Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be beginning to think there is some sort of bot presence here starting threads doing down the UK?

117 replies

MrsBixbysMinkCoat · 25/10/2024 14:24

I am so fed up with it. Nearly every day there is a thread about how awful the UK is. Today it's about how filthy we are compared to other places. A couple of days ago it was about how shyte it is here. Moaning about the NHS, weather, transport, about how Ukrainian refugees feel sorry for us, about bloody everything.

There are lots of things I dislike about Britain in 2024. However, this is still a beautiful country where the vast majority of people live peacefully. The very worst thing about this country is that we don't realise how bloody lucky we are. It's not too hot like Southern Europe (sunning yourself on a beach in 38 degrees might be lovely; working in a kitchen every day much less so), not too cold like Russia or part of Canada. We don't get hurricanes like the Southern US has just dealt with. We don't get floods on the scale of Bangladesh. We don't get earthquakes like Japan or Haiti. We don't have volcanoes like Iceland or Italy. We don't have poisonous snakes and spiders like Australia or India. We don't have wild animals stopping us roaming freely like Africa. We don't have drug cartels running things on a huge scale like parts of South America. Neither do we live under despotic rule like North Korea. We don't live in daily fear or famine like the horn of Africa or of war like the Middle East. Our women are reasonably free and not forced to live diminished lives like in Afghanistan.

We live in a generally benign Western democracy and yes times have been hard and yes some of that has been self inflicted - eg via Brexit - and yes we have struggled with leadership too removed from working class priorities. Yes there are knife crime issues and gangs in some of our cities and towns and I wish there weren't. But on balance in a global scale this is fucking paradise compared to many people's lives.

Please can we have a thread bigging up the UK instead of this constant, neverending, tone deaf whingeing, that really is one of the worst things about the British (and possibly, the English most specifically).

OP posts:
ArseyVarsey · 25/10/2024 17:28

Believe me, you’d find walking around many parts of Athens an absolute death trap. Unless you lived in the extremely posh areas.@NewGirlinClass I can only find one or two decent shops for clothes in the city in which I live in the U.K., and do online shopping. Cracks in a pavement are nothing.

ArseyVarsey · 25/10/2024 17:22

Was in Greece for a few weeks. Christ, you have to watch EVERY single step as the pavements are full of rubble, open holes where drain covers should be, rubbish everywhere and so many dilapidated buildings. Don’t get me wrong. Weather brilliant, fruit and veg massive and cheap, food cheaper, people friendly. Eating out cheap. There is A LOT of poverty in Greece.
Healthcare crap, stinking fumes from bashed up cars, mopeds and vans. Graffiti everywhere, a lot of metro trains covered in graffiti. Chaotic streets, gypsy kids galloping about, Albanian kids begging on buses and trains, someone trying to sell you something with every 5 steps you take. Mafia from Bulgaria, Russia………
Contrast with uk. Streets clean, and ordered. Can walk without breaking feet, toes, or legs.
Nice architecture in many places in U.K..No graffiti (not where I live, anyway) no rubbish. No street dogs. No electric scooters; Europe is not some utopia. The Greeks complain about Albanians. The Turkish complain about the Greeks. The Romanians complain about the Hungarians. My sons were in Germany for the Euros (football) and many people they encountered (from many different nations) did not have nice things to say about Serbia. Other son works in Sicily. Again, speaks about dangerous streets, mafia, crumbling buildings, loony drivers, begging children, abject poverty. Yes, Britain has its fair share of issues, but it’s really not that bad.
I’m interested in some of the Scandi countries, Denmark is a sensible place, with a much more equal society, their political system tends to work well. I personally love many that I’ve met from The Netherlands. Norway, I find the lifestyle and people to be very good. Food and drink prices through the roof though.
Look. Boris has gone (thank god) and be selective where you get your news and media offerings. British folk are particularly good at moaning, would win gold medals frequently if it became a sport.

SleepToad · 25/10/2024 17:21

Personally I've always felt that the Soviet era infiltration by Burgess, Philby etc went much much deeper and across the social classes, leading to a huge number of people who seemed in the 60s and 70s when they reached positions of responsibility, to attack the UK from within, attacking the monarchy, the legal system, the way we have 2 chambers elected and unelected, the police, the forces etc.
This has grown and whilst I can see in many cases why people feel the way they do about the house of lords for example, the relentless attacks and the inability to actually discuss issues seems strange.(Personally I am reconsidering my position on the house of lords having been for many years an advocate, the fact that someone who writes musicals about cats gets to decide the future of the country seems wrong! )

unsync · 25/10/2024 17:15

MrsBixbysMinkCoat · 25/10/2024 15:01

I can only assume you've never been to India or Africa?

🙄 Let's not compare apples with oranges. How about comparing with other northern European countries? The UK is disgusting in comparison. It has definitely got worse in the last twenty years.

StaunchMomma · 25/10/2024 17:09

EasternStandard · 25/10/2024 16:06

It has been the case since Covid regardless of Labour not being in, maybe it's more noticeable now to those who voted for Labour

I've definitely seen a ramping in the last few months. The Starmer hate has been particularly OTT. It feels like managed smearing, rather than opinion giving.

Palianytsia · 25/10/2024 16:48

AuntieJoyce · 25/10/2024 15:07

YANBU

How they know how bad the UK is from Moscow I’ve no idea OP

Haha! Burn! 🔥

NewGirlinClass · 25/10/2024 16:42

Went into my nearest big town yesterday. Bus was very uncomfortable as the road surface was so damaged, Pavements uneven and cracks everywhere. (I walk with a stick).
Shops crammed with people sorting over some nice clothes but only a few sizes on offer. So I shall have to buy on line.
A pub and a cafe were not dirty but neither were they polished and shiny clean.
Yes I moan because all of those things could have been improved with some effort and not huge amounts of money. I feel many people are only doing the minimum that is acceptable, few are making the effort to be exemplary.

SlowPonies · 25/10/2024 16:29

Very very well said!!

The negativity and navel gazing and self criticism is one of the worst parts of British nature but I think it’s much more prevalent online than in real life. A vocal minority dominates and tries to manipulate facts, bring others down. Good to be conscious of this and rise above it.

ByMerryKoala · 25/10/2024 16:25

Yes. In addition we have prepayment certificates so that even if you need multiple medicines to manage a condition, the total cost is capped to less £10/month on an annual or £11.50/month on a three month certificate. It saves me a fortune.

Ivyn · 25/10/2024 16:19

I agree.

I remember returning from.a holiday in Egypt and being so relieved that I could walk down the street without being stared at, sexually assaulted or has someone try to sell me something.

I've lived in 2 other countries outside of the UK and although it was a great experience I now value the UK much more.

We have a milder climate, more choices of food and other goods in the shops, better public transport, a fairer police and justicesystem (I saw a man being beaten with sticks by the police in an Asian country, and a friend was advised against reporting a crime as the perpetrator was an organised criminal in an Eastern European country).

The Asian country I lived in also had no free education system so many children didn't go to school. And no health care either unless you could pay.

And as someone else mentioned, women here are so much safer and have better life choices and freedoms than in many other countries.

This country is by no means perfect but I for one am extremely grateful to have been born British.

MrsBixbysMinkCoat · 25/10/2024 16:17

"Its governments obsession with pandering to large sections of the working class, and ignoring the middle class over the last decade which has seen the deterioration of living standards for all."

Can you explain further @Whenwillitgetwarm

I really do not see the metropolitan elite as having prioritised working class concerns over the middle classes over the last decade. While the Tories were in power? They made sure food, housing and transport was affordable, did they? Made sure domestic abuse was a high priority? Put lots of money into state education and ensured the curriculum was accessible and gave equal priority to vocational qualifications?

Really?

OP posts:
PrincessAnne4Eva · 25/10/2024 16:17

MrsBixbysMinkCoat · 25/10/2024 14:49

I totally disagree. I grew up in a developing country and I think that living in the UK is incredibly privileged as a starting point.

I do see that we are worn down. I do see that some aspects of life are harder, such as getting a GP appointment. I specifically agree that the government has ignored working class priorities (in fact I said it in my OP) in order to virtue signal middle class values. I have disabled family members who struggled to get benefits etc. However just the fact that benefits exist, that my family member is getting life saving biologic medication delivered to our house for free, when even if we lived in the US we would be looking at copays of
$1,558 per 40 mg dose - which he takes every fortnight -

I mean. How lucky are we!

The problems we face in most things are fixable, and do not diminish the fact that on a global scale, we are incredibly privileged in this country.

You wouldn't believe how many people in England don't know how much a prescription costs. Quite a lot of people think the real cost of the medication is the (massively subsidised) £10-ish they pay for an item. We were paying hundreds a month in prescription costs when we lived abroad. And we were not in America.

ByMerryKoala · 25/10/2024 16:12

Yes, I think it's post-covid. I've been around these parts, on and off, stretching back to Gordon Brown, and this place has just become a doom and gloom cesspit of one post, new name, bellyaching thread starters.

MonkeyToHeaven · 25/10/2024 16:10

We're the the 9th most unequal in terms of income of 38 OECD countries.

It's really difficult to work out where is better in terms of welfare, as factors like housing costs, wage related unemployment benefits & maternity/paternity pay differ.

But, using % of gdp to welfare is a reasonable guide to looking further into the differences. So that would include the Scandinavian countries, France, Germany, Italy, Spain, France, Belgium, Japan who all spend more as % of GDP on "social benefits".

So a few.

EasternStandard · 25/10/2024 16:06

StaunchMomma · 25/10/2024 16:02

I've though the same thing in the last month or so. The anti Labour, far right and generally goady posts have really ramped.

It's all a bit Twitter, isn't it? It feels 'managed' and manipulative.

It has been the case since Covid regardless of Labour not being in, maybe it's more noticeable now to those who voted for Labour

Delphiniumandlupins · 25/10/2024 16:04
  1. I'm not sure if it's a particularly British trait but we do rather like to moan about stuff. We don't like boasting or self-congratulation. A lot of our best comedy is self-deprecating. Also, as people get older they often remember the past as better than the present.
  1. Mumsnet is a weird place. Some threads I read and feel really happy that I have found kindred spirits. Others I wonder how so many people can share a view that I think is totally wrong, that I don't know anyone who behaves like that irl.
StaunchMomma · 25/10/2024 16:02

I've though the same thing in the last month or so. The anti Labour, far right and generally goady posts have really ramped.

It's all a bit Twitter, isn't it? It feels 'managed' and manipulative.

ByMerryKoala · 25/10/2024 16:01

I think we’re also so used to having everything easy here that a bit of rubbish on the street = hysteria ‘the WHOLE place is filthy’

Yes, it's hilarious. I particularly liked ...everywhere is filthy ... except for my place which is lovely, because other people are generous with their time and caring of their environment - but they shouldn't to, which they do, but if they didn't - it really would be awful.

I mean talk about a glass half empty 😁

MrsBixbysMinkCoat · 25/10/2024 16:00

Shoutinglagerlagerlager · 25/10/2024 15:58

Africa is a whole continent OP.

Yes. So is South America. And?

OP posts:
Shoutinglagerlagerlager · 25/10/2024 15:58

Africa is a whole continent OP.

Moppingul · 25/10/2024 15:56

Yes, some people have never travelled and it shows. Seeing other countries made me realize how lucky we are in the UK!
I think we’re also so used to having everything easy here that a bit of rubbish on the street = hysteria ‘the WHOLE place is filthy’. Classic mumsnet really.
I follow someone on Instagram who is living in the uk for the first time from the US, and going to all sorts of beautiful places, seeing the country through her eyes has really made me appreciate it more too!

MrsBixbysMinkCoat · 25/10/2024 15:53

YarkYark · 25/10/2024 15:31

Perhaps it not so much the comparison with other places, but the change over such a short time here in the UK. There really is a decline in every town and city in terms of shopping, health care, anger just bubbling under the surface. Shops like Debenhams just gone and boarded up in so many places leaving dead town centres. The country needs investement but there's a real people problem, too.

This I can agree with. Things are hard. I just get sick of people making out that nowhere else on earth is also struggling with cost of living, post COVID.

OP posts:
NC1029 · 25/10/2024 15:49

MonkeyToHeaven · 25/10/2024 15:09

Maybe, but they'd probably fare better in a country with greater income equality, better welfare & access to services that work.

So quite a few other places.

Please list 🙂

MrsBixbysMinkCoat · 25/10/2024 15:37

Whothefuckdoesthat · 25/10/2024 15:31

Actually I grew up in East Africa and we were not allowed out of the garden walking, because of baboon troops living locally which were highly dangerous. Have you seen the teeth on them?

@NoButBut I’m guessing you were thinking she’d grown up in Surrey? 😂

I am not sure I have ever been to Surrey in my life.

OP posts:
Windchimesandsong · 25/10/2024 15:34

Anotherparkingthread · 25/10/2024 14:41

I think those who repeatedly say they things like 'i don't see it' and 'not in my area' are denying and undermining what others are saying. Just because you can afford inflated food prices, can get a doctor's appointment and the police still respond to call outs in your area does not mean it's the same everywhere in the UK. I am from a shit hole, it's always been a shit hole but I've never noticed it be as desperately bad as it became recently. It's revolting and an awful place to be, truly. I am not exaggerating and everybody is desperate and hopeless.

I am well off (I did not grow up well off) and moved after another particularly distressing incident on the bad area. I now 'don't see it' either. I live in a very nice neighbourhood where my neighbours all know my name. Where it is very safe, it's a gated community. I can easily see the GP, people are much better off and don't seem to be suffering really, yes they complain things have 'gone up' but they aren't complaining that now they have to go without.

It's very easy to turn a blind eye to the poverty in the UK. To avoid areas that look awful and run down and only go to nice places and put it out of sight and out of mind. This does not mean that that these 'bot' threads, are not the lived experience of very real people who are struggling within the UK. In fact is is incredibly narrow minded and shows extreme privilege to be able to assume as much.

Edited

Yes this.

And also why compare to countries where things are worse? Why not compare to countries where, on average, things are better?

Eg. France has a better healthcare system than the UK. Actually so do quite a few other European countries.

And the UK has one of the lowest state pensions in the developed world, and much worse and lower amount of money working age welfare benefits than many other European countries.

Of course there's a lot of good things and areas in the UK. But it's very dependent on where someone lives and their individual circumstances. Speaking about the problems doesn't necessarily mean "hating on the UK". It's more likely people struggling and who justifiably want a better deal.

The false economy of austerity has badly damaged both individuals - and the UK in general. That's been confirmed by various studies conducted by experts (although it doesn't take an expert to realise this). Hopefully the government will address the issues and repair the damage done - starting with an end to the false economy approach.