Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not even a card!!

89 replies

Abitmiffed1 · 08/11/2024 16:29

I recently got married and we had a gorgeous day with friends and family. My sister was matron of honour and her children were page boys. We didn’t ask for gifts as we are a bit older and have everything we need, however most of our guests were very generous and gave us cards/gifts/money etc. Everyone that is apart from my own sister - I was shocked to find that we didn’t even have a card from her and her family. My sister can be quite selfish at times and thinks the world revolves around her, however I feel this is another level - who doesn’t get their own sister a card on their wedding day? Every single other guest - even our evening guests came with a card. I thought maybe something had got lost so I messaged to ask her but she gave me some rubbish excuse about how she had accidentally taken it home with her and she would post it to us the next day - it has still not arrived. AIBU to be upset by this?

OP posts:
Diarygirlqueen · 09/11/2024 07:06

I can't believe some of these responses! Of course you're upset your sister didn't get you a card, especially after paying for everything. You're also entitled to be upset. Never have I been to a wedding where I didn't bring a card or a present, it's bad manners. She sounds jealous.

Annabellouise · 09/11/2024 07:02

Genuinely some people just don’t think! I’ve noticed through the years, I give cards and presents when i think appropriate, I don’t expect back but there are times when it would’ve in my mind been appropriate, but some people just aren’t like that at all unfortunately. Funny thing is, some of them get upset if it’s done to them! Some don’t, which is fair enough and they also don’t expect. I guess everyone’s different.

MissTrip82 · 09/11/2024 06:55

I’ve never heard anyone say they would have been happy with a card whom I believed would, in fact, have been happy with a card.

I can’t belive you messaged to ask! How rude.

CatPlanet · 09/11/2024 06:55

How old is your sister in relation to you?

gedwards666 · 09/11/2024 06:50

YANBU! I can't believe how many people are against you on this. You're asking, in essence, if we would also feel aggrieved not to get a card. I would. I'd be mildly annoyed and would definitely grumble to other friends and family about it. I'm clearly not as grown up as all the other Mumsnetters who are above such petty trifles. After my wedding, we matched up a list of attendees with a list of gifts. There was one gift with no name so we didn't know who to thank. I had no card or anything from my best man so I thought it was from him. Very awkward when he had to say it wasn't, and he hadn't given anything, even a card! It's the absence of a card that gets me. Even my friend who was really struggling financially at the time brought a card his children had made. Very sweet! Some people, I think, are just more literal minded and less bothered. They say things like, "they know I love them; why do they need a card?" My sister never gets my dad a birthday card because of this logic. She thinks he doesn't care about cards. And she's right, he doesn't literally care about cards, but he does care that the only name missing from the mantelpiece is hers.

BlastedPimples · 09/11/2024 06:47

It is normal to give a gift usually accompanied by a card.

The op has been very generous from the sounds of things.

A small token like a card to wish someone well is a lovely gesture and also a standard gesture

Perhaps the op intended to keep all the cards.

However, if your sister is often thoughtless like this, op, then I would simply reign in any spending on her. Sounds like you've spent a lot already.

How is your relationship normally??

Secradonugh · 09/11/2024 06:42

Storybot · 08/11/2024 23:37

I think you're being ridiculous. So glad I eloped if this is the fucking nonsense that weddings being about

My wedding was only us and 2 witnesses (and a foetus... cough) . The party we did a few weeks later, was our celebration for friends and family (where we also announced 4 months pregnant (alteady told parents and close family)). We paid for it all, we housed people in our houses. We refused presents or gifts. We just said if you want particular drinks then bring your own. So much better than making expectations on people. Low key everyone enjoyed themselves, my advice to all is never expect, nor set high goals for a wedding.

WhyamIinahandcartandwherearewegoing · 09/11/2024 06:20

Hillrunning · 08/11/2024 20:29

I wouldn't expect a card from a sister or any of my immediate family for my wedding and I'm 100% I didn't get any from my 4 sisters or 2 brothers. I'd actually think it odd. Cards for my wedding is what people who don't know me well would give.

Totally agree here. I wouldn’t expect anything from the matron of honour. Showing up and supporting me would be gift enough.

mum11970 · 09/11/2024 06:14

Crikey I only had a small wedding of less than 20 and I don’t know if I got a card off everyone, really wasn’t something I thought to check

Artistbythewater · 09/11/2024 06:06

Amyknows · 09/11/2024 05:22

This, op is being pathetic about a silly card when her sister was right there being a huge part of the day. In my culture we give little gifts to the guests for attending as a gesture of thanks and appreciation.
Op sounds like she wants to control her sister.

In our culture it is absolutely standard to bring a card and gift for the happy couple. Quite unthinkable not to do so.

Artistbythewater · 09/11/2024 06:04

I would have to ask her op.

‘Sister, we have just enjoyed reading through our cards and I am just checking whether you gave a card or gift to us? As I haven’t seen one and I am worried it has been lost’

It is possible it is lost. It is possible she xent something that didn’t turn up, but if she didn’t send anything at all - not even a card that needs to be flushed out op. And discussed. You could be honest that it has hurt your feelings.

Amyknows · 09/11/2024 05:22

Storybot · 08/11/2024 23:37

I think you're being ridiculous. So glad I eloped if this is the fucking nonsense that weddings being about

This, op is being pathetic about a silly card when her sister was right there being a huge part of the day. In my culture we give little gifts to the guests for attending as a gesture of thanks and appreciation.
Op sounds like she wants to control her sister.

Amyknows · 09/11/2024 05:17

She's your sister, why do you need a card from her? What difference would it make in your life for receiving a card? Sounds like you want some control here.
She was MOh, her kids were part of your wedding and you're scrounging around for a card? That sounds really petty on your part.

gillefc82 · 09/11/2024 05:11

We got married in Greece, less than 30 people altogether (immediate family and a few close friends) and everyone basically made the trip into their summer holiday. Given the costs involved, we told everyone not to get us any gifts. Many did anyway, ranging from personalised champagne flutes to monetary gifts of a few hundred pounds. One of my DB didn’t get us a card nor a present, whilst the other did both. One of my BILs gave a card and gift, the other also gave neither.

Would it have been nice to have had a card from my brother and brother in law as a keepsake from the day? Well, yes probably (I have actually kept all of the cards we received as it’s nice to read through them occasionally - some of the messages were really lovely). But in the grand scheme of things it’s insignificant. It hasn’t changed my relationship with either of them and ultimately I’m just grateful that they went to the time, effort and expense to be a part of our special day (and the hen/stag dos in the lead up), which is far more important and meaningful to me.

OCDMUMMA24 · 09/11/2024 02:52

I actually have my bridal party gifts. Also the last thing I was concerned with after my wedding was who didn't and didn't give a gift or card

Nclow · 09/11/2024 01:56

OP I think you're using the card (or lack thereof) as a proxy for something. Your sister was there on your day and therefore presumably did spend time, effort and attention on you. So what is still lacking for you in your relationship with her that the failure to send a card represents? I say this kindly. Introspect and try to work out what symbolism the card has for you, and therefore what exactly she has failed to do for you that is represented by the card. It could be money, general consistent care or attention, thoughtfulness, etc. I think you need to work out what this card is standing for, for you.

Proudestmumofone1 · 09/11/2024 00:16

We are always extremely generous with gifts for weddings, birthdays, Xmas etc.

However I don’t think I got my brother or SIL cards or presents when they got married. Not out of lack of care - we speak constantly, they know how happy I am/was for them and there was nothing that a card would symbolise that my joy at the occasion didn’t.

Equally don’t think we received cards / gifts from them, or bridesmaids.

StarSlinger · 08/11/2024 23:54

Screamingabdabz · 08/11/2024 23:37

You’re not being unreasonable op. At all. The idea that your own sister couldn’t be arsed to go and get a card and write a few nice words on it is inexcusable. Some people are utterly selfish. And I can’t believe the snarky comments on here, maybe they are the same thoughtless and lazy ilk.

Maybe some people don't give a fuck about getting cards.

Screamingabdabz · 08/11/2024 23:37

You’re not being unreasonable op. At all. The idea that your own sister couldn’t be arsed to go and get a card and write a few nice words on it is inexcusable. Some people are utterly selfish. And I can’t believe the snarky comments on here, maybe they are the same thoughtless and lazy ilk.

Storybot · 08/11/2024 23:37

I think you're being ridiculous. So glad I eloped if this is the fucking nonsense that weddings being about

GoldenSunflowers · 08/11/2024 23:28

Am I the only one confused here? When you say a card do you actually mean money? Is that it?

SilverChampagne · 08/11/2024 20:44

StarSlinger · 08/11/2024 20:43

If your sister got wind you were being petty and slagging her off on the internet for not buying you a wedding card.Your relationship might be over.

Quite…

StarSlinger · 08/11/2024 20:43

If your sister got wind you were being petty and slagging her off on the internet for not buying you a wedding card.Your relationship might be over.

Abitmiffed1 · 08/11/2024 20:40

SilverChampagne · 08/11/2024 20:30

No, I’m not any of your other guests either.
Not sure what’s so hilarious about being this grabby, tbh?

oh lighten up! I seem to have hit a nerve that’s all. Not at all being grabby, I just think it’s bad manners and making light of it - I’m sure mine and my sisters relationship is not over because of it!

OP posts:
MumChp · 08/11/2024 20:35

First-world problem...