Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Clarks shoe fiasco

142 replies

ApolloRain · 05/11/2024 13:01

I just went into Clarks as the sole had begun to come away from the front of my daughter’s school shoes. I purchased them late Aug and obvs she didn’t start wearing them until term began. Well I just be naive because I expected them to be really helpful, I have only ever bought them Clarks for school and never had another other than great service and shoes. Well the lady was vile! She said I hadn’t looked after them and it’s normal wear and tear, she was referring to the bottom being dirty and inside where the sole had come away having some dust inside. It is her first year of secondary so not running around on a playground and school is a short walk away. I said as much and that they had been properly polished weekly and have never had issues before. She was really rude and in front of my 11year old, I am truly baffled. I said they have been worn for 35 days total, surely for £50 they shouldn’t fall apart after that? However she totally disagreed. I went in fully thinking it would be a helpful/polite process as it was when I made the purchase and have walked out utterly shocked?

Clarks shoe fiasco
OP posts:
ApolloRain · 05/11/2024 13:35

SparklyEyes1 · 05/11/2024 13:28

We have these and have taken two pairs back exactly for this reason - one after 4 weeks and one after 6. The shop manager simply replaced them. I assume they know it's an issue. Unfortunately, my daughter's school has a narrow list of acceptable footwear and these are the only ones she can comfortably wear.

How interesting, they clearly aren’t upto much then. Have the latest pair done it?

OP posts:
Isobel201 · 05/11/2024 13:34

that's not right, the sole should last for ages, at least a few years.

NeedToGetOutOfThisSomehow · 05/11/2024 13:33

Dd trashed through Clarks in a month.
Geox or start rite now..never have a problem with them

ApolloRain · 05/11/2024 13:33

Thanks for all other brand recommendations. I definitely will write a complaint. I agree, if they were cheaper shoes I would have just bought new ones, maybe not after 35 days used though as that is rubbish for any shoe isn’t it. But for one of the market leaders in children’s shoes you would expect better. She didn’t give me a new receipt or have me sign anything, just chucked the box in my direction. All of this in front of my 11 year old aswell so even more annoyed. I feel like the quality of so many items has got progressively worse and we are just expected to accept that so I am glad people agree it’s unacceptable. I am going to call/email as even though I have new shoes, Its put me off going back, if it’s a fault with the shoe guessing it could happen again.

OP posts:
CocoDC · 05/11/2024 13:32

Buy from the Clarks Outlet Store (there’s a website). I rarely spend over £15 on DD’s shoes by shopping in sales etc. That way even if they do fall apart it’s not a big deal

DeliciousApples · 05/11/2024 13:30

Under the sake of goods act, goods have to be fit for the purpose for which they are intended.

Shoes that last a month clearly are not.

Have a google

I'd complain about her attitude in writing

mongoliandoll · 05/11/2024 13:30

In a moment of enlightenment my son's school, which is one of those ones who gets overly (IMO) invested in uniform, now allow Nike AirForce in plain black.
Now DS's feet have stopped growing I am happy to invest in these. They are very durable and sturdy.

SparklyEyes1 · 05/11/2024 13:28

We have these and have taken two pairs back exactly for this reason - one after 4 weeks and one after 6. The shop manager simply replaced them. I assume they know it's an issue. Unfortunately, my daughter's school has a narrow list of acceptable footwear and these are the only ones she can comfortably wear.

TheDeepLemonHelper · 05/11/2024 13:27

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

swiftieswoop · 05/11/2024 13:27

Cardboardeaux · 05/11/2024 13:04

I know not quite the point of your thread, but have you tried getting them repaired? Try Timpsons

Every time I've taken shoes or boots to get repaired with them, they've quoted me more than just buying new.

mongoliandoll · 05/11/2024 13:26

I gave up with Clarks when they never had my sons' size and helpfully pointed out 'it's a busy time' - no shit, it's August, get more sodding shoes in, and that I could order some in to be delivered to their store 20 miles away.

itsmylife7 · 05/11/2024 13:23

Clarkes aren't the Clarkes of the old days.

They now have some investment from a Chinese company.

ApolloRain · 05/11/2024 13:22

Yes I think it’s because of their name and heard about guarantees that I thought they would be super helpful. I mean they certainly were when I was spending over £100 buying hers and my sons. His are absolutely fine, admittedly the boys ones are better but he is still at primary and running around in them all day. She does a ten minute walk to school and then is in school, lunchtime she sits on outdoor bench and eats. That’s it. I bought two pairs of Clarks shoes, 2 pairs of cheap trainers for PE and 2 pairs of Nike trainers for day to day on the same day and it’s only her school shoes that we have had issues with.

OP posts:
Cardboardeaux · 05/11/2024 13:19

soupfiend · 05/11/2024 13:17

I didnt say you said she was taking the piss, I asked how it could possibly be perceived that she was given there is a clear flaw with the shoe.

Again, I wasn't talking about the OP but future, hypothetical, CFs. Who are even less relevant than in my post because the OP got her replacement anyway

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 05/11/2024 13:19

DC are 13 and 16 now. I've bought a lot of school shoes in the last 11 years!

Clark's school shoes are not cheap enough to reflect the quality or high enough quality for the price. They have a reputation of being high quality, which they no longer deserve.

M&S are far better quality for 2/3 the price, and always lasted all year.

Bangwam1 · 05/11/2024 13:19

These companies drive me mad, they’re all taking the proverbial. Your daughter’s shoes should last the whole school year.

Make a stink about it on TikTok, mumsnet etc. Give Clark’s a chance to fix it but let them know you’re not dropping it and bad publicity coming their way

I had the same with Geoxx and Nike. I only use hush puppy now, it wasn’t this hard when my mum needed to buy me school shoes. Just a nightmare now.

soupfiend · 05/11/2024 13:18

ApolloRain · 05/11/2024 13:14

She threw the new box at me and said she will sent the old ones to head office who will say it’s my fault, I said ok well I want to take a picture of them first so I have my own record. I took the one I uploaded and then she snatched them off of me and said ‘they don’t belong to you anymore’. I think I’m old and stuffy and have too much faith in Clark’s. She said they aren’t very robust ones, which is fair but of the girls ones they are some of the most robust and get feet are an e width so very limeted. I just thought blimey, £50 isn’t cheap is it, that should last more than a term. To be fair it happened at the start of the last week but I couldn’t take them in or she wouldn’t have then to wear/I was at work.

That is outrageous and you need to set this out in a formal complaint

Cardboardeaux · 05/11/2024 13:17

Topjoe19 · 05/11/2024 13:15

@Cardboardeaux I received a 3 month guarantee when I purchased my daughters shoes. After a month my daughter said they felt tight so they did swap them (for some reason they sold a narrow fitting shoe initially when she is usually a wide fit). It's unacceptable that the shoes are like that OP, I would also be asking for a refund. Honestly what is it with staff having an attitude like this? It's like they take it personally!

Interesting about the guarantee, I didn't know they did that

soupfiend · 05/11/2024 13:17

Cardboardeaux · 05/11/2024 13:14

I didn't say that OP was taking the P (in fact I said I thought she is NBU if you read my post). I suggested that giving refunds could lead to OTHER people being CFs. But from later posts I see that they have in fact replaced the shoes, so clearly I'm wrong anyway! 😅

I didnt say you said she was taking the piss, I asked how it could possibly be perceived that she was given there is a clear flaw with the shoe.

Tooffless · 05/11/2024 13:17

Clarks get by on their name but the quality and service is appalling. I stick to ricosta and geox for my DC.

Cardboardeaux · 05/11/2024 13:16

ApolloRain · 05/11/2024 13:14

She threw the new box at me and said she will sent the old ones to head office who will say it’s my fault, I said ok well I want to take a picture of them first so I have my own record. I took the one I uploaded and then she snatched them off of me and said ‘they don’t belong to you anymore’. I think I’m old and stuffy and have too much faith in Clark’s. She said they aren’t very robust ones, which is fair but of the girls ones they are some of the most robust and get feet are an e width so very limeted. I just thought blimey, £50 isn’t cheap is it, that should last more than a term. To be fair it happened at the start of the last week but I couldn’t take them in or she wouldn’t have then to wear/I was at work.

😮 that's awful!

Topjoe19 · 05/11/2024 13:15

@Cardboardeaux I received a 3 month guarantee when I purchased my daughters shoes. After a month my daughter said they felt tight so they did swap them (for some reason they sold a narrow fitting shoe initially when she is usually a wide fit). It's unacceptable that the shoes are like that OP, I would also be asking for a refund. Honestly what is it with staff having an attitude like this? It's like they take it personally!

Moier · 05/11/2024 13:15

I'd email head office.
Clarks is usually great on things like these.
Point out the consumer act " fit for purpose act"

ApolloRain · 05/11/2024 13:14

She threw the new box at me and said she will sent the old ones to head office who will say it’s my fault, I said ok well I want to take a picture of them first so I have my own record. I took the one I uploaded and then she snatched them off of me and said ‘they don’t belong to you anymore’. I think I’m old and stuffy and have too much faith in Clark’s. She said they aren’t very robust ones, which is fair but of the girls ones they are some of the most robust and get feet are an e width so very limeted. I just thought blimey, £50 isn’t cheap is it, that should last more than a term. To be fair it happened at the start of the last week but I couldn’t take them in or she wouldn’t have then to wear/I was at work.

OP posts:
Cardboardeaux · 05/11/2024 13:14

soupfiend · 05/11/2024 13:09

The sole is hanging off? How is that OP taking the piss (or being perceived as if she might be)

I didn't say that OP was taking the P (in fact I said I thought she is NBU if you read my post). I suggested that giving refunds could lead to OTHER people being CFs. But from later posts I see that they have in fact replaced the shoes, so clearly I'm wrong anyway! 😅