Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to set boundaries with widowed parent and how not to feel too guilty or resentful

63 replies

GreatSnail · 19/10/2024 07:27

I'll try to keep it brief as possible.

My parents split up when I was in primary school and my Dad moved back to his home town hours away from where I still live. He met my Step-Mum within a few months and they were together ever since till she passed away 4 months ago, so 30 years.

Step-Mum was a mixed character but very possessive of my Dad and my relationship with her was complicated due to that and that effected my relationship with my Dad so at one stage I had only 'phone contact with him for 6 years. In the last few years Step-Mum became chronically unwell and covid was a thing so I saw my Dad twice in 10 years till Step-Mum died.

As soon as she passed away I went to support him emotionally and practically and stayed for 2 weeks. Then I visited again for a few days after another couple of months and have two more visits planned in the next 6 months.

Dad calls every day, sometimes 2-3 times a day which i've been happy to go along with to support him but he stresses about things he doesn't need to and often, there are things he could do to make life less stressful for himself but he refuses.

I've been happy to step up and help him with things and offer support and visit even though there's lots of aspects of doing that that cause me a lot of stress; because i've been thinking it's early days and things will settle down.

But the last few weeks i've been gently hinting that I can't or don't want to talk to him every day and he just hasn't picked up on the hints. So i've said it out loud and it's clear that he's been expecting me to visit every few weeks and talk at least once a day forever, and he's getting really upset and saying he'll have no-one else to talk to and so on. I'm not suggesting I never talk to him, just not every day and that it's still early days and we can talk every day for now but that isn't healthy long-term for either of us.

If he was a demanding ass-hole it would be easier but he's not, he's just expressing his fears and vulnerability then I feel guilty and pressured.

And the other side is part of me thinks it's a bit of a cheek that he wasn't a particularly involved Father for the majority of my life and now that his circumstances have changed, he's wanting me to be the most important person in his life and for him to be the priority in mine but I don't want to think like that, feel resentful or drag up the past when he's vulnerable.

He's not elderly, he's just retirement age. He can look after himself and the house, he drives, has a dog, IMO no money worries but he still stresses about money. He's a lovely man, never abusive or nasty, not ND but very set in his ways. I don't have kids or other caring responsibilities but do work full-time, albeit remotely which makes it harder to be boundaried as he knows I have the time to talk to him every day.

Any advice from anyone who has gone through this or advice in general would be much appreciated as i've given it four months thinking he'd naturally need less support but he's becoming more not less dependent on me.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
autumnleavesrcoming · 19/10/2024 12:28

I would start by calling him every day but you call him then it's at your convenience and you can eg call when you're walking somewhere

TorroFerney · 19/10/2024 12:13

GreatSnail · 19/10/2024 09:26

Lots of great points and I know some are valid to my situation.

I am doing my best and i'm actually quite proud that i'm raising these points with him and setting boundaries as I struggle with anxiety and guilt.

I am sitting with it and trying to be comfortable with it but it ain't easy.

I found that knowing what I was feeling and acknowledging it was half the battle. You are incredibly self aware already .

littleburn · 19/10/2024 11:18

Oh bless you @thepariscrimefiles that's very kind of you.

The 2 phone calls, I put him on speaker phone and say 'yes' occasionally (the monologing means that's all is required of me) whilst I get on with other things, such as scrolling mumsnet or cooking dinner. I limit them to 10/15 minutes at most.

The 'visit' is actually he picks up my DC from school once a week and brings them to my house, so not as onerous for me as it maybe sounds and we're done in 90 minutes.

It feels manageable to me, but very interesting to have your perspective (thank you!) as I still have guilty feelings that it's not enough.

Mischance · 19/10/2024 11:03

https://www.u3a.org.uk/ - really worth a look for him.

I WhatsApp my family all the time - he needs nudging in this direction! It is a real lifeline for me and I feel a part of what is going on. If he does not reply, then don't give up, just keep messaging.

u3a - Home

u3a is a UK-wide movement of locally-run groups providing a wide range of opportunities to come together to learn for fun exploring new ideas skills & interests

https://www.u3a.org.uk

thepariscrimefiles · 19/10/2024 11:00

littleburn · 19/10/2024 10:44

We've had this with my DF after my DM passed 3 years ago. Slightly similar scenario in that both of my parents were emotionally distant and not really 'there for me' growing up (or as an adult), so I learnt early on to be emotionally very self-reliant and cope with things on my own. They were also very insular individuals who retired in their late 50s and didn't pick up any hobbies or interests to keep them occupied in their (long!) retirement.

Since my DM passed my DF (late 70s but physically and mentally in very good health) has retreated into a mindset of 'poor little me, everyone must constantly fuss over me and check that I'm ok'. (I know that sounds harsh, but I've had 3 years of it!) There's also a lot of rewriting of family history, that we're this close unit who must 'stick together' when that was absolutely not my experience growing up.

I've set clear boundaries - I phone twice a week and see him once a week. My DB does the same, so he has 6 days out of 7 with a phone call or visit from one of us. This is still not enough apparently, but I stick to it. I won't take calls during working hours (he thinks wfh means I'm free for a call). We've suggested bereavement clubs, hobbies etc none of which he's interested in (he's 'not ready for that' apparently, and he 'has us'). The phone calls and visits are also 90% him monologing and are incredibly draining.

It's hard and I feel guilty, but I keep to my boundaries and accept that he has the autonomy to fill his days and live his life differently if he chose to. He doesn't want to do that and that's his choice, but it's not my job to fill that gap either.

It's still early days for you - and hopefully your DF will start to take responsibility for himself - but absolutely start putting some boundaries and expectations in place now. You've been very supportive so far, but he can't reasonably expect that to be the new normal, so don't feel guilty about starting to recalibrate things and protect your time and emotional energy.

I don't think you sound harsh at all. I think you sound extremely kind and helpful to a degree that your father actually doesn't deserve.

Have you ever spoken to him about how he treated you growing up? If so, does he take any responsibility for being such an inadequate and selfish parent?

Two phone calls and one visit per week each from you and your brother is a lot and many older people who have been perfectly decent parents don't get that level of contact with their adult children. Is this something that you are doing short-term while he adjusts to his widower status or do you envisage this amount of contact continuing for the rest of his life?

GreatSnail · 19/10/2024 10:54

Thanks everyone for your input and perspectives.

OP posts:
littleburn · 19/10/2024 10:44

We've had this with my DF after my DM passed 3 years ago. Slightly similar scenario in that both of my parents were emotionally distant and not really 'there for me' growing up (or as an adult), so I learnt early on to be emotionally very self-reliant and cope with things on my own. They were also very insular individuals who retired in their late 50s and didn't pick up any hobbies or interests to keep them occupied in their (long!) retirement.

Since my DM passed my DF (late 70s but physically and mentally in very good health) has retreated into a mindset of 'poor little me, everyone must constantly fuss over me and check that I'm ok'. (I know that sounds harsh, but I've had 3 years of it!) There's also a lot of rewriting of family history, that we're this close unit who must 'stick together' when that was absolutely not my experience growing up.

I've set clear boundaries - I phone twice a week and see him once a week. My DB does the same, so he has 6 days out of 7 with a phone call or visit from one of us. This is still not enough apparently, but I stick to it. I won't take calls during working hours (he thinks wfh means I'm free for a call). We've suggested bereavement clubs, hobbies etc none of which he's interested in (he's 'not ready for that' apparently, and he 'has us'). The phone calls and visits are also 90% him monologing and are incredibly draining.

It's hard and I feel guilty, but I keep to my boundaries and accept that he has the autonomy to fill his days and live his life differently if he chose to. He doesn't want to do that and that's his choice, but it's not my job to fill that gap either.

It's still early days for you - and hopefully your DF will start to take responsibility for himself - but absolutely start putting some boundaries and expectations in place now. You've been very supportive so far, but he can't reasonably expect that to be the new normal, so don't feel guilty about starting to recalibrate things and protect your time and emotional energy.

NeckolasCage · 19/10/2024 10:19

You d love him to text but he ‘won’t’

Oh well then he can just put up with not being in touch? You know, like you as a child had to?

Or maybe he could get used to texting. You know it’s amazing what people can get used to if they are told - suck it up buttercup. Like, small children told to just suck up not having a dad any more.

Sorry OP but you’re simply being used, this guy has SHOWN you that he does what benefits him and has absolutely ZERO loyalty.

NeckolasCage · 19/10/2024 10:07

Pumpkincozynights · 19/10/2024 07:52

Ok so I don’t know you and don’t have to sugar coat this.
You say he was a lovely man but he really wasn’t was he?
He left you as a child and never gave you a backwards glance. For all he knew you could have been starving to death or being beaten by your other parent/family.
I sincerely believe that you reap what you sow.
He made his bed and I would leave him to lie in it,
He wasn’t calling you twice a day when you needed him was he?
Me-I’d stop answering his calls. Start by not answering today. Then cut it down to answering every other day. Then less frequently.
What excuse did he give for not calling you? Use the same excuse.
I’ve come across many, many people in your situation- mainly always women because women are socialised to always put the feelings of others before them. I can tell you straight that the ones doing what you are get no benefit from it in the long run. All it does is screw them up even more. Reopening wounds and never giving answers.
He isn’t the father you want him to be.
Pull back for your own sake. Quite frankly he will drop you like a tonne of bricks when he meets his next squeeze.

This, sorry.

He wouldn’t have got this far with me. The difference being is that at least he’s an adult, not a child who genuinely needed, and should have been able to expect care and support from, their parent.

So many men like this 😡🤮

Just because he’s old, and because it’s easier mentally OP, don’t make too much of the ‘it’s not his fault’ stuff. It was his fault - he chose a new wife and a new life over his child. He’s a shit.

PermanentTemporary · 19/10/2024 09:54

Bless you. I do agree with others that he won't be alone for long.

I kept my Dad at arms' length for many years until his death and I think you sound much nicer than me and find it harder. It was certainly easier for me to do that because he had a girlfriend pretty much all the time (different ones but the last one was for about a decade).

He desperately needs therapy. I can't imagine in a thousand years that he would accept it but you could suggest it. Bereavement is hard. Cruse are a good starting point. Seeing his GP would be a really good idea too, he may well be clinically depressed.

I agree with the PP who suggests delaying picking up the call. Do you have an answer machine? Maybe they still exist? That way you could hear that he's alive and sounding OK without talking at that exact moment. I agree with taking back your working hours for you.

HarlieJae · 19/10/2024 09:46

GreatSnail · 19/10/2024 09:38

I'd love to text but he won't.

He has a flip 'phone from the early 2000s lol and only has that so he can call in emergencies, like if his landline is down which it was recently.

And I am admittedly, a very anxious person (diagnosed) so if he calls and I don't pick up because i'm not able to, I try to think 'call back in a few hours, he can wait' but then my anxiety takes over and I think what if...what if it's important, he's ill or something? and for me, the what if? and just wanting to get the call out of the way so I can relax for another 24 hrs takes over so I call back pretty soon anyway.

He is very boundaried about what he can't or won't do and i'm trying to replicate his energy lol.

So you also need a clear plan 😆 to help you wean yourself off being at his beck and call!

Timer, five minutes!
Timer, 10 minutes!

I am smiling and hope you are taking this well.

You need to realise that when you return his call in 10 minutes, he is still alive! Build your security and confidence.

GreatSnail · 19/10/2024 09:38

HarlieJae · 19/10/2024 09:23

I have very similar feelings to you about my parents. Different background to you, they made their own choices, putting themselves first and before anything we needed. (moved abroad, we saw them once a year).

As they have aged, they need me more, when they returned to the UK they chose to move an hour away from me.

It feels complicated working through your feelings it doesn't it?

I don't resent them their choices, we all have the right to create a life that suits us. However, I keep the same mantra about my choices too and refuse to feel guilty about not being able to be fully there for them.
My parents choices have impacted our relationship and the practicalities of our lives now. These are not of my choosing.

In your situation I wouldn't be as vocal with him about ‘ we will speak in two days’, or ‘in the long term we won’t have this much contact’, he can't process that yet and is scared.

I would very slowly wean him off. (as a teacher/headteacher I have had to do that with parent contact!).

So feed the need now as he is anxious.
Next don't pick up his call but respond five minutes later with a call back, 10 minutes later, 20 minutes later.
In your responses replace a text with a call and extend the time between. Your messages could start to say ‘ busy at work, call in 30’. Eventually you can start to leave the return call to the next day. Eventually you will have a pattern that suits you, but that he is secure with.

Whilst doing that set a date for your next visit, so he knows that he isn't going to be abandoned. Keep reminding him of the visit. Plan to go out together, local pub, a group etc, to give him a start. Repeat the next time you visit. He might continue without you, he might not, but you have given him the support, his choice if he doesn't.

I manage my parents in a similar way. We talk once a week by phone. If I'm busy and miss the call I return it as soon as I can. Sometimes I'm not up to talking either and I return the missed call at a later time. I have tried going out to groups with them when I'm there and ask about them when I call. They don't really maintain the opportunities they have around them, but that is their choice.

I've accepted that our relationship is only OK, we are not really close. That is the choices they made and I am not going to feel guilty about that.

You sound really caring. Look after you!

I'd love to text but he won't.

He has a flip 'phone from the early 2000s lol and only has that so he can call in emergencies, like if his landline is down which it was recently.

And I am admittedly, a very anxious person (diagnosed) so if he calls and I don't pick up because i'm not able to, I try to think 'call back in a few hours, he can wait' but then my anxiety takes over and I think what if...what if it's important, he's ill or something? and for me, the what if? and just wanting to get the call out of the way so I can relax for another 24 hrs takes over so I call back pretty soon anyway.

He is very boundaried about what he can't or won't do and i'm trying to replicate his energy lol.

OP posts:
GreatSnail · 19/10/2024 09:26

TorroFerney · 19/10/2024 08:54

Feelings aren’t facts, just because you feel guilty doesn’t mean you should. Therapists say to sit with the guilt and I have found that helpful as guilt is a horrible feeling and often we will do anything to stop it.

he is manipulating you, pulling on your heart strings in my opinion. He needs a woman to look after him, doesn’t matter who it is.

Lots of great points and I know some are valid to my situation.

I am doing my best and i'm actually quite proud that i'm raising these points with him and setting boundaries as I struggle with anxiety and guilt.

I am sitting with it and trying to be comfortable with it but it ain't easy.

OP posts:
HarlieJae · 19/10/2024 09:23

I have very similar feelings to you about my parents. Different background to you, they made their own choices, putting themselves first and before anything we needed. (moved abroad, we saw them once a year).

As they have aged, they need me more, when they returned to the UK they chose to move an hour away from me.

It feels complicated working through your feelings it doesn't it?

I don't resent them their choices, we all have the right to create a life that suits us. However, I keep the same mantra about my choices too and refuse to feel guilty about not being able to be fully there for them.
My parents choices have impacted our relationship and the practicalities of our lives now. These are not of my choosing.

In your situation I wouldn't be as vocal with him about ‘ we will speak in two days’, or ‘in the long term we won’t have this much contact’, he can't process that yet and is scared.

I would very slowly wean him off. (as a teacher/headteacher I have had to do that with parent contact!).

So feed the need now as he is anxious.
Next don't pick up his call but respond five minutes later with a call back, 10 minutes later, 20 minutes later.
In your responses replace a text with a call and extend the time between. Your messages could start to say ‘ busy at work, call in 30’. Eventually you can start to leave the return call to the next day. Eventually you will have a pattern that suits you, but that he is secure with.

Whilst doing that set a date for your next visit, so he knows that he isn't going to be abandoned. Keep reminding him of the visit. Plan to go out together, local pub, a group etc, to give him a start. Repeat the next time you visit. He might continue without you, he might not, but you have given him the support, his choice if he doesn't.

I manage my parents in a similar way. We talk once a week by phone. If I'm busy and miss the call I return it as soon as I can. Sometimes I'm not up to talking either and I return the missed call at a later time. I have tried going out to groups with them when I'm there and ask about them when I call. They don't really maintain the opportunities they have around them, but that is their choice.

I've accepted that our relationship is only OK, we are not really close. That is the choices they made and I am not going to feel guilty about that.

You sound really caring. Look after you!

GreatSnail · 19/10/2024 09:14

DoubleTribble · 19/10/2024 08:31

Bereavement and social clubs seem an excellent idea. It’s a shame that smoking is being a barrier to him maintaining a social life- any chance he’d consider quitting?

FWIW my experience is that men in this situation quite quickly find a new partner- I mean, surprisingly quickly. I don’t know how you would feel about that if it happened?

I always thought he'd find someone else very quickly just because he's literally never lived alone.

He went from his Mum to marrying my Mum (they were teens), then back to his Mum for a few months when my Mum had an affair and ended the relationship and he was living with SM within a few months of relocating back to his home town and then with her ever since.

I have spoken to him about maybe meeting someone else in the future and he's saying he's not interested so far. Partly because he's been a carer for the last few years and with his age, wouldn't want to end up with high levels of caring responsibilities again and I get that.

The fact he's been a carer for years means he's really able to do almost everything he needs to be live independently and look after himself; it's the social and emotional support and interaction that he's missing. He's not one of those men in his 60s who can't cook, clean, iron, pay a bill, organise finances or arrange appts. So long as it's not online, he's really good with all that stuff.

Edit - I didn't answer your question, I'd be fine with him having another relationship so long as it seemed healthy and not like he was being exploited or taken advantage of.

OP posts:
narniabusiness · 19/10/2024 09:08

@GreatSnail You may find the Elderly Parents board is a more supportive place for your question

GreatSnail · 19/10/2024 09:03

Carouselfish · 19/10/2024 08:23

I get it to some.extent. step mother here was thoroughly awful and made it very hard to have a relationship with him. She died in an awful way and since then I have had more of his time, however he has mainly turned to serial online dating. He's on his phone constantly.
I chose to accept that he was a pretty selfish weak.person who didn't stand up to sm for an easy life and who can't function on his own. I wish he was calling me more actually. So, n your case, I'd forgive the past, accept he is generally quite selfish yet for your sanity, arrange a weekly call and fortnightly visit.

I wish my Dad was on his 'phone constantly lol.

One of the stressors we have is he refuses to come into the 21st century and have a smartphone, so anything online, have an email address etc.

So that's often related to what he's stressing to me about, things that i'm having to do for him and so on.

OP posts:
thepariscrimefiles · 19/10/2024 09:03

GreatSnail · 19/10/2024 07:51

He never really 'check out', he just went for the easy option and prioritised my Step-Mum which does hurt a lot but since she dies he's been explaining a lot about how controlling she was and so on so I sympathise with him but also, it is very hard not to feel a bit resentful.

That's why i'm trying to establish the boundaries now, just don't want to feel too guilty nor bring up the past to throw at him when he is in the very early stages of grief and living by himself for the first time in his entire life.

Thanks for your post.

You were a primary aged child when moved away to his home town, married your step-mum and stepped away from your relationship. I think that was unforgiveable and he is very entitled to believe that he is deserving of your time and attention with daily phone calls and regular visits.

He was a dreadful father to you and you shouldn't feel any guilt about setting boundaries.

GreatSnail · 19/10/2024 08:59

IhaveanewTVnow · 19/10/2024 08:22

I’m sorry to read your post OP. My father did the same except my mother had died at the young age of 48. He moved on and prioritised every new woman in his life. He then married and I rarely saw us. She had no children and didn’t understand the child parent relationship. She controlled his access to us. When he died, she moved house and I’ve never heard from her again, including my kids who she knew from birth. Just goes to show she was never interested in us. Your father may be different but you control it.

I'm sorry to hear about that.

It does sound a bit different to my situation but with some similarities too.

I'm glad my Step-Mum died first to be honest as i'm able to hear my Dads views of their relationship and have a closer relationship to him.

She'd said in the past that she wanted to have a relationship with me if Dad died and I said oh of course, but had Dad died first I would have never spoken to her again and I suspect she'd have me taken out of the will and I wouldn't have given a shit. I was very prepared to lose inheritance if the alternative was faking that I liked her and having to have her in my life.

But - when I was younger and going through a lot, good or bad, we were very close at times. She was a complicated person and because of that, her relationships with everyone in her life were complicated so my feelings towards her now she's dead are also complicated.

OP posts:
TorroFerney · 19/10/2024 08:54

GreatSnail · 19/10/2024 07:51

He never really 'check out', he just went for the easy option and prioritised my Step-Mum which does hurt a lot but since she dies he's been explaining a lot about how controlling she was and so on so I sympathise with him but also, it is very hard not to feel a bit resentful.

That's why i'm trying to establish the boundaries now, just don't want to feel too guilty nor bring up the past to throw at him when he is in the very early stages of grief and living by himself for the first time in his entire life.

Thanks for your post.

Feelings aren’t facts, just because you feel guilty doesn’t mean you should. Therapists say to sit with the guilt and I have found that helpful as guilt is a horrible feeling and often we will do anything to stop it.

he is manipulating you, pulling on your heart strings in my opinion. He needs a woman to look after him, doesn’t matter who it is.

GreatSnail · 19/10/2024 08:49

ForZingyHazelTraybake · 19/10/2024 08:26

One possibility is that he was selfish, another was that he was in an abusive relationship, something that happens to men as well as women.

Bit of both.

He was/is selfish and I don't know if i'd say his relationship with SM was abusive but she was definitely controlling and moody and weaponised her experiences in her 1st marriage (not to my Dad), and her MH - she was always sensitive, anxious, needy etc.

She didn't speak to me for years which was a pattern for her throughout her life with her family (including her DD), friends etc. When she died, it was a minefield trying to figure out who to invite to the funeral because of it. I'm not sure if a lot of her family even know she'd dead as they'd been estranged for so long.

I saw how she was growing up and knew to keep in her favour but in my 20s I got a bit more vocal and boundaried, hence her not talking to me for years and then when she started talking to me again, I just put aside all my feelings about her to keep her on side so I could see my Dad more/have a better relationship with him, even though Dad had never stopped talking to me, it was difficult.

But my Dad could have, if he'd wanted to, left her at any time if he chose to but he didn't. It was a controlling relationship but I wouldn't say coercive control really, though other people might, I don't.

OP posts:
Desperateforsleepplease · 19/10/2024 08:39

Sending love and strength to you. What a difficult mix of emotions. My mother is bereaved and we don't have the complex history and I've still had to put in my own boundaries as the effect on my own wellbeing, my grief and my family was growing and growing. I also don't share my full diary and bend the truth. A work call might actually be a speed bath before having to pick up kids or a dentist appt might actually be a quiet walk to bakery for my own sanity.
Id ask you to consider that to be kind, these boundaries will benefit him too. There's lots of great helplines that are a listening ear. Would it be worth earmarking a time each week that suits you that you can have a proper chat? Or would it be possible to extend the time gap each time? Eg I'll ring you on Monday then Thursday then Wednesday then next Wed etc !?

Mischance · 19/10/2024 08:37

Maybe suggest a time for a call each day so that at the very least you feel a bit in control. Tell him this would suit you best as you have work and other commitments. And during those calls, talk to him about ways he can open up his life a bit. Maybe research some ideas for him yourself.
You are both making up for lost time but.this has to be in a balanced way.
I am widowed ... it is pretty bloody tough TBH especially as I have been ill .... but I am determined that my troubles should be as little burden to my family as possible. It is a difficult balance as, like you, they want to help and I have to consider that, but I also make sure I talk a lot about all the things I am doing to fill my life, which is what your dad does not have ... yet.
I am lucky to have musical interests and talents so these fill a good chunk of my life. I also belong to the local U3A (and in fact run concert trips for them) and they are a godsend ... endless interest groups and social events ... you might research this in your area.
By the way .... I am quite a bit older than him!
Good luck with this.

Lovetotravel123 · 19/10/2024 08:36

How about you try to set a particular time for one call each day and then don’t pick up if he calls other times? You could agree one call a day and if he needs anything else then it’s WhatsApp. Explain that you have work. Then, set a routine where you meet for Sunday lunch once every two weeks/ frequency that suits you.

UhOhSpagettiOh · 19/10/2024 08:34

You need to tell him that you can call him twice a week, yes he'll be upset, allow him to be upset. He has to go through that upset to work out how to handle it going forward.

Have a think about when best to break that to him and make sure you have something to look after yourself with, as you'll be understandably upset too. Maybe have something to look forward to after the call.

Do some research into stuff he can fill his time with and meet new people and encourage him as much as possible to do those things.

Here's one:

https://www.ageuk.org.uk/services/befriending-services/

Be ready for him to put up all sorts of reasons why he shouldn't but keep reminding him he needs to find other ways to connect with people and live his life. You can't be it all for him.

https://www.ageuk.org.uk/services/befriending-services