Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse to teach this lesson

113 replies

cantthinkofausername26 · 19/10/2024 08:13

Secondary teacher of a practical subject. Maximum amount of students doing practical at one time has always been 16. Suddenly this term it has increased to 25! Boys school so big kids, year 10.
Head of department has decided this particular practical should be taught. I feel it is dangerous. Multiple hazards, too many kids, accident waiting to happen,
AIBU to say I'm not doing it. WHEN an accident happens I will be held accountable as class teacher.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
pollymere · 22/10/2024 12:10

My child was seriously burnt in a Practical lesson in Y7. They saw their chicken was swimming in hot fat and decided to pour off the fat into a bowl. The teacher hadn't noticed because there were way too many students cooking. The fat ended up all over their bare legs and feet (with shoes and socks). The teacher was so over-run all they could do was send my child to the nurse rather than doing any practical immediate first aid.

You are right to be concerned. I think I'd probably be talking to Senior Leadership for Learning or my Union Rep for advice.

Deeperthantheocean · 21/10/2024 19:28

cantthinkofausername26 · 19/10/2024 09:28

@ThatCalmHelper if only all HODs were as reasonable as you!

So for context. It's a food lesson. We have enough cookers for 2 kids to share one, but one has to be shared between 3. The practical requires 3 pans per kid so obviously not doable. Other teacher suggested using one pan twice so two pans per kid. That's 25 boiling pots of water, 25 frying pans with chicken and bacon. There's some areas of the room that are very narrow, the boys are big now, it's claustrophobic. The classroom is designed for 16 kids. It just seems like too much going on at once to be safe. 3 severe SEND kids (with LSA) at least 4 with adhd and behavioural issues.

Frankly that's way too much! I can imagine if it's a new build as well it will be small, windows which open barely an inch? Keep putting your case and good luck! Xx

Deeperthantheocean · 21/10/2024 19:25

I know we expect y10s to be more sensible but not all are. It sounds like you know the group and I assume have concerns about a certain few? Also sure you've put in written form the possible danger issues etc.

Do you have or can ask for support in the lesson? It is a big jump form 15 to 25 with dangerous equipment. If your requests won't be met, you have your concerns in writing, also highlighted the few who could cause difficulties (behaviour, not understanding instructions etc)

Not your subject but I've had to squeeze 35 students into a room designed for 30 max, but because top set no problem Miss? If you can't manage them that's down to you...

Such is our wonderful education system

Watfordwoman · 20/10/2024 20:45

Can you escalate it to the HOD line manager - head of faculty or Assistant head? Outline your exact concerns and request a risk assessment be undertaken by the H&S person. Consider a grievance? Whistleblowing policy?

marmiteisnttheonlyspread · 20/10/2024 19:22

If this is a DT situation there’s a sympathetic group on FB. Design and Technology Teachers Forum.

I taught this and my HOD would fighht against monster groups. A bit easier as the Head was an ex DT teacher.

So get advice, risk assessments, there used to be a notional limit of 20? But widely ignored.

Sometimes its the size of group, sometimes the size of pupils vs size of room, sometimes an individual or two. Or a combination of all of these.

Splitting the class is an idea - a crap one. You can’t teach/leave half to get on and properly teach supervise those doing practical.

Ideally HOD/SLT need to come up with a safe workable solution.

Can this activity be demoed/controlled demo by pupils and others watching on? Or do they all have to do it themselves?

May be ask for union advice?

Pixiedust88 · 20/10/2024 19:16

YANBU. If it’s not safe to do all together then it shouldn’t be done as such. We used to have a PE class of 60 split between two teachers. We used to do trampolining and badminton in our indoors lesson with the same ones doing the same activity every week. one time there were only about 20 of us in my class and the teacher gave us the option of what we did. Because the majority of kids who preferred trampolining were off we all had to play badminton because there weren’t enough of us to be able to safely spot each other on the trampoline. Just because the head of department says it must be a practical doesn’t mean it’s safe to be. I’d refuse to and if they insist make them sign something to say that they and not you will be held responsible for any accidents because of their insistence. They’ll soon back down

MrBlobbyWasTrulyAwful · 20/10/2024 18:14

Also CLEAPS are the people to talk to about safety guidance in Food lessons, make sure you have spoken to them.

MrBlobbyWasTrulyAwful · 20/10/2024 18:07

Have you posted on Food Teachers centre for advice?

Keech · 20/10/2024 01:06

Just refuse to do it. I worked in one school where I was expected to take 22 non swimmer children in year 4 to a pool and teach them how to swim each morning for 3 weeks. I had no swimming teaching experience or qualifications and massive health and safety concerns. I refused to do it and they got some other sucker to do it! Don’t do anything you’re not comfortable with.

ThatCalmHelper · 19/10/2024 23:09

LongLiveTheLego · 19/10/2024 20:10

Your attitude is appalling. If your concern is genuinely for the children then as I said you need to educate yourself.

What on earth is wrong with SEN or SEND, we still have a SEN department and a SENCO, what does it stand for Special Educational Needs (Co-ordinator), and do the children covered by that department not have special needs in terms of what we deliver and how we deliver it to them, require differentiation in teaching delivery - if they have a new acronym its not made it to the rural South West yet.

Incidentally, I'm dyslexic, so have a Special Educational Need, or would have, in my day we got sent to a lady for extra English & Maths to what the other teachers delightfully called the spanners and spoons class which was bloody offensive, we have moved on thankfully - personally I'd rather it had been SEN back then, which I don't see as in any was offensive.

Regulus · 19/10/2024 20:30

LongLiveTheLego · 19/10/2024 20:10

Your attitude is appalling. If your concern is genuinely for the children then as I said you need to educate yourself.

You are unbelievable.

LongLiveTheLego · 19/10/2024 20:10

cantthinkofausername26 · 19/10/2024 17:16

@LongLiveTheLego err why isn't it acceptable? Been in a school lately? We're not all slaves to PC bullshit. In fact, our primary concern is the children, not ridiculous people getting upset by the use of terminology. Get a hobby.

Your attitude is appalling. If your concern is genuinely for the children then as I said you need to educate yourself.

ThatCalmHelper · 19/10/2024 18:04

HEMole · 19/10/2024 17:29

It's hard to judge without knowing what the practical entails.

You still wouldn't be able to judge. It's up to the school's fire safety officer. It's not something people on here can decide on.

Fire safety has nothing to do with it🙄

HEMole · 19/10/2024 17:29

It's hard to judge without knowing what the practical entails.

You still wouldn't be able to judge. It's up to the school's fire safety officer. It's not something people on here can decide on.

cantthinkofausername26 · 19/10/2024 17:28

Thank you so much all who have given advice and made useful comments. I don't know why every post on MN attracts the smart arses who have nothing constructive to say but just come to be nasty or make shitty comments for the sake of it. It really is disappointing that these people feel the need. I haven't the time for such bullshit so will be going now. Thanks

OP posts:
Sugarbeaches · 19/10/2024 17:27

beccahamlet · 19/10/2024 17:21

I wouldn't normally dream of correcting people, but I feel that teachers should use correct grammar.

Oh bore off

beccahamlet · 19/10/2024 17:21

bergamotorange · 19/10/2024 16:08

Off topic. I don't mean this in a smart Alec way but correcting people like this is really bad manners.

If you need help with general etiquette on correcting people, the general rule is 'don't'.

I wouldn't normally dream of correcting people, but I feel that teachers should use correct grammar.

Polkad · 19/10/2024 17:20

OP, create a paper trail, explaining clearly your health and safety concerns and examples of what accidents could happen.
Find out from your union what your position is.
Check with ACAS too.
Very easy to push you to do this, but if an accident happens it will be on your head.
I could well imagine an accident in such a crowded situation.
I would be very unhappy as a parent.
You need to ask who will be responsible in the case of a serious life changing accident?
A pot of boiling water for example.

You need to protect yourself.

cantthinkofausername26 · 19/10/2024 17:17

@bergamotorange no one cares

OP posts:
AutumnLeaves24 · 19/10/2024 17:16

No it's really not.

the experienced teacher says it's not safe, so something needs to be done.

half the class do it at a time & the HM finds someone to take the other half the class.

@cantthinkofausername26 don't do it until YOU are happy it's safe to do so.

cantthinkofausername26 · 19/10/2024 17:16

@LongLiveTheLego err why isn't it acceptable? Been in a school lately? We're not all slaves to PC bullshit. In fact, our primary concern is the children, not ridiculous people getting upset by the use of terminology. Get a hobby.

OP posts:
MrsHamlet · 19/10/2024 17:13

Zebedee999 · 19/10/2024 16:36

Because that should be a last resort if you have tried to resolve the issue. Not a first resort for every obstacle you face at work.

Nonsense. Unions are made up of impartial, trained advisors.

cantthinkofausername26 · 19/10/2024 17:12

Food specialist I meant!

OP posts:
cantthinkofausername26 · 19/10/2024 17:11

Invisimamma · 19/10/2024 15:43

Yanbu. I'm not a teacher op but I am a parent of a 13yr old boy and I would be really unhappy with this set-up. Knowing an experienced class teacher had flagged safety concerns and being told to forge ahead anyway with no mitigations, is shocking.

I'd much rather you split the lesson and do half and half and it took longer than put kids at risk of injury. It's also an incredibly stressful situation for you to be put in even if nothing goes wrong.

I'm in Scotland and it's not allowed here to have more than 20 pupils in a practical lesson. This is clearly set out contractually.

I hear you. Im a parent too and that's how I would feel. Im actually considering leaving. I don't want to be put in this position but the HOD is inexperienced and also isn't a good specialist. To be Frank she knows nothing about the subject. It's a recipe for disaster... excuse the pun!

OP posts:
Tomorrowisyesterday · 19/10/2024 17:04

Zebedee999 · 19/10/2024 16:36

Because that should be a last resort if you have tried to resolve the issue. Not a first resort for every obstacle you face at work.

What do you think union reps are? The Spanish Inquisition? They are a sounding board for people like the OP to get advice about the best next steps for them, and support if required.

Swipe left for the next trending thread