Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed with ladies clothing sizes?!

115 replies

dreamer24 · 01/11/2024 18:37

This is a first world problem, I accept.

I went shopping today for new jeans. I'm a size 10-12. Started off in New Look, took both sizes 10 & 12 into the changing rooms, couldn't even fasten the button of the 12. 😳 I absolutely refused to accept I needed a size 14 when all my other clothes are 10-12.

Gave up and went to Next - again took both sizes into the changing room - size 10 were perfect!

So how come at New Look I'd need a size 14, yet in Next a 10 fits perfectly?! That's quite a gap. I was chatting to the lady who served me in Next about it, she was saying she's a size 8 in most places but needs a 12 in New Look.

Is it just me, or is that quite a disparity? Why is there no consistency in women's clothing sizes across stores? Anyone else notice this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CharlotteCChapel · 27/06/2025 19:06

Rocksaltrita · 01/11/2024 20:15

This is why I like Hobbs - always the perfect fit and the sizing is accurate.

On the other hand , it doesn't suit me. I look really frumpy in their clother

hannahbanana93 · 27/06/2025 18:49

Because every single person has a unique body and what fits one size 10 might not be the best fit on another size 10.

Just buy what fits your body best, who cares if the label says 10 or 14?

YourTealEagle · 27/06/2025 18:27

I'm the same I've lost 50lbs in 3 months. I was size 20/22 in primark leggings and tops. I'm now in 14/16 in leggings and 18/20 in tops (vests are 16/18) but went to get jeans not even size 20 would fit went to asda size 22 don't fit either size 24 was to big.

But their jeggings and leggings the ones are £9 size 16-18 fit.

I'm 5 ft 6 and 300lbs and

Mezzoprezzo · 02/11/2024 14:26

It's a thing but it's just never bothered me. I do think woman see the size label as labelling themselves. Despite my best efforts I've got around 40kg to lose. The clothes in my wardrobe range from size 12 to 20! I just buy what fits. Normally pick up a 16, if it looks my size I take it into the fitting room, if it looks skimpy I take an 18 and a 20. I agree with someone earlier who said it's a millennial thing. (I'm 57 though). My 21 year old daughter is a very petite size 10. She likes everything oversized though and thinks nothing of buying a jumper in an 18.

Bambooshoot · 02/11/2024 14:08

dreamer24 · 02/11/2024 10:38

@Completelyjo

You are entirely missing the point. Who mentioned a "personal attack from the store"?? 😂 You are clearly projecting.

My point is that there is no universal consistency in women's clothing sizes, and I find that frustrating. Whether I'm a size 10 across every single store except for one, or whether I'm a size 20 across every single store except for one - the frustration remains. Why is there no consistency?

And no, it's not bizarre to have gone to another shop that I was passing anyway to get back to my car, and decide to pop in and see if they had jeans in my size that fitted. They did, and they are lovely. Happy ending.🤷‍♀️

I think there are two problems with what you are asking for, though I completely understand where you’re coming from, since just like everyone else, I have clothes ranging from 10 to 14 in my wardrobe. Firstly, each shop uses a different body type as a standard - athletic, slim, curvy, older etc, so what fits in a 10 in one shop won’t look good in another because it’s designed for a different shape. So your New Look jeans are designed for a particular shape that happens not to be you. This is a good thing, because with the variation of stores, mostly, different body shapes are catered for - I know, for example, that Hobbs will fit like a glove, but Zara will not let me have boobs unless I buy L or XL (which will not work for the rest of me)

Following on from this, I was one (healthy) weight throughout my teenage and uni years, lost some weight starting work, gained some with age, then dieted it off to be my teenage weight - then was very dismayed to see I still looked a bit chubby, because the ratio of muscle and fat has obviously changed with age, and I am much less muscular, toned and a very different shape after having a child. Literally, your hips and ribs get wider due to the weight you have to carry. So to expect that you will always be X size in all shops throughout your life, and that neither your body nor the template size measurements will change, is perhaps a bit misguided.

dreamer24 · 02/11/2024 11:48

@Janicchoplin
Wow that's a huge disparity isn't it! Craziness.

OP posts:
dreamer24 · 02/11/2024 11:48

also, a "stealth boast" about the fact my ab muscles are fucked from having a baby meaning I'm no longer the body size and shape I was for 17 years of my adult life - oh yes, that sounds like the perfect thing to show off about 🙄

OP posts:
Janicchoplin · 02/11/2024 11:46

Completelyjo · 01/11/2024 18:46

I actually find it’s a case of some stores being more generous with their labelling than other shops being smaller than standard.
I find older skewing places like Next, M&S etc really big fitting in their bottoms and younger skewing places, topshop, new look, zara to be standard size fitting.
I’ve never found I’m a 8 in one, 12 in another and 16 in another the way some people say.

I'm a 12-14 in most places. In H&M I'm a 20 make that make sense.

dreamer24 · 02/11/2024 11:46

@Moremustard

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Yeah, you got me, it's all about "attention" 🙄

Haven't you anything better to do with your day?

OP posts:
Moremustard · 02/11/2024 11:40

OP Well you've discovered how your body has the ability to change through life. A garment with stretch (like a jumper dress) will always be more forgiving to a something with a fixed stiff waistband, as will something floaty. You keep mentioning your relatively small size and now you talk about abs so you are obviously body conscious. If the biggest problem you have is that jeans from (only) one shop don't fit you despite bigger sizes are available you are very fortunate. I also get the impression you are enjoying the debate and attention on here 😉 a stealth boast perhaps

dreamer24 · 02/11/2024 11:36

@SallyWD
I find top sizes more consistent too. It really does just tend to be jeans for me, for some reason!

OP posts:
dreamer24 · 02/11/2024 11:35

Manasprey · 02/11/2024 11:23

This is why is really pisses me off that places like asos are charging for returns. If I genuinely don't know if I'm going to be a 10,12 or 14, or whether I need normal length or tall, I have to try them all.

Exactly! So annoying.

OP posts:
largeprintagathachristie · 02/11/2024 11:28

I span size 8 - a pair of trousers from Toast, luckily all the reviews advised to massively size down - to 16 - a jumper from M&S. admittedly to allow the inevitable shrinkage even after hand washing.

I’m a solid size 12.

Manasprey · 02/11/2024 11:23

This is why is really pisses me off that places like asos are charging for returns. If I genuinely don't know if I'm going to be a 10,12 or 14, or whether I need normal length or tall, I have to try them all.

SallyWD · 02/11/2024 11:18

dreamer24 · 02/11/2024 10:53

@Makingchocolatecake
The whole point of the thread is, how can women reliably know and predict what size (or sizes) they need to either take into the changing area in a shop or order online, if there is no universal consistency?

That's the point of my thread.

I agree. It is odd.
I never buy trousers or jeans online. I really need to try them on as they are so varied. I'm a difficult shape - fairly slim but with a big bum and thighs so trousers are a nightmare.
I find sizes for tops more consistent and generally wear the same size top from all shops.

Allschoolsareartschools · 02/11/2024 11:06

So true! I'm wearing M&S size 10 jeans, v comfortable fit so I ordered a black pair. There's no way I could ever have fastened them. Same shop, same style.
I once owned jeans in size 8, 10 & 12. The 12 were by far the smallest. It's mad, I hardly ever dare order jeans or trousers online now but at least I got my M&S advent calendar...

dreamer24 · 02/11/2024 10:53

@Makingchocolatecake
The whole point of the thread is, how can women reliably know and predict what size (or sizes) they need to either take into the changing area in a shop or order online, if there is no universal consistency?

That's the point of my thread.

OP posts:
Makingchocolatecake · 02/11/2024 10:51

dreamer24 · 02/11/2024 08:51

That sounds hugely convenient for ordering new clothes online then, when I have no clue what my size is 😂

Well it probably won't be whatever size you've ordered in the past, isn't that the whole point of the thread!

dreamer24 · 02/11/2024 10:45

So basically what I'm saying is, my body was the same shape and size (size 8) from adulthood at 18 and to age 35. It's only now since my pregnancy which hugely affected my ab muscles, that I'm noticing the inconsistency in my new sizing.

OP posts:
dreamer24 · 02/11/2024 10:43

@Moremustard

Actually, I haven't noticed this issue before. Up until age 35 I was a consistent size 8, in every store. I became pregnant at 35 and had my daughter at 36, and from that point onwards due to severe muscle separation on my stomach during the pregnancy (my stomach was gym toned with visible abs prior to my pregnancy), I suddenly have encountered this issue, whereby I am between a 10-12 in trousers (tops I remain an 8-10). I've been living in leggings since the birth of my daughter during to this issue. So actually it's only very recently I've decided to try jeans again.

And I won't stop shopping at New Look because they have gorgeous stuff, tops and dresses etc, which are reliably well fitting in a size 10. I bought a jumper dress from there yesterday actually and I am currently wearing it, I didn't try it on, it fits lovely. I actually probably could have sized down to an 8 as it's quite oversized.

OP posts:
dreamer24 · 02/11/2024 10:38

@Completelyjo

You are entirely missing the point. Who mentioned a "personal attack from the store"?? 😂 You are clearly projecting.

My point is that there is no universal consistency in women's clothing sizes, and I find that frustrating. Whether I'm a size 10 across every single store except for one, or whether I'm a size 20 across every single store except for one - the frustration remains. Why is there no consistency?

And no, it's not bizarre to have gone to another shop that I was passing anyway to get back to my car, and decide to pop in and see if they had jeans in my size that fitted. They did, and they are lovely. Happy ending.🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
Misfitkickedoutonthestreet · 02/11/2024 10:37

How funny, I never have this problem at all - a size 8 will fit me 99% of the time regardless of where it’s from. some clothes are just designed differently and I assume it’s the style as opposed to being ‘incorrectly’ labelled. Different jeans feel different depending on where the waistband lies etc eg if you’re apple shaped and want high waisted jeans, a bigger size would be more comfortable etc.
I will caveat this with the fact my weight/size never changes though so I think that helps.

dreamer24 · 02/11/2024 10:35

Completelyjo · 02/11/2024 09:44

I weigh myself daily

Ultimately this is the issue and why you feel so strongly about this situation.

Weighing yourself daily and refusing to size up because to have a size 10 pair of jeans from another store at the back of your wardrobe is bizarre.

Oh thank you for coming along to spout judgemental bollocks and call me "bizarre"

You have a lovely day now 😀

OP posts:
dreamer24 · 02/11/2024 10:34

@Haitchoraitchnobodygivesafuck
I did buy the ones that do fit - from a different store 😃

OP posts:
BobAintMyUncle · 02/11/2024 10:24

There’s no consistency, even within the same stores.

Admittedly, I do have quite a difficult shape when it comes to buying nicely fitted trousers. I’m usually an 18 on the bottom but I have a relatively small waist compared to my hips and thighs and small ankles.

I have 3 pairs of jeans on rotation at the moment, in sizes 16, 18, and 20 and none of them fit exactly how I would like. The 18 and the 20 are much too big on my waist and ankles, but the 16 is a little snug around my hips but perfect on my waist and ankles. I’ve tried getting shorter leg jeans to combat the baggy ankle problem and it still doesn’t work! They’re either too short or sort of flare out at the ankle.
If I had the funds to do so I would have all my jeans tailor-made to me 😂

I try not to look at the size on labels anymore, if I’m shopping in-store I just pick up what looks like it’ll fit.