Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it o.k to let your 11 year old daughter hang out on the local park?

341 replies

Sammy900 · 30/10/2024 13:28

Reasonable - Of course it's fine, all the other kids are, can't keep them locked in forever, got to start somewhere, build up trust time, etc

Unreasonable - No way, don't send her to the wolves, she isn't street wise, way too young, gangs of teenagers, creeps and weirdos, county lines, worst place possible to hang out, etc

Hi

Just looking for advice, preferably from parents who have been through this before or are going through it. My daughter is 11 in Yr7 and it's time to give her some more freedom. She's had sleep overs at friends and gone to friends houses etc.

She has a phone and has been walking to and from her new secondary school with her friends so far so has been getting used to that, but not really across the park, just sticking to the streets.

Recently she has been asking to meet with some friends after school on a Friday on the park and we have a few concerns but also don't want to be strict over-bearing parents and realise we need to allow her some time out of the house to just hang around with her friends.

The issue is it's getting darker and as a local urban park usually does, attracts older kids/ teens most likely a bit of dodgy this and that going on, Friday night after dark is not safe I don't think.

She then asked to meet some friends in the day between 2-4 - we said o.k this sounds fine..who are you meeting? Bit of a sketchy answer, umm I think so and so is going, maybe ...then I asked if they could call for her so we know who it is - nope this isn't the plan. Then it turns out she wants to meet a boy in her year group and it is just going to be those two. I feel uncomfortable about this as A) never met him, not sure where he lives or anything - this is a new friend she's met at school...B) She's not yet even tried hanging out with a few of her girl mates on the park yet.

I've said no to this this time until we know who he is and she said they both understand and perhaps mums can swop numbers and arrange something. I don't want to make her feel embarrassed if this is a new boyfriend by monitoring everything and introducing parents and all that..but equally need to know where she is who she is with and safeguard her.

How the hell has this all crept up so soon!!

How does everyone else deal with it. What are your thoughts please

Cheers

OP posts:
PaperTyger · 02/11/2024 08:37

What's there to comment on?
I'm privy to safeguarding data, you are not and you won't be budged or even look it up.

The extreme of micro managing kids lives is not true but risks are different now to when we were younger.

Errors · 02/11/2024 08:34

PaperTyger · 02/11/2024 08:32

Error you are wrong.

You have no idea about county lines, they do get children from nurturing happy families

So you talk to your kid about the risks then, surely? Not just stop letting them go out.
And I notice you haven’t commented on any other aspect of my post

Errors · 02/11/2024 08:33

Natsku · 02/11/2024 08:30

When my DD was in scouts, the last camp she went on at 11 years old, they dropper them in the middle of a forest in groups of 3 with a compass and a map and told to find their way to the campsite 8km away. They cooked their lunch on their trangia on the way. Now that was proper scouting!

Yes and this sounds great. Part of ‘all round’ independence building. I’m glad kids are still doing this stuff. But it is still an activity chosen for the kid by adults, arranged by adults, the rules are given by adults and the adults drive them there and pick them up. It’s still more regimented than allowing an 11 year old to decide when and where they meet their friends and what they’re going to do together.

PaperTyger · 02/11/2024 08:32

Error you are wrong.

You have no idea about county lines, they do get children from nurturing happy families

Natsku · 02/11/2024 08:30

Errors · 01/11/2024 19:04

The guides thing sounds great, really it does. But these are still activities arranged by adults, completed under adult supervision and probably judged by adults too. This is not real independence IMO

When my DD was in scouts, the last camp she went on at 11 years old, they dropper them in the middle of a forest in groups of 3 with a compass and a map and told to find their way to the campsite 8km away. They cooked their lunch on their trangia on the way. Now that was proper scouting!

Errors · 02/11/2024 08:29

Ooops wrong thread!

Natsku · 02/11/2024 08:28

SLeanne · 01/11/2024 18:51

Of course he cleans up. He tries. But a teenage boy isn't going to do the job to the same specification that I am happy with. I'm not going to pick on him and have a go when he has tried his best and done a good job (mostly). Why do I get the impression that some ppl are just looking for an argument on mumsnet?

Sorry, I just see too many people giving teenage boys a pass on cleaning up and made an assumption that was wrong.

Errors · 02/11/2024 08:27

And I have already posted about how life carries risks in all sorts of areas. You need to manage risk vs reward IMO. Anything can happen to any one of us and our kids on a daily basis.

Errors · 02/11/2024 08:26

PaperTyger · 02/11/2024 07:59

What stats? Murder? Abduction?
What about plain bullying, attacks and county lines?

If you remember, me saying ‘it’s rare’ was on the back of some news stories specifically about stabbings.
But yes, stats on murder abduction, attacks and count lines. As someone said upthread, it’s not going to be resilient and streetwise kids from good nurturing families that will be targeted for county lines.
Bullying is another matter entirely. And largely happens over social media (still nobody has answered my question whether they’re ok with their kids having smart phones and social media if they’re not allowed to go to parks) and bullying can of course happen at school. This is another area where kids need to try and learn to stand up for themselves - again, the resilience and confidence that independence brings will help with that.
We are imparting too much fear on to our kids. It manifests in them having anxiety which will end up staying with them for life if they’re not careful.
How many of these kids will need their parents to continue to manage every aspect of the lives for them through Uni and then in to the real world?

PaperTyger · 02/11/2024 07:59

What stats? Murder? Abduction?
What about plain bullying, attacks and county lines?

Errors · 02/11/2024 07:58

I certainly will once my DS gets to this age.
My point is, many on here are acting as though it’ll definitely happen and I am saying that it won’t. That whatever the stats are, it’s rare

PaperTyger · 02/11/2024 07:46

County lines iz probably the biggest threat, where your child is turned into a terrified slave.

PaperTyger · 02/11/2024 07:45

Yes but we don't know where you are errors.. Why should anyone else show you this stuff?
Surely you would look up local threats?

Errors · 02/11/2024 07:42

PaperTyger · 02/11/2024 06:32

@Errors what do you mean provide me some statistics and I'll start to believe you?

Surely you've done your due diligence yourself before working out what to do with the situation?

Why not look up local threats, speficically county lines in your area

I mean that if you show me the % all all children who go to all parks who end up being abducted or killed. It’ll be a very, very low percentage. Hence, me saying it is rare. It’s tragic and sad but thankfully rare. You cannot mitigate against every single risk to your children or they will never have a life.

mitogoshigg · 02/11/2024 06:37

Mine did, only when light though and didn't have a mobile because they were still expensive 15 years ago.

No don't ask for friends parents numbers and arrange a play date between parents, this does not happen at secondary. Fine to get an emergency number of parents just don't make arrangements for them I mean

PaperTyger · 02/11/2024 06:32

@Errors what do you mean provide me some statistics and I'll start to believe you?

Surely you've done your due diligence yourself before working out what to do with the situation?

Why not look up local threats, speficically county lines in your area

Mummyoflittledragon · 02/11/2024 03:14

SLeanne · 01/11/2024 21:55

I travelled alone with my mates when I was 17 to my parents' house in Portugal. We went to nightclubs. I don't need to go into details but no way would I allow that

I travelled alone with my mates to a static caravan site in the south of france when I was 17. We met some other girls and boys the same age. We were fine despite drinking a bit too much and at least one of us having sex whilst there. I think that is young. But we were actually relatively sensible and looked after ourselves pretty well. It was a little bit of a dry run for university.

I was clubbing abroad from age 14 ds I wouldn’t be ok with the clubbing. I was fine but I took stupid risks with myself and was a honey pot for older men: Girls were given a free drink at every club to entice boys / men in.

None of these things are possible nowadays anyway as you have to have at least one 18 year old in the group and prove your age to go into clubs or buy alcohol. I don’t really understand the relevance of not allowing something, which isn’t possible.

Would I be ok for dd to do these things when she is 17? No. But I wasn’t vulnerable in the same way as my dd. I don’t have a medical condition, where I go unconscious and my heart stops beating then am unable to move for an hour or two and can be unwell for almost a week. I didn’t have anorexia. She will be doing them at 18. She’s already dry run planning. My job is to get her ready for that.

Errors · 01/11/2024 22:02

SLeanne · 01/11/2024 21:55

I travelled alone with my mates when I was 17 to my parents' house in Portugal. We went to nightclubs. I don't need to go into details but no way would I allow that

Why?
People to need to accept that your kids WILL rebel against you at some point. We all did with our parents. It’s developmentally normal. Better for them to have some resilience and street smarts so that the rebellious course they choose won’t be catastrophic

Errors · 01/11/2024 22:00

SLeanne · 01/11/2024 21:49

I'm 50 and have a degree from a 'proper university' from the time

I don’t get your point?

SLeanne · 01/11/2024 21:55

I travelled alone with my mates when I was 17 to my parents' house in Portugal. We went to nightclubs. I don't need to go into details but no way would I allow that

SLeanne · 01/11/2024 21:49

Errors · 01/11/2024 21:41

Says who?! There really is no such law.
I am not talking about leaving an 11 year old at home by themselves while you go off on holiday for a week. Clearly that would be neglect… but there is a balance. Organising every single aspect of your child’s life, filling it with adult supervised activities that you personally drive them to and from is not going to teach them any resilience.
Before you know it, they will be off to uni and won’t be resilient enough to handle being away from home.
I am a millennial and I was out hanging around with my mates at ages 11. Getting the bus by myself, walking to places, obviously not being tracked as there was no such thing. I am one of the most resilient people I know. I moved out of home at 17. I have travelled the world. I have worked my arse off and gotten a great career despite only getting a few GCSEs. Stuff doesn’t phase me as much as it does my friends who were molly coddled. I am so glad my parents didn’t police my every move growing up

I'm 50 and have a degree from a 'proper university' from the time

Errors · 01/11/2024 21:46

I don’t know why I am even discussing this sometimes. My boy is going to grow up so independent and resilient in a world where most others won’t. He will be just fine.

Errors · 01/11/2024 21:44

And still nobody has answered my question about whether the kids that aren’t allowed to go on parks are allowed to use snap chat with reckless abandon

Errors · 01/11/2024 21:43

Arran2024 · 01/11/2024 21:39

Tbh not so rare. Here is another one just from today www.google.com/amp/s/www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c4gxj7ygglyo.amp

So, three?
Get me a statistic that shows these horror stories as a percentage of the number of children who go to parks and I may start to believe you.
Statistically, kids are more likely to die in a car crash or get groomed by a family member or some weirdo online.

Swipe left for the next trending thread