Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be miffed mum has given DSis valuable jewellery

55 replies

whatalemming · 25/10/2024 15:22

I am one of 3 sisters all in our 50's. Parents 80 & 82 are still pretty fit & well living independently. They are really quite wealthy (relevant for the topic not a random boast!)

My middle sister was burgled earlier this year and amongst other items had a lots of jewellery stolen that unfortunately won't be covered by her insurers (she didn't ever provide the required proof of ownership or get valuations). We all met at the weekend and she was talking about buying some cheap costume jewellery so she doesn't feel so bare & has something pretty for when she goes out. Our mother then jumped in and offered her a number of pieces of jewellery & my sister swiftly accepted. Some are items she had inherited from her own mother, others items my father has gifted over the years - all pretty valuable and an assumption they would be shared between the 3 of us in time.

I didn't say anything as the jewellery is my mother's to do what she pleases, but I'm really miffed they are now all going to middle sister just because she was was too lazy to complete the paperwork on her insurance! And hopefully we won't have to worry about it, but there is also the potential for IHT issues if she died within 7 years so my DH reckons there should be some formal record of the gift. I haven't spoken to my youngest sis but the look of incredulity on her face suggests she was similarly shocked.

So AIBU & a spoilt brat who should butt out, or YANBU & entirely justified in feeling miffed and Dsis shouldn't get an early inheritance.

OP posts:
Peclet · 25/10/2024 15:42

Was it some or all?

I would mention it

TheYearOfSmallThings · 25/10/2024 15:42

I would wait and see because I wouldn't be surprised if your mother gives jewellery to each daughter. I can't see anyone just handing it all to one daughter (unless the other two never wear jewellery).

Pickled21 · 25/10/2024 15:37

I'd be hurt but perhaps your mum had always intended on these pieces going to her and had now given them early. You could ask of course rather than feel resentful. That being said noone is owed an inheritance and she can divide her jewellery however she decides.

I'm one of 4 (3 sisters and a brother) and my mum has already given us the pieces we were due to inherit. I have 2 girls and have written down what they will each receive and hope to gift them during my lifetime so I can see my girls wear them.

Catza · 25/10/2024 15:32

Doesn't sound as though your mum gave up all of the jewellery, only some of it. Not sure what the issue is, really. My great aunt had her house broken into and lost all her jewellery. It was extremely traumatic and the last thing I would be thinking of is how "lazy" she is by not completing insurance paperwork.

autienotnaughty · 25/10/2024 15:27

I suspect many will find you unreasonable but i'd feel the same as you. Your sis is being rewarded for her incompetence at the cost of the other sisters receiving tokens to remember your mother by.

Not sure you can say anything without sounding grabby tho.

Swipe left for the next trending thread