Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lost weight, now losing friends!

242 replies

Artistbythewater · 11/11/2024 20:45

I have been over weight for many years. I decided about six months ago I have had enough.

I am now a size 10 and some of my friends have taken it very badly, and it has shocked me. I am now often quizzed, judged and I no longer feel like one of them. My feminist values have been questioned subtly, I am adhering to the patriarchy is the overall impression I am given. I have ‘given in’ or something like that.

I am furious. This is my body. I can be fit and well if I want to be. I spent an entire dinner party listening to friends telling me I should be proud whatever my size at the weekend. All the while looking slightly peeved.

I was pre diabetic with a host of health problems before, which was the main reason behind my decision. I feel fitter, more confident in myself. I can run, feel comfortable in clothes. It’s made such a difference to me personally.

We are not young - menopausal age. I thought I had better friends than this! Has anyone else experienced this?

OP posts:
auderesperare · 13/11/2024 18:13

I’m sorry you are experiencing this OP. A bit late now but I would advise just saying “it’s a mixture of exercise, diet and medication and I’m doing it for health reasons and on medical advice”. If they persist, I’d say “I don’t want to talk about private medical issues”. Or “let’s talk about something else. Our weight is the least interesting thing about us”. If they keep going, just get upset and say how upsetting and disappointing it is that they can’t respect your boundaries or be happy for you as your health had improved.
They will always be friends but maybe not such close friends. It’s perfectly possible to make great new friendships in middle age. And because you are feeling energised, happy and confident, you will!

Hungrysalmon87 · 13/11/2024 18:07

Artistbythewater · 11/11/2024 21:07

Well it’s mixed but my slimmer friends have been okay, it’s the ones that were a similar size or bigger.

Edited

That's your answer right there. They're conflicted and their own insecurities ("we're all overweight together etc") are overpowering any feelings of goodwill that they should be having to you.

They're not your friends, or at least they don't deserve to be.

For the avoidance of doubt - I am not saying anything negative about being overweight or anything like that, more just about your friends inability to have genuine happiness for your journey.

Crakajak · 13/11/2024 18:03

Artistbythewater · 11/11/2024 20:45

I have been over weight for many years. I decided about six months ago I have had enough.

I am now a size 10 and some of my friends have taken it very badly, and it has shocked me. I am now often quizzed, judged and I no longer feel like one of them. My feminist values have been questioned subtly, I am adhering to the patriarchy is the overall impression I am given. I have ‘given in’ or something like that.

I am furious. This is my body. I can be fit and well if I want to be. I spent an entire dinner party listening to friends telling me I should be proud whatever my size at the weekend. All the while looking slightly peeved.

I was pre diabetic with a host of health problems before, which was the main reason behind my decision. I feel fitter, more confident in myself. I can run, feel comfortable in clothes. It’s made such a difference to me personally.

We are not young - menopausal age. I thought I had better friends than this! Has anyone else experienced this?

You just unleashed their insecurities and jealousy I'm afraid. It's why I prefer dogs.

Purplehydra · 13/11/2024 18:01

How much weight have you lost? What size were you before?
Can’t they just be happy for you?!

AgathaMystery · 13/11/2024 10:45

Disturbia81 · 13/11/2024 10:36

Can you imagine men giving thought to this or treating friends differently for losing weight, group dynamics changing. I love being a woman but do hate some of these behaviours I see and hear about that I can't relate to at all, reminds me of the school playground days.

I agree with you. It’s really fascinating. Men don’t seem to have similar dynamics.

Disturbia81 · 13/11/2024 10:36

AgathaMystery · 13/11/2024 10:13

I think, genuinely, that when we lose weight we really do lose our place in our friendship groups. None of us like to think it but our place in our social circles is multi layered and appearance is part of that. Weight, like it or not, forms part of our appearance.

I have friendship groups where I have been the slimmest and groups where I have been the biggest. I am no longer the biggest in any of my friendship groups and some dynamics have changed.

I have never discussed my weight loss with any of my friends. Not once. I am absolutely incapable of discussing it as it is so private to me.

But still, they discuss it. I feel for you OP. it is hard.

Can you imagine men giving thought to this or treating friends differently for losing weight, group dynamics changing. I love being a woman but do hate some of these behaviours I see and hear about that I can't relate to at all, reminds me of the school playground days.

AgathaMystery · 13/11/2024 10:13

I think, genuinely, that when we lose weight we really do lose our place in our friendship groups. None of us like to think it but our place in our social circles is multi layered and appearance is part of that. Weight, like it or not, forms part of our appearance.

I have friendship groups where I have been the slimmest and groups where I have been the biggest. I am no longer the biggest in any of my friendship groups and some dynamics have changed.

I have never discussed my weight loss with any of my friends. Not once. I am absolutely incapable of discussing it as it is so private to me.

But still, they discuss it. I feel for you OP. it is hard.

fairycakes1234 · 12/11/2024 20:02

Littleannoyingperson · 12/11/2024 13:23

I don’t expect them to be ‘happy’ for me at all, but I expect them to be honest with themselves about why they find this so difficult

you can’t ask them that though. However I see a bit of smugness and gloating creeping in. Amd I say that as someone on mounjaro who gets it. The thrill. The cheek bones. The right choices. The Looking good. The clothes. And I do wonder if this is as one way as you say.

becasye it’s bad how they’ve behaved, but sitting going on about the thrill of looking good and how healthy you are, your great cheekbones and new clothes, in front of a bunch of friends struggling is just as bad. And wholly lacking empathy. And will result in what you experienced.

I know you are saying you didn’t, but you couldn’t resist a gloaty post telling everyone how great you look. Even when it was really not required , tells me there is more to this.

Good god, she just said she didn't do any of that and is secretly thrilled, whats wrong with you!!

Artistbythewater · 12/11/2024 19:47

Littleannoyingperson · 12/11/2024 19:44

Ok fair enough, as said, I get you, I’m on the same drug, just I wondered as it was a sudden discussion on it if you’d done anything to make them react negatively, but it appears not. So it’s as per the rest of the thread. They are just envious and a gang mentality occurred.

I not convinced they are necessarily envious but maybe a feeling that I am no longer one of them vibe. That I have gone over to the dark side.
We are older women and no one is rocking the car walk at this point. I would say it feels more like disappointment. Which is somehow worse to me, than jealousy.

OP posts:
Littleannoyingperson · 12/11/2024 19:44

Artistbythewater · 12/11/2024 19:28

Absolutely not smug or anything of the sort. I was saying I acknowledge there may have been some changes that I hadn’t taken into account. Clothes being one, facially being another. That to say nothing has changed but a few stone probably isn’t accurate on reflection.

I would not dream of saying this to anyone. Why would my friends want to know the intricate details of my weight loss, and the fact it’s having a far bigger impact on me psychologically than I ever envisaged? I wouldn’t want to bore them quite frankly and there are other subjects that are far more interesting!

Edited

Ok fair enough, as said, I get you, I’m on the same drug, just I wondered as it was a sudden discussion on it if you’d done anything to make them react negatively, but it appears not. So it’s as per the rest of the thread. They are just envious and a gang mentality occurred.

Artistbythewater · 12/11/2024 19:28

Littleannoyingperson · 12/11/2024 13:23

I don’t expect them to be ‘happy’ for me at all, but I expect them to be honest with themselves about why they find this so difficult

you can’t ask them that though. However I see a bit of smugness and gloating creeping in. Amd I say that as someone on mounjaro who gets it. The thrill. The cheek bones. The right choices. The Looking good. The clothes. And I do wonder if this is as one way as you say.

becasye it’s bad how they’ve behaved, but sitting going on about the thrill of looking good and how healthy you are, your great cheekbones and new clothes, in front of a bunch of friends struggling is just as bad. And wholly lacking empathy. And will result in what you experienced.

I know you are saying you didn’t, but you couldn’t resist a gloaty post telling everyone how great you look. Even when it was really not required , tells me there is more to this.

Absolutely not smug or anything of the sort. I was saying I acknowledge there may have been some changes that I hadn’t taken into account. Clothes being one, facially being another. That to say nothing has changed but a few stone probably isn’t accurate on reflection.

I would not dream of saying this to anyone. Why would my friends want to know the intricate details of my weight loss, and the fact it’s having a far bigger impact on me psychologically than I ever envisaged? I wouldn’t want to bore them quite frankly and there are other subjects that are far more interesting!

OP posts:
anonny55 · 12/11/2024 18:17

Happened to me. We was the same size and I lost weight and she didn't. She didn't want to be friends anymore!

BunnyLake · 12/11/2024 18:10

The13thFairy · 12/11/2024 09:10

It's like when someone in your friendship group stops smoking or drinking. You're no longer doing what your friends are doing: you've examined your life and changed your habits. Other people can get a bit arsey about this but with luck things will settle - congratulations on your weight loss and the wonderful boost to your health

That’s reminded me, back in the early 80s (I was late teens) we all used to smoke. My bf at the time decided to stop. I remember feeling a bit annoyed. I snapped out of it quickly, realising I was being unreasonable but at least I was still a teen (and I haven’t smoked in a long time now). It’s maybe understandable for the friends to have a short lived negative feeling but not to carry it on further into the friendship.

Twilightstarbright · 12/11/2024 18:09

I had to avoid doing the school run for a while because people were commenting on it so much. I made DH come with me as he said I was exaggerating but he saw for himself that there are some people absolutely obsessed with what someone else weighs.

What I find sad is it’s not a scarcity thing- there’s no rule that it a group of friends only X number can be a healthy weight. Appreciate it’s a complex thing for many though.

Pyjamatimenow · 12/11/2024 17:32

JohnTheRevelator · 12/11/2024 17:19

From personal experience,there is nothing like admitting that you are using weight loss injections to bring out the worst in some people!

Yep might as well tell them you’re shooting up
heroin

FinallyHere · 12/11/2024 17:30

Absolutely agree with PO who refuses to entertain any discussion about their weight.

Some people are surprised and want to reassure me that it's absolutely a compliment

I tell 'em there are only two reasons it could be, either a serious wasting disease or I had put on too much weight. In either case, it's just none of their business. Simples.

JohnTheRevelator · 12/11/2024 17:19

Pyjamatimenow · 11/11/2024 21:10

Are you on weight loss jabs? That seems to irk people a lot

From personal experience,there is nothing like admitting that you are using weight loss injections to bring out the worst in some people!

Cappuccinowithonesugarplease · 12/11/2024 17:18

Well done OP 👏
They're just jealous.

paradisecircus · 12/11/2024 17:04

I lost 8 stone, also at menopausal age, and one of my friends (slimmer than me) tells me I'm vain if I ever mention clothes size. I've never liked the way I look, which she knows, and I'm definitely not vain. I think it's a way to try and put you back in your place. I've also had comments about the risk of becoming gaunt - well as I've reversed diabetes and am now running half marathons I think I'll take the risk thanks. I hope your friends manage to change their tune OP.

Littleannoyingperson · 12/11/2024 16:55

SwingTheMonkey · 12/11/2024 16:24

And yet you didn’t hesitate to accuse the op of something utterly baseless and quite nasty. Perhaps you’d benefit from taking some of your own feedback.

Got that out your system or you wanna come in for another kick? Have at it.

ObieJoyful · 12/11/2024 16:38

Artistbythewater · 11/11/2024 21:07

Well it’s mixed but my slimmer friends have been okay, it’s the ones that were a similar size or bigger.

Edited

They think that by deciding not to be overweight, you’re criticising them in some way.

It’s bonkers, but that’s what it is!

SwingTheMonkey · 12/11/2024 16:24

Littleannoyingperson · 12/11/2024 15:09

alright it was just a thought, we don’t need a pile on. Someone said it already. 😟

And yet you didn’t hesitate to accuse the op of something utterly baseless and quite nasty. Perhaps you’d benefit from taking some of your own feedback.

Littleannoyingperson · 12/11/2024 15:09

SwingTheMonkey · 12/11/2024 14:39

What an odd response.

Saying how good you feel being lighter, to a bunch of strangers on the internet, isn’t gloating.

Seems like you’ve got some issues that have made you read something into this post that others can’t see.

alright it was just a thought, we don’t need a pile on. Someone said it already. 😟

SwingTheMonkey · 12/11/2024 14:39

Littleannoyingperson · 12/11/2024 13:23

I don’t expect them to be ‘happy’ for me at all, but I expect them to be honest with themselves about why they find this so difficult

you can’t ask them that though. However I see a bit of smugness and gloating creeping in. Amd I say that as someone on mounjaro who gets it. The thrill. The cheek bones. The right choices. The Looking good. The clothes. And I do wonder if this is as one way as you say.

becasye it’s bad how they’ve behaved, but sitting going on about the thrill of looking good and how healthy you are, your great cheekbones and new clothes, in front of a bunch of friends struggling is just as bad. And wholly lacking empathy. And will result in what you experienced.

I know you are saying you didn’t, but you couldn’t resist a gloaty post telling everyone how great you look. Even when it was really not required , tells me there is more to this.

What an odd response.

Saying how good you feel being lighter, to a bunch of strangers on the internet, isn’t gloating.

Seems like you’ve got some issues that have made you read something into this post that others can’t see.

Disturbia81 · 12/11/2024 14:05

@ToriMJ Yeah very weird when someone says you look ill/don't lose more when they're still thinner.