Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think “rude” has little meaning

28 replies

StolenChanel · 22/10/2024 11:10

I don’t really know how to word this properly, but I come from an English-speaking country which is very culturally different to Britain. Think loud music, loud laughter and sarcasm as conversation starters. I knew a man with one leg whose nickname was Runner, for example. Everyone called him this, including himself. These things are pretty standard in my culture, but I can imagine most Brits being horrified by it. Also things like “please” and “thank you” don’t hold as much as importance in day to day life.

I was brought up in a family who wanted me to “survive” British culture, so the ability to code switch is second nature to me and I have no problem presenting myself as “polite” to British people. DH, on the other hand was raised far more immersed in our culture than I was (AND he’s autistic), so he really struggles with what most would consider to be “basic manners”. I used to be incredibly embarrassed by it when out in public, but over the years I’m starting to care less and less as I realise that the British way does not = the “right” way. (I would love to be able to switch off and just not care like DH does, but it’s so deeply ingrained in me that I can’t.)

My question is, AIBU to think that rudeness or politeness are often simple cultural differences as opposed to a “good” or “bad” upbringing?

OP posts:
Agix · 22/10/2024 11:20

Whether something is rude or not is definitely cultural.

That said, if you go live in another culture or even just visit on holiday, you should really be mindful to not be rude in their society. I mean, it's not a legal obligation (most of the time), just seems rude in itself to not care if you're rude to the people of that country.

We're thinking of visiting Japan at some point and there's a lot of etiquette there that isn't a thing here. I think it would be wrong for me and my partner to ignore that, for example, and just run around being rude. I wouldn't blame anyone for thinking we were brought up badly if we did.. because maybe we were, if we weren't respectful of what's rude in the culture of the country we're visiting. Kinda like a baseline for rudeness.

Octavia64 · 22/10/2024 11:20

Absolutely.

Rudeness is breaking the cultural rules.

Moonshiners · 22/10/2024 11:16

I grew up in a multicultural household and my non English parent is a) often confused why she has upset someone - very direct country way of speaking, no please and thank you as separate words, will talk loudly about other people as she complimenting their bun or something so they should be happy not upset. B) can be put out that we haven't been invited to a neighbours daughter's wedding, or that someone has called by her first name even though they are younger to her, or that someone hasn't eaten all the huge amount of food she has offered to some poor sod who's come round to drop off a letter or some such.
I love the differences though but can see how wars start over a perceived slight!

Swipe left for the next trending thread