Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the injections for weight reduction should be offered to the unemployed?

137 replies

llizzie · 15/10/2024 20:01

The Government has just announced the intention of offering weight reducing injections to those unemployed who are obese?

AIBU to think it might backfire and cause more problems?

OP posts:
CautiousLurker · 16/10/2024 00:09

PandoraSox · 16/10/2024 00:03

Starmer said:

“I think these drugs could be very important for our economy and our health. One of the biggest pharma companies has decided to invest in our country. That is consistent with our pitch that now is the time to invest in Britain.

“This drug will be very helpful for people to lose weight, and it’s very important for the NHS. It will help in all of these areas.”

But carry on with your alternative reality, I'm out.

Edited

LOL our posts crossed.

CautiousLurker · 16/10/2024 00:08

llizzie · 15/10/2024 23:49

So the BBC us wrong, and Starmer didn;t say it was a good idea to give obese people drugs to get them off the dole and I am completely wrong in thinking it will fail and backfire on the government?

Well, actually, the BBC didn’t say that at all.

‘Proposals to give the unemployed weight loss jabs’ (in the byline, not the body of BBC article) are precisely that, a proposed idea that the Health Minister (not the PM) has discussed in an separate article in the Telegraph (which I am going to assume Op has not actually bothered to read or digest).

And these proposals that are not even directly referenced by the PM where the BBC reports: ‘Sir Keir told the BBC the jabs would be "very helpful" to people who want and need to lose weight.
"[The drug is] very important for our NHS, because, yes we need more money for the NHS, but we've also got to think differently".

Ie., PM does not state he thinks it is a good idea to give people these drugs to ‘get them off the dole’ at all. This is an utter lie.

Someone needs to learn to read news articles more critically.

PandoraSox · 16/10/2024 00:03

llizzie · 15/10/2024 23:55

Here is what came out of the horse's mouth. If you disagree, I suggest you take it up with the PM and BBC

This is what the BBC has said. It is on the teletext on TV. This is what the Prime Minister says barely 103 days in office:
Proposals to give weight loss jabs to unemployed people living with obesity could be very important for our economy and health, the Prime Minister told the BBC.
Starmer said 'he acknowledged that more money was needed for the NHS, and the Government also needed to 'think differently' to ease pressure on the health system.
His comments came after Wes Streeting said the jabs could be given to help people get back into work.
Some injections are already prescribed on the NHS for the treatment of obesity and also for people with diabetes.
Now where does he say that it is only a research?

Starmer said:

“I think these drugs could be very important for our economy and our health. One of the biggest pharma companies has decided to invest in our country. That is consistent with our pitch that now is the time to invest in Britain.

“This drug will be very helpful for people to lose weight, and it’s very important for the NHS. It will help in all of these areas.”

But carry on with your alternative reality, I'm out.

SilenceInside · 15/10/2024 23:59

The key word is "could". Not "will". The context of the comments that you are severely missing is that they were commenting after the research trial was announced by Lilly and Health Innovation Manchester.

llizzie · 15/10/2024 23:55

PandoraSox · 15/10/2024 22:49

YABU @llizzie , because that is not what is happening. There is a LOT of misinformation being spread about this. The unemployed aren't suddenly going to be offered weight loss jabs, despite all the frothing that has gone on today on MN. I think this might be thread no. 5 or 6 that I have seen.

This is what is actually happening: there is going to be a five year study on the effectiveness of weight loss jabs and the potential impact of their use on health related quality of life and employment status and sick leave.

ETA: Other posters have tried to acquaint you with the facts, I see. But you are ignoring them.

The long version:

Health Innovation Manchester has today (14 October 2024) announced a groundbreaking strategic partnership with Eli Lilly and Company (Lilly) to initiate a five-year real-world evidence study (SURMOUNT-REAL UK), subject to relevant approvals.

The announcement has been made as part of a collaboration agreed between Lilly and UK Government today, unveiled at the Government’s International Investment Summit.

The study will evaluate the real-world effectiveness of tirzepatide in weight loss, diabetes prevention, and prevention of obesity-related complications for adults with obesity. The evidence generated will seek to increase the global evidence base on the long-term impacts of weight loss medicines and potentially inform the UK’s care pathway approach to the treatment of obesity.

Significantly, the five-year study will also aim to collect data on healthcare resource utilisation, health-related quality of life and changes in participants’ employment status and sick days from work.

https://healthinnovationmanchester.com/news/greater-manchester-plans-to-partner-with-industry-on-a-new-study-to-deepen-understanding-of-a-weight-loss-medication/

HTH

Edited

Here is what came out of the horse's mouth. If you disagree, I suggest you take it up with the PM and BBC

This is what the BBC has said. It is on the teletext on TV. This is what the Prime Minister says barely 103 days in office:
Proposals to give weight loss jabs to unemployed people living with obesity could be very important for our economy and health, the Prime Minister told the BBC.
Starmer said 'he acknowledged that more money was needed for the NHS, and the Government also needed to 'think differently' to ease pressure on the health system.
His comments came after Wes Streeting said the jabs could be given to help people get back into work.
Some injections are already prescribed on the NHS for the treatment of obesity and also for people with diabetes.
Now where does he say that it is only a research?

OP posts:
PandoraSox · 15/10/2024 23:52

I have encountered OP on another thread. You can post all the facts you want and it will not make one iota of difference.

SilenceInside · 15/10/2024 23:50

@llizzie yes! Finally. You were wrong about all of that, absolutely.

Ozanj · 15/10/2024 23:50

One of my friends who has Arthritis would like it to be offered to people with joint issues. It’s so unfair, that as always, it’s the people who contribute least who get all the benefits from the state.

llizzie · 15/10/2024 23:49

SilenceInside · 15/10/2024 23:39

@llizzie I have no idea who you are and I don't recall having ever responded to you before. I am not suggesting you are simple minded. Rather that you appear not to have read or understood anything about this whole topic.

So the BBC us wrong, and Starmer didn;t say it was a good idea to give obese people drugs to get them off the dole and I am completely wrong in thinking it will fail and backfire on the government?

OP posts:
SilenceInside · 15/10/2024 23:49

He hasn't acted on this. He has taken no action, he has not announced any action. No govt action will be happening in this regard.

He was talking about a private company continuing research on the medicine that they have developed.

llizzie · 15/10/2024 23:46

Tiredallthetimeneedsleep · 15/10/2024 23:37

Genuine question. Are the injections a forever thing? From what I've heard, they reduce your appetite, hence the weight loss. Surely when you come off them, you get your appetite back ( perhaps even increased) and you put the weight back on?

It struck me as odd, too. Another reason why it will backfire on the government.

It fills me with horror that we have a Prime Minister who latches on to the slightest suggestion, and acts upon it. He has been like a kid in a sweet shop being told he can eat what he likes and can't wait to try everything out.

He would do better concentrating on the manufacturers of life vests and inflatable boats to find out who buys them.

OP posts:
SilenceInside · 15/10/2024 23:39

@llizzie I have no idea who you are and I don't recall having ever responded to you before. I am not suggesting you are simple minded. Rather that you appear not to have read or understood anything about this whole topic.

KrankyKumquat · 15/10/2024 23:39

Superworm24 · 15/10/2024 23:31

Does "the teletext on TV" even exist anymore?

@llizzie probably has an telly from the good old days, when fat people knew their place and didn't go round demanding new fangled medication. And lived in gutters cause they spent their dole money on crisps.

llizzie · 15/10/2024 23:39

Ladymuck2022 · 15/10/2024 23:25

I joked with my Mum I should try harder to lose my job which only has a few months to go anyway so a new massive oversight by current div’s in power to make themselves look good for 5 mins.

But in all seriousness my brother who is a paraplegic (through accident a number of year's ago now) and as a more severe diabetic as a type 2 on insulin this mj is one of his last hopes, out of work so no means to pay for it, should be helped in my view.

Let’s hope it opens flood gates to people told to fat to be operated on when it isn’t an emergency - queue weight loss injections for them on prescription to lose weight for that important but denied surgery - no?

Last week as a diabetic offered the soup and shakes diet on the nhs along with 6 other counties in the UK as I’m fed up hearing oh as a type 2 diabetic I automatically qualify for my GP to just blaise write a prescription for mj. I’m fairly insulted I’m active 7 days a week (fit bit proof available for the last 10 months of the year) but got to run with disgusting punches for the laughs.

I will await the red carpet for my unemployment and far more then I can expect beyond the UC. Just another labour insult to working people. Priorities all wrong but nothing shocks me with labour and the so called medical profession.

I sympathise with you. I am disabled, and when things get to me I think about those who are far more disabled than I am, and thank God. He should not have to wait for anything.

People who are diabetic do not have to pay for their medicines, at least I always thought so, and know people who do not have to pay prescription costs. Are you saying that you have been denied the injections? That is shocking.

I cannot really believe what Starmer is doing. It is like a nightmare.

OP posts:
BuzzieLittleBee · 15/10/2024 23:38

I'd like them to use NHS money to carry out plans that are already in place but which don't have the funding before they put another plan in place without the money to do it.

My T1D husband has been repeatedly told he can move onto a closed loop insulin delivery system (NICE guidelines are now that these should be available to all diabetics, but our local trust has just decided to give them to pregnant women and children). He has jumped through all the hoops he was asked to (gone on courses, submitted no end of data, altered some of his regime) and now because his glucose levels are within acceptable levels, they say there isn't a clinical need. Levels are only in an acceptable range because he works bloody hard at keeping them there - constantly checking, injecting way more often, eating different things at different times. His mental health is shot to blazes from working so hard at managing it. He is now way down the list, behind people who don't take good care of themselves and who aren't doing what is within their capabilities to manage their condition. If the funds were there, he could (for the first time in 40 years) live without having to inject 5+ times a day. I'm aware that obesity costs the NHS a lot of money, but I can't bring myself to be pleased that this is a plan that's being given serious consideration.

Tiredallthetimeneedsleep · 15/10/2024 23:37

SpudleyLass · 15/10/2024 21:03

No I think drugs like Ozempic need to be reserved for those who need them I.e diabetics.

Offering relatively quick fix solutions to weight loss has never ended well.

Probably going to get flamed but the best way to tackle being overweight is to diet and exercise. There really are no short cuts.

Hell, I hear you need to diet and exercise even when on these drugs.

Genuine question. Are the injections a forever thing? From what I've heard, they reduce your appetite, hence the weight loss. Surely when you come off them, you get your appetite back ( perhaps even increased) and you put the weight back on?

Superworm24 · 15/10/2024 23:31

Does "the teletext on TV" even exist anymore?

llizzie · 15/10/2024 23:30

SilenceInside · 15/10/2024 22:24

@llizzie Jfc. People have explained to you that this story is about an actual research project! One of the outcomes they will look at will be whether losing weight has any impact on gaining employment. What you are asking for is literally what will be happening.

I object to your suggestion that I am simple minded and unable to understand anything, just because I do not agree with you.

Such pride, which denigrates anyone who disagrees with you? What makes you think you are always right? You have said the very same thing to me on other threads. I don't care.

OP posts:
llizzie · 15/10/2024 23:27

TheGoodEnoughWife · 15/10/2024 23:16

It is clear now @llizzie you are on some sort of wind up but hey ho I am invested now.

It will save the PRIVATE research so much money from running this TRIAL. since the wonder of you have already declared it won't work. Thank goodness you are around. Any other research you would like to assess as being a fail from the start while you are at it?

I think anyone who is obese should be offered weight loss drugs as required on the NHS. Just like I think antidepressants should be offered.

I also think we should accept that people who live with obesity need sympathy and kindness. The ability of some people to control their eating is not the same as others for whatever reasons and there is now medical help for that. Great.

If you feel the need to judge and criticise other people then I feel sorry for you. Educate yourselves.

I question whether what the PM suggested is workable. I knew when I gave reasons that I would be torn apart with them.

I have posted what the BBC repeated from Starmer, the horse's mouth himself. I have misgivings. I think that a man who is leading the country and has our livelihood in his hands has once again spoken out of turn and caused alarm which was totally unnecessary, just because he suddenly got an idea in his head.

Obesity might well be why they are unemployed, though you have to wonder what came first, but if no one will employ them, for fear of not being able to sack them when the weight goes back on, what is the point? They will still be unemployed, still on benefit, and still cost the taxpayer even more.

The drug was not intended for anyone other than diabetics in the first place, and no government has the right to change that in the hope of reducing the unemployment budget, because Starmer ONLY talked about money.

OP posts:
KrankyKumquat · 15/10/2024 23:27

@llizzie
I think it's way past your bedtime. You clearly know nothing about weight loss medications, obesity, health policies, medical research strategies, or employment law and practice.
I'm glad you've found a safe space you can discuss your 'reservations' and I'm sure we're all very grateful to have been entertained by you here this evening, but enough already.

Ladymuck2022 · 15/10/2024 23:25

I joked with my Mum I should try harder to lose my job which only has a few months to go anyway so a new massive oversight by current div’s in power to make themselves look good for 5 mins.

But in all seriousness my brother who is a paraplegic (through accident a number of year's ago now) and as a more severe diabetic as a type 2 on insulin this mj is one of his last hopes, out of work so no means to pay for it, should be helped in my view.

Let’s hope it opens flood gates to people told to fat to be operated on when it isn’t an emergency - queue weight loss injections for them on prescription to lose weight for that important but denied surgery - no?

Last week as a diabetic offered the soup and shakes diet on the nhs along with 6 other counties in the UK as I’m fed up hearing oh as a type 2 diabetic I automatically qualify for my GP to just blaise write a prescription for mj. I’m fairly insulted I’m active 7 days a week (fit bit proof available for the last 10 months of the year) but got to run with disgusting punches for the laughs.

I will await the red carpet for my unemployment and far more then I can expect beyond the UC. Just another labour insult to working people. Priorities all wrong but nothing shocks me with labour and the so called medical profession.

CautiousLurker · 15/10/2024 23:21

Am leaving this thread/and muting because I feel my IQ dropping with every post.

CautiousLurker · 15/10/2024 23:20

llizzie · 15/10/2024 23:17

CautiousLurker · Today 22:54They are hardly going to declare to potential employers that they’ve lost weight, what methods, or hold it over those employees if they regain weight on the job. It will be voluntary (just as covid vaccinations were, because there is such as thing as human rights and we are still signed up to those… and we also are bound by UK data protection laws protecting individuals from invasive scrutiny into medical records etc by employers).

Do you mean to say that someone applying for a job doesn't have to give details to a prospective employer about their health?

I am very surprised. Here's me thinking it was fraud to withhold anything when applying for a job. No wonder our economy is as bad as it is now.

No, they may have to have a medical - but that is still privileged and confidential. The employer has no legal or moral right to know what medications a person is taking or for what ailments unless the employee/applicant choses to disclose it. With respect to a health check prior to confirmation of employment, the medical professional is only legally and ethically permitted to disclose whether they have satisfied the criteria required for employment.

CautiousLurker · 15/10/2024 23:17

llizzie · 15/10/2024 23:14

When the government announces something like this, it is never thought out properly, and therefore it will fail.

Employers have a right to know if the person for interview is applying because they have had treatment for obesity. They have a right to decide whether to employ that person in the first place, and if they put the weight back on when the re are no more jabs. to sack them.

If the idea that obese people can have a drug to get them back to work means employers are willing to take a chance on their keeping the weight off, it cannot get off the ground. Who will employ them?

NO, AN EMPLOYER DOES NOT HAVE A RIGHT TO KNOW AN APPLICANT OR EMPLOYEE IS ON OBESITY MEDICATION. UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES.

I used caps because the idea that they do is totally insane, illegal and contrary to multiple human rights conventions and UK laws.

FFS

llizzie · 15/10/2024 23:17

CautiousLurker · Today 22:54They are hardly going to declare to potential employers that they’ve lost weight, what methods, or hold it over those employees if they regain weight on the job. It will be voluntary (just as covid vaccinations were, because there is such as thing as human rights and we are still signed up to those… and we also are bound by UK data protection laws protecting individuals from invasive scrutiny into medical records etc by employers).

Do you mean to say that someone applying for a job doesn't have to give details to a prospective employer about their health?

I am very surprised. Here's me thinking it was fraud to withhold anything when applying for a job. No wonder our economy is as bad as it is now.

OP posts: