention that I have 50/50 custody, because I was thinking that it's good to be up front, and I (perhaps naively) thought that women might read that and think that I'm a good dad.

But I'm now thinking I should remove that, because I'm scared it might be a "red flag".

I remember a thread on here by a woman who was unhappy that her husband wanted to go from having his (not her's) kids every other weekend and one evening a week to 50/50 custody (he wanted to see them more). She was unhappy with this, basically saying that she hadn't anticipated his children being a significant part of their lives when she married him. (She wanted him, not the kids).

I particularly remember one comment from a woman who'd said that when her step-children were kids, her and her husband had had them to stay every other weekend and one evening a week and that this "was enough".

(It wouldn't be enough for me. I would miss my daughter terribly.)

But I'm thinking maybe that because in our (sexist, patriarchal) society, women generally do most of the child rearing, EOW/1NAW is the default, and that might be what women are expecting if they meet a bloke with kids from a dating site. And that if they find out that instead, he has his child/children half the time, that this would be "too much?" Or even, they might thing that it's a strange thing to mention on a profile even if they didn't have a problem with it per se? Or they'd just be worried that I'm looking for someone to do the parenting so I don't have to. (For reference, I'm not one of those scumbag blokes who only wants 50/50 so that he can get out of paying maintenance, and then palms the kids off on his mum).

Anyhow, I'm thinking that I don't want any instant red-flags on my profile that would cause someone to "swipe left" without considering me.

Would it be unreasonable (and / or advisable) for me to just say that I have a daughter and leave it at that?

Not unreasonable: don't say you have 50/50 on your profile, because women might see that as weird or off-putting. Mention it later, if / when things develop.

Unreasonable: do say that you have 50/50, it's being honest and you should be proud of it, and women appreciate that.

OP posts:
WillVioletsDad · 12/11/2024 10:24

Hoardasurass · 12/11/2024 10:14

@WillVioletsDad women have learned the hard way not to really mention much about our dc in dating profiles because of the large amount of pedophiles who will specifically target women with children to get access to their children and their children's friends.
Women are generally not a risk to children in the way men are, and because of this, it's an unfortunate fact that women have to deal with, but on average, men don't.
So it's safe for a man to say he has 50/50 care of his dc and allows both parties to see from the start if they are compatible, rather than waste time with someone who is looking for something different

That's a very good point, one that I hadn't thought of, and one that I'm a bit ashamed not to have thought of. :(

OP posts:
Kbroughton · 12/11/2024 10:23

I met my fiancé on OLD. He was clear he had three children and lived with one on his initial profile, although I didn't know which one. On discussion the child he lived with was his older son in his twenties. I thought it was very lovely that his older child chose to live with him. I wouldn't be put off with 50/50 although i dont think you need to put it on your profile. That should come out in early discussions. If you are dating anyone with a child you know that they need to spend time with them and if you don't want that, you don't date them. Whether its 20% (which would put me off FYI) or 100%. You will have a narrower pool as you have children, but that's just the way it is. I love my Fiancé's children (25, 24, 10) but I was always open to a man with children.

WillVioletsDad · 12/11/2024 10:22

stanleypops66 · 12/11/2024 10:09

A man with dc wouldn't be my preference, but I'd think more of you for doing 50:50 than EOW so you'd go up in my estimation. How old is your dc?

I notice that you're 55. If I was similar age, then your age with a young child/ primary age child would put me off more than actually having a dc, as I'd be thinking of slowing down and wouldn't want to be with someone who was still raising a young child.

She's 12. (In her second year of secondary school, year 8).

OP posts:
PizzaPowder · 12/11/2024 10:21

NeverDropYourMooncup · 12/11/2024 09:00

Is it that important for you to get laid that you are trying to work out with the help of women which approach will be most successful for you?

This is harsh.

OP - I think you should keep it.

If it puts people off then that's a good thing. If you're looking for a long term relationship then you will only get the people who are comfortable with this.

McGregor33 · 12/11/2024 10:21

I don’t mention I have kids on my dating profile. Once conversation is initiated I will put it out there.

It doesn’t bother me if a man has kids, if anything it usually means they already understand coparenting and how valuable child free time can be when your overwhelmed therefore not likely to waste it!

BrandNewHeretic · 12/11/2024 10:20

I've starting seeing someone and honestly the fact he has his kids 50/50 is something I found attractive about him. Anyone who is swiping left based on that information isn't compatible with you, so what's the point in rewording it for them to give you a chance, for it enivitably to end up going the same way, except both of you have now wasted time on each other and possibly created tension re timetabling dates etc

TwistedWonder · 12/11/2024 10:16

stanleypops66 · 12/11/2024 10:11

Just seen your update, maybe put your age preference a bit lower, like 45. You may match with a woman who is younger who would be happier to be with someone raising a child.

Agree with this. I do think most women in your age range will be past school age kids and be enjoying not having to revolve their life around childcare.

Ill be honest my DS is 20 and I’ve loved the last few years where I don’t have to go on holiday in August and plan nights out around him being with his dad.

Hes still with me part time but I don’t have to worry about him when I’m out - he’s perfectly happy with a Deliveroo or using the air fryer 🤣

Hoardasurass · 12/11/2024 10:14

@WillVioletsDad women have learned the hard way not to really mention much about our dc in dating profiles because of the large amount of pedophiles who will specifically target women with children to get access to their children and their children's friends.
Women are generally not a risk to children in the way men are, and because of this, it's an unfortunate fact that women have to deal with, but on average, men don't.
So it's safe for a man to say he has 50/50 care of his dc and allows both parties to see from the start if they are compatible, rather than waste time with someone who is looking for something different

stanleypops66 · 12/11/2024 10:11

Just seen your update, maybe put your age preference a bit lower, like 45. You may match with a woman who is younger who would be happier to be with someone raising a child.

Sdpbody · 12/11/2024 10:11

Women don't need to write on their profiles that they have 50/50 custody or even custody as it is just assumed that they will already have custody.

If you have a women over the age of 40 is on a dating site, you can generally expect her to have children. You can also generally expect her to have more than 50/50 custody of those children.

stanleypops66 · 12/11/2024 10:09

A man with dc wouldn't be my preference, but I'd think more of you for doing 50:50 than EOW so you'd go up in my estimation. How old is your dc?

I notice that you're 55. If I was similar age, then your age with a young child/ primary age child would put me off more than actually having a dc, as I'd be thinking of slowing down and wouldn't want to be with someone who was still raising a young child.

BarbedButterfly · 12/11/2024 10:09

If I was single I wouldn't consider someone with children as I am childfree by choice and it just wouldn't work for me. Others may consider it but have a flat no to someone with 50/50 as it would cut down on time you could spend together since they shouldn't meet them too soon. So I think you should be upfront to prevent wasting either of your time.

WillVioletsDad · 12/11/2024 10:08

Menowhatdoyoucallit · 12/11/2024 10:00

For me it's your age with school age children that's off putting. I would want/expect an older mans children to no longer be dependent on him.

Yeah, I'm thinking that might also be a problem. I've set my filters to ages 50 to 60, so maybe the reason why none of them mention anything similar is because if they have kids, they've all grown up and left home.

They're looking to become a step-grandma, not a step-mum. :(

Thing is my ex-wife and I didn't meet until I was 36 and she was 35, and after a lot of difficulties, our daughter arrived as a bit of a miracle baby when I was 43 and my ex-wife was 42.

It was a bit depressing when we went to the introduction day thing at our daughter's secondary school, and the headmaster said "Back in my day, GCSEs had grades A to E" and I was thinking, "I didn't do GCSEs, I did O'Levels... shit I'm older than the headmaster." :)

OP posts:
Daisy12Maisie · 12/11/2024 10:06

I'm in a relationship with someone who has his kids 50/ 50. It does make things go a lot more difficult than if he has them every other weekend. He is the default parent so sometimes the mum doesn't turn up which really upsets the kids and then we have to cancel plans if we had made plans. So a lot of people wouldn't want that (just as I'm sure a lot of people wouldn't want to date me as a single parent of a 15 year old who is with me nearly all of the time.) so you may as well be honest from day 1 then if they don't want that they don't need to message you.
I was prepared for the 50/50 but not how disinterested the mum is as it's actually more like 65/35. That would be fine but it's last minute changes so it makes it difficult to plan things and it upsets the kids when their mum doesn't turn up so that's sad to see.

Menowhatdoyoucallit · 12/11/2024 10:00

WillVioletsDad · 12/11/2024 09:50

No, I'm figuring this is all stuff that would come out the first time we have a serious chat on the phone, before meeting up. I'm not looking for hookups.

But yeah, I am currently getting no responses, so I'm getting paranoid that the fact that I've said it is a red flag (even if it's the info-dump nature of mentioning it that's the red flag, rather than the thing in itself).

For me it's your age with school age children that's off putting. I would want/expect an older mans children to no longer be dependent on him.

CookieMonster28 · 12/11/2024 09:58

You're nearly old enough to be my dad! but I'd appreciate the upfront honesty personally

ReleaseTheHoneyBadgers · 12/11/2024 09:50

Always be honest. Any woman put off by it isn’t right for you anyway.

WillVioletsDad · 12/11/2024 09:50

LAMPS1 · 12/11/2024 09:45

Having your DC with you 50% of the time is very important to you so surely you wouldn’t be happy not mentioning it? You may have far fewer responses but the ones you do have won’t be put off by your honest and decent situation.

If you have tried being honest and have received no responses then I suppose you feel you might have more OLD chances by omitting your important information and hooking somebody in, only to reveal it later down the line when it becomes a dilemma.

It depends what you want from dating really doesn’t it.
IMO, leaving out the important info at the beginning won’t lead to a serious relationship but may lead to a few brief affairs or ONS’s. Is that what you are looking for?

I’d prefer to know the real situation from the onset.

No, I'm figuring this is all stuff that would come out the first time we have a serious chat on the phone, before meeting up. I'm not looking for hookups.

But yeah, I am currently getting no responses, so I'm getting paranoid that the fact that I've said it is a red flag (even if it's the info-dump nature of mentioning it that's the red flag, rather than the thing in itself).

OP posts:
ReleaseTheHoneyBadgers · 12/11/2024 09:50

NeverDropYourMooncup · 12/11/2024 09:00

Is it that important for you to get laid that you are trying to work out with the help of women which approach will be most successful for you?

Really savage. If a woman asked you’d be fine with it.

Stirrednshaken · 12/11/2024 09:49

I think being upfront is the way to go. I suspect the issue is the age of your daughter - most people at your age are either past the young kids stage and don't want to start again, or never wanted kids in the first place. But that is just all the more reason to be up front - for the right person it will be a big tick.

fearfulworrier · 12/11/2024 09:48

I think you sound lovely, kind and honest. A devoted dad and clearly if your ex helped read over your profile you were not a terrible husband! I personally would appreciate honesty it’s the most important thing for me. I also believe that at your age it’s very difficult to fond someone who doesn’t have children/an ex wife etc because that’s life! Personally I would take out the 50/50 but state you have a daughter you adore. Then on first date I’m sure they will ask how often do you see your dd?
Good luck with it, my best friend and cousin both met their husbands through online dating so once you weed through it is worth it!

Stirrednshaken · 12/11/2024 09:48

Attelina · 12/11/2024 09:44

@WillVioletsDad

'Sorry, it's ridiculous for me to believe that we live in a sexist society?

Surely, there's evidence of sexism everywhere, in how women get lumbered with childcare, get paid less than men for doing the same job, are victims of sexual assault (in a society that teaches girls how not to get raped but doesn't teach boys not to be rapists) etc etc?'

😂😂😂😂😂

If you genuinely believe that utter, utter nonsense than I feel sorry for you and I conclude that you will not be successful in saying unless some god awful extreme feminist takes pity on you!

Think you're in the minority in thinking we don't live in a sexist world. Burying your head in the sand doesn't change that.

Avatartar · 12/11/2024 09:46

Just BE YOU! You’ve got children

SprinklesSparkles · 12/11/2024 09:45

you can’t win on here, you have your child eow you are a deadbeat that barely sees them, you have 50/50 you are just doing it for the maintenance and you are wrong for “taking” the child away from their mothers (seen both on here often) i don’t think you need to mention anything i have my kids full time but wouldn’t mention it on a dating profile.

MrsJoanDanvers · 12/11/2024 09:45

Just be upfront you have children. You don’t have to discuss the minutiae of care until you’re conversing but I’d imagine most women would assume that if you put you have kids that you’d be doing some care. In my view, it might deter women who don’t have children because they may only be looking for people without kids but at least they know upfront. Honesty is a good quality-the worse thing you can do with OLD is to be evasive or fib about things which will easily be found out. I met my DH old , we knew we both had children from the get go although we didn’t live together until the kids were young adults.

Swipe left for the next trending thread