Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how I’m perceived as a bigger woman after the previous thread?

288 replies

Threecactusplants · 07/11/2024 10:25

After reading the previous thread about weight and how posters are always thinking about their weight (even when they are size 10 or 12!) which to me is crazy.
I used to be very slim as a child, in my teens and early 20s.
Since having my son I have ended up at a size 20/22. I am consistently that size and have been since he was born 6 years ago.
I don’t know exactly how much I weigh , but it’s around 16 stone and I’m 5’7.
I’m pretty comfortable with my weight, I don’t really think about it much. I don’t think I’m unattractive and I dress for my size. Lots of cord pinafore dresses, tights and boots are my go to. Also wide leg trousers, midi dresses and skirts. I have good boobs and a (big) bum 😂 I have a c section pouch which I’m not keen on, but that’s what comes with a 9lb baby I guess! My DH and I have great sex (sorry if TMI!)

After reading that thread, I’m wondering what people think of me when they see me around, for example I’m in a cafe now, having a coffee and a breakfast. It never bothered me before much; but after reading that thread I’m pretty taken aback!

OP posts:
Kerensa70 · 08/11/2024 17:50

I was looking at this lady in the waiting room of the doctors today. She was a big lady, really nicely dressed and accessories etc. Gorgeous hair and face/smile. I think it’s more about self care. I notice more if someone looks uncared for, bit scruffy. The lady I saw today was double my size but she honestly looked stunning. I guess health comes into too as you get older.

Snowflakeslayer · 08/11/2024 17:47

Threecactusplants · 07/11/2024 10:25

After reading the previous thread about weight and how posters are always thinking about their weight (even when they are size 10 or 12!) which to me is crazy.
I used to be very slim as a child, in my teens and early 20s.
Since having my son I have ended up at a size 20/22. I am consistently that size and have been since he was born 6 years ago.
I don’t know exactly how much I weigh , but it’s around 16 stone and I’m 5’7.
I’m pretty comfortable with my weight, I don’t really think about it much. I don’t think I’m unattractive and I dress for my size. Lots of cord pinafore dresses, tights and boots are my go to. Also wide leg trousers, midi dresses and skirts. I have good boobs and a (big) bum 😂 I have a c section pouch which I’m not keen on, but that’s what comes with a 9lb baby I guess! My DH and I have great sex (sorry if TMI!)

After reading that thread, I’m wondering what people think of me when they see me around, for example I’m in a cafe now, having a coffee and a breakfast. It never bothered me before much; but after reading that thread I’m pretty taken aback!

I would t judge anyone on their size, but from your description, and to answer your question, I would most certainly say you’re a ‘bigger woman’.
Fab and beautiful no doubt. But no denying that is a large size.

Wherethewildthingsfart · 08/11/2024 07:58

What was the other thread?

I might notice in the same way I might notice someone’s hair but wouldn’t care (nothing to do with me).

SharpOpalNewt · 08/11/2024 07:52

WhatASadLittleLifeJayne · 08/11/2024 07:30

To be fair that looks more like a foot and i could get in there and I’m an 18-20!

It's not a foot. It is eight inches at most. Even getting my work bag in wasn't easy. The car door obviously took up space also when it was open

WhatASadLittleLifeJayne · 08/11/2024 07:30

SharpOpalNewt · 07/11/2024 17:49

Yeah me too.

Also I just squeezed into my car (on the left) with a six inch gap. There were no other cars on either side when I parked (properly!) this morning. The passenger side was even worse. So I can't be that big. And I had a short fitted skirt on, it wasn't pretty but I made it! 😵

To be fair that looks more like a foot and i could get in there and I’m an 18-20!

GiddyRobin · 08/11/2024 01:01

Everyone is overweight. I don't think about it tbh, unless they're actively making themselves obvious. Which is their right - girls in crop tops and leggings that don't fit, etc. I can't not notice that.

It's normal. I'm a size 6 and have been for yonks but if I spent all my life judging others, I'd be bored. Are they happy? Good. That's all I'm arsed about. Most healthy minded people don't give a shit.

Disturbia81 · 07/11/2024 19:52

GhostCicada · 07/11/2024 10:29

I care about my own weight but I don't give a single thought to anyone elses.

This. Most of us judge ourselves by a high standard but not others. I honestly don't think anything when I see overweight people, it's so common now.

SharpOpalNewt · 07/11/2024 17:49

BleachedJumper · 07/11/2024 17:17

I notice slim women a lot more, like seeing a tall willowy woman wearing gym leggings and think ‘I wish I had her very slender legs!’

Generally I think the averagely overweight person is a bit invisible in public really, like electric pylons. I’m not paying any attention.

I think if someone looks uncomfortably large it can grab my attention briefly, if I think anything it’s probably something along the lines of ‘There but for the grace of god go I.’

Yeah me too.

Also I just squeezed into my car (on the left) with a six inch gap. There were no other cars on either side when I parked (properly!) this morning. The passenger side was even worse. So I can't be that big. And I had a short fitted skirt on, it wasn't pretty but I made it! 😵

To wonder how I’m perceived as a bigger woman after the previous thread?
buffyspikefaith · 07/11/2024 17:44

Ethylred · 07/11/2024 15:29

I have trouble believing those posters who claim not to notice other people's weight. Really? Human beings are social animals, noticing everything about other people is what we do.

I might notice but I wouldn't think anything about it

At an old job I walked in on some colleagues watching a soap. Every sentence was
"God she looks awful"
"Hasn't she aged"
"That top is rank"
"No wonder he ditched her"

I made a decision then I didn't want to be that person so every time I start to think something negative about someone I force myself to change it to a compliment in my head

Now all my thoughts are neutral or positive because I didn't want to give headspace to so much negativity about people I don't even know when there's better things I can do with my time

Londontown12 · 07/11/2024 17:39

GhostCicada · 07/11/2024 10:29

I care about my own weight but I don't give a single thought to anyone elses.

I’m the same !! And think most people are tbh !
we are our own worst critics!!!

CheezePleeze · 07/11/2024 17:33

Comedycook · 07/11/2024 10:30

I thought the same thing after that thread too op. Thin women with low bmis saying how they thought they were too fat....I did wonder what they must think of women who are actually overweight

Why do people always wonder this?

I'm slim with a healthy BMI and a flabby menopausal stomach.

Even before I hit my mid fifties and my stomach went to pot, I never 'thought' anything about people who were fatter or slimmer than me.

I think you'll find most people are too busy with their own lives to care about strangers bodies.

Saschka · 07/11/2024 17:29

BadSkiingMum · 07/11/2024 12:06

I have, thankfully, never really had body hang-ups and rarely weighed myself so it took me years to actually notice that I was overweight and even longer to want to do anything about it! But I am (BMI 26.5) so I have begun calorie counting for health reasons.

But it's still not really appearance-related - I am far more bothered about other parts of life - this is just my outer casing!

So much is socially determined - where do you stop dieting? The camera adds pounds and I suspect that many women in the public eye who are deemed to be 'slim' are actually quite underweight. I find this photo interesting - click on it to see the BMIs. At 70kg a woman has to be taller than 5'8" to look 'slim', even though several of the women are within healthy BMI.

Edited

And the interesting thing about that photo is that even the two women who are the same height, weight and BMI look very different in terms of body fat.

Maria1979 · 07/11/2024 17:22

@Threecactusplants I love being around "bigger" women who feel secure in their bodies. I can't explain why. It has nothing to do with me feeling skinnier in comparaison, I'm happy with my weight and wouldn't like to loose or gain. I remember at nursery as a small child, there was one "bigger" woman and I always went to her when I was sad. It was something recomforting with her softness I think and still today I much prefer hugging my "bigger" friends than the skinny ones. But it's really weird so I wouldn't dream of saying this out load.

Fluffywalrus · 07/11/2024 17:20

Spinet · 07/11/2024 16:57

And driving and living in the city are different in that driving and residing are actions, where 'being' is a state, but they are related in that all of them are statistically more likely to result in your harm/ earlier life expectancy for reasons of safety and health. HT also H.

You're speaking in riddles to me. What the hell is HTH??

You can talk about actions vs 'being' all you want. Driving and living in a city are different to being overweight first and foremost because they have essentially no impact on your health or life expectancy.

Quick Google says UK adults have a 0.0023% chance of dying in a car accident.

Obesity will lower your life expectancy by an average of 3-10 years (NHS website).

Not comparable in the slightest.

BleachedJumper · 07/11/2024 17:17

I notice slim women a lot more, like seeing a tall willowy woman wearing gym leggings and think ‘I wish I had her very slender legs!’

Generally I think the averagely overweight person is a bit invisible in public really, like electric pylons. I’m not paying any attention.

I think if someone looks uncomfortably large it can grab my attention briefly, if I think anything it’s probably something along the lines of ‘There but for the grace of god go I.’

CheezePleeze · 07/11/2024 17:15

After reading that thread, I’m wondering what people think of me when they see me around, for example I’m in a cafe now, having a coffee and a breakfast. It never bothered me before much; but after reading that thread I’m pretty taken aback!

If you're in the UK, 63% of the population are overweight.

So why would they think anything particularly? 😳

applepipshake · 07/11/2024 17:13

WhatASadLittleLifeJayne · 07/11/2024 17:07

I am glad to hear that and genuinely can’t comprehend it - I guess that’s what happens when you’re aware of your weight from being tiny!

I do get that and I am sad that people are dwelling on it so much that its causing them distress.

I am extremely inward focused I suppose, but in general, I think people dont think about others as much as we think they do.

SharpOpalNewt · 07/11/2024 17:10

I'm about 13 stone and 5'7", size 14 at the most though and fit and muscular. I don't look big compared to most people in the UK. I think of myself as a strong solid person.

WhatASadLittleLifeJayne · 07/11/2024 17:07

applepipshake · 07/11/2024 17:05

People don't care what other people look like, they literally aren't thinking about you

Yes, this is my feeling too. I am very aware of my own weight because I want my clothes to fit well etc but I dont care about others' weight.

As for the people scoffing saying we do all think about other people's weights, no, we dont lol. I might notice someone overweight in the same way I notice a car driving down the road or other general things going on around me as I go about my day but it doesn't go further than noticing it. Thats literally it. I really am that self absorbed in my own stuff that I dont dwell on what other people look like or think about it. I would only pay attention to it if someone specifically told me they were unhappy with their weight and started a conversation about it.

I am glad to hear that and genuinely can’t comprehend it - I guess that’s what happens when you’re aware of your weight from being tiny!

applepipshake · 07/11/2024 17:05

People don't care what other people look like, they literally aren't thinking about you

Yes, this is my feeling too. I am very aware of my own weight because I want my clothes to fit well etc but I dont care about others' weight.

As for the people scoffing saying we do all think about other people's weights, no, we dont lol. I might notice someone overweight in the same way I notice a car driving down the road or other general things going on around me as I go about my day but it doesn't go further than noticing it. Thats literally it. I really am that self absorbed in my own stuff that I dont dwell on what other people look like or think about it. I would only pay attention to it if someone specifically told me they were unhappy with their weight and started a conversation about it.

WhatASadLittleLifeJayne · 07/11/2024 17:01

Yepyepyepducky · 07/11/2024 16:46

I disagree, ppl comment on my size regularly
You're pretty for a fat lass
Big bird
You'd be prettier if you lost weight
Your too fat for short hair
Fatttttyyyyyyyyy ( shouted from a vehicle)
Longer hair would look better
Fat twat/bitch/c*nt
Move you lump ( in the supermarket)
Are you so fat you can't walk ? ( I use a mobility scooter)
Who ate all the pies? ( Ordering a black coffee in a cafe)
A guy at the gym walked behind me making sound effects
( Not all the comments have been from men)

Edited

God yep, ‘you’ve got a pretty face (for a fat lass)’

Or, ‘bubbly’. Show me a time a thin woman has been described as bubbly….!

Spinet · 07/11/2024 16:57

Fluffywalrus · 07/11/2024 16:49

How was the poster making a moral judgement? 🤔

How are driving or living in a city the same health-wise as being obese?

It's not following the current crowd tbh, people were MUCH more judgemental about people being overweight in previous decades because it was unusual and less accepted.

And driving and living in the city are different in that driving and residing are actions, where 'being' is a state, but they are related in that all of them are statistically more likely to result in your harm/ earlier life expectancy for reasons of safety and health. HT also H.

jwnib · 07/11/2024 16:57

So you slim women I guess are just going by how you feel within yourself rather than compared to others, as you’re not noticing others? Interesting. God every time I see someone I notice their body shape and compare myself.

I'm slim and constantly look at others and compare (negatively and positively). Some of these posts come across a bit "I don't see colour, I just see the person".

mathanxiety · 07/11/2024 16:57

User54614664 · 07/11/2024 13:26

In video games there's a concept of NPCS (non-playable characters) who are generic characters in the background or with whom you might have a short but insignificant interaction. My belief is that most people are perceived as NPCs, with the exception of both ends of the spectrum.

As a woman, it makes zero difference if you're slightly overweight or fairly overweight. The vast majority of strangers see you as an NPC. An average person you meet in everyday life. They will not judge you more negatively because you are a size 20 rather than a size 16.

Women with EDs or weight obsessions will obviously notice other people's weight far more acutely. However this might not count as average perception since everyone has selective attention for certain things. Men especially only really notice the extremely young and slim end of the spectrum...think size 6, 20-something year olds. If that's not you, then there's no real point in splitting hairs about how a certain size might be perceived relative to another size, if all of these sizes are in the average or overweight category.

That's a really interesting take.

I am late 50s and decided to set my gray hair free a couple of years ago. I am pretty much invisible to men and women alike. It's very liberating.

The woman with an ED that I know never stops commenting on other people's shape and size, and fretting about her backside. She believes everyone is looking at her with the same critical eye that she uses on others.

Spinet · 07/11/2024 16:55

Fluffywalrus · 07/11/2024 16:49

How was the poster making a moral judgement? 🤔

How are driving or living in a city the same health-wise as being obese?

It's not following the current crowd tbh, people were MUCH more judgemental about people being overweight in previous decades because it was unusual and less accepted.

She was making a judgement that somebody isn't 'willing to do something' - so both that they are behaving in a particular way and that they could behave differently but choose not to. She is disapproving about this = a moral jusdgement. Hth.