Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Found out I was left out of secret family inheritance

258 replies

Teaortea · 17/10/2024 17:50

I am married with two children. I live in the UK but grew up in a different country where my DM and DB still live.

A few years ago my aunt in my home country (DMs brother's wife) passed away. They had no children.

I found out 6 months ago that at the time my DM and DB (single, no kids) inherited £10,000 each and agreed between them not to tell me.
One one knows why my aunt left me out, possibly dementia? Or not being in the same country?

I felt sick when I found out, both at the fact that they'd conspired together to not tell me and that they didn't share any of the money, especially my DM didn't even send my DCs a little bonus or anything.

I'm not saying I am entitled to any of the money but I am feeling left out of the family and protective of my kids who seem to mean nothing to rhem.
There is a history of my DM treating me badly bordeinf on neglect and abuse when I was younger, favouring my DB but this seems so unbelievable, even for them!

My DH says it's unforgivable the way they've left me out, lied by omission and not even wanted to gift the kids.

Aibu to still feel upset and that they were the unreasonable ones? I have been LC since finding out.

OP posts:
Teaortea · 17/10/2024 20:51

yeaitsmeagain · 17/10/2024 19:08

How did you find out?

My DM and DB's neighbour told me. DM has been complaining to her that she hasn't seen my kids for a while and she'd spent all the money and was going to ask DB for the airfare.
The neighbour wanted me to know in case DM asked for money from me when she'd already had and spent her windfall.

OP posts:
thepariscrimefiles · 17/10/2024 20:48

Teaortea · 17/10/2024 20:28

Its a fair point but I can assure you it isn't about the money..I wish I could edit my op to make that more clear.
I feel betrayed by the deliberate secrecy of my DM and DB who have intentionally and cynically kept their good fortune a secret.

We are not rich but we don't need their money, it's not about the money as I keep saying.

I would have shared with my sibling and DM in the same situation.

I have shared with my DM, paid for her to visit me and my family in the UK.

I have always shared my belongings home, money, time and kindness.

My MIL shared a small windfall with all her childrem, in-laws and grandchildren.

Families share and show openness and generosity.

This isn't about my aunt's decision, it was a shock initially because she had always shown us all affection equally, and to my knowledge my DM and DB were not involved in her care.

It sounds as though you were the scapegoat and your DB was the golden child when you were growing up and that dynamic has continued into adulthood.

You have shared with your DM and paid for her to visit you in the UK, but this hasn't been reciprocated by her. I would take a step back and concentrate on your family. Your in-laws sound much nicer than your mum so concentrate on those relationships.

ObieJoyful · 17/10/2024 20:46

They probably didn’t want you to feel hurt that she didn’t want you to have anything, so they didn’t tell you.

Damned if they do; damned if they don’t.

Teaortea · 17/10/2024 20:44

bluebellsandspring · 17/10/2024 18:37

Did they provide a lot of help and care to her? Could this be your aunt's way of repaying them for what they did for her?

No they didn't. She lived near her sister and they helped each other.

OP posts:
Barney16 · 17/10/2024 20:44

Your aunty can leave her money to whoever she likes and beneficiaries can do what they like with it. It's upsetting to feel excluded and I understand why you are upset. Perhaps they thought you would be upset so they kept quiet so they didn't have to get into it with you. Admittedly that's being charitable.

Teaortea · 17/10/2024 20:43

lljkk · 17/10/2024 20:36

We are not rich but we don't need their money, it's not about the money as I keep saying. I would have shared with my sibling and DM in the same situation.

Do you mean you would have shared the INFORMATION or you would have shared the MONEY ?

Actually both.
If I was in my DM'S position and one of my DCs were left out I would share my money with them.

I definitely wouldn't suggest making a secret with one of them against the other.

If I was in my DBs position I wouldn't feel comfortable keeping a secret against my sibling, and I would share some of the money with them.

OP posts:
Teaortea · 17/10/2024 20:36

Riverd · 17/10/2024 20:28

How would you really expect the conversation to go?
"DD/DS we were left an inheritance from DS/aunty. You werent though so you get nothing and we get 10k each. Have a nice day". Given that you have gine low contact over this i xab completely understand why they wouldn't tell you. Ive also noticed you are refusing to answer how much of an effort you actually made with your aunty which makes me think you made no effort

Sorry I'm not ignoring the question but it's not the point, I am not upset with my DA.
However for those asking:
When I was younger I spent a lot of time with my aunt and uncle.
As a family ie grandparents, DA, DU, DM and DB spent weekends together for many years.

I was 23 when my DA died. I stayed with DA after his funeral. Soon after I moved to the UK.
I wrote to DA a few times. The last time I wrote was just before my first child.

Afaik my DM and DB kept in contact to a degree.

They didn't do any caring for her or help her in her home which is what I've been asked.

OP posts:
lljkk · 17/10/2024 20:36

We are not rich but we don't need their money, it's not about the money as I keep saying. I would have shared with my sibling and DM in the same situation.

Do you mean you would have shared the INFORMATION or you would have shared the MONEY ?

diddl · 17/10/2024 20:34

So if they had told you you would have expected them to share as that's what you would have done.

And when it became obvious that they weren't going to share?

What then?

Ozanj · 17/10/2024 20:33

Are you sure your aunt left 10k to your DM and DB. and not you and DB. It seems very odd to exclude you.

sprigatito · 17/10/2024 20:33

Wellingtonspie · 17/10/2024 18:05

Your aunty left her money to who she’s wished as is her right. Nobody has to share with anybody that they have inherited either.

You seem very mad or upset over money you have no right or claim too. Rather grabby. Maybe why they didn’t tell you.

This is needlessly spiteful. OP is upset about being excluded, clearly not for the first time, by her family. Very often when families fall out over inheritance, it's not about avarice but about the family relationships and people feeling slighted, forgotten or unloved. The will becomes a battleground for all those deep-seated feelings and dynamics.

But if you were the sort of person who was capable of understanding that, you wouldn't have felt the need to twist the knife by calling OP "grabby".

pinkdelight · 17/10/2024 20:32

I would have shared with my sibling and DM in the same situation.
I have shared with my DM, paid for her to visit me and my family in the UK.

The latter is not even remotely similar. She came to visit you and wouldn't have had to pay to come to the UK if you hadn't moved here. Presumably you paid at least partly because you wanted her to come. You can't say what you'd do in the same situation, but it's always people's inclinations to think they'd be selfless, kind and generous when they don't have to actually be the one to do it.

McCauslandOnSpeeddial · 17/10/2024 20:30

I'm also sceptical about the "secret". Just because someone doesn't tell you something that's happened in their life that doesn't mean their keeping it secret. Things happen in my life all the time that I don't happen to tell my DB, and we live in the same city.

If they went on a big holiday/repaired their roof/bought a car and were very cagey about the source of funds then that edges into "keeping secrets" territories.

sammylady37 · 17/10/2024 20:28

LikeWhoUsesTypewritersAnyway · 17/10/2024 19:35

It's not about the money FFS. 🙄

It's about the deceit and lies and secrecy. Do you not have a shred of empathy in you?!

I don’t think there has been any deceit, lies or secrecy. The op was not a beneficiary of the estate therefore had no right to know the details of it. People are entitled to privacy in their financial affairs, there was no obligation on her mother or brother to inform her and judging by her reaction, I can see why they didn’t.

Also, she says in her op that one of the reasons why she ‘feels sick’ is that they didn't share the money, and goes on to mention a little bonus for her dc, indicating that actually, it is about the money.

Teaortea · 17/10/2024 20:28

MumonabikeE5 · 17/10/2024 19:46

I think this is why they didn’t want to tell you. You sound pretty money grabbing here.

Its a fair point but I can assure you it isn't about the money..I wish I could edit my op to make that more clear.
I feel betrayed by the deliberate secrecy of my DM and DB who have intentionally and cynically kept their good fortune a secret.

We are not rich but we don't need their money, it's not about the money as I keep saying.

I would have shared with my sibling and DM in the same situation.

I have shared with my DM, paid for her to visit me and my family in the UK.

I have always shared my belongings home, money, time and kindness.

My MIL shared a small windfall with all her childrem, in-laws and grandchildren.

Families share and show openness and generosity.

This isn't about my aunt's decision, it was a shock initially because she had always shown us all affection equally, and to my knowledge my DM and DB were not involved in her care.

OP posts:
Riverd · 17/10/2024 20:28

How would you really expect the conversation to go?
"DD/DS we were left an inheritance from DS/aunty. You werent though so you get nothing and we get 10k each. Have a nice day". Given that you have gine low contact over this i xab completely understand why they wouldn't tell you. Ive also noticed you are refusing to answer how much of an effort you actually made with your aunty which makes me think you made no effort

Littletreefrog · 17/10/2024 20:26

McCauslandOnSpeeddial · 17/10/2024 20:19

As long as you paid the money back to the estate before it's distributed then there would be no need for your brother to know. But obviously if he was an executor he'd need to know in order to collect all the estate's assets together: it's a key part of the executor's job.

TBH even if you or an independent solicitor were acting as executors any residuary beneficiary would have a right to see the accounts if they asked, which would include your repayment.

And that would be fine its not a secret but also he doesn't have a god given right to know just because we are related which is the point I am trying to make to OP. Just encase someone is relayed to you does not mean they have to share all their financial information.

soupfiend · 17/10/2024 20:22

Wherehasallthetimegone · 17/10/2024 18:04

I totally sympathise OP.

Yiur aunt was perfectly entitled to leave her money to whom she wished and even if it does seem hurtful to leave you out there are possible valid explanations.

But it's the deliberate secrecy of your DM and DB I would find difficult to get past. I had this in my own family: I was deliberately left out of things that the rest of the family knew about. I was made to feel like an outsider. So I totally get why you feel so upset by this.

Im not sure deliberate secrecy is the right phrase there?

Someones financial affairs are their own arent they? Would someone 'declare' they had been left an inheritence? Is there a need. Particularly if they felt that OP would feel like she is feeling, particularly around the 'not even a little bonus for my children'. Perhaps they didnt want any comments or guilt trips or pressure

265IceCream · 17/10/2024 20:20

Teaortea · 17/10/2024 18:19

The secret isn't about my aunt. I'm not upset my her.
I'm upset at my DM keeping such a big secret from me. But it fits with a wider pattern of leaving me out.

@Teaortea but you could also interpret this as your mum protecting your feelings? If the aunt left money to your DB and not you, why upset you with it?

Also, is your home country much poorer than the UK? I'm from a much poorer EU country and I have refused an inheritance so far because the people at home need it more. Even in a bog standard job in the UK, I will earn 4-5x money they can. 6- 7k in England (which is what 20k divided by 3 is) is not exactly life changing.

McCauslandOnSpeeddial · 17/10/2024 20:19

Littletreefrog · 17/10/2024 20:07

Nope still not his business.

As long as you paid the money back to the estate before it's distributed then there would be no need for your brother to know. But obviously if he was an executor he'd need to know in order to collect all the estate's assets together: it's a key part of the executor's job.

TBH even if you or an independent solicitor were acting as executors any residuary beneficiary would have a right to see the accounts if they asked, which would include your repayment.

lljkk · 17/10/2024 20:18

OP asked AIBU so I am trying to understand why she takes this so personally. She's Been low contact after she found out... how much contact did she have before?

it's not a life changing amount of money. If it had been £100 would she expect to be told? £1? £10? £1000? What is the threshold where one should get the info about their inheritance? If the amount matters wrt why OP expects them to tell her and it's a slight not to be told, why does the amount matter? If amount doesn't matter, then why is it disrespectful to OP not to be told?

Teaortea · 17/10/2024 20:17

HotCrossBunplease · 17/10/2024 19:07

Is your family not very well off? At most you have missed out on 10k, probably even less if Aunt only had 20k total to give.

It’s hardly untold riches. Your Aunt was entitled to leave it to whomsoever she chose and your mother and brother kept quiet because they knew it would upset you. They only gained 10k each.

Actually no we're not very well off, what a ridiculous question! Do you think everyone is well off? Are you not poor?

And even so, I don't care about the money, I care that my DM and DB intentionally agreed to specifically not tell me, never once mention it.
I guess the issue is really that they have form for this type of secrecy not just from me but other family members. I may not have expressed myself well to try and keep the op brief and to the point.

OP posts:
Gwenhwyfar · 17/10/2024 20:14

Littletreefrog · 17/10/2024 20:07

Nope still not his business.

Well, I think it might be. If the will stipulates 50-50 to each child and you've already had some of it, then that's not fair, is it?

Gwenhwyfar · 17/10/2024 20:13

Purplebunnie · 17/10/2024 19:00

Have you actually seen a copy of the Will. Maybe you weren't left out which is why all the secrecy

If she was a beneficiary the solicitor would have contacter her surely?

Littletreefrog · 17/10/2024 20:07

Gwenhwyfar · 17/10/2024 20:05

I think some people would argue that it is your DB's business if your father dies before you pay him back and you then both inherit the same amount.

Nope still not his business.