Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you to help me be smart about this mat leave issue?

105 replies

ConkerGame · 15/10/2024 11:24

Struggling with this mat leave issue and hoping the viper hivemind can help me work out how to deal with it! Apologies for the length but didn't want to leave out any relevant factors!

I started a new job 18 months ago. I took it in a bit of a hurry as I wasn't planning to leave my old job, which I loved, but found I was completely side-lined (to the point of not being given any work) after returning from my first mat leave, despite things going really well before I took the leave. I had to get out relatively quickly as I knew I wanted a second DC and would need to be in any new job for a year before qualifying for enhanced mat leave.

I told the recruiter from the very start (and kept repeating) that I needed to see the mat leave policy ASAP as I'm the main breadwinner but he kept fobbing me off and in the end I didn't get to see it until after they had offered me the role (after a gruelling 4 round process, which included me staying up until 1am the night before having all of our family round for DC1's first birthday, preparing a presentation), so obviously I was already quite invested by that point.

The policy is terrible. I was really upset with the recruiter and made it clear to him I would never have even interviewed for the role if I'd seen the policy first, as we need the money, but by this point I was very invested and felt rushed as I had interviewed for a couple of other roles which didn't feel right at all. Despite the policy, I really got on with my now boss, the work was a step up and there was a small pay increase. I even raised my concern with my new boss before accepting the role and he told me that the company realised the policy was terrible and were in the process of updating it, so it should be fine by the time I would need to qualify for it.

Fast forward 18 months, the job has been good but I'm now pregnant and of course the policy has not been updated, leaving DH and I in a very stressful situation. It was true that HR were updating it and I was following its progress as part of the Women's Network, so I was as sure as possible it would be updated this summer, but the Board just hasn't approved the new version and it won't be done in time for me, if at all in the near future. We are talking about a big, successful FTSE 100 company here, not some small, struggling start-up or similar, so there is no excuse for it, it's just not a priority so not being done. I know I took a risk when taking on the role but am honestly just so, so disappointed that nothing has improved in 18 months. I also couldn't time my pregnancy perfectly - if it had taken us 6 months or longer to conceive then we would have been ok financially as they have a 2 year enhanced policy which, while not great, is acceptable. However we were lucky to fall pregnant first time, which of course you can't count on so need to leave a bit of wiggle room and age is not on my side.

My heart says to just completely check out of the company now - they've really screwed us over as a family so why should I care about them? Just work to rule until I go on leave, then go part time and work to rule when I return until I feel ready to apply to move somewhere new. My head says: the job is otherwise good, working to rule would mainly punish my boss and my team, who are in no way to blame for this, I should play the long game as this will be my last mat leave so I won't be affected by the policy after this. Yet another part of me thinks I should fight for an improvement for the next couple of months - speak to anyone I can on the Board and make it clear I'm unhappy, in the hope this will spur them to approve the new policy in time for it to benefit me? But I'm not very senior in the corporate hierarchy (have only spoken to one person on the Board previously) and worried that this could go wrong for me and I'll be frozen out before I'm ready to leave, which would create a bad atmosphere and cause stress around my mat leave, which would be horrible.

Don't really know where to go from here :-( Please nobody respond telling me I'm lucky to get mat leave at all, lucky to have a job at all, etc. that's all the bare minimum we should be expecting - I'm a highly skilled professional and know my worth to the company (as does my boss and his boss). Just looking for a fair package for women in 2024 from a large, successful company, but apparently that's still too much to ask for...

OP posts:
JustMarriedBecca · 15/10/2024 13:11

I wouldn't rock the boat for two months pay.

I'd be looking at your outgoings. Why would your son be in nursery if you were at home? I moved jobs post second mat leave after negotiating a compromise agreement during my second pregnancy and so didn't put my eldest in nursery when the second was born as I was at home. Was nice.

LostMySocks · 15/10/2024 13:10

As you are the main income can you do shared parental with your partner? You take a shorter time and he takes the rest up to a year. Does his job offer enhanced parental or shared parental.
Might save on childcare for a short period and children will have a parent at home for the full year.
Do you have the option for overtime? Can you increase your income over the qualifying period giving a higher than normal wage during the statutory 6 weeks at 90% period. This can also work if bonus timing hits in the right months.
Could you negotiate returning part time for a short period so you still have some income?

TemuSpecialBuy · 15/10/2024 13:09

I’d go to boss initially and say you want approval / special dispensation/ whatever and you want sign off on 2 yr enhanced when you go on mat leave.
Ultimately you’ll prob then need your bosses boss or VP and maybe HR to sign it off.

if declined or rationale requested I’d say it’s a make good on your expectations from when you were offered the job.
Ie I’d explain you took the job based on good faith and expectation of an updated policy… offering you 2yr enhanced is the right thing to do given policy is not updated.
if they don’t want to give you the enhanced you take that as a clear message from the business re your value and will be operating accordingly,

If they decline still I would then be very liberal / free and easy with my sick leave in the run up (only up to the point they can force mat leave commencement) but then I’d be present but checked out and take up mat leave very late. I started mine the day before I gave birth with my second child.

MissScarletInTheBallroom · 15/10/2024 13:04

Pleasebeafleabite · 15/10/2024 12:39

Maybe a wake up call to the OP who needs to start taking responsibility for her own choices before she inflicts a work to rule on her manager and team members.

She was the one who kept on interviewing despite not seeing the policy. She was the one who agreed to the contract terms that were given. She is the one who got pregnant too early to benefit from enhanced maternity pay.

None of that is helpful to her in this situation. She's been there 18 months and she was led to believe that this was going to be addressed. Frankly their mat pay policy is absolutely pathetic for a large company. No wonder they're not keen to share it with recruiters.

I think it would be worth having a meeting with her boss and saying, "The company's mat pay policy really isn't in line with what other employers are offering. Everyone knows this. I was told repeatedly that the new policy was going to be brought in and it was just a case of the board signing off on it now it's been mothballed, what, indefinitely? Why? What's going on?"

She could also consider leaving a review on Glassdoor to warn any potential job candidates.

Personally I think the government should make it a legal requirement for employers to publish their maternity pay policy on their website.

Onlyonekenobe · 15/10/2024 13:03

Is this an American firm? If so, ime nothing will change unless they’re forced to change: pressure locally, local laws, etc. On that basis, I would use the rest of my pregnancy to secure another job for when my mat leave expires (this family unfriendly a firm wouldn’t have been for me when I had two small children at home), and think hard about how my DH and I can afford for me to be home longer than 8 weeks eh if I’m home maybe I could cut back on paid childcare.

You’ve made all the decisions at each step and this is where you are. Blaming everyone else in a “recruitment company did this, board did that” way isn’t helpful or productive (the opposite, actually). Take better control of your choices from now on. This could end up being the easy part, babies and toddlers and two working parents can be difficult years.

FinallyHere · 15/10/2024 13:02

All you can do is push via the women's network for the policy to be reconsidered

In any large corporate, however good or bad the pay and conditions are, there is always scope for the right individuals to negotiate themselves an even better deal.

IMO the first place to start is to see how supportive your boss is prepared to be. Establishing their position active supporter, passive supporter or blocker lets you know where you are starting from.

Then start reaching out for other contacts, of course include the women's network, try every single other contact you can find. Ideally you want someone with no add to grind to desperately want to keep you and prepared to make that happen

Position it however you like, negotiate yourself a better deal and/or bring about approval for the enhance policy sooner. If approval has been blocked, find out why and have a go at converting the blocker. Whatever the result, if you go about it in a business like way, you are demonstrating your competence at business.

This is what you do, you have got it.

I don't know any corporate with a really good policy that didn't have someone who was key in bringing it about. The more junior you are the better. People will remember and it can really help your career to be known for getting seemingly unpopular policies adopted.

Good luck

You have got this.

rainfallpurevividcat · 15/10/2024 12:54

I would ask for enhanced - if you don't ask you don't get. And it doesn't sound like you want to be around much longer anyway.

SaltySallyAnne · 15/10/2024 12:50

dreamer24 · 15/10/2024 12:31

Your chances of getting pregnant don’t increase every month you try. So saying you started trying as time wasn’t on your side is just nonsensical.

I think the point is that a woman's chances of pregnancy decrease with time, therefore starting earlier makes sense if you're at or heading towards an age where you're past peak fertility.

It won’t drop in 3-6 months that significantly!

Pleasebeafleabite · 15/10/2024 12:44

MissScarletInTheBallroom · 15/10/2024 12:25

They're not updating it. They've been saying they are updating it but they are not actually doing that. It doesn't take years to do these things if you are actually committed to doing them.

Any business the size of OPs employer has no doubt been very sensibly awaiting sight of the new employment bill and the autumn statement before they make any decision on improvements to benefits.

There is very likely to be a significant rise in employer NICs which will need to be factored into overall remuneration strategy

ringmybe11 · 15/10/2024 12:42

Our policy changed while I was on mat leave - I had the equivalent of 9 weeks full and then down to stat. What I also got though was a return to work bonus which is repayable if you leave within a year. I would try to find out more about the new policy that's pending implementation and if there's any way you can benefit from that, if not maybe try and get a return to work bonus with conditions attached as it shows you're genuine about staying there. It will be easier for the company to approve that as a one off payment rather than give you special maternity pay out of policy. I realise there could be a cash flow impact of that coming at the end of mat leave but could you make that work.

HowYouSpellingThat10 · 15/10/2024 12:40

I understand why you are frustrated but you have to go about this in the right way.

I agree with others that for 8 weeks pay, it isn't worth ruining your long term prospects there.

All you can do is push via the women's network for the policy to be reconsidered. Are there any minor changes that might help it get through? Is it better to settle for a lower level of improvement to benefit women now and then to continue to push for more later.

Could the carry over of annual leave be improved to allow it to be put on the end of mat leave (if not in place already).

I don't see how any arrangements can be made for you individually without it landing them in hot water elsewhere.

Are there any other policies you can take advantage of? We can purchase two weeks additional annual leave. Could you do something like this and take it in the run up to mat leave so you save all your paid period for after the birth?

You won't need childcare if on mat leave so that's a cost you can change. Otherwise it's cutting right back and taking a shorter time off or shared paternity leave. Sorry

Pleasebeafleabite · 15/10/2024 12:39

MissScarletInTheBallroom · 15/10/2024 12:24

I'm not sure what all of the people sticking the boot in are hoping to achieve with their "helpful" comments.

Maybe a wake up call to the OP who needs to start taking responsibility for her own choices before she inflicts a work to rule on her manager and team members.

She was the one who kept on interviewing despite not seeing the policy. She was the one who agreed to the contract terms that were given. She is the one who got pregnant too early to benefit from enhanced maternity pay.

mitogoshigg · 15/10/2024 12:38

You have only been there 18 months, insisting on 2 years service before enhanced maternity kicks in seems fair enough to me. Many employers only offer statutory, it's hardly rare.

lateatwork · 15/10/2024 12:35

It's not just women. It's leave for baby care (and adoption). They will all be aligned. So, whilst you are main breadwinner, and will be giving birth, the benefit of the mat policy will also be applied to fathers. Whether they opt to take it not is another thing....

So, that means the people impacted is not just the women's network... So use other means to lobby too

And, the 'cost' to the business will not just be female staff- but to any staff that have a new baby or adopted child. For women, that will generally end when they can't pop out a kid anymore , and for men it could be well into their 80's.

So, if men were sensible and actually thought about it, they have more of an interest to lobby for it as the benefit applies to them for more years.

Motnight · 15/10/2024 12:34

Timeforaglassofwine · 15/10/2024 11:53

You haven't been screwed over op, you did have the information but weighed up the fact that you wanted the job against the bad maternity policy. What is the policy BTW, and is there scope for negotiation.

Agree with this.

Lemonadeand · 15/10/2024 12:32

Does DH have a better policy at his work? Look at shared parental leave?

dreamer24 · 15/10/2024 12:31

Your chances of getting pregnant don’t increase every month you try. So saying you started trying as time wasn’t on your side is just nonsensical.

I think the point is that a woman's chances of pregnancy decrease with time, therefore starting earlier makes sense if you're at or heading towards an age where you're past peak fertility.

ANiceCuppaTeaandBiscuit · 15/10/2024 12:26

Nugget have a masterclass on how to negotiate better parental leave you might find useful https://www.nuggetsavings.com/category/all-products

DownThePubWithStevieNicks · 15/10/2024 12:25

Does your DH work FT but earn a lot less than you, or is he a SAHP? If the latter, can he get some work for the period you want to be on mat leave? If it’s the former, what can you do to reduce outgoings during leave, e.g. taking your eldest out of childcare, asking for interest only on the mortgage? Sounds like you must live in London or another big city if you work for a FTSE 100, so can you get rid of car?

If you can’t negotiate your package, it’s either increase income from your DH, or make sacrifices to seriously cut your outgoings. If neither are possible, you’ll need to start facing up to going back much sooner than you’d like - whilst having contingency plans in case you’re not physically able.

MissScarletInTheBallroom · 15/10/2024 12:25

Overthebow · 15/10/2024 12:23

They are updating it though it just won't be ready in the timeframe that you need it to be. It's not a personal insult to you. You knew that it hadn't been done when you took the job and then decided to TTC.

Edited

They're not updating it. They've been saying they are updating it but they are not actually doing that. It doesn't take years to do these things if you are actually committed to doing them.

Boltonb · 15/10/2024 12:25

Well you’ve taken a lot of risks, and they haven’t paid off. It’s all down to you though, and it’s your responsibility/mistake.

You do have options, that don’t need to involve sabotaging your job/relationship with your boss and team.

Negotiate.
Start saving now to cover the 8 weeks pay gap
Share parental leave
Don’t take the full 12 months
Borrow the money to afford full maternity leave, and pay it back when you’re working full time again.

MissScarletInTheBallroom · 15/10/2024 12:24

I'm not sure what all of the people sticking the boot in are hoping to achieve with their "helpful" comments.

MissScarletInTheBallroom · 15/10/2024 12:23

@ConkerGame How many weeks pregnant are you and how sure are you that you won't qualify for the two years' enhanced mat pay?

Overthebow · 15/10/2024 12:23

ConkerGame · 15/10/2024 12:13

@SprigatitoYouAndIKnow it's not just the recruitment company though - it's the company I work for. They clearly don't value female employees at all and it just makes me wonder why I bother going above and beyond for a male board who don't care about me.

They are updating it though it just won't be ready in the timeframe that you need it to be. It's not a personal insult to you. You knew that it hadn't been done when you took the job and then decided to TTC.

narns · 15/10/2024 12:22

Do you definitely have to have worked there for two years before becoming pregnant? I'm sure you've read it properly I'm just suggesting to check because it might be that you work there for two years before the baby is born, or you're 25 weeks pregnant etc and given you've been there 18 months already you might end up qualifying x