Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think primary schools now days are more misogynistic amongst the boys, than in the past?

161 replies

Thatcastlethere · 07/11/2024 19:23

I hate to be all 'back in the good old days' and tbh I don't even think it was that great in the past... I think I just expected it to be better now days.
But am I wrong for feeling like there's been a massive upsurge in misogynistic feeling amongst primary age boys?
My two eldest are at primary school. It's a state school but it's regarded as a good school in a very middle class area. It's also considered a faintly hippy/alternative place.
Yet some of the things I've seen and heard regarding my 9yo son and my 6yo daughters experiences at school have really shocked me.
My son for example uses all this language 'sigma' 'alpha' etc... well he did until I explained to him that it was harmful macho nonsense. He's also asked me about andrew tate and trump etc as these people seem to be hero's for some of his male friends. These boys are 9!!
My son doesn't have unsupervised access to the Internet. And the access he does have is limited to one hour on his tablet in the living room on weekend days. During which he just plays roblox and Minecraft. We have disabled YouTube from the TV and he is not allowed YouTube on his tablet.. yet he still seems to come across endless misogynistic content at school somehow.
My son is a sweet boy imo and he forms his own opinions.. he was telling me how he disliked andrew tate for example, without me even having said anything
So it's not that I'm worried about him absorbing these ideas.. it's just a bit concerning that it's so prevalent!
I've also overheard some of his friends in the park sating horrific things about girls and women. Once I even heard one of them threatening to punch a girl. I did step in at this and told him it was disgusting and the boy did look faintly ashamed at least.
Has anyone else noticed this?
Also my 6yo has been subject to comments on her appearance by boys! Already at 6!
I'm sure it wasn't quite this bad wen I was at school or perhaps I just didn't notice?
My husband is a fair bit older than me and was also remarking that he never knew anything like this at school..
Altho obviously misogyny was alive and well when we were kids.. you just never really heard this so directly

OP posts:
OneBlackHeart · 07/11/2024 23:46

Whingewithme · 07/11/2024 22:07

At my children’s primary school there’s a rhyme the boys proudly chant -

Boys are strong, like King Kong
Girls are weak, throw them in the creek

This is from reception age. No idea where it’s come from. It deeply disturbs me.

They sing that at my dd school. She was constantly telling me how horrible the boys are to the girls. I raise it with the teacher to be told she can't be everywhere she knows the boys are like that but there really is nothing she can do!

There were other contributing factors but this was a part of my decision to home educate. My dd is absolutely much happier in herself now I hadn't realised how bad her mental health was due to school I just thought I had a whiny child

TempsPerdu · 07/11/2024 23:44

I find this whole debate fascinating and depressing in equal measure. I have a sort of academic interest in it, as a teacher and having studied a lot of gender and childhood-related topics as part of an MA a few years ago, but also more recently a personal interest as parent to a 6-year-old DD.

In part the current issues surrounding boys and young men undoubtedly stem from access to porn and excessive internet use. But the conditioning runs far deeper than that and starts much earlier. Parenting has changed dramatically since my own childhood; as a primary teacher a decade or so ago I was surprised at how gender stereotypes were becoming more rather than less ingrained among the small children I was teaching - clothing was coded pink or blue; Disney princesses for girls were everywhere and I had several worried Dads at parents' evening fretting that their sons would never be 'proper men' because they disliked football and enjoyed Lego and drawing. At the time online campaigns like 'Pink Stinks' and 'Let Toys Be Toys' were sounding the alarm about this stuff, but their concerns sound really pretty quaint now. I remember at the time there was also a spate of TV documentaries about how gender stereotypes played out in parenting/educatjon, so it was clearly part of the zeitgeist.

Roll on a few years, and by the time my own daughter was born the gender conditioning had ramped up considerably, starting with the gender reveal party trend and progressing through to highly stereotyped birthday parties (dinosaurs, football and Pokémon for boys; princesses, mermaids and unicorns for girls) and separate preschool activities for boys (football) and ballet (girls) - for four years now my daughter has been the lone girl in her Saturday football class, and we're in supposedly liberal north London.

While it was a fairly standard thing, when I was teaching, for at least a few of the boys in my classes to prefer to play with the girls, in my DD's school the sexes have been strictly delineated from the outset and exist almost in two separate bubbles, seldom interacting. 'Boys will be boys' prevails, and lazy gender stereotypes about boys being better at maths and girls being more docile are thrown about constantly by parents. It's all incredibly different from my own experience of growing up in the '80s and '90s, and it feels like we've regressed in a lot of ways.

I spend a lot of time working with children at the upper end of the primary age range, and can confirm several PP's reports of boys making sexual noises and porn/Andrew Tate-related 'banter' even in Year 6. The upshot of all of this is that we've decided we'll be sending DD to a girls' school for secondary.

CCreasty · 07/11/2024 23:03

Combattingthemoaners · 07/11/2024 22:53

Conservative views of women? In what way?

No, with the exception that he thinks women are bad drivers. Conservative as is in greed is good. The problems of other countries aren’t our problems. Not views learnt from me.

I’m a financially successful and independent woman who mostly raised him solo from the age of 10. But I am a shockingly bad driver.

Combattingthemoaners · 07/11/2024 22:53

CCreasty · 07/11/2024 22:44

Conservative accurately describes my 22yo son. Not like me, he has his own mind.

Conservative views of women? In what way?

TheYearOfSmallThings · 07/11/2024 22:52

Mlanket · 07/11/2024 22:27

*At my children’s primary school there’s a rhyme the boys proudly chant -
Boys are strong, like King Kong
Girls are weak, throw them in the creek
This is from reception age. No idea where it’s come from. It deeply disturbs me.

We used to say GIrls win, boys in the bin. Its normal for boys and girls to dislike each other at some points in primary.

I don't know if it depends on the schools but my son's school is light years more right-on and the children less savage than when I was a child. It is true that they sing "Seven, eight, Andrew Tate" but I am sorry to say we used to sing pro IRA versions of hymns because we found it funny. Children are stupid and pick up snippets of culture they don't fully understand.

It is not that I think we live in an idyll but it is easy to forget that the past wasn't always great either.

CCreasty · 07/11/2024 22:44

fitzwilliamdarcy · 07/11/2024 19:37

There are concerns that gen z men are much more conservative than millennial men, and it wouldn’t surprise me if that trend continues to gen alpha. It’s supposedly also one of the reasons why Trump got re-elected - a big vote share in young men.

One of my friends teaches primary and she says that the way the boys talk is so sexual, despite them being so young, and the girls are targets of aggressive sexist bullying. She says it scares the life out of her for what the future will be like.

It doesn’t surprise me though. The rise of feminism was always going to produce a massive backlash from men, and boys get drawn into it early.

Conservative accurately describes my 22yo son. Not like me, he has his own mind.

Lelophants · 07/11/2024 22:34

Threeandahalf · 07/11/2024 22:31

Bluey episode

seriously? I’m guessing this ends better!

Lelophants · 07/11/2024 22:34

The internet. 🤢

Although society is generally more educated and less sexist in lots of ways, horrendous stuff is creeping through. How depressing. Hopefully you can have open conversations with your children about this all.
Also it’s always sort of cool to say things your parents obviously hate so some of these kids may be trying to be ‘different’.

Threeandahalf · 07/11/2024 22:31

Whingewithme · 07/11/2024 22:07

At my children’s primary school there’s a rhyme the boys proudly chant -

Boys are strong, like King Kong
Girls are weak, throw them in the creek

This is from reception age. No idea where it’s come from. It deeply disturbs me.

Bluey episode

Mlanket · 07/11/2024 22:27

*At my children’s primary school there’s a rhyme the boys proudly chant -
Boys are strong, like King Kong
Girls are weak, throw them in the creek
This is from reception age. No idea where it’s come from. It deeply disturbs me.

We used to say GIrls win, boys in the bin. Its normal for boys and girls to dislike each other at some points in primary.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 07/11/2024 22:11

This is incredibly depressing as a boy mum

Screamingabdabz · 07/11/2024 22:09

“I'm just a bit fed up of the constant boy bashing on here to be frank.”

This is not personal. It’s a widely reported and worrying social phenomenon. Your child might be Perfect Peter now but at some point he’ll be breathing that toxic air. You need to take the blinkers off and be part of the resistance.

Whingewithme · 07/11/2024 22:07

At my children’s primary school there’s a rhyme the boys proudly chant -

Boys are strong, like King Kong
Girls are weak, throw them in the creek

This is from reception age. No idea where it’s come from. It deeply disturbs me.

Peopleinmyphone · 07/11/2024 22:04

My son is 8, year 3 and has no idea who Trump or Andrew Tate are. He just wants to run about at lunchtimes and watch spongebob when he gets home.

Luddite26 · 07/11/2024 21:42

Yes of course I discussed it and with school they thought I was loopy.
It's the fact that it's on the Oxford reading tree that annoyed me.
Things need updating.
Also demonising the character of Rumpelstiltskin is problematic but I was writing in the context of the thread.
I've always disliked traditional fairy tales.

Catza · 07/11/2024 21:32

Luddite26 · 07/11/2024 20:02

Rumpelstiltskin is an old fairy story.
My issue with it the father arranged for his daughter to marry the king because she can spin straw to gold and the language at the end of the story is the king let's his wife live in his castle.
It is such a horrible story which used to anger me 50 years ago as a child. But why the hell is it still part of the Oxford reading scheme used in schools.
It's got arranged marriage, elements of slavery and domestic abuse all normalised and the king then ALLOWS his wife to live in his castle. It makes me rage!

Do they discuss it at school? Do you discuss it at home? We did have to have a discussion about the beauty and the beast with our kid. Wouldn't ban her from watching it but I do encourage discussions about problematic story lines at home.

Snorlaxo · 07/11/2024 21:22

It’s alarming how quickly things change because of parents allowing unsupervised internet access.

My son was in primary school in 2016 and him and his friends would do Trump impressions about building a wall rather than the extreme misogynistic crap that some kids are watching today. In his day, it was very unusual for primary school kids to be doing stuff like vaping too.

Mlanket · 07/11/2024 21:15

You're completely right, sadly. But there's no doubt that this kind of misogynistic behaviour from rich men is a bit of a honey trap for lots of young men and my point really was that we should assume that could include our own sons. And make sure equally that our daughters don't start thinking it's acceptable or something they can turn a blind eye to!

But this is another element where I think it’s very confusing. My younger female colleagues are very different to myself (I’m a millennial) and older colleagues in terms of how they think eg a lot more gendered & old fashioned.

chumpt · 07/11/2024 21:10

fitzwilliamdarcy · 07/11/2024 20:27

I’m pretty sure those aren’t the only two options.

Hahaha ofc, just a joke.

Mlanket · 07/11/2024 21:09

@ThisZippyDenimGoose I think it’s so confusing for both sexes & there are real mixed messages. That’s a convo I’ve had a lot with my niece, she doesn’t like how the whole Onlyfans is a legitimate career choice but says she can’t say that as it’s shaming. She doesn’t want to send photos of herself to boys but again said she’s the odd one out.

Mlanket · 07/11/2024 21:05

@Mlanket I know but it’s so normalised. Some other older relatives were showing me their insta feed which had lots of photos of classmates posing suggestively in bikinis etc. my nephew said he felt uncomfortable liking the posts but that it would be seen as rude if he didn’t & my niece said she felt she had to like the photos too but didn’t want to as she felt it put pressure on her to be sexy & she doesn’t feel sexy or want to be sexy but that’s apparently bad. I had no idea what advice to give, thank god I grew up without it.

PuddlePeeps · 07/11/2024 21:05

Mlanket · 07/11/2024 20:59

We'd all be pretty naive to see how popular a man like Trump has been to young men in America and think that a significant number of young men over here won't also believe that they are being under represented and marginalised.

Hes popular with plenty of women….

You're completely right, sadly. But there's no doubt that this kind of misogynistic behaviour from rich men is a bit of a honey trap for lots of young men and my point really was that we should assume that could include our own sons. And make sure equally that our daughters don't start thinking it's acceptable or something they can turn a blind eye to!

ThisZippyDenimGoose · 07/11/2024 21:03

This is something we all need to be aware of. I listen to some quite out there stuff with Andrew Tate, Tommy Robinson, Jordan Peterson etc which my sons find equally shocking and hilarious as an almost 40 year old feminist but we need to hear what these people are saying and understand what about them is appealing to young men. We do ourselves a disservice by writing this stuff off and refusing to even try to understand because it’s out there and it’s striking chords. It’s difficult to be a man at the moment, young men don’t quite seem to know where to position themselves, mental health is poorer than ever and instead of looking to their fathers as previously, some of them are finding role models in some pretty divisive figures which won’t end well. I like to be able to talk to mine about this stuff openly and offer my views from the perspective of a woman they hopefully love and respect as opposed to just what they hear from their friends in school. Luckily their father is brilliant and we all have some interesting discussions.

StrumpersPlunkett · 07/11/2024 21:01

I agree with things being problematic at a young age for both boys and girls.
I teach in primary and the amount of children in year 3 talking about the things they watch on you tube and comments about fortnight games is awful.

The thing that got me last week was I over heard a child being incredibly unkind to another child whilst I was on playground duty. When challenged the year 2 child said... its all good we are just having a roast battle you know.... roasting each other. I said I wasn't interested in what they thought they were doing it was unpleasant and we don't use language like that in our school.

TooBigForMyBoots · 07/11/2024 21:00

Michelle12A · 07/11/2024 20:58

You clearly that you are against them supporting him… Nothing more controlling than that whatever their opinions may be.

What are you talking about?Confused