Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To begrudge her perfect little life

738 replies

Sistafromanothermista · 18/10/2024 00:25

I’m struggling to articulate this but I have a friend who I actually really like as a person but can’t help begrudge her life sometimes.

we went to school together and she was a high flying achiever. Type A person who was never in trouble but pushed boundaries if she thought teachers were wrong or there was an injustice etc. She was a workaholic and wanted to focus on her career with no time for boys, alcohol and ‘distractions’ like that.

we lost touch for a few years and got back in touch recently and I feel I don’t know, demoralised maybe, because of how her life has turned out.

when we met up again she told me she’d met someone (I was happy for her because I knew she had been in an abusive relationship for a while) and was happy. She then goes on to show me pictures of his proposal (think movie style every girl’s dream rose petals and swan towels) and says they’ve booked their wedding. Again all good.

she THEN proceeds to tell me shes 16 weeks pregnant and her and her fiancée had bought a house. I without thinking asked how can you afford all this…of course miss workaholic accelerated in her finance role.

since we’ve gotten closer she’s had her wedding and just so happened that her husband has made friends with my friends through a hobby. They all went out recently (as in all the men), including my own boyfriend. They went to a more sleazy part of town and I (and this is so horrible I know) asked specifically about my friends husband to see if he’d been upto anything (a couple of the other men had). Apparently her husband talked about her the whole night, didn’t drink alcohol and went home early because he missed her.

just tonight she text me to tell me she’s expecting another baby and how she would love to meet for lunch. She’s a lovely woman and she has a heart of gold and she should obviously be so proud of herself but for fuck sake I just feel like I can’t catch a break around her sometimes. Aibu?

edited to say: she’s stunning by the way. She was always attractive in school but when I saw her again she looked like a real elegant type of stunning. I’m not bad myself but again I just feel a bit bleugh when I’m with her.

OP posts:
SerenityNowSerenityNow · 18/10/2024 12:23

Why can't you just be happy for your friend and proud of her achievements?

I also can't get past the fact you were almost hoping he'd cheated on her on a night out!! That's is just awful of you.

BunnyLake · 18/10/2024 12:22

ObtuseMoose · 18/10/2024 12:06

think movie style every girl’s dream rose petals and swan towels
Have I been womaning wrong all these years because I've never, not once dreamed of rose petals and swan towels?

The kids loved the swan towels when we were on a cruise once so not a romantic setting. A hotel once put rose petals on our bed and it was so bloody annoying!

Applemayjune · 18/10/2024 12:22

Crushed23 · 18/10/2024 12:19

@MyFairMintCat That's not true. I know quite a few people who have just had a smooth sailing life. Of course, they have to work hard etc like everyone else. But they don't have a tragic backstory like your friend. They were just born into financially comfortable families, did what was expected, married someone similar and reaped the rewards.

Same. I know plenty of people where there is no 'catch' to their relatively idyllic lives. I am close enough to them to know that their life is and always has been smooth sailing, they have every privilege under the sun, and they live an instagram-worthy life without - in almost all cases - showcasing any of it on instagram. Some people just have great lives.

Do you think it's just money that makes a great life then?

Because I think there are a lot of other factors.

For example I know a woman, who looked like she had a quite nice life. She was born into a very wealthy family.

One night she told me that her dad had badly sexually abused her as a child and she had never recovered from it.

Money isn't everything. It's one part of a nice life. But you could have been brought up in a wealthy family, with abusive parents

Applemayjune · 18/10/2024 12:20

MyFairMintCat · 18/10/2024 12:15

That's not true. I know quite a few people who have just had a smooth sailing life. Of course, they have to work hard etc like everyone else. But they don't have a tragic backstory like your friend. They were just born into financially comfortable families, did what was expected, married someone similar and reaped the rewards.

You are still somewhat jealous if you have to 'justify' it. 'Oh, X has a perfect life but well this happened'.

Jealously, for me is seeing what someone else has and wishing I had it too. That's all. I dont wish them harm and I also don't need any 'bad' things to make up for it.Also, successful, prettier, richer whatever friends come in useful.

Im not jealous at all. My point is that im not jealous of anyone, as every single person suffers in this life.

to be human is hard.

Youve talked about people who smooth sailed through life . But you just talked about material things and money in relation to them .

What about the rest of their lives.

How could you possibly know every single thing about their lives?

Crushed23 · 18/10/2024 12:19

@MyFairMintCat That's not true. I know quite a few people who have just had a smooth sailing life. Of course, they have to work hard etc like everyone else. But they don't have a tragic backstory like your friend. They were just born into financially comfortable families, did what was expected, married someone similar and reaped the rewards.

Same. I know plenty of people where there is no 'catch' to their relatively idyllic lives. I am close enough to them to know that their life is and always has been smooth sailing, they have every privilege under the sun, and they live an instagram-worthy life without - in almost all cases - showcasing any of it on instagram. Some people just have great lives.

MyFairMintCat · 18/10/2024 12:17

Also @Applemayjune really good friends are hard to find .. don't have time to be jealous of them really.
I'm neurodiverse and click with very few people so I want to keep them!

MyFairMintCat · 18/10/2024 12:15

Applemayjune · 18/10/2024 12:08

I don't really feel jealous of people, because I know that everyone goes through struggle.

One example, I have a friend who is very well off and lives in practically a mansion and has a nice husband .

I also know that she had a terribly sad early life. And that both of her parents died before she was 12. One parent died by medical negligence and she got compensation.

Shes materially rich. But she went her whole life without a mother and I know she struggled from it

Edited

That's not true. I know quite a few people who have just had a smooth sailing life. Of course, they have to work hard etc like everyone else. But they don't have a tragic backstory like your friend. They were just born into financially comfortable families, did what was expected, married someone similar and reaped the rewards.

You are still somewhat jealous if you have to 'justify' it. 'Oh, X has a perfect life but well this happened'.

Jealously, for me is seeing what someone else has and wishing I had it too. That's all. I dont wish them harm and I also don't need any 'bad' things to make up for it.Also, successful, prettier, richer whatever friends come in useful.

CornishCreamTeas · 18/10/2024 12:15

I don't know what a swan towel is though can imagine.

I've clearly missed out.

Crushed23 · 18/10/2024 12:14

ObtuseMoose · 18/10/2024 12:06

think movie style every girl’s dream rose petals and swan towels
Have I been womaning wrong all these years because I've never, not once dreamed of rose petals and swan towels?

Me neither.

Mind you, I've never dreamt of being proposed to either (and indeed have never been, in my 35 years), so I'm definitely womaning wrong.

twilightermummy · 18/10/2024 12:09

Everybody experiences the ups and downs of life. In ten years, her "perfect little life" might have dissipated. I hope it hasn't for her sake, but nothing is permanent.

I can't really see what she's done wrong here. She has a happy family life, so what? You haven't implied she's a horrible person so doesn't deserve it, in fact it sounds the opposite - like she deserves some happiness. I'm surprised you asked her how she was affording a baby and a wedding 🤦 That's not normal!

People are right. You need to focus on your own life and happiness. I know sometimes that can be difficult. If you can't contain your jealousy, you need to distance yourself from her.

Applemayjune · 18/10/2024 12:08

MyFairMintCat · 18/10/2024 11:49

Because pretty privilege?
You know, I think it's human to be jealous. I've got some friends whom I envy although my life is pretty great.
But it's just the occasional twinge, not an obsession like the OP.

OP it's simple you feel what you want to feel. But friends should make you feel good about yourself. If you're obsessing to this degree do the woman a favour and remove yourself from her life. She doesn't deserve this. And neither do you.

I don't really feel jealous of people, because I know that everyone goes through struggle.

One example, I have a friend who is very well off and lives in practically a mansion and has a nice husband .

I also know that she had a terribly sad early life. And that both of her parents died before she was 12. One parent died by medical negligence and she got compensation.

Shes materially rich. But she went her whole life without a mother and I know she struggled from it

ParliamentofBadgers · 18/10/2024 12:07

It’s a side issue but swan towels are good, but quite dated. Like prawn cocktail or Black Forest gateau.

ObtuseMoose · 18/10/2024 12:06

think movie style every girl’s dream rose petals and swan towels
Have I been womaning wrong all these years because I've never, not once dreamed of rose petals and swan towels?

Applemayjune · 18/10/2024 12:05

MyFairMintCat · 18/10/2024 11:49

Because pretty privilege?
You know, I think it's human to be jealous. I've got some friends whom I envy although my life is pretty great.
But it's just the occasional twinge, not an obsession like the OP.

OP it's simple you feel what you want to feel. But friends should make you feel good about yourself. If you're obsessing to this degree do the woman a favour and remove yourself from her life. She doesn't deserve this. And neither do you.

Jealousy often leads to abuse though.

If you look at many reality tv programmes, where women love together, the prettiest girl often gets severely bullied , from jealousy

Purpleroseofbiro · 18/10/2024 12:02

Sistafromanothermista · 18/10/2024 09:10

Honestly why would I waste my time and create a story. Wise up. If anything this just proves my point that her life is nearly too good

People do all kinds of stuff to pass the time, I’m afraid I’m with @Sooverwork the OP seems like made up rubbish to try and stir people up.

BirthdayRainbow · 18/10/2024 12:00

Sistafromanothermista · 18/10/2024 09:10

Honestly why would I waste my time and create a story. Wise up. If anything this just proves my point that her life is nearly too good

That's not what it proves at all..

GCAcademic · 18/10/2024 11:50

DramaLlamaBangBang · 18/10/2024 08:28

Yes I wonder if OP was a school bully/ Queen Bee at school, making fun of the girly swot at school, and expected the same dynamic as an adult. OP, just have a child and form a bitchy clique at the school gates if you want to go back to your mean girl school days.

I thought the same. The school bullies never seem to grow out of it and get even worse (within the parameters of what's acceptable as an adult) when they find out that the kids they bullied at school grew up to be more successful than them.

Gummybear23 · 18/10/2024 11:50

OP to needs recognise her personality and traits need to change.

MyFairMintCat · 18/10/2024 11:50

ThatTealViewer · 18/10/2024 11:49

I don’t think fairness comes into it. That’s like thinking it’s unfair I’m not Beyonce.

It’s not a zero sum game. I find that people who have the attitude you describe tend to be people who don’t like their own lives very much. I maintain that their time would be better spent improving their situation than questioning the good fortune of others.

Yes, when I was single and alone I found my sense of jealousy being so much stronger than when I'm also fulfilled.

It's a signal that you need to change. Not the itejr person.

ThatTealViewer · 18/10/2024 11:49

Blondiney · 18/10/2024 10:42

Some people seem to have more than their fair share of ‘wins’ though don’t they. It’s human to notice and question that.

I don’t think fairness comes into it. That’s like thinking it’s unfair I’m not Beyonce.

It’s not a zero sum game. I find that people who have the attitude you describe tend to be people who don’t like their own lives very much. I maintain that their time would be better spent improving their situation than questioning the good fortune of others.

MyFairMintCat · 18/10/2024 11:49

Applemayjune · 18/10/2024 11:42

I actually think that women being jealous of other women, is a big problem in society.

Everywhere that I've been , school, workplaces, groups etc

I see the prettiest and kindest women - being ruthlessly attacked by nastier and jealous women

Edited

Because pretty privilege?
You know, I think it's human to be jealous. I've got some friends whom I envy although my life is pretty great.
But it's just the occasional twinge, not an obsession like the OP.

OP it's simple you feel what you want to feel. But friends should make you feel good about yourself. If you're obsessing to this degree do the woman a favour and remove yourself from her life. She doesn't deserve this. And neither do you.

MauveCritic · 18/10/2024 11:47

Seeing how our peers are doing can be motivating and sometimes tricky too. I often scope my life against my friends and fall short. It sounds as if she worked hard in life and sacrificed to get what she wanted, which says good for her! Very sad that she went through an abusive relationship, though. Many of us do, but she's found freedom, thank goodness. I've also learned that not everything in people's lives are roses. I have a beautiful friend, who has two amazing sons who've done well, she also does well in her career and had a loving husband. I know in private, she struggled with her husband because he was an avoidant personality. Then he dropped dead from a heart attack. They were childhood sweethearts. Paint your own life beautiful and also get what you want it's not that hard.

Fancypopop · 18/10/2024 11:46

Oldermum84 · 18/10/2024 11:38

I'd feel the same way OP. I shouldn't, but I would. Happy people annoy me. Eugh.

Well more fool you. You’re only harming yourself, not them 🤷🏻‍♀️

Applemayjune · 18/10/2024 11:45

It's like the dark attacking the light.

Applemayjune · 18/10/2024 11:42

Oldermum84 · 18/10/2024 11:38

I'd feel the same way OP. I shouldn't, but I would. Happy people annoy me. Eugh.

I actually think that women being jealous of other women, is a big problem in society.

Everywhere that I've been , school, workplaces, groups etc

I see the prettiest and kindest women - being ruthlessly attacked by nastier and jealous women