Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think "pretty privilege" can start really early?

237 replies

donniedarko89 · 23/10/2024 19:31

"Pretty privilege" is the term used to describe the unfair advantages that people who conform to society's beauty standards receive.

AIBU to think that it can start as early as the first years of primary school? I am noticing these dynamics in DD's school, with "popular cliques" already forming in Year 1. Is this just in my head?

OP posts:
Ottobeak · 24/10/2024 08:41

Naunet · 24/10/2024 08:30

Ahh yes, the privilege of starting to get sexually harassed by grown men at 7 years old 🙄

FFS grow up.

It's not that, or not just that. The fact is attractive people (men and women) have advantages in all aspects of life. It's just a fact. People respond more positively to them in every situation, they earn more too.

Naunet · 24/10/2024 08:30

Ahh yes, the privilege of starting to get sexually harassed by grown men at 7 years old 🙄

FFS grow up.

HappyTwo · 24/10/2024 08:28

Dramatic · 23/10/2024 19:51

I think it is a thing but at that age I don't necessarily think it's about looks, it's usually the confident, funny, charismatic kids who end up being in the "popular" group

This - it’s confidence people are drawn to.

User14March · 24/10/2024 08:05

I think very attractive children can have a lasting confidence however they look as adults.

Teachers are kinder, Mary in the school play, etc. Playdate popularity, etc.

mamajong · 24/10/2024 08:00

My 16yo in particular is very pretty, to the point where everyone comments, but it doesn't feel like a privilege to her. Barely a day goes by when she isn't beeped at from a car, or commented on by pervy adult men telling her they can't stop looking at her or that she is so beautiful and when she was waitressing it was awful for her to deal with. She has been followed and also had comments when in her school uniform from men old enough to be her dad. In addition she has had bitchy comments and low level bullying from other girls accusing her of thinking that she's 'all that' but she really doesn't. She wears no make up at all and lives in joggers and trainers yet she still gets it. If there is a plus side we have yet to.uncover it for her!

Bollyhob · 24/10/2024 07:51

@SallyWD I totally agree, also remember those FHM 100 hottest women lists from the 2000s? Often the women who made those lists and were high up were those with the most exposure in popular culture rather than the most objectively beautiful. I can't remember but I think they may even have been reader votes that determined who sat where on the list. It definitely seems about more than just looks even if that is part of it.

Bewareofthisonetoo · 24/10/2024 07:48

I have definitely benefited from this not stunning but have a good figure and pretty face - but I think it is a positive reinforcement cycle in that people (men and women) telling me I look gorgeous gives me confidence and makes me smile more (according to a friend recently) I ‘exude’ confidence. I just expect people to be nice to me because the invariably are, and so I am nice to them and so it circles.
But I do think smiling/laughing and being animated (not gushing or ‘bubbly’) and being interested in people has got me many more opportunities than just looks.
There is a very interesting book by Richard Wiseman ‘The Luck Factor’ that examines this.

SallyWD · 24/10/2024 07:42

Looking back to my school days, it wasn't necessarily the pretty girls who were in the In Crowd. It was more to do with attitude, wearing the right clothes, confidence etc. There were plenty of pretty girls who were the opposite of cool and lacked confidence.

Bollyhob · 24/10/2024 07:27

I think it does start early like in primary school it was always the blonde haired blue-eyed girl who would be picked to play mary in the nativity without fail. Hopefully that doesn't happen anymore!

I found my old high school yearbook recently and looking back through it I did think the most popular girls weren't actually the prettiest so by them something else is in play popularity perhaps reflects some kind of social dominance that isn't about looks but more about fitting in and controlling the conditions around fitting in. It seems like the girls who could do this were deemed prettier by people at the school but looking back ad an adult they really weren't the most attractive at all.

Newposter180 · 24/10/2024 07:23

NoahsTortoise · 23/10/2024 21:21

Agree. Tbh it was very rare (when I was at school at least) for any of the less popular girls to be objectively pretty. All of the girls who fit the usual idea of 'pretty' were very popular.

But then that could also be due to following more trends, make-up, hair etc. That has a big impact on who's seen as 'pretty' in a teen environment doesn't it.

I think at school in the popularity stakes is it more about “hot” than “pretty” (thinking of teen years). The ones that all the boys fancied in my school weren’t spectacularly beautiful, they were the first to develop and usually had highlights and lots of makeup which made them look a lot older than they were. The confidence that gave them however seemed to last.

Also agree with PP that truly beautiful people remain so. My DM was still striking when she passed away in her 60s and people would make comments to me often (even as a child!) about how attractive she was.

RustyandDusty · 24/10/2024 07:18

My son is attractive but only 7. A boy told his mother my son had a lovely face and he's so popular.

RustyandDusty · 24/10/2024 07:17

My looks are probably going now but I didn't find it a privilege. Creepy men and bitchy women. I was shy when younger so any attention wasn't welcome and made me anxious. I had some horrible co workers who used to try and bring me down a peg or 2. I really didn't need that as I wasn't a conceited person.

MsCactus · 24/10/2024 06:53

GiddyRobin · 23/10/2024 21:32

Yes, I've had that too. I'm pretty in a less generic way, but I've had people behave awfully with me. I don't see it as a privilege. I'm not saying I want to be ugly. I like how I look. But I also don't think it's easy, maybe it depends on the people you've met.

Men have always been really awful with me, apart from DH. And I still get it now. I hate going to conferences because I know what I'll get in the meet ups after. I've read emails from people saying I don't know what I'm talking about and referring to my face. It's horrible. It made me want to shrink.

Didn't, but it's still always there.

EDIT: I don't mean catalogue models are generic. I mean more that about me. I think I look odd. Very small, big eyes, high cheekbones. Men used to scream about Kate Bush at me, and I fucking HATED it. To the point my long hair is gone.

Edited

I'm confused by your comment - you say you're pretty but in your later paragraph say "I think I look odd". If you have usual looks you're probably not going to get pretty privilege.

I think I have pretty privilege because men go out of their way to be nice to me. I've had random men run across a railway track because I dropped something - I've been gifted random things, allowed to ride public transport for free etc. I only really noticed the privilege disappeared when I was heavily pregnant, swollen face and objectively not that attractive and random people in the street weren't super nice to me like usual. I don't relate to your post saying men are awful to attractive women - in my experience men fawn over attractive women

autienotnaughty · 24/10/2024 06:46

Yes it is proven that pretty people are more likely to attract friends, be forgiven or let off when doing something wrong. They can also be subject to bullying tho.

CraftyPlumViewer · 24/10/2024 03:41

Pretty privilege is absolutely a thing among adults, and there are countless studies to back that up.

I'm not convinced it's a huge factor in how younger children form friendship groups, though.

Highelf · 24/10/2024 02:46

GiddyRobin · 23/10/2024 19:59

Is it really a "privilege" to be pretty? As someone who has been called that and other terms throughout my life, I don't know.

I've had to work harder to be taken seriously.
I've had men use me and have no interest in my brains or thoughts.
I've been brushed off by other women even, which is the most hurtful of all.

Had it since I was a kid, and this is no humble brag. I don't like it.

I see it already beginning with DD. She's only young, and it aggravates me. I don't talk about her beauty. I talk about her brains, her personality and strength.

I know there'll be people saying "oh ho, look at you able to say this!" but it's true. I've had to work so, so hard to earn the position I'm in and I've had bosses who've been absolutely disgusting, and colleagues. Boyfriends before DH? Sickening.

I really don't even look for it myself. I love people. In the position I'm in now, I'd hire a "plain" woman over a "beautiful" woman for a front facing job if her skills were on parr.

Beauty isn't a talent.

I fully agree. Getting to the point where most of your male friends have had an intention beyond friendship, and losing friendships, other women jealous or off towards you. People don't like to say it and get accused of humble bragging... but it only gets you so far in life, and it's usually with creepy men.

FrauPaige · 23/10/2024 23:47

Things have changed so much. When I was at primary school in the 80s, efforts were being made to de-genderise schools, trousers were being introduced to uniforms, sports were unisex, short hairstyles were accepted, society was moving towards a gender free ideal.

Now, it's girls wear pink, boys wear blue; boys play soccer, girls do ballet; girls are demure, boys are boisterous. Massive regression.

And then you have social media and sexualisation at secondary - totally alien to the 80s early 90s experience that I enjoyed.

I actually wish my daughter was unattractive - that way she may escape being sexualised and objectified, and can just study, play, make friendships, pursue hobbies, and live her life - like boys are still able to do.

Being a "pretty" girl in 2024 is not the same as it was in 1984.

Shhhthedogssleeping · 23/10/2024 23:29

Being perceived as beautiful, ugly or different absolutely garners how we are treated, and I agree, from a very young age.

I was low birthweight (just shy of 4lbs) and as an adult reached just shy of 5’. As a child, teen and until a few years ago, looked much younger than my age as well as a bit fragile and unusual (turned out I had a genetic condition). I didn’t have pretty privilege but from early on got away with far more in terms of cheekiness, allowances being made and extra attention, especially from adults. Older kids at school and friends in my street would carry me about even though I had no mobility issues and didn’t ask to be picked up. I’d just ask for something and my DBs would do it without question. Looking back I definitely milked it but as an adult just wanted to be blend in. As I got older I became more anss and stopped putting up with being infantilised. My ex really took this to a ridiculous degree and it ruined my confidence and esteem. Society is hugely judgemental and looksist, no matter what is said about body positivity, different beauty standards etc. if I had been beautiful as well as looking tiny and rather fragile, I’d probably have been a total nightmare.

Dutchhouse14 · 23/10/2024 22:54

Never heard the term "Pretty privilege" but know exactly what you mean. I have 2 very attractive friends, one I've known since childhood, people have always responded very positively to her, given her attention, sought her out, I think it's a huge confidence boost when people react so positively to you.
Another very attractive friend I've only known through adulthood but I definitely notice the difference in how people respond the second she walks into a room people, especially men!, will always want to chat to her, seek her out, take an opportunity to make small talk etc it's palpable the attention she attracts. She also is offered every job she interviews for , especially if interviewed by men, she is aware of this and says I can tell they (he) really liked me-tbf she also works hard as and is good at what she does.
I'm hoping "plain priviledge" as mentioned by pp works to my advantage 😂

SunnyHappyPeople · 23/10/2024 22:38

Bikessmikes · 23/10/2024 20:56

Not at all. DD is objectively pretty (big blue eyes, blond hair)

I never understand the above. Having blonde hair or blue eyes doesn’t mean you are pretty. You might be but that will be down to your features & bone structure.

I'm always baffled by this too!

Personally, brown skin and brown eyes, olive skin is much more exotic and attractive IMO but hardly mentioned!

Ladyzfactor · 23/10/2024 22:33

Bikessmikes · 23/10/2024 22:01

@Ladyzfactor Im sorry you have experienced that. I only have my experiences & as I said I’m still friends with a few girls from modelling days & some of them are/were much better looking than me & it’s just not something that has happened to us. We also didn’t get that many comments from strangers then or now. Turned heads? Yes but I would say people wouldn’t really approach us particularly in a group. Certainly the boys I liked never approached/talked to me! 😆😆

I could see a model not being approached much. A tall, thin beautiful woman could be intimidating, especially in groups. I'm shorter, very busty, and give off a "sexy" vibe (I've worked in strip clubs). I try to be very nice and approachable but they're people that will always judge me as being a slut just at based on appearance, both men and women.

Bikessmikes · 23/10/2024 22:09

@Jazminsbutter i think men & women often have different beauty ideals, I also think its depends on area. I’m a Londoner and growing up individuality was a good thing but when I went to uni in a different city a lot of people there dressed in a very different way eg much more glammed up and a lot of them liked to dress the same eg all girls with completely straight ironed hair, same shoes etc. I did feel like I wasn’t seen in the same way as I was at home and felt a bit out of sorts initially.

Bikessmikes · 23/10/2024 22:01

@Ladyzfactor Im sorry you have experienced that. I only have my experiences & as I said I’m still friends with a few girls from modelling days & some of them are/were much better looking than me & it’s just not something that has happened to us. We also didn’t get that many comments from strangers then or now. Turned heads? Yes but I would say people wouldn’t really approach us particularly in a group. Certainly the boys I liked never approached/talked to me! 😆😆

Jazminsbutter · 23/10/2024 22:00

iv observed a lot of boys / men who will call a pretty but plainer girl usually brunette ( as in not fake tan make up blonde brassy etc ) ugly and give her a complex about her attractiveness, then drool & perv all over blonde, orange, filler and spanner faced wanna be Barbie’s so I think a lot of men confuse high maintenance and fake looking with pretty. I see it all the time.

TheSnugHare · 23/10/2024 21:52

BarbaraHoward · 23/10/2024 19:43

I think it starts early but I think it's more in the unconscious ways that adults treat children at this age than cliques among the children themselves. Little kids are pretty open to everyone IME. The cliques do come later of course.

I disagree when I was in primary school a few children were in a clique but their parents were the same and they were bullies. I’m sure it happens in every primary school

Swipe left for the next trending thread