Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inappropriate movies at sleepovers

180 replies

Curiousitykillsthecat · 20/10/2024 22:39

I can't decide if I'm being ridiculous or not. DS12 has been invited to a Halloween sleepover. I was delighted as doesn't get many invites. But the other kids are planning the movies they will watch and they are all 18+ including things like the SAW movies, etc. Hosting mum is pretty relaxed about it. But I don't think it's appropriate. My DS doesn't want to watch really scary films but does want to go to the party. I'm sad to say he can't go but I also don't feel it's right to be watching those movies at 12. Aibu to say DS can't go?

OP posts:
HighPerformingFlamingo · 21/10/2024 06:04

I think I would let him go. Saw is 100% totally inappropriate for that age but from your update you say it’s included in the moves they may watch.

I would be sure that other kids parents would be thinking similar to you and not be keen on that kind of violence. It’s possible it won’t be screening at all and they may watch other movies. If he is at the sleepover and they watch, and he is uncomfortable, could he text you to pick him up? When you pick him up you could pretend you have a family emergency, “Sorry boys, our great aunt Mildred has passed, we need to travel early tomorrow to (town) to support family.”

How many movies would the kids watch in reality as well as be talking, eating, playing video games and looking at phones (and who knows what they will look up on those). Will they bunker down for hours for a movie marathon or just have a movie on as background noise?

I would let him go (but have the backup plan to pick him up, if Saw or similar movies are being screened as the main event).

ToNiceWithSpice · 21/10/2024 05:00

My 13 year old enjoys horror films, I was the same at that age. My older 2 dc have never really been fans though.

It sounds like he doesn't really want to go due to the film choices , if he did he wouldn't have told you

WiddlinDiddlin · 21/10/2024 04:44

I kind of think watching 'age inappropriate' films is the standard fare of sleepovers to some extent..

However, you know your kid and if they'd genuinely struggle with something its definitely good to give them an out like 'ill say you're not allowed, it's me thats the meanie' or 'I can call with an emergency and come get you' plan if necessary.

Does depend on what they're watching though... I wasn't easily scared by gore, I have watched all sorts of horror, Stephen Kings IT is one of my all time favourites, as is The Green Mile... and some very gory early 80s stuff, all the Hell Raisers, Elm Sts etc, all well under 15.. never mind 18.

I can't do jump scare films though, I've watched one of the Final Destination series and cannot watch the others! They have my adrenalin through the roof and can't calm down for days!

I don't like the more modern psychological wobbly camera stuff though, and I think it can lead to silly teenager hysterical behaviour in some kids.

Best bet is to have a chat with hosting mum, possibly mention that them watching 18's if they mention it in school, could stir up unnecessary trouble, see what she says.

PenelopeSkye · 21/10/2024 02:14

I remember watching Seven at a sleepover when I was about 12, I had nightmares for months (it gives me a horribly sick uneasy feeling now even thinking about it in my 40s- even though it’s not one of the scariest out there- the memory of how it made me feel has stayed with me). I think kids have hugely difference tolerances to scary films, and it’s fine to carefully judge this with your own kids, but not fair to impose them on others. Good for your DS for speaking up about it OP

CosyFanTucci · 21/10/2024 01:56

Firm no from me too. There’s a big difference between a creepy film and those grotesque gore fests. Can’t they just watch Beetlejuice?!

Notaurewhy · 21/10/2024 01:46

Curiousitykillsthecat · 20/10/2024 23:04

My DS has told them he doesn't want to watch an 18 but his mates called him babyish. I'm glad he told me. I totally get it that they are growing up and want to test boundaries and do sneaky things. I remember the fun of sleepovers and watching things but I remember being traumatised watching nightmare on elm street at an early age.

If your son doesn't want to see these things he's making the right choice. Help him get out of this graciously, if the friendship matters, e.g sorry guys I can't make it we are already doing xxx for aunties celebrations". I get it might be an invite with mates he's not been so social with before and that's good but do not expose him to the likes of SAW etc just to be cool. I worked in a field where age limits were relevant. They are important and to be looked at. For example a mature 10 year old may cope with cartoon sci-fi type action and happily watch 12+ films as mine does. But 15,+ and above is a big no no for his age group, for an absolute raft of reasons.

For the pp who have no age restriction boundaries except very "very" sexual content. You are absurd. Watch age and maturity appropriate content on your TV, tablets and SM for your family and their visiting friends.

Drinkdrinkduuurink · 21/10/2024 01:37

God I watched so many horrors at that age (oldest brothers doing!).

The one that got me was IT (the original Tim Curry one..."oh yes, they all float down here"). Been wary of clowns ever since. Also Clownhouse, Pet Semetary, and of course The Exorcist.

Pennywise was terrifying, as was the old man (Kane) from Poltergeist II. Seeing him slowly walk up the driveway, then at the door saying "let me in".

Marblesbackagain · 21/10/2024 01:09

AmateurDad · 21/10/2024 00:35

Are you utterly mad?
Watching certain horror films when aged around 17 left me disturbed for many years. Many of the scenes in these films are inherently psychologically disturbing. The same cannot be said for a glass of wine, a couple of shots of whiskey, or an illicit puff on a fag!

No I am a perfectly sane person. Did you mean to be rude and disrespectful to those with MH issues.

Amazingly I like many enjoy books and films in the horror genre.

We didn't poison our bodies with alcohol nor smoke or drugs. You really want to throw stones from that glass house ? Muppet.

Nanny0gg · 21/10/2024 01:05

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 20/10/2024 23:29

I'm guilty of this.

There's no censorship in this house unless it's very, very sexual.

When there are children of various ages in the household and/or sharing a room they're going to see films aimed at 15 or 18 year olds.

Why aren't you considerate of other children?

Would it kill your kids to watch something age appropriate for once?

(and not watching things that are inappropriate or not suitable isn't 'censorship')

Goldenbear · 21/10/2024 01:02

AmateurDad · 21/10/2024 00:35

Are you utterly mad?
Watching certain horror films when aged around 17 left me disturbed for many years. Many of the scenes in these films are inherently psychologically disturbing. The same cannot be said for a glass of wine, a couple of shots of whiskey, or an illicit puff on a fag!

At 17?? I get that they are disturbing but don't you find them ridiculously so? They are so unrealistic that it reminds you it is all make up and fiction!

Nanny0gg · 21/10/2024 01:02

StressedQueen · 20/10/2024 23:01

My son is 12 too and I'd honestly let him go. But he doesn't scared by horror movies whatsoever and finds them quite funny. I know I'll get judged for that but I think it is a different situation for you as you say your son doesn't want to see scary movies. He might say yes to going so as not to feel left out but if you feel he will genuinely be affected, I'd say don't let him go. I wouldn't recommend talking to the mom though really.

It's not just a question of being scared or not, those films are totally inappropriate for 12 year-olds.

They're not even 15s they're 18s!

That would have been an absolute No from me

Goldenbear · 21/10/2024 00:58

leccybill · 21/10/2024 00:14

I remember going to a tea party when I was 10 and one of our friends had to stay in the kitchen with the mum because she wasn't allowed to watch Grange Hill 😳

I knew someone who wasn't allowed to watch Biker Grove for similar reasons.

Early to mid 90s I was a similar age and remember watching IT and Pet cemetery as my friend's slightly older brother had it playing with his friends and the parents were out. I hated/hate Horror genre as I find it mostly ridiculous and therefore boring- I wasn't personally traumatised. Unfortunately, it was pretty typical where I came from but it wasn't with agreement from Parents, they just weren't around. On another occasion we watched Boyz In The Hood.

minipie · 21/10/2024 00:45

I still remember the horror movies I watched at a sleepover age about 13.

Jesus they scared the hell out of me and stayed with me for a long time. And they were fairly tame with hindsight.

Speak to the parents - as a pp said this may be boys exaggerating and the parents have no intention of allowing this kind of thing. And there may be a few of the other boys who’d secretly really rather not too but aren’t brave enough to say so.

AgileGreenSeal · 21/10/2024 00:44

For me sleepovers are 🚩 already and a Halloween one is 🚩🚩🚩.

So it’s a hard no from me.

EngineEngineNumber9 · 21/10/2024 00:39

AliceMcK · 21/10/2024 00:22

Me too, but I forced myself to rewatch it recently and it was amusing how scared I use to be of it.

Not that I will ever say those two words in a mirror ever 😂

Just had a flashback to the sleepover when I had to watch Candyman. It was at my friend’s dad house and he was a farmer so lived in this huge ancient farmhouse miles from anywhere. He also had various old furniture and antiques all over the house that he had collected.

It had a massive living room with a fireplace where we watched the film. Then we all went up to sleep in a room that had a huge brass bed in it. The room also for some reason was filled with old mirrors. Like, about fifteen or so mirrors all propped up around the walls. My friends all thought it would be funny to repeat the title of the film and I didn’t sleep a wink all night.

SassK · 21/10/2024 00:36

No from me! My daughter is 14 and allowed to watch scary 15+ movies. I've told her we'll have a discussion about scary 18+ movies when she's 15 - she won't have my blessing to watch any of the Saw type gorefests though!

AmateurDad · 21/10/2024 00:35

Marblesbackagain · 20/10/2024 23:08

Each to their own I was watching and loving horrors at that age. I would let my own children probably around 13+ as they appear to have my appetite and enjoy similar books.

Judgement of entertainment choice in comparison to alcohol or drugs is ignorant and ridiculously inaccurate. Honestly talk about a leap!

Plenty of people love the genre and are perfectly normal individuals. If it's not your bag then so be it.

If it was my sons friends I would go vintage, the omen, pet cemetery, rosemary's baby, the shining etc. Exploring a genre of film is a hell of a lot preferable to them experimenting with something else.

I would ask the parents we only had one decline due to religious reasons so we arranged an alternative event another time.

Are you utterly mad?
Watching certain horror films when aged around 17 left me disturbed for many years. Many of the scenes in these films are inherently psychologically disturbing. The same cannot be said for a glass of wine, a couple of shots of whiskey, or an illicit puff on a fag!

whynotwhatknot · 21/10/2024 00:31

Curiousitykillsthecat · 20/10/2024 23:04

My DS has told them he doesn't want to watch an 18 but his mates called him babyish. I'm glad he told me. I totally get it that they are growing up and want to test boundaries and do sneaky things. I remember the fun of sleepovers and watching things but I remember being traumatised watching nightmare on elm street at an early age.

same op that filme fuked me up for a long time

i woulnt let him go or arrange to pik him up

marmadukedoggo · 21/10/2024 00:30

The one that stuck with me ( from when I was 13) was Cannibal Apocalypse. When she kissed him then bit his tongue off I hid under my blanket!
Do not recommend

AliceMcK · 21/10/2024 00:22

JubilantTurquoiseGerbil · 20/10/2024 23:24

I was forever traumatised by watching The Candyman as a young teen.

Me too, but I forced myself to rewatch it recently and it was amusing how scared I use to be of it.

Not that I will ever say those two words in a mirror ever 😂

AtomHeartMotherOfGod · 21/10/2024 00:22

And 'babyish' FFS...

Hope they don't end up sleeping with their parents, or terrified of the dark because of it. Then who'll be the baby?

Your DS must shrug that insult off and stick to his opinion. Knowing your own mind is so far from being babyish that I'll bet it will garner some respect if he does, especially if they actually go ahead and some of them end up regretting it.

AliceMcK · 21/10/2024 00:18

hhmmm he’s probably blown it for himself saying he dosnt want to watch an 18, he’d have been better saying great, but don’t let my parents know, then blame you when he’s stopped from going. I’d happily take the fall for my DCs to save face.

My 12yo dd would absolutely hate a scary movie but my 10yo dd would love one, in fact she has pushed the age related lines in her tv and movie viewing choices, but she has what I refer to as my gore gene, scary and gory movies don’t phase her at all, she knows they aren’t real. There are several movies she’s dying to watch but I’ve said no due to overly graphic or sex scenes. I’m fairly relaxed on age rating but I have to rewatch something first so I can remind myself if I’m ok with dd watching it. I know her limits which are very different to her older sister who is very happy watching Christmas rom coms and barbie movies with my 7yo.

Although I’m saying this, this is my child, I wouldn’t let another child watch something without their parents ok, my dd knows this and also knows not everyone is ok with what she likes to watch.

Do you know the exact movie? If it was a case of DS wanting to fit in, you said he dosnt get invited to many things, could you see what movie it was and maybe to a screening with him first. There are different levels of scary movies.

id be very reluctant to be that parent who insists or “suggests” a different movie to the parents if they are ok with what they have already agreed to their DS as that’s just making your DS a target. It would be far easier to say he’s fine watching it then back out last min for him to save face. High school is rough as it is without him being referred to as a baby.

leccybill · 21/10/2024 00:14

I remember going to a tea party when I was 10 and one of our friends had to stay in the kitchen with the mum because she wasn't allowed to watch Grange Hill 😳

AtomHeartMotherOfGod · 21/10/2024 00:10

What are people like?! I am genuinely flabbergasted that any parent of a child whose brain is changing and easily worked on could nonchalantly wave away it being exposed to such strong violence.

Echoing PP, it would be logged as a safeguarding issue, and probably a call to the parent. It would be there as part of the bigger picture should a child go on to do something of concern.

Article in the Lancet: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10025407/

From Safeguarding Hub; no conclusions but the fact the questions have been asked is enough of a concern for me:
'Routinely professionals in mental health services, education and safeguarding raise questions about how sexual and violent imagery impacts on a child’s mental health. Over the years, academic study dating back to the 1970’s has raised some of the key questions around children’s exposure to potential harmful content:

  • do children become desensitised to violence and the harm and suffering of others?
  • does their anxiety and fear of the real-world increase?
  • do children show higher levels of aggression?
  • are they more likely to act in a more harmful way to others?
  • will exposure to sexual content lead to children becoming sexually active sooner?
These are debates that are as old as television itself. One thing we can be certain of, legislation alone will not protect children from harmful content. Protecting children from potentially damaging material can only be achieved through a combination of parental control, educating children about harmful content and helping them to become digitally resilient.'

Screen violence: a real threat to mental health in children and adolescents - PMC

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10025407

Namerchangee · 21/10/2024 00:06

Greenqueen40 · 20/10/2024 22:59

I am a massive horror fan but am horrified by some of the films people let their young kids watch - terrifier, hostel, saw.... It's just wrong, they are too young to be exposed to that sort of nastiness, no way in hell my 12yr old is watching those and luckily he doesn't seem to want to.

Same here. I love horror films but no way would I knowingly allow my DC to watch them underage. No way.

Swipe left for the next trending thread