Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

NMW to increase again next year to £12.21 ph.

810 replies

ZoeZee · 29/10/2024 19:51

If you’ve not had a pay rise this year, despite bringing it up to your employer, and now there’s set to be another 6% NMW increase next year (which is fantastic, don’t get me wrong) the pay gap is narrowing ever more between skilled/unskilled employees.

Skilled and those with MANY years of experience, might as ditch their responsible/stressful jobs (which often keep you awake at night) and look for something that doesn’t have the added responsibility?

Almost 20 years experience means nothing to some employers! AIBU?

Any employers who have a view on this increase, please let me know how this might affect you and your staff.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
LadyGrinningSoul8517 · 30/10/2024 06:22

ZoeZee · 29/10/2024 19:51

If you’ve not had a pay rise this year, despite bringing it up to your employer, and now there’s set to be another 6% NMW increase next year (which is fantastic, don’t get me wrong) the pay gap is narrowing ever more between skilled/unskilled employees.

Skilled and those with MANY years of experience, might as ditch their responsible/stressful jobs (which often keep you awake at night) and look for something that doesn’t have the added responsibility?

Almost 20 years experience means nothing to some employers! AIBU?

Any employers who have a view on this increase, please let me know how this might affect you and your staff.

Are you honestly throwing your toys out of the pram over people being paid better and maybe not struggling as much as a result?
Are you seriously saying that those that haven't trained in something deserve to be paid badly so you can feel better about your job/wage?

Ok then 🙄

Bump3tyBump · 30/10/2024 06:13

Differentstarts · 30/10/2024 06:04

Nmw goes up every April. Why is everyone being so dramatic about this one

Exactly- it’s 80p!

IVFmumoftwo · 30/10/2024 06:12

Differentstarts · 30/10/2024 06:04

Nmw goes up every April. Why is everyone being so dramatic about this one

Indeed. I suspect those saying they would have to raise their prices etc would have done it anyway.

Differentstarts · 30/10/2024 06:04

Nmw goes up every April. Why is everyone being so dramatic about this one

Holidaywarning · 30/10/2024 05:29

ZoeZee · 29/10/2024 20:00

Once I take my travel costs into consideration I might as well go wash pots in my local pub! End of the day, my job will be done and I can go home stress free!

You'll be lucky to have a local pub if the budget goes as anticipated. NMW is all well and good, except the reality is the cost of everything goes up in response and we are not actually gaining as much as the government want you to think.

cakeorwine · 30/10/2024 05:13

Tories increase NMW = good
Labour increase NMW - bad

Bump3tyBump · 30/10/2024 04:51

Livelovebehappy · 30/10/2024 00:51

I predict on the back of this that lots of smaller businesses will fold, and lots of staff laid off in those that survive. If businesses have to increase wages, then they pass the cost to the consumer. Restaurants and cafes are already struggling because they’ve had to hike prices in line with gas and electric price increases, and decreasing footfall due to cost of living. I had half hoped that Labour might not do too much damage in the five year term they have, but I reckon at the rate they’re going, the country will be on its knees within a year. What a shitshow…

A country that can’t pay its lowest paid a decent wage that keeps up with the col is already on its knees and a shit show.

PyongyangKipperbang · 30/10/2024 02:29

mondaytosunday · 29/10/2024 20:07

Yes but will you be satisfied washing pots in a pub? Isn't work more than just a paycheque? Rather than resent those on NMW getting a rise, which with inflation taken into account isn't much, those in your position need to advocate for better wages. Not simple I realise.

This is a good point.

I got made redundant just before the second lockdown and worked in a supermarket for "the duration" and it was soul destroying. Boring beyond words. I had never thrown a sickie in my life, but did three in 2 years at that job just because I hated every single sodding boring boring boring second.

Now I am NMW in a pub doing my old job (but without the management bullshit) and love it. So no, it isnt just about the money.

Blanketyre · 30/10/2024 02:04

Dh is planning to cut hours. He makes no profit as it is (manufacturing) and the NI and the MW increase is unaffordable. Yes, perhaps the company is destined to close anyway and he shouldn't be in business, but he's kept it hanging on to keep 20 staff in work, some of them have been there 40 years. I will be encouraging him to close the business. The most recent Tories were no help for small manufacturers and Labour are worse.

Willyoujustbequiet · 30/10/2024 02:01

flosset · 29/10/2024 23:41

Whilst I'm happy this will help those on minimum wage jobs I can't help but feel so demotivated in my own role. I'm a social worker and work for the public sector (not a local authority but other government sector) I am only on £2.20 an hour more than this
For the stress I'm under and case load I manage it's just not worth it. I know it isn't a job you do for the money but the pressure, expectations and accountability is crazy high :(

A typical band 6 was starting on £35k plus where I worked so that's the average household income and not far off twice the minimum wage.

I'd look for a new employer.

Willyoujustbequiet · 30/10/2024 01:50

DownThePubWithStevieNicks · 29/10/2024 20:06

I find this a really depressing attitude. By all means fight for better pay, but to begrudge a NMW increase because you think you’re better is awful. Care workers with 20 years experience might be on NMW.

If you have so much responsibility that you’re kept up at night worrying about it, I’d be very surprised to hear you’re on less than c. £20p/h equivalent. That’s still a big gap from NMW.

I have a high stress job. I’m paid accordingly (probs around £40 p/h). I’ve had NMW jobs, many years ago. They were awful. Still plenty of stress, but next to no autonomy, and treated like crap by employers and customers alike.

So do I. We have thread after thread on here about the squeezed middle and how people are finding it difficult to manage on £70k plus yet people begrudge some of the most vulnerable in society a small increase?

Their kids have to eat too fgs.

The disconnect is real.

Nat6999 · 30/10/2024 01:49

I've just been looking at Civil Service pay grades, admin roles are very close to NMW, an admin officer who in HMRC has to know a hell of a lot about taxation laws is only earning £1k above annual NMW. I can remember when NMW was introduced, we had to have a pay increase as we were paid well below the legal amount.

AlexMason01 · 30/10/2024 01:46

covid proved that only a fraction of the population is required to run the essential services of society, the rest of the unnecessary businesses are expendable assets eg cinemas, fast food etc , .;

sansou · 30/10/2024 01:35

lateatwork · 29/10/2024 22:01

Will it reduce the benefits bill as the top up will now be less for some?

No, it will increase the benefits bill because jobs will go and unemployment will rise.

AlexMason01 · 30/10/2024 01:20

“Well, they have their minimum wage and queue enter… no jobs, zero wage, no innovation, no creativity, no ambition, so their community is now dead.”

There is little empirical evidence that minimum wage increases destroy communities, reduce innovation, or eliminate ambition.

AlexMason01 · 30/10/2024 01:18

“The wage before this increase wasn’t below subsistence, neither was the one before that or the one before and so forth.”

This assertion overlooks regional variations in the cost of living and the evolution of economic needs over time.

AlexMason01 · 30/10/2024 01:17

Maggispice · 30/10/2024 01:13

“Rhetoric is no substitute for reality.”
― Thomas Sowell

“One of the sad signs of our times is that we have demonized those who produce, subsidized those who refuse to produce, and canonized those who complain.”
― Thomas Sowell, The Vision of the Anointed: Self-Congratulation as a Basis for Social Policy

No society, community or country ever grew by imposing minimum wage or dishing out welfare benefits.
Working is not slavery. It's ignorant to use that word in the way you have.
Most people don't stay on the wage they started for the rest of their lives. it will increase naturally but with a high minimum wage, they won't even get a leg on to the employment ladder and remain stuck on benefits.

The wage before this increase wasn't below subsistence, neither was the one before that or the one before and so forth.
Well, they have their minimum wage and queue enter..... no jobs, zero wage, no innovation, no creativity, no ambition so their community is now dead. They abandoned it in spite of the redeeming and clever minimum wage.

“It is hard to imagine a more stupid or more dangerous way of making decisions than by putting those decisions in the hands of people who pay no price for being wrong.”
― Thomas Sowell

Upskilling or learning a new skill or trade that the market values is what creates wealth and independence. Politicians have instead killed industries, manufacturing and farming. Replacing them with welfare.

Edited

Minimum wage laws and welfare programs have, in fact, played significant roles in the growth of several economies by reducing poverty, increasing consumption, and promoting stability.

Maggispice · 30/10/2024 01:13

hamsterchump · 30/10/2024 00:45

How would keeping a starving class of local workers doing slave labour on below subsistence wages have helped matters?

At the very least I'd expect the holiday makers to object to having to step over their shanty town tent encampments and emaciated, disease ridden children...you know eventually.

“Rhetoric is no substitute for reality.”
― Thomas Sowell

“One of the sad signs of our times is that we have demonized those who produce, subsidized those who refuse to produce, and canonized those who complain.”
― Thomas Sowell, The Vision of the Anointed: Self-Congratulation as a Basis for Social Policy

No society, community or country ever grew by imposing minimum wage or dishing out welfare benefits.
Working is not slavery. It's ignorant to use that word in the way you have.
Most people don't stay on the wage they started for the rest of their lives. it will increase naturally but with a high minimum wage, they won't even get a leg on to the employment ladder and remain stuck on benefits.

The wage before this increase wasn't below subsistence, neither was the one before that or the one before and so forth.
Well, they have their minimum wage and queue enter..... no jobs, zero wage, no innovation, no creativity, no ambition so their community is now dead. They abandoned it in spite of the redeeming and clever minimum wage.

“It is hard to imagine a more stupid or more dangerous way of making decisions than by putting those decisions in the hands of people who pay no price for being wrong.”
― Thomas Sowell

Upskilling or learning a new skill or trade that the market values is what creates wealth and independence. Politicians have instead killed industries, manufacturing and farming. Replacing them with welfare.

another1bitestheduck · 30/10/2024 01:03

Fromage1 · 29/10/2024 22:47

A paramedics starting salary may be that but after 2 years it is usually £35k plus and if you get to the top it can be £75k plus.

A bar persons salary may be £25,396 when they start but 10 years later it will pretty much still be £25,396 plus increases in minimum wage,

if anyone is in a poorly paid job and feels undervalued in relation to what they could be doing for NMW then change jobs. There is nothing stopping anyone if your only criteria is money.

Great solution

And what will happen when you call the ambulance or police but nobody attends because they've all taken your advice?
Look at teaching for example - thousands have left the profession on the last few years and its a complete shit show getting worse every year. You want to do that with all the emergency services rather than increasing their wage slightly?

It's easy to be sniffy about people's main reason for working being money and not, what, job satisfaction or a lovely glowy feeling if you earn enough of it.....

Also you're deluded if you think most or even many paramedics are on anywhere like £70k plus, that is a tiny minority. But if paramedics aren't a good enough example for you try police officers or there's a poster upthread who is an experienced social worker presumably at the top of their LA banding still only earning £2.20 more than MW....

hamsterchump · 30/10/2024 00:59

Maggispice · 30/10/2024 00:52

Well said! It appears those supporting this wage increase don't even analyse at all.They're playing into the hands of big corporation, big business, wastage and poverty for the majority.

As opposed to playing into the hands of big and small businesses and poverty at the moment? Do you think low paid workers are ok or something?

Have you not heard about people in work using food banks and not being able to afford rent so having to live with their parents or in shared accomodation forever so they can never really start their lives? What are you arguing for?

Should low paid workers just live in poverty out of the goodness of their hearts to prop up the business owners forever? What exactly makes them so deserving of charity, slave labour and government subsidy?

Maggispice · 30/10/2024 00:52

RedToothBrush · 29/10/2024 23:00

DH was talking to a bloke this weekend. He runs his own company.

Last year he was importing goods from china for £14k per container. This year due to trouble in the Middle East affecting shipping its £34k for the same container.

He's been trading for 30 years.

THEN add wages.

You can talk about how people shouldn't take the risk and should understand these issues and the business should close etc etc. But you are a fucking idiot.

Then you can all work for huge multinationals who have bigger turnovers than many countries and therefore huge amounts of political influence. And see how long the NWM stays where it is and how long workers rights are maintained. It represents a weakening of the power of the labour force if you wipe out small business.

We seem to think that wages can only rise...

Well said! It appears those supporting this wage increase don't even analyse at all.They're playing into the hands of big corporation, big business, wastage and poverty for the majority.

Livelovebehappy · 30/10/2024 00:51

I predict on the back of this that lots of smaller businesses will fold, and lots of staff laid off in those that survive. If businesses have to increase wages, then they pass the cost to the consumer. Restaurants and cafes are already struggling because they’ve had to hike prices in line with gas and electric price increases, and decreasing footfall due to cost of living. I had half hoped that Labour might not do too much damage in the five year term they have, but I reckon at the rate they’re going, the country will be on its knees within a year. What a shitshow…

hamsterchump · 30/10/2024 00:45

Maggispice · 30/10/2024 00:40

“Much of the social history of the Western world over the past three decades has involved replacing what worked with what sounded good.”
― Thomas Sowell

A quick trip to seaside towns and the like is a good example of how minimum wage has destroys economies. Cleaners, waiting staff etc are too expensive for the business so most people fly to cheaper countries wit no minimum wage for their holidays.

Most of these towns are now full of asylum seekers being feed and housed by grafters taxes.

How would keeping a starving class of local workers doing slave labour on below subsistence wages have helped matters?

At the very least I'd expect the holiday makers to object to having to step over their shanty town tent encampments and emaciated, disease ridden children...you know eventually.

Maggispice · 30/10/2024 00:40

RedToothBrush · 29/10/2024 23:52

But hey, someone who has magic money will swoop in to create a new service because there will be such demand and the service will be so viable.

Christ knows how they'll get the business plan past the bank outlining how they can run the business when the previous one went tits up, but hey, we live in an economy thats always expanding right? Cos thats how its always been.

And stagnation and social and economic decline isn't possible.

Oh wait thats part of the point. The only people who can set up will be those who already have the capital (and no costs associated with loans) and they can come in and cyphen off the profits off shore. Cos thats just so great for us all. Theres no need to undercut anyone. Why would you? Thats just going to hurt your bottomline.

Disaster Capitalism is where its at in 2024.

“Much of the social history of the Western world over the past three decades has involved replacing what worked with what sounded good.”
― Thomas Sowell

A quick trip to seaside towns and the like is a good example of how minimum wage has destroys economies. Cleaners, waiting staff etc are too expensive for the business so most people fly to cheaper countries wit no minimum wage for their holidays.

Most of these towns are now full of asylum seekers being feed and housed by grafters taxes.

HairyPie · 30/10/2024 00:21

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.