Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My Partner Does not Remeber Childhood

110 replies

Peach0123 · 09/11/2024 00:15

Hi,

I am looking for some opinions on this situation and also some advice .

My partner and I have been together for 6 years, very happy and have 1DS. During the whole time we have been together he has never chatted about childhood, his teenage years, or now noticing any recent times.

Things come up whether watching TV, out with our DS or just in general conversation where I'll say " yeah I remember doing so amd so as a kid" or talking about teenage years, what posters were on my wall . What friends I had and how we drifted, you get where going with this. My partner has absolutely no memory of his years whatsoever. 2 memories, which are the exact same MIL talks of every single time and there's no space to ask questions there or would be first person I'd ask, he would have been about 5 then.

So there's no drip feed- I do feel he keeps alot to himself. A few months ago, went to an event and met really key people, had photos with them, he would have been buzzing with excitement. Came home and I had no idea until seeing his camera roll a few days ago he had photos with them. He told no one at all. This was a big deal for him but was brushed away like nothing.

I am so open with him and always have been, it feeling like opeing up whenever needed is not right.

I have tried to speak to him at various different times about things then felt better to stop getting nowhere to help.

stuck now, do I help. If so how?

AIBU to think 6 years I should be treated like a stranger.

OP posts:
lunar1 · 09/11/2024 02:23

I have very big gaps in my childhood memory, it's for the best, the ones I do have aren't something I'd wish on anyone.

I've been with my husband a lot longer than 6 years, and he'd never pressure me over it.

Bankholidayhelp · 09/11/2024 01:57

Like pp I have virtually no memories of my childhood. My sister can remember absolutely everything from being about 18 months old. No trauma.. Normal childhood really.

Threesacrow · 09/11/2024 01:57

Does he have any friends, cousins, other family members? Getting together with them might start to unblock his memory. It's an increasing problem; when families grew up and stayed in the same area, they used to constantly talk together about their history and memories. Comparing memories led to shared and enhanced memories. They are important, because they shape who we are and strengthen bonds. Does he get anxious or annoyed when you ask him about his past? Hypnotherapy may help him if he's willing to give it a go.

TheDeepLemonHelper · 09/11/2024 01:47

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

welshmuma · 09/11/2024 01:40

My mind unfortunately went straight to childhood SA , hopefully this isn't the case but it's a definite real possibility.
You say "he says he had a good childhood" because that's what everyone's supposed to say, if you can't remember but it's supposed to be a certain way you just fill in the blanks and say ah yes that was it.
The problem is with trauma response, you physically cannot make yourself remember (without help) because your system is blocking those memories completely from your mind.

I do hope this is not the case and it's a simple case of bad memory ect , I do understand it must be frustrating for you to feel like you don't know much about your partner but maybe give it more time and exploration, I'd avoid trying to force the issue incase it is a situation like the above and you lock a whole load of memories and feelings that you aren't equipped to deal with.

Take Care xx

TempestTost · 09/11/2024 01:34

This isn't that uncommon, quite a few people have very limited memories of their childhood.

MarkingBad · 09/11/2024 01:29

I know someone who almost never talks about anything past even if he is reminded, he'll just shrug his shoulders. It's not that he forgot he tells me, it's just no longer important now it isn't happening. You couldn't get it out of him with an oyster knife.

MrsSkylerWhite · 09/11/2024 01:27

My childhood was horrific. I remember some of the horrors but very little else, which I think is deliberate. My brain stepped in to block a lot out.

I very much doubt that he did have a happy childhood.

Threeboystwocatsandadog · 09/11/2024 01:27

I have very few memories of my childhood and my teenaged years are patchy. There are even bits as an adult that I can’t really recall. My granny died when I was 7. She was living with us for several years before she died yet I have no memory of her at all. I didn’t even realise this was strange until my younger sister (by 2.5 years) told me she remembered her well. My ddad died when I was 21. I can recall certain events or conversations we had but very few. I can’t picture him in my head at all. When I try I see him as he is in photos I have but not in real life. I was a real daddy’s girl and had a happy childhood. I have also made 5 return flights to various countries and yet I can recall hardly anything about the airports, boarding, being on the plane or landing.

I only discovered a few years ago that this is actually a “thing”. A couple on the adoption board were not being approved to adopt as the husband couldn’t recall a lot of things from his childhood and it was thought that he had suffered abuse and they wanted him to have therapy despite his insistence he had a very happy childhood. Other people posted saying that they had similar.

Peach0123 · 09/11/2024 01:26

VegTrug · 09/11/2024 01:22

He’s pulling the wool over your eyes of course he has memories! He’s just not fully committed and not sharing anything with you. I’d beware if I was you

While I don't totally agree with you, its what I've been thinking in order to post here.and ask for opinions x

OP posts:
Teanbiscuits33 · 09/11/2024 01:24

Peach0123 · 09/11/2024 00:25

This was my first thought throughout the time we have been together, but he says he had a happy childhood. Just can't remember.

This is why I'm worried to be honest.

How does he know it was happy if he can’t remember anything about it? I don’t have a lot of recollection of when I was very young, really. My childhood memories are patchy, but I remember significant events, just not always the order in which they occurred. I think that’s normal? But to have no memories at all, he probably had significant trauma and is telling himself it was happy. It happens.

Peach0123 · 09/11/2024 01:23

iamnotperfect · 09/11/2024 01:08

I don't remember my childhood - always thought I had a great one. Very luckily I ended up in therapy but took a long time to realise why I was really there. Not having access to the memories is potentially a protection from something - and likely not within his conscious control. Look up complex ptsd. May not apply to him but I'll tell you a little more in case it helps...

Some of my other symptoms include hypervigilance, over explaining, never feeling like I matter, binge eating, triggered in unexpected ways, depression and anxiety. I never really realised most of these things (weren't normal) - they were just my normal. I was really starting to struggle more with the food and low mood when I eventually sought help.

If it is something like that for him - I think he does need to find a way to recognise it in himself which is very difficult to do when your brain and body is working so hard to protect you from it (but really (as an adult) doing more damage than good now).

I hope he can find a way to get help.

I really hope your getting there now 💙
This is happening x

OP posts:
VegTrug · 09/11/2024 01:22

He’s pulling the wool over your eyes of course he has memories! He’s just not fully committed and not sharing anything with you. I’d beware if I was you

Peach0123 · 09/11/2024 01:19

Thanks for the responses, there's probably alot to be dealt with here but feels like none of my business, when it should be. It's hard to have a relationship when the boundaries are so strict. Totally respect him but finding it hard when a basic conversation is shut down. Even his opinion on things is just a yes or no, literally everything. Surley he's been allowed his own opinion before 30 yrs old. No discussions on anything, it's very strange now putting it here tbh.
This is over 6 years, no way putting pressure on. Although my post here is to see if I should. Definitely won't 💙

OP posts:
zeddybrek · 09/11/2024 01:16

I don't remember much from my childhood and don't recall any abuse. It really bothers me sometimes but then I am becoming quite forgetful as an adult so guessing having a good memory is not my thing .

iamnotperfect · 09/11/2024 01:12

I forgot to mention dissociation - in certain situations (and I'm still trying to figure out exactly what those are and are not) I dissociate and something happens to my memory which means I don't remember them after - I can't actually nearly feel my brain clouding over...it is incredibly frustrating and definitely linked to stressful situations of some sort.

buffyspikefaith · 09/11/2024 01:09

I remember very little of my childhood to the point I thought I went to one school when I didn't
Nothing from before age 11 really except for odd bits. Don't remember any of my teachers or stuff like that

iamnotperfect · 09/11/2024 01:08

I don't remember my childhood - always thought I had a great one. Very luckily I ended up in therapy but took a long time to realise why I was really there. Not having access to the memories is potentially a protection from something - and likely not within his conscious control. Look up complex ptsd. May not apply to him but I'll tell you a little more in case it helps...

Some of my other symptoms include hypervigilance, over explaining, never feeling like I matter, binge eating, triggered in unexpected ways, depression and anxiety. I never really realised most of these things (weren't normal) - they were just my normal. I was really starting to struggle more with the food and low mood when I eventually sought help.

If it is something like that for him - I think he does need to find a way to recognise it in himself which is very difficult to do when your brain and body is working so hard to protect you from it (but really (as an adult) doing more damage than good now).

I hope he can find a way to get help.

mrsfollowill · 09/11/2024 00:57

My sister has no memory prior to being around 10. I remember everything including a photo of me being at 6 months old. We both had the same childhood- v happy and secure- same mum and dad who were together throughout and in a happy marriage until dad died in our 20's. Weird I know more about her childhood than she did! Loads of photos I remember - going abroad on holiday to Spain aged 5 & 6 and we both learned to swim. No recollection from her at all- seems weird to me with all my memories - we are lucky as had a great childhood and have continued this into middle age. Oh and she does remember from her teens onwards - just the early years.

Garlicpest · 09/11/2024 00:49

A traumatic childhood wouldn't really explain why he didn't even mention his photos from the recent event, though, would it?

Sounds like, whatever diagnoses you may choose to apply, you are married to a secretive very private person. You might be able to get him to loosen up a little but, ime, such individuals will always keep their experiences strictly compartmentalised.

username7891 · 09/11/2024 00:46

Peach0123 · 09/11/2024 00:41

Yes before 10 and also after. No teenage memories apparently or up to the day we met is the way things seem, he's in 30s.

Sounds like Memento. I don't think he can't remember, I think he CBA to tell you anything about himself.

DuckBee · 09/11/2024 00:45

I’m an oddity in that I have compartmentalise my life and don’t really remember things in different sections and I wouldn’t talk about meeting a celebrity for example as it’s just not in my nature. I didn’t have an abusive childhood I’ve just moved onto the next phase of my life.

Maybe you just need accept him for who is and not look for problems? By trying to drag something out of him you may do more harm.

Peach0123 · 09/11/2024 00:41

CocoDC · 09/11/2024 00:27

When you say childhood what do you mean? It’s actually very normal for a happy well adjusted childhood before 10 to result in very few memories.

Yes before 10 and also after. No teenage memories apparently or up to the day we met is the way things seem, he's in 30s.

OP posts:
Adviceneeeeded · 09/11/2024 00:39

I have a lot of childhood trauma. (Not sexual abuse) but 3 dad's over the course of 12 years. Last one was the worst and mentally and physically abusive.

I only realised about a year ago that I had blocked about 90% of my childhood out! It's sad as I seem to be forgetting the good times too. I'm only 32 so it's not an age problem!

Peach0123 · 09/11/2024 00:38

MadnessIsMyMiddleName · 09/11/2024 00:22

I think from what you're saying OP, that maybe your DH is choosing not to remember his childhood for some reason, and other than occasionally speaking about your own childhood to see if he eventually starts to open up, that you are probably better off not trying to force the issue. It could be that he was sexually abused at a young age, and has therefore chosen to block out his childhood, but I really don't think it would be wise to try and push him on this. However if this was the case, then obviously if it should come out at some point, you need to be prepared to listen, and allow him to share as much, or as little of his story as he wants to, and then encourage him to seek counselling, if necessary.

Thanks, you and @ScaredAndPanicky have pretty much summed up what I have been thinking. At no point have I pushed too hard just asking, although I realy want to sometimes. He thinks I'm really strange for remembering childhood (mine was no pic nic, forster home etc). He won't speak to any professionals either as "there's no issues."

I don't want to shut down so to speak, but feel like it's going to end up that way. That wouldn't be right for me to do x

OP posts: