Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it weaponised incompetence or are men just rubbish?

114 replies

NarnianQueen · 15/10/2024 10:35

I absolutely believe that men pretend they can't do things like cooking or laundry without making a disaster of it, so they won't be asked again, but now I'm starting to wonder... I've seen so many men struggle with simple tasks when it really isn't going to benefit them to do it badly. Sometimes I think it's because they believe their way of doing it is the proper way, and everyone else is bodging it. My dh will meticulously place items in the dishwasher, taking 40 minutes to stack it, whereas I would take 5-10 minutes to shove it in - probably not to his liking, but perfectly adequately. But it's one of his jobs (his choice!) so I know he's not doing it slowly to make me take over. Same with guys at work - I work in events, and there can be lots of waiting around - when a man's in charge we all just stand around, when a woman is running it, she will always say "While we're waiting for the lights, let's sort out x..." You get so much more done.
They genuinely seem to struggle with things that women just get on with! Anyone else notice similar?

OP posts:
Hadalifeonce · 16/10/2024 08:25

Despite being 'trained' by me (his anal mum) DS has developed this good enough attitude to, seemingly, everything in life. He sees no point in going the extra mile when good enough, is good enough. He is so much more laid back than me. In some ways I am a little envious.

Purplestorm83 · 16/10/2024 08:20

Anonymous2224 · 15/10/2024 16:28

I think it’s a bit of both, I’m sure some men use incompetence as a weapon but not always. People are better at different things, my husband is brilliant at lots of stuff, is an amazing father and an amazing husband and more than pulls his weight at home, however… he’s useless at cooking, useless picking outfits for the kids and doing DDs hair, and really not the best at doing the shopping (generally forgets lots of stuff). The other side of this is I’m hopeless at gardening, DIY and managing the finances. We have “our” stuff and as long as it’s somewhat equal I don’t see any problem in each person sticking to their jobs.

Also men and women’s brains ARE different and traditionally male and female tasks started that way because it is generally speaking what each gender is good at!

I’m sorry but bollocks to your last paragraph - are you a tradwife?

Willoo · 16/10/2024 08:19

I hate loading the dishwasher so I did it in a really bad way. My DH now does it all the time so I never have to do it. It’s not just men.

inamarina · 16/10/2024 08:08

GinAndJuice99 · 15/10/2024 15:46

You throwing everything in the dishwasher willy nilly might save time but it might also lead to problems down the line.

The stuff might come out still dirty and need scrubbing
Failure to rinse might lead to a blocked drain
Things might break or chip
Items placed the wrong way around might retain dirty soapy water

Thought about all that, then? Mmm?

Ha, I agree! It’s definitely not taking me 40 min to load the dishwasher (how is that even possible?), but I do make sure it‘s done properly.
Hate it when stuff comes out dirty or the filter gets blocked up with muck 😣

TheBitchOfTheVicar · 16/10/2024 07:47

CheerfulBunny · 15/10/2024 15:26

@Comedycook This. For example, my OH will clean the bathroom once a year to a forensic degree (and then tell me how I should be doing it) whereas I do it every other day to a basic level which goes unnoticed. He expects a biscuit (thank you) when he does domestic stuff where I just get on with it, mostly.

Oh my god yes

TheaBrandt · 16/10/2024 07:39

Dh is very competent does most of the laundry. He is a good cook but my god he is slow. You cannot be a perfectionist chef when bashing together Tuesday tea before activities. He cooks weekends only now.

CommanderHaysPaperKnife · 16/10/2024 07:36

yeah, if they wanted to do it well they would... most of them hold down jobs...so presumably they turn up to work on time looking clean and presentable.

Many just don't care if the house is untidy and the dishes are unwashed.

Some are very tidy and clean though, my BIL is. And it's his wife who is messy... though she is still cleaner and tidier than your average man.

Jessica167353 · 16/10/2024 07:34

This is a really interesting threat and the PP Felix sums up my suspicions. No malice in it, just men have different brains and can’t hold the thousands of parallel thoughts that woman might be having in a day regarding school uniform, shopping, Christmas thinking that starts happening in October, what’s for dinner, ingredients needed for dinner etc etc. I do think they would cope without woman but the world/house would be a dirtier and less organised place. Kids would turn up to school half dressed and fed on whatever is in the cupboards. They’d probably all be perfectly happy and would get around to it all eventually just in a really inefficient way. All the dads would be at the supermarket the night before Christmas jumper day rather than just a handful of mums. Or maybe they would forget completely and all the stupid pointless things that mums have to do everyday would fall away and cease to exist. Like natural selection for household jobs.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 16/10/2024 07:32

I don't know tbh. My DH seems perfectly capable and he pulls his weight. He doesn't always approach tasks in the same way that I would, but I don't always assume that my way is the only right way, so this isn't really an issue.

Jessica167353 · 16/10/2024 07:26

Maray1967 · 15/10/2024 15:54

There’s a happy medium though isn’t there? Mine is well stacked with none of those problems, and I rinse very dirty plates and cutlery, but I’m very fast at doing it. 40
minutes is a complete joke.

My DH does one thing at a time - stands there while the kettle is on, doing nothing else. It’s very rare that I do that - there’s usually something else that can be done .

The unloading and re-loading of the dishwasher takes the EXACT same time as making a cup of tea!

Purpleturtle46 · 16/10/2024 07:25

Comedycook · 15/10/2024 15:20

I've noticed that when my dh has to carry out a household task... loading the dishwasher, hanging out the laundry etc he will do it 100 times better than me...but imo thats because hes only focusing on that task. Whereas if I'm loading the dishwasher, I'm also probably making dinner, wiping down the surfaces and helping DD with her homework at the same time.

I agree with this. I made a lovely Chinese meal from scratch the other night and was a bit stressed playing it all up at the same time and asked husband to put the rice in the microwave, omg, what a palava reading the instructions within an inch of their life asking about 50 questions about it, ahhhhh! He is a good cook himself but needs a huge amount of time to do it.

Lookslikemeemaw · 16/10/2024 07:13

No idea, but as a gay woman I can tell you that this generally isn’t a thing in my gay men friend’s relationships!
The male couples manage to run households - from cooking to cleaning to laundry to mowing the lawn to fixing the car to taking out bins to doing DIY etc - just as well as me and DW do…
And my widower dad has an immaculate house and garden so he too seems to be able to manage it all.

cookiebee · 16/10/2024 07:13

Couples seem to slot themselves into what will be their normal early on in a relationship. Many a 50/50 split of everything or some happily negotiate a labour split that works for them, you won’t read much about these couples on here because they are happy and functioning as a team. But for all these sort of couples getting on with life in the background, there are the ones who have a shit time with a lazy man and an overworked woman, but personally I’ve got no sympathy for either, it’s their fault that they formed these shitty unbalanced relationships.

Couples like this get together and a woman won’t care she’s treated like shit because her guy is hot or cute when he lays there on the couch and lets her serve him and of course he’s never gonna change, he can do fuck all, but eventually that lazy twat is laying on that couch with a beer belly, she’s run ragged with a twat but it’s too late, they are stuck together, they forged their dynamic while blinded by love, but when you first start dating you’ve got to look out for these red flags, and I don’t believe they are not there.

Another type of scenario I’ve seen with toxic couples is a woman who micro manages and martyrs herself, they guy cares enough but not to her standards and she takes on too much stress and everything has to be her way, it’s usually controlling and I equally have no sympathy for a guy who lives with that sort of shit, that controlling behaviour would be there from the start.

what I’m saying is at the beginning we need to look out for red flags and what sort of relationship we want to have, it can be done, most are not manipulated into these situations, some are but not most, but lots are blind at the beginning and don’t want to see these faults until it’s too late, I have no sympathy for men or women who don’t look objectively for a life partner who will work with them.

Barney16 · 16/10/2024 07:01

In my experience if there's something a bloke wants to do or is interested in doing it will be done. Otherwise forget it. They have zero interest in anything unless it's particularly important to them. Completely focussed on self.
Add that to a herculean level of laziness exhibited by most men and you have the usual situation where women do almost everything whilst carrying huge amounts of mental load for children, elderly parents, siblings and men just carry on unbothered.

There is always some paragon of virtue, a man whose great with their children, great cook, brilliant at house work but they are outliers and frankly why would they be seen as amazing when women just do all that stuff anyway.

Comedycook · 16/10/2024 06:28

One thing I've noticed a lot of men like doing in the home is cooking for big events or social occasions....they do this because they enjoy it and because it leads to plenty of praise. They also invariably use every utensil and trash the kitchen which the wife ends up sorting out, whilst the man basks in the glory of his amazing meal. They also dress this whole spectacle up as 'helping' and the guests loudly proclaim as to how lucky the wife is.

So yeah, they can do it when the rewards are high enough

dottiehens · 16/10/2024 05:11

My father was the perfect man doing all the repairs and maintenance and also used to cook and drive everyone to places with a big smile and sense of humour. I took this for granted I guess. I unfortunately married a person whose mother and father did everything for him. ( realised much too late) Therefore, once we got a big house he came out as useless plus also very tight to outsource help. It is a nightmare in our house when things need to be repaired or even maintenance. I feel he also pretends he is rubbish at most things not to help. He moans endlessly about anything you ask. Damage cause for late repairs costs more sometimes. He is not good and very grumpy all the time so I had enough. Divorce is imminent as he is ruined our day to day and I resent and loss respect for him.

Diomi · 16/10/2024 04:59

It isn’t weaponised incompetence. It is simply not doing jobs that you don’t want to do or don’t think are necessary. I actually think virtually everyone does it (men and women) except a few people who have something to prove and have to show they are competent at everything. Surely there are things that you have no interest in doing but you could do if you really had to?

Thepossibility · 16/10/2024 04:53

My DH absolutely tries his best and would never weaponise incompetence but he is much slower than me at tasks. Often I would rather do it so I can have him on hand helping with the children rather than him pissing about forever doing something I could do in less than half the time.

RickiRaccoon · 16/10/2024 04:38

I used to allocate work in my team. Generally speaking, if you wanted something done accurately, you'd give it to one of the women who were more likely to stress about doing it right and on time. If you wanted something done fast but with errors, give it to one of the men. Men also won't tend to pitch in or help out other team members in the same way as women.

I'd say, generally speaking (because there's always exceptions), men choose not to take on extra responsibility easily. When they do choose to do something, they are still more likely not to ask or to look up how and are happy for their work to have mistakes. eg When we had a baby, I was constantly online looking up what to do. My husband was very involved but happy to just wing it.

lolit · 16/10/2024 04:35

It's a combination of weaponised incompetence and indifference. They won't do chores or will do them badly because they are simply indifferent to them. People put effort into things they care about and a lot of men don't care about living in a clean and tidy house.

MermaidMummy06 · 16/10/2024 04:06

When my DH does housework it's far better than my efforts because I do it quickly. He can take 30 minutes to hang or fold a load of washing.

However, he also doesn't prioritise those tasks unless they're shoved in front of him & he knows it's expected. I.e., washing machine beeping repeatedly or he's asked to do something. He has a couple of weekly cleaning jobs we've allocated at his, because I was sick of doing it all. I REFUSE to do them. Come Saturday I pointed out they hadn't been done yet as I went to do groceries. Came home to him watching YouTube & DC on screens. It's just not his priority. He did it, because I said I wasn't doing it. I'll be doing the same this week, too.

Edingril · 16/10/2024 04:06

Well men manage to live on their own and have jobs and do all manner of grown things like my husband

If they are so bad how on earth do they have partners?

LostittoBostik · 16/10/2024 03:50

Oh god @Appletreepots I wouldn't ever leave a man in charge of your finances - that way hell lies.

LostittoBostik · 16/10/2024 03:48

@Appletreepots did that not give you the most enormous ICK? !

LostittoBostik · 16/10/2024 03:47

yeaitsmeagain · 15/10/2024 16:43

Honestly I think women are just accepting lower and lower standards.

My partner would never act like this, and he's equally or more competent than me at basically everything.

But this is probably because he's been raised well and also has to do these types of tasks all the time. If he doesn't do his laundry, he can't leave the house (unless he wants to go out naked) because I don't do it for him. So it's pretty quick learning once it's happened once.

He's not perfect, but if I remind him of something house-related he was supposed to do/didn't spot, he'll happily do it the second time.

If you're an enabler then no, they will never learn to do things, or they'll learn them but never do them because someone else will.

I don't think so. My father (now in 70s) has barely done a single day's worth of domestic tasks in 50 years of marriage

Swipe left for the next trending thread