Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that i can lose 6 kilos in the next 6 weeks?

135 replies

captainmarvella · 09/11/2024 02:04

i am going on a once in a lifetime holiday to a fabulous beachy and instagrammable worthy location and feeling horrible about my size 20 body with protruding a$$ and treble chins. i want to try this one meal a day thing for some instant results but bestie says it won't work for some one like me - mid 40s, hypothyroidism, binge issues in the past, and can actually make me sick. I don't want to be sick right before my bucket list vacation! Should I listen to her?

i don't plan to do low carb or anything, just eat one filling and balanced plate of my fav stuff, once a day. right now i'm at 85 kilos. I want my weight to be at least in the seventies when I leave for my xmas vacay. i have seen so many inspiring progress pics online about the OMAD lifestyle it's really giving me hope. But most of these are from men, so I don't know if it really works for perimenopausal women! Aibu to even consider this with my current health profile?

OP posts:
StandingSideBySide · 10/11/2024 17:55

Based on your weight and height ( ethnicity does change the calc but I just ticked prefer not to say )
Your bmi is 31.6

nb as you said your details I’m hoping you dont mind me doing the calc for
you

68kg would put you in the ‘healthy’ range.

Its just a basic online calc though

captainmarvella · 10/11/2024 17:54

Autumnweddingguest · 09/11/2024 08:10

Do you function during the day if you eat nothing until 5.30pm? DH and i have been doing the 5:2 diet. Two days a week on 600-800cals, since September. I haven;t lost a pound. In fact it has triggered old bingeing habits that I'd had no issue with for a while, on the off-days. I find I just can't focus on work on the low calories days. I feel tired and cold and my brain, which needs to be in sharp focus all day long for the work I do, is just sluggish and makes mistakes. Meanwhile DH is looking slimmer and skipping about on the low cal days going for long walks (he's retired.) It pissed me off so much I told him I am stopping doing it now, as I was wasting two precious workdays a week, staring into space.

How can people function all day long with no food? It baffles me.

This happened to me too when I tried keto and IF together, husband kept getting visibly thinner and all I was feeling was misery! It was quite frustrating. I think the culprit could be the electrolytes, I wasn't having them.

OP posts:
captainmarvella · 10/11/2024 17:51

SpidersAreShitheads · 09/11/2024 03:18

I’m another one saying that keto/low carb is revolutionary.

I’ve lost 35lbs in 3 months doing keto. No exercise yet as we’re mid house renovation.

I eat loads. I’m never hungry. I have an insanely sweet tooth and there are plenty of ways to get a chocolate fix on keto while still sticking to your daily allowance.

I drink sugar-free squash. I have had the occasional diet fizzy drink if I’ve felt the urge on a weekend.

I love food. I love bread, potatoes, and cake. And dear god I love chocolate.

But with keto you just don’t have those things. So no need to try and only have a small portion which imo is much harder than just cutting it out. You have alternatives instead. Halloumi cheese instead of chips, for example.

I’m 49, pre diabetic and perimenopausal. And dress size 22 when I started. If I can do it, anyone can. I’m utterly shit at dieting and have no self-control.

The thing is, it’s up to you. You need to work out what your priority is and what your triggers are. If you want to get healthier and lose weight then you keep that in focus. Whatever you pick, don’t have contraband food in the house.

I have dark chocolate sweetened with vanilla, sugar-free jelly, and sometimes either Grenade or Fulfil salted caramel protein bars. There’s virtually no carbs - about 2-3g or so - in each bar so it gives a chocolate hit without ruining your diet.

My issues were being hungry, not planning, and a sweet tooth so I’ve made sure my diet addresses all of those.

It’s absolutely possible to do but whatever diet you follow, there will need to be changes and compromises made. Only you can decide what’s the most important to you. For me, being told I was prediabetic was the kick up the arse I needed to make a change.

i am so glad this works for you. i'd love to do it but with my history of emotional eating/binging it's very hard for me to sustain it. i am still going to make my 3 plates as low carb as possible. Just one portion of carbs a day - whether it is rice, pasta or chocolate.

OP posts:
captainmarvella · 10/11/2024 17:47

Garlicpest · 09/11/2024 03:17

Wouldn't you be a prime candidate for GLPs? Superdrug's offering 33% off at the moment, or check the weight loss threads.

thank you and all others who suggested this, i have spent the past two days reading up on GLPs. i never knew this was an option! I have made an appointment with my GP tomorrow and consult about taking GLPs for my obesity.

OP posts:
captainmarvella · 10/11/2024 17:43

J1Dub · 09/11/2024 03:05

If you are breathless when walking normally, you are already pushing yourself, so it's probably not a good idea to walk on an incline. I can't push myself any harder than the breathless stage without having to stop after a (very) short while.

my stamina is really bad. i haven't exercised in a long time - just started swimming, mostly coz i live in a hot city and it's just not enjoyable to walk. p.s. i am breathless only if i walk fast, if i walk slow i can walk for hours (as long as I take frequent breaks in between - bad back)

OP posts:
captainmarvella · 10/11/2024 17:38

Anonymousess · 10/11/2024 17:33

What’s your BMI? If you’re obese, you could consider medication to help you alongside diet and exercise. 1kg weight loss a week is unrealistic for smaller frames but if you have a lot to lose, it could be possible. Realistically though I don’t think you’ll look much different in 6 weeks.

well i am 86 kg on a five and half feet tall frame. i don't know if it's a lot but my body fat percentage is nearly 40. at least if i could get rid of my bloated thyroid face and the third chin by xmas i'd be ecstatic 😣 i'm beginning to realise that i won't be losing 6 kg by dec 20, it's just 5 weeks away sigh

someone mentioned this, i don't plan to stuff myself during the actual holiday, it's not in a country that really does xmas, i will get a lot of fresh seafood, i love it and plan to eat a lot of it

OP posts:
Cerealkiller4U · 10/11/2024 17:37

captainmarvella · 09/11/2024 02:28

this sounds lovely but i can never do portion control, i love food and i just stuff my face with it even if it's just porridge... the reason why i am in this situation ig

Pretty much diet and losing weight are down to two things

calorie deficit and exercise.

you need to burn more calories than you’re eating. That’s literally it

its impossible to eat less calories and not start to lose weight.

the big big thing though is psychological. Most people who struggle to lose weight have some problems with food. Disordered eating. Hormones and bad food control.

that will be what you’ll struggle to change in the time frame as it will take years to change it.

I think 6kgs would take probably a good while and can’t be wuick

because as you youreself stated you’re the size you are because of one or some of these issues

i do not think those issues will go away in time for your holiday

but start now and see where you end up. Eating one meal throughout the entire day,…also not healthy eating

fasting is a good way though so I’d incorporate that somehow

captainmarvella · 10/11/2024 17:33

Mummyoflittledragon · 09/11/2024 03:01

I ate 3 plates of food consecutively as described in my comment above and ate in the space of an hour. That’s one meal a day. You don’t have to eat it slowly. Just mindfully.

  1. Starter - salad bits with vinaigrette as this aids digestion.
  2. Meal - ensuring plenty of protein and veg.
  3. Pudding - crackers with butter and marmite. I could have added cheese. But I had grated cheese with my mains along with stuff like an avocado.

Eating over 3 hours is eating more than one meal a day. OMAD is eating once, for an hour. Don’t worry if you don’t achieve this. Some days I needed something light in the evening as my body became accustomed to the new regime.

My body actually really likes OMAD. I am unable to eat like that unfortunately due to circumstances beyond my control.

thanks for clarifying, i think i am not quite ready for the one hour eating window goal. perhaps i should start with the 21:3? i realise now that i have done this for the past 3 days without any huger pangs

3 plates as 3 courses is a great idea! i can imagine doing that over 3 hours and feeling quite satisfied and full

OP posts:
Anonymousess · 10/11/2024 17:33

What’s your BMI? If you’re obese, you could consider medication to help you alongside diet and exercise. 1kg weight loss a week is unrealistic for smaller frames but if you have a lot to lose, it could be possible. Realistically though I don’t think you’ll look much different in 6 weeks.

captainmarvella · 10/11/2024 17:30

yeah I have attempted keto many times but its not sustainable bcos of my monster sweet tooth. i am going to the gym tomorrow to take a look and see if they have anything that fits my 6 week goal

OP posts:
Storybot · 10/11/2024 09:01

Moonlightstars · 10/11/2024 07:01

Where did I say 3 hours? 2 hours is the standard sort of mid way point for 10,000 steps and it could be done through out the day. Walk to work and back but add an extra 10 mins both ways half an hour at lunch and then a walk after work.
Personally think its really important to increase exercise if losing weight to build up muscle and be more toned.

I think so too but that's long term, OP will not get toned before her holiday in 6 weeks

Bigredcombine · 10/11/2024 08:37

Mounjaro! Many people are really weird about weight loss drugs as they believe fat people should suffer in order to lose weight. But if you want guaranteed success of actually losing that about of weight by Christmas, take mounjaro.
I'm surprised more people haven't mentioned it.

ForMintUser · 10/11/2024 08:15

I’ve lost about 6kg in 2/3 months without trying. Been eating vegetarian a lot, been walking most days and wherever possible avoiding anything processed.

Haven’t cut out carbs or sweet things but if I want something sweet I’ve been making things rather than buying them. Even had a few takeaways.

Wasn’t trying to lose weight and was surprised I had but seems to be working for me so I’m keeping to it.

I would advise against any quick weight loss diet, I went through phases for years of low carb and calorie restriction, after reading The Diet Myth I realised why I would always put the weight back on and then some so decided to stop dieting.

Can’t guarantee this will work for everyone but that would be my diet tips to try - eat vegetarian, walking, avoiding processed foods.

Editing to add that eating home made sweet things means I less of them. And the cravings for chocolate etc disappear (I’m a big sugar junkie). I really feel UPF is highly addictive.

Tryingtomoveisdrivingmecrazy · 10/11/2024 07:54

Have you considered trying mounjaro? It’s an absolute game changer. You will lose all those cravings and is ideal if you are pre diabetic. I have lost well over a stone in 6 weeks and it has been relatively easy, and very few side effects. I have also completely given up alcohol which I am sure has helped too. I feel great.

Smallsalt · 10/11/2024 07:51

Pylwin · 09/11/2024 02:13

Only eat though when you actually feel hungry

Bad advice, as a currently slim fat person .
I was fat because I am literally always hungry. So I would be eating all the time if I ate when I was hungry. Even after a huge meal, my body simply doesn't get the full up feeling. I am still hungry. I think people who dont live with this particular problem have a clue what it feels like .

Nottodaythankyou123 · 10/11/2024 07:41

I’m in the same boat - 6 weeks to lose 6kg for a holiday. I started last week and lost 0.5kg so I quickly realised it wasn’t going to happen. Instead what I’ve done is focus on eating healthy, nutritious food, up my water intake and just do movement I like without thinking about calories. Even after a week I already feel so much better even if the weight loss is slow.

I also bought a few new skincare bits (including some decent fake tan) to pamper myself and a few dresses and swimsuits that actually flatter my current size, and booked a facial and my nails before I go away. My goal now is just feeling as good as possible and laying the groundwork for decent habits that I can continue for long term results and not ruining a once in a lifetime holiday by worrying about my weight.

I hope you have a lovely holiday regardless of how much weight you lose x

Theextraordinaryisintheordinary · 10/11/2024 07:37

Join Noom. You can EASILY cancel your subscription after the trial. It holds your hand through each day and educates you around food as you go. It’s fun to use too. I found just learnt a lot about my food habits. Do it! Enjoy your holiday.

Farmgoose · 10/11/2024 07:26

Sounds unsustainable until you stop telling yourself you need sugar. You don’t. You need to change your mindset. Yes you’ll feel shaky and crave chocolate for a while but unless you want to be obese and diabetic in the future you need to accept sugar is generally off the menu. It’s up to you.
Maybe try watching some of the many online programmes about how poor western diets are. It takes about three days to get over ‘carb flu’.
Low carb you can eat meat, cottage cheese, veg. Lots of fat. You’re not hungry you’re just craving sugar.
I wish you all the best and hope you have a wonderful holiday. Once you get there nobody (including you) will be focusing on your weight but it’s good to think about your long term health.

PortiasBiscuit · 10/11/2024 07:22

Chop an arm off?

Westfacing · 10/11/2024 07:20

As you've had an eating disorder in the past I think you're mad to consider OMAD - it's too drastic and hard to stick to.

Low-carb would be an easier way to lose 6kg, IMO.

SpidersAreShitheads · 10/11/2024 07:16

freddyfluffball · 10/11/2024 06:48

@SpidersAreShitheads what an amazingly useful post, thanks. Inspired me to try this!

Aah you’re very welcome! I knew absolutely nothing about keto when I started and was weighing up different diets after I got my blood test to say I was prediabetic. Very overwhelming trying to pick a diet to try as a total newbie! Just luck that I settled on keto - and I had some really wonderful advice from people to help me get started.

I went cold turkey on everything instantly - because cutting back on stuff slowly just doesn’t work for me. Zero willpower! 🫣😂

So just a heads up - if you do what I did and plunge right in, keto flu is a thing. Mine was particularly rough as I cut out caffeine as well. It’s 2-3 days of feeling rotten - sluggish and headaches. I felt really grotty. But if you grit your teeth and power through it passes and you feel much better. Less bloated and more energy. Once you’re over the carbs and your body is getting energy from fats, you feel great.

Also, as a PP said, electrolytes really help with keto flu. In that transition period, if you up your electrolytes temporarily you won’t suffer as much. I did myself a Bovril drink and put some salt in my squash drinks. I couldn’t taste it but the salts helped. Once I added salts/increased electrolytes I got over the symptoms quickly.

In fairness, I might just be a wuss 😂

HellsBalls · 10/11/2024 07:15

Absolutely do not join a gym or do anything other than walking as exercise. You need to concentrate on maintaining the diet and not overeating. It will already be difficult enough without adding in a sore body and (if you even managed to do enough exercise to burn calories) extra hunger pangs.
Losing weight is all about the diet. It’s so much easier not to eat a bar of chocolate rather than eat it and then try and burn those calories off.
Worry about exercise once you’ve conquered the dirt.

firef1y · 10/11/2024 07:07

So I'm a personal trainer, who lost 10stone about 8years ago and has mostly kept it off.

Ok so if I were you, and I have been plus a lot more weight, I would aim for 1lb/week weight-loss, which is a 500Calorie a day deficit.

Prioritise protein in your meals, if you eat meat then that would be your meats, if you're vegetarian (like me) then beans, pulses, tofu and meat substitutes.

Meal prep as much as possible, batch cook and freeze meals that you've calorie counted. I have a freezer full of home made curries, stews, home made pasta sauces and cottage pie.

Create a plan for a weeks meals, and do your best to stick to it. Don't buy the foods that you'll binge on, easier said than done when you have children, I know.

If you like to eat a lot of food then it's still possible to volume eat. I make huge bowls of salad, using things like rice and beans, so big that I can't eat them in one sitting, but they have less than 500 Calories for the whole bowl.

Activity wise, the recommended minimum is 150minutes of intentional, moderate exercise or 75minutes intense exercise a week, spread over 5 days. This doesn't need to be all in one go, you could go for a brisk 15 minute walk in the morning and another in the evening. And intensity is relative, what would be a brisk walk for you might seem like a stroll for someone else, you just want to get your heart rate up.

I would also recommend incorporating some sort of resistance training, this can be bodyweight or with actual weights. There are lots of great videos and workouts available on the Internet. Recommended minimum is 30min twice a week. Resistance training will not only help you look better as the weight comes off, but will also help reduce the risk of osteoporosis.

No matter what with the exercise, find something you enjoy, it's then more likely you'll stick with it.

Finally, don't focus too much on the number on the scale. I'm 78kg, 4'11" and a size 10-12. BMi has me as obese, but in reality I lift heavy weights and have a much higher than average muscle mass. I'm also a marathon runner, not a fast marathon runner, but a marathon runner none the less.

Moonlightstars · 10/11/2024 07:01

TheSilkWorm · 10/11/2024 06:51

Weight loss is not created by exercise. And very few people have the time to walk 3 hours a day. Why post things like this that aren't factual and seem designed to make people feel disheartened? It's perfectly possible to lose weight without additional exercise.

Where did I say 3 hours? 2 hours is the standard sort of mid way point for 10,000 steps and it could be done through out the day. Walk to work and back but add an extra 10 mins both ways half an hour at lunch and then a walk after work.
Personally think its really important to increase exercise if losing weight to build up muscle and be more toned.

TheSilkWorm · 10/11/2024 06:51

Moonlightstars · 10/11/2024 06:38

Definitely need to do more. At least 2 hours I would say to lose weight and hour to maintain.

Weight loss is not created by exercise. And very few people have the time to walk 3 hours a day. Why post things like this that aren't factual and seem designed to make people feel disheartened? It's perfectly possible to lose weight without additional exercise.