Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse to have DD’s boyfriend in the house because he CHEATED o

163 replies

BusyOnMyPhone · 10/11/2024 00:50

Or should we get over it because she has?

She’s been with him for 3 years, he cheated on her a year ago. She walked in on it actually happening during a party at his house. Saw it all. Massively traumatic and she was hysterical. Initially dumped him but then got back with him a few months later after he chased her. We were absolutely gobsmacked (and furious). No way DH or I would stay together if one of us had done that despite having DC and she knew we fully had her back and we wanted to do him some harm. We certainly didn’t model to her to stay with someone who disrespects you and causes you massive emotional pain, quite the opposite. She’s quite feisty personality wise too so it was shocking when she admitted she was back with him.

She accepted his excuse (drunk) but we were hoping she’d wake up eventually as maybe still in shock and get rid of him completely but she hasn’t and she’s completely in love with him. It makes my skin crawl. We refused to have him as part of the family or anywhere near the house afterwards (DD still lives at home) and she is pretty secretive about her relationship with him which also worries me as in a normal situation, he’d be a part of the family and she could tell us what’s going on/ask advice if anything is bothering her about her relationship.

She’s only early 20’s, obviously no DC, they don’t live together and have no ties so we just can’t understand why she insists on staying with him after he did the unforgivable. She has other options other than staying with a disgusting twat like him. We’ve discussed if she has kids with him, that it might come back to haunt her when she’s vulnerable and she’ll resent him but be tied to him for life with DC etc. I can’t imagine how she’d want to have DC with him but she does! He’s her first and only boyfriend and she can’t see herself ever with someone else.

I’ve said to DH we can’t keep on shunning him as it’s gone on too long and it could lead to her distancing herself from us if they move in together or have DC, or stuff going on that we won’t know about. He doesn’t want anything to do with him and nor do I but we’re going to have to?

OP posts:
TheDeepLemonHelper · 10/11/2024 01:13

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

redalex261 · 10/11/2024 01:12

@OAPapparently and @HerBloodIsLikeLiquidFire have summed it up. She’s taken him back and knows you think it’s a weakness. Unless you put in the (fake) acceptance of him there’s no chance she’ll discuss any worries or admit to any doubts. She will hang on and not want to face “I told you so” even if you wouldn’t say that.

TH1NG1E · 10/11/2024 01:05

You're going to end up having her keeping everything from you because you don't trust her to make her own decisions. She's a grown up, let her be before she resents you.

HerBloodIsLikeLiquidFire · 10/11/2024 01:04

The more you take a hard line on this, even though clearly it's for her benefit, the more she'll end up pushing you away. She has to be free to make her own (even more) mistakes. But keep it pushed down so that she can feel secure in coming back to you for support if (when) it all blows up in her face again. I'd feel murderous too. That instinct makes you her ultimate protector. But she won't understand that for quite some time yet.

FiveShelties · 10/11/2024 01:03

Don't make her pick between you.

twyst82 · 10/11/2024 01:03

I really feel for you Op, we were recently in a very similar situation but with a boyfriend who wasn't treating dd right (no cheating)
I couldn't believe that someone we had welcomed into our home was doing this to dd, we said he was no longer welcome at the house and even though we talked to dd loads she was determined she wanted to stay with him!
I completely backed off, told her when his name came up that I knew she deserved better and he wasn't the one for her but didn't push it.
She was convinced he had changed and would live happily ever after. Anyway long story short she told us out the blue a few weeks ago it was all over, she had seen the light and dumped him. I was delighted (though still played it cool, told her she'd made the right choice and I was proud of her for seeing her worth etc) but I really did not see the break up coming at all. Hopefully you will be the same with your dd. I was so worried that going forward it was going to push dd from us if we wanted nothing to do with her boyfriend.

OAPapparently · 10/11/2024 01:01

I wouldn’t want him in the house either, but I think in this instance it’s best to keep your enemy close until she sees sense and hopefully dumps him.
If you are hostile towards him, it could make her just leave and stubbornly build a life with him full of regret.
Just be there for her. You are doing it for her, not him. You don’t want to make her feel isolated by making it difficult for her to talk to you about him.

Ubugly · 10/11/2024 00:58

Ugh I would be raging to but young love and young people don’t see what we do down the line, I imagine I would have been the same at that age tbh but guess the more you say no you will push her away or lead to lies. I mean maybe it was a mistake or a one off who knows but you may have to grit your teeth then hopefully she sees sense soon and you can breathe a sigh of relief.

Willyoujustbequiet · 10/11/2024 00:57

Nope. I wouldn’t.

Forgiveness can be the quickest route to being hurt again.

NoBiscuitsLeftInMyTin · 10/11/2024 00:57

BusyOnMyPhone · 10/11/2024 00:54

I just can’t imagine having him over and not wanting to smash his face in. Having to have him over for dinner, at Christmas!

Her brothers feel the same!

I can see that -but what about in a few years time when they may have children together? You could risk not seeing them at all.

BusyOnMyPhone · 10/11/2024 00:54

I just can’t imagine having him over and not wanting to smash his face in. Having to have him over for dinner, at Christmas!

Her brothers feel the same!

OP posts:
NoBiscuitsLeftInMyTin · 10/11/2024 00:52

I know it’s a shit situation but it’s her circus and her monkeys. You don’t have to approve but it’s down to her I’m afraid. I have adult DC’s myself and this is the way it is I’m afraid.

BusyOnMyPhone · 10/11/2024 00:51

Apologies title should have said CHEATED on her.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread