Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lost weight, now losing friends!

242 replies

Artistbythewater · 11/11/2024 20:45

I have been over weight for many years. I decided about six months ago I have had enough.

I am now a size 10 and some of my friends have taken it very badly, and it has shocked me. I am now often quizzed, judged and I no longer feel like one of them. My feminist values have been questioned subtly, I am adhering to the patriarchy is the overall impression I am given. I have ‘given in’ or something like that.

I am furious. This is my body. I can be fit and well if I want to be. I spent an entire dinner party listening to friends telling me I should be proud whatever my size at the weekend. All the while looking slightly peeved.

I was pre diabetic with a host of health problems before, which was the main reason behind my decision. I feel fitter, more confident in myself. I can run, feel comfortable in clothes. It’s made such a difference to me personally.

We are not young - menopausal age. I thought I had better friends than this! Has anyone else experienced this?

OP posts:
Littleannoyingperson · 12/11/2024 13:40

TheSilkWorm · 12/11/2024 13:37

Jesus Christ a post on mumsnet to total strangers is completely different to gloating to friends! I have barely told anyone I'm on them and while I wouldn't lie if asked I would not entertain any conversation about them as it's nobody's business. However on mumsnet I post lots about them and how amazing they are. Different audiences! Most people IRL aren't shouting about the medication. Why would they?

Calm down, you shouldn’t explode like that. And it’s very different to a discussion about the drugs, we all do it and our nsv to posting suddenly on this thread about how great you look.

TheSilkWorm · 12/11/2024 13:37

Littleannoyingperson · 12/11/2024 13:23

I don’t expect them to be ‘happy’ for me at all, but I expect them to be honest with themselves about why they find this so difficult

you can’t ask them that though. However I see a bit of smugness and gloating creeping in. Amd I say that as someone on mounjaro who gets it. The thrill. The cheek bones. The right choices. The Looking good. The clothes. And I do wonder if this is as one way as you say.

becasye it’s bad how they’ve behaved, but sitting going on about the thrill of looking good and how healthy you are, your great cheekbones and new clothes, in front of a bunch of friends struggling is just as bad. And wholly lacking empathy. And will result in what you experienced.

I know you are saying you didn’t, but you couldn’t resist a gloaty post telling everyone how great you look. Even when it was really not required , tells me there is more to this.

Jesus Christ a post on mumsnet to total strangers is completely different to gloating to friends! I have barely told anyone I'm on them and while I wouldn't lie if asked I would not entertain any conversation about them as it's nobody's business. However on mumsnet I post lots about them and how amazing they are. Different audiences! Most people IRL aren't shouting about the medication. Why would they?

Dontwearmysocks · 12/11/2024 13:33

I think the responses would have been completely different if you had mentioned weight loss jabs in the original post.

WHY??

I’m staggered at the amount of women punching down other women because of their choices in trying to improve their health.

Fat shaming is seen as unacceptable, but slating someone for trying to minimise obesity related health risks using legitimate medication is not? Mad.

Think how much more the NHS could save if all those obese people weren’t obese anymore….lets not pretend obesity isn’t a massive burden on NHS resources, type 2 diabetics takes a big old chunk of the budget, and could very easily be reduced if people lost weight.

its not “cheating” or a cop out - weight loss meds can make it a lot easier for people with food related issues to get a bit of bloody respite and make progress.

@Artistbythewater you keep on going with what’s making you feel healthier and happier 💪

JWKD · 12/11/2024 13:27

If they don't approve of the injections, they don't have to get them. Whether you should or not isn't up to them.

I've decided against the injections for now. I see my doctor every six months about my diabetes, and we'll discuss it again next time. Nobody else gets a say.

Littleannoyingperson · 12/11/2024 13:23

I don’t expect them to be ‘happy’ for me at all, but I expect them to be honest with themselves about why they find this so difficult

you can’t ask them that though. However I see a bit of smugness and gloating creeping in. Amd I say that as someone on mounjaro who gets it. The thrill. The cheek bones. The right choices. The Looking good. The clothes. And I do wonder if this is as one way as you say.

becasye it’s bad how they’ve behaved, but sitting going on about the thrill of looking good and how healthy you are, your great cheekbones and new clothes, in front of a bunch of friends struggling is just as bad. And wholly lacking empathy. And will result in what you experienced.

I know you are saying you didn’t, but you couldn’t resist a gloaty post telling everyone how great you look. Even when it was really not required , tells me there is more to this.

Artistbythewater · 12/11/2024 13:12

Maybe I have underestimated that a change like this would impact my friends, after all, it’s just some weight loss and nothing earth shattering. I am not a brand new person.

It does mean I have been able to wear some new clothes which was so enjoyable to find I looked nice in some of them, they hang well. My face looks much better. Who knew I had cheekbones? I guess there are more changes than I realised. Maybe it is a shock to them. I have always been a confident person, maybe they didn’t expect this of me. I have never been especially body conscious or worried about weight.

We did speak about it, and they don’t want to use the jabs (fear of being ill, not having energy and lack of research) Their reasons are valid and it’s their decision. My decision is different, and I’m absolutely sure I have made the right one for my circumstances.

My body feels so different, I am stlll getting used to my own new self. It’s privately quite thrilling to see myself emerging out of the mirror each day. I had counselling before this, so it was a considered decision. Based around giving myself the time and resources to finally be the healthiest version I can be. There was much more to the weight than simple middle age spread. It was keeping me safe, unseen. Insulation. I don’t need it now, and I don’t need the friends that can’t accept me as I am.

I am quite happy to let them go if this continues for much longer. I don’t expect them to be ‘happy’ for me at all, but I expect them to be honest with themselves about why they find this so difficult.

OP posts:
RunSlowTalkFast · 12/11/2024 11:45

Maybe one or both of them have secretly tried the jabs and they didn't work for them and they're jealous?

Just putting forward another theory!

dottiedodah · 12/11/2024 11:29

Many of us (inc me!) are a bit overweight and would like to lose it.However we are not able to get access to injections .You have lost weight and thats good .Your friends are being unreasonable .They see this as a "quick fix" and it really isnt .I think its a shame to lose chums ,as new ones are harder to find when older. I wonder if going for meals is a good thing with them. Presumably you cannot eat very much and they may feel embarassed when going for a pud! perhaps a walk and coffee,trip to cinema, or a trip to the pub may be better ?

Fizzywizzywoowoo · 12/11/2024 10:09

Weight and dress size is a massive trigger for women . I remember when I listened to weight and two witches at work started to make my life hell . I had gone under the radar until then . Put the weight back on and was left alone .

Avocadot0ast · 12/11/2024 10:07

@Artistbythewater you need to set some firm boundaries. Your friends keep going back to this subject because they get away with it. I’d have given them a very simple “I am not discussing my body, health or weight loss anymore. Let’s move into another topic, I am happy, I am healthy and that is the last I will say on the matter, as my friends please respect that and let’s have a nice evening”

Then if they pushed the boundary again you don't respond, you stay silent for a few seconds, look at them calmly and then bring up another topic. Rinse and repeat. And if they push harder you get up and leave the table, say you really can’t keep going round in circles on this topic, you value their friendship and company but right now you feel ganged up on and bullied when all you’ve done is work in your own personal health, something which doesn’t impact them. You’ve said you don’t want to have this topic brought up and they are disregarding your feelings, so you’ll see them another day when your weight and body shape isn’t the main conversation.

i have lost 100lbs myself, I’ve never had this with my friends/family but I have had to put firm boundaries in place in other aspects of my life, and yes it’s hard at first but years later I realise how much damage I was doing to myself by allowing such bad behaviour from others. It’s important you set the precedent now.

OriginalUsername2 · 12/11/2024 09:50

God yes. My own mil was incredibly jealous of my weight loss. She would visibly bristle and look angry when she heard me get compliments. A neighbour also lost some weight. I mentioned how well she looked when I got inside and mil immediately spat out something about her bad dress sense.

ToriMJ · 12/11/2024 09:41

billybear · 11/11/2024 23:03

im having similar always been very over weight tried very hard lost 3 stone 1 stone to go, all i get is you look ill dont lose any more weight, usually a thin person saying it i think we were ok as the fat friend but they dont like thin person competition.

I had this when I lost a chunk of weight. I was young and bmi 23, absolutely didn't look too thin or ill but one skinny friend said I was losing too much. She was smaller than me still. Dickhead move.

Littleannoyingperson · 12/11/2024 09:38

Aghastohmy · 12/11/2024 09:27

I said nothing about how she lost the weight. Nothing. You have brought that to the table.

When someone loses weight, they have absolutely gained a position of privilege - in terms of health, in terms of happiness, in terms of societal acceptance - and for those who are still standing back at square one it can cause some difficult emotions.

I don’t think it’s a place of privalge. How did we get to a position where anyone would think being a healthy weight is a privalge.

the poster is right, your snippy tone is an example of the issue being raised on this thread.

Disturbia81 · 12/11/2024 09:29

SwingTheMonkey · 11/11/2024 21:05

I haven’t experienced it but I’m not at all surprised that it’s happening to you. As an overweight person, you fulfil a role in your social group. You’re the staple, the failsafe, the comforting ‘at least I’m thinner than artistbythewater’. And now you don’t fulfil that role. There’s no one there to feel superior to, to look down on, to make them feel better about themselves.
Even if your friends aren’t thinking these things openly, they will be thinking it subconsciously.
Im also losing a lot of weight currently and having been overweight for years, I expect this to happen to me too.

It's awful isn't it, thinking that your friends thought of you as the reliable fat friend who looked worse than them. It's insecurity. A true friend would just be glad that you're happier!

Aghastohmy · 12/11/2024 09:27

SlovenlyOldSlut · 12/11/2024 09:22

it's a wonderful achievement - but acting innocent from your new place of privilege and excitement and you pretending you can't possibly understand why they might be feeling some strong emotions about it is tone-deaf.

And this is precisely the sort of problem the OP is facing. Apparently now weight loss is a “privilege”. Would it still be a privilege if she’d done it the “right” way, I wonder?

I saw recently that Lizzo went to a Halloween party dressed as an Ozempic syringe in response to what she described as “accusations” that that was how she’s lost weight recently. I was angry to see she’d used that term - but really, my anger was misdirected. I should have been annoyed with the people who act like you can diminish the achievement of weight loss by acting like medical help is “cheating”. No wonder it feels like an accusation.

I said nothing about how she lost the weight. Nothing. You have brought that to the table.

When someone loses weight, they have absolutely gained a position of privilege - in terms of health, in terms of happiness, in terms of societal acceptance - and for those who are still standing back at square one it can cause some difficult emotions.

SlovenlyOldSlut · 12/11/2024 09:25

TheSilkWorm · 12/11/2024 09:23

To be fair to Lizzo the Halloween costume was a clap back to South Park and it was funny

I didn’t say it wasn’t! It’s just sad that she felt she had to specify it was a response to “accusations”.

tishtishboom · 12/11/2024 09:24

Most people go one of two ways. Those who obsess about their own weight and think they're too fat will tell you that you've lost too much, are "gaunt", that they don't recognise you and that you need to stop. Those who have always been slimmer will very clearly, if not explicitly, communicate that they were right all along and thank goodness you've come to your senses. In the process making it clear that they despised you all these years.

A very few (and thankfully I have some in my life) will be happy for you achieving your goals.

It is a mental, social and psychological minefield.

TheSilkWorm · 12/11/2024 09:23

SlovenlyOldSlut · 12/11/2024 09:22

it's a wonderful achievement - but acting innocent from your new place of privilege and excitement and you pretending you can't possibly understand why they might be feeling some strong emotions about it is tone-deaf.

And this is precisely the sort of problem the OP is facing. Apparently now weight loss is a “privilege”. Would it still be a privilege if she’d done it the “right” way, I wonder?

I saw recently that Lizzo went to a Halloween party dressed as an Ozempic syringe in response to what she described as “accusations” that that was how she’s lost weight recently. I was angry to see she’d used that term - but really, my anger was misdirected. I should have been annoyed with the people who act like you can diminish the achievement of weight loss by acting like medical help is “cheating”. No wonder it feels like an accusation.

To be fair to Lizzo the Halloween costume was a clap back to South Park and it was funny

SlovenlyOldSlut · 12/11/2024 09:22

it's a wonderful achievement - but acting innocent from your new place of privilege and excitement and you pretending you can't possibly understand why they might be feeling some strong emotions about it is tone-deaf.

And this is precisely the sort of problem the OP is facing. Apparently now weight loss is a “privilege”. Would it still be a privilege if she’d done it the “right” way, I wonder?

I saw recently that Lizzo went to a Halloween party dressed as an Ozempic syringe in response to what she described as “accusations” that that was how she’s lost weight recently. I was angry to see she’d used that term - but really, my anger was misdirected. I should have been annoyed with the people who act like you can diminish the achievement of weight loss by acting like medical help is “cheating”. No wonder it feels like an accusation.

The13thFairy · 12/11/2024 09:10

It's like when someone in your friendship group stops smoking or drinking. You're no longer doing what your friends are doing: you've examined your life and changed your habits. Other people can get a bit arsey about this but with luck things will settle - congratulations on your weight loss and the wonderful boost to your health

Littleannoyingperson · 12/11/2024 08:50

The other key point is this is women on women. We have a male friend who has lost several stone, literally, after being obese for decades. I strongly suspect he’s using medication to help him on his journey and not admitting it. All the men in the group are nothing but pleased for him, and give it little to no notice other than a passing well done mate. From the fit to the fat, there is no judgement. They don’t care about his weight other than from a health perspective. The women talk about it much more, but there is no envy or judgement, I assume as he’s a man, that comparison or competition doesn’t exist,

but woman on woman. That’s a whole different ballgame. One of the women in the group recently lost weight, she was always an upper but flabby healthy weight but became fit. No jabs, just exercise classes, and When she walked in after not seeing her for a while, I told her she looks great, you could see she’d lost weight and looked fit, and another woman turned round and said for “for christ sakes look at the state of your legs, they look like they could snap. “ they didn’t, they looked fit and toned, and the woman who made the comment, she is the fattest in the group. So She immediately made a bitchy comment. She didn’t do that to the man who lost several stone. I can only assume as it didn’t reflect on her as much, but her go to for the woman was to immediately have a go.

BunnyLake · 12/11/2024 08:50

Even some of Adele’s fans vilified her for losing weight, saying she’d betrayed them. It’s so twisted.

MidnightBlossom · 12/11/2024 08:50

Mummyratbag · 12/11/2024 08:27

Society is so messed up with moral judgements linked to weight!
The whole big = lazy, stupid
thin = disciplined
that people think that the jab is a get out and circumnavigating the above. You only have to read some recent threads here about life long slim people being cross that others have access to tools to be slim... Very much as "know your place fatties"

what i wanted to say but much more concise and better!

MidnightBlossom · 12/11/2024 08:49

well done op.

change can be difficult. i don't understand the sneering at people who are on meds to help with trying to lose weight. being overweight has serious health implications and the cause can be difficult to resolve, because for lots of people there are emotional factors that aren't as straightforward as 'eat less move more'. if there is help available then why wouldn't you take it?

people can be funny about what they see as cheating. i think it's tied to a view of overweight people, especially women, as being lazy and unmotivated and less disciplined. losing weight the so-called traditional way through restriction is acceptable, because going without is the penance you have to pay for being overweight in the first place. having help looks like a sidestep of that; you're getting a taxi to the finish line instead of running the marathon.

utter bollocks - help or not you still have to put in effort, and you have to retrain your habits and sort out the root cause in order to maintain a healthy weight esp when you finish meds. but people can be funny about it. emphasising the difficulty means that they can comfort themselves about why they haven't done it.

to be fair it is bloody difficult, but that goes back to the first point about why not accept help when it's offered? equally if i decide not to accept help but someone else does, why do i have the right to judge them? I've lost 26lbs since 1 jan by changing by diet and upping my exercise. i have a friend on mounjaro and we're doing a weight buddies thing at the moment. me losing weight is not any more or less valid by her losing weight using a different method.

focus on you. it's a great result and you should feel happy about it.

Mummyratbag · 12/11/2024 08:27

Society is so messed up with moral judgements linked to weight!
The whole big = lazy, stupid
thin = disciplined
that people think that the jab is a get out and circumnavigating the above. You only have to read some recent threads here about life long slim people being cross that others have access to tools to be slim... Very much as "know your place fatties"