Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand the snobbery around skiing?

287 replies

Cappuccinowithonesugarplease · 14/10/2024 06:22

An actual conversation I overheard:

"Virtually anyone can afford to go skiing these days"

Do people really still think like this in 2024? It just seems so classist....

OP posts:
Neurodiversitydoctor · 14/10/2024 08:29

Cappuccinowithonesugarplease · 14/10/2024 06:54

10 grand 😳

I'm sure you can go to eastern europe skiing for much less than that. I guess the alps must be the cream of the crop so to speak

Actually the alps isn't what it was. Canada or Japan are the real cream of the crop.

ohtowinthelottery · 14/10/2024 08:26

I've got 2 (totally unconnected) friends who go on skiing holidays as adults, neither of whom went skiing as children and both from very working class backgrounds. Obviously they have more disposable income as adults than their parents ever had.

GrouachMacbeth · 14/10/2024 08:25

Cappuccinowithonesugarplease · 14/10/2024 06:22

An actual conversation I overheard:

"Virtually anyone can afford to go skiing these days"

Do people really still think like this in 2024? It just seems so classist....

You can go skiing somewhere that is probably within 400 miles of where you live. The water is same to drink, they speak the same language and the natives are usually friendly. Scotland-shire.
Glencoe, Aviemore, The Lecht, Glenshee - all good skies areas, handy for us former schemies fae Dundee and Embra, ken.

Saschka · 14/10/2024 08:25

Timeforaglassofwine · 14/10/2024 06:52

It's a sport. Learning to ski isn't expensive, going skiing though is. When my kids were young we lived near a dry ski slope. Every school holidays the slope ran day camps, so for £40 a day for the two of them they got a couple of ski lessons plus a hot lunch and activities. They can both ski pretty well. Scout and schools run ski trips, at a cost of about £1,500.

Exactly. I used to live in a country (Canada) with a lot of snow, and everyone could ski (mostly cross country) and/or ice skate. There were free cross country tracks in the park, and free outdoor rinks everywhere. Good second hand market for equipment - my ice skates cost $20. People did ice skating at school in PE. All kids already own snow pants etc for playing outside.

It’s a marker of being MC here because it costs a fortune to go to the alps in Feb half term, but that isn’t the case if you eg live in Germany and can drive to a non-glamorous slope in Bavaria on a normal weekend, or live in Finland and can go to a local slope.

Lemonadeand · 14/10/2024 08:22

It depends. Ski to and from door with a lovely chalet and a chalet maid? Still exclusive. Getting a coach each morning up to the mountain? Much more affordable.

CautiousLurker · 14/10/2024 08:20

lamiconds · 14/10/2024 06:50

The thing with skiing is that it's a signal of multiple generational wealth

Almost no one takes up skiing as an adult - I said "almost" not none to be clear for the pedants - because as an adult, it's a lot of money to spend on a holiday that you might not like and where there are few other options if you don't like it

So it's a signal that you are from a wealthy family because you went skiing as a child and so did your parents etc etc

Sorry but this is BS. My DH and his BFFs from school all go skiing. They took it up in their 20s when they were single income lads and working because they were bored of going on boys’ piss up holidays. They went cheap - stayed in hostels, hired the cheapest boots saved their money for beer and ski passes. One was a chef and on shit pay. They all went to the standard (rubbish) local comp, had never been introduced to it via family (in fact most grew up on interrail and caravan holidays). They went because they wanted a holiday where they DO something other than leer at bikini clad girls on shite beaches all day and start drinking at lunchtime because there is nothing else to do.

30 years later by DH and his mates take my/their kids every year (I have a fear of high open spaces after a childhood accident), and yes it is expensive when taking kids, trying to rent an apartment that essentially 3 adults can use (2 hotel rooms costs even more). The cheap, but fun, ski train that used to run before lock down to enable cheap/short ski weekends has only just started up again and packed/infrequent, so the biggest cost is flights/transfers and the rip off accommodation costs. The kids’ first encounter was a school trip (around £700 I think, offered as part birthday gift). All the men in this group are very successful in their fifties, so they no longer need to go to hostels, can afford decent hotels/apartments, and pull the stops out on which resorts and slope passes they buy the kids so yes, they are pretty loaded now… but they weren’t for the first decade of doing it.

So yes, there is a huge amount of inverted snobbery - the assumption that people who ski have their own family ski chalet with chalet maids etc is the stuff of crap films and Jilly Cooper. Rather as believing all private schools are Eton.

Frankly, I’ve never moved in circles (investment banking before kids, but again no generational wealth here, I started life in a council flat with a single mother on benefits) where anyone was thought less of for not having skiied since they were 3. Most of them just love the sport, the scenery, the air, the apre ski beers/parties.

massistar · 14/10/2024 08:19

I learned as an adult but married someone from a country where you could ski relatively easily on a day trip. It's only in this country that it's seen as an elitist holiday. Big French and Swiss resorts will be full of British posh people but go to smaller resorts in France or Italy, Andorra etc and it's full of pretty normal people who just love an active holiday. That being said we spend around 4.5-5 k all in so it's not exactly within everyone's reach but not more than a week's AI in August.

TickingAlongNicely · 14/10/2024 08:18

YourLastNerve · 14/10/2024 08:16

Austria, at Christmas. No ski school needed (kids now 11&13), own equipment (except the kids ski boots) but ski passes for whole valley. Self catering apartment.

Does that include:

  • flights
  • other travel if not flying- ferries, petrol & tolls to drive there
  • Food? If you are self catered thats a lot of meals to sort when out skiing all day

Is it for a full week & is it within the state school holiday period?

Edited

Flights for people, 2 people driving (a 7 seater car) with equipment. And yes, in the school holidays!

Its not a resort popular with Brits so is quiet at Christmas... but lots of snow as its glacier.

Worldgonecrazy · 14/10/2024 08:17

I’ve noticed a shift from ‘do you ski?’ To ‘where do you ski?’

Plus the office conversation will move to discuss a tricky bit of the black run at wherever is perceived to be the current in place.

Snobs will always find a way to judge.

drspouse · 14/10/2024 08:17

My DH grew up in a council tower block after his back to back was pulled down.
He learned to ski as an adult.
I learned to ski as a child because my parents met in a country where it's the norm, and my DM grew up in an area where it's also the norm.
My dad however is from "that background" and his family had been skiing for about 100 years. My DF is in his 80s and still does cross country.

If we go skiing it costs more than our "main" holiday which is £2000 for self catering.
A friend just booked AI for £8000 for a week.
It's definitely a cultural thing but not exclusively middle class.

miserablecat · 14/10/2024 08:16

Tiredalwaystired · 14/10/2024 07:37

And if you’re a family of four there is a MASSIVE difference between being able to afford to pay for one person only.

Skiing isn’t all inclusive either. There are additional costs on top. Plus you probably need to pay for some beginner lessons when you go

so waaaay more expensive

DH went skiing in his late teens/early 20s. I think thry used to go by coach to keep costs down.

He's been comparatively cheaply in recent years because he goes with BIL and mates outside school holidays. BIL friend has an apartment that they use for mates rates. They make most of their own food in the apartment, and they can all ski so no lessons needed. DH has most of the clothes he needs, but hires skis. When we've looked to go as a family of 4 (where 3 of us have never skiied) it is more expensive than our usual holiday budget

YourLastNerve · 14/10/2024 08:16

Austria, at Christmas. No ski school needed (kids now 11&13), own equipment (except the kids ski boots) but ski passes for whole valley. Self catering apartment.

Does that include:

  • flights
  • other travel if not flying- ferries, petrol & tolls to drive there
  • Food? If you are self catered thats a lot of meals to sort when out skiing all day

Is it for a full week & is it within the state school holiday period?

TriangleSquareFringe · 14/10/2024 08:15

lamiconds · 14/10/2024 07:48

I do know some people who learned as adults but they either married someone who loved it and grew up skiing or had a crowd of friends who loved it and grew up skiing. It's just a pretty intimidating thing to do if you haven't done it as a child and don't know what you're doing or where to go.

This would be me. I go into a cold sweat thinking about it. We've had lots of invites from DH family to join them but simply can't afford it. An ex boss would go annually and loved telling us about it, mainly the wine drinking. I would always scratch my head at that. Wine and ski, what a combination!

Willyoujustbequiet · 14/10/2024 08:13

Cappuccinowithonesugarplease · 14/10/2024 06:35

See I didn't think it was much more expensive than say an all inclusive somewhere. One of the years in my sons school all got to go skiing, pretty much all of them went, and it's a normal state school. 🤔

State school does not equate to poor parents.

RosesAndHellebores · 14/10/2024 08:12

NoraLuka · 14/10/2024 06:56

I think it’s difficult to get into as an adult if you never went as a child. Do they even do lessons for adults? My DC went with school and I made sure I saved up for them to go because it was much cheaper than taking them myself. I’ve never been because it would blow my entire holiday budget for the year and I’m afraid of the ski lifts. I would actually love to try it, apart from the ski lifts!

I think some families take it for granted that skiing is something you do. In our family we had my grandma who went skiing once in the 1950s, broke her leg after literally 15 minutes on the slopes and spent the rest of her life warning people against the dangers of it!

DH got into it as an adult. He started taking DS from about the age of 7 and they learnt together. They still ski every February and DS is 29 and married!

I went once before I got married. I hated it and should have known as I don't especially like looking down from the top of an escalator! And no I don't just want Apres, I prefer the sun - frankly I'd rather hoover!

Suzuki70 · 14/10/2024 08:12

BuzzieLittleBee · 14/10/2024 07:48

I'd be interested to know how it compares, cost wise, with a trip to Disney in Florida. Or even Paris.

Every time I baulk at the price of a lift pass, I always remind myself that it's essentially the cost of entry to a massive theme park, and access to use all its facilities. Can you get into Disney for €50 a day? And hotels/food there are presumably way more than they are for skiing?

Working on the assumption that Disney costs more, it's interesting that it has none of the snobbery aimed at it that skiing has. And whilst SOME skiers go every year, SOME people also go to Disney multiple times. But without the same raised eyebrows!

We are skiing New Year week for £6k all in (apart from lunch) for a family of 4 (Inc lessons for the kids), so it's most definitely doable for under 10K!

I went to Disneyland Paris for 5 nights last May for 3 of us; including flights and hotel and tickets it was £1800. Then another £400ish for food.

Mumsnet is awash with snobbery about Disney!

Ginmonkeyagain · 14/10/2024 08:09

That's exactly my worry, what if I don't like it - what else is there to do?

I went on my first package beach holiday at 19, it was a cheap and cheerful package to Kos. I worked out quickly I am not a "lounge on the beach and have cocktails in the hotel bar" person. But it is easy on the Greek Islands to find other stuff to do - which I did.

Suzuki70 · 14/10/2024 08:09

Sassysoonwins · 14/10/2024 06:53

Exactly this. Around here several families ski in Feb, main holiday in July and then cornwall or the lakes in Oct. We have one holiday and I want that to have sun and a pool. I have never wanted to ski. It is a class mark question though. 'Do you ski?', means 'Are you in my tribe?', no I am definitely not!

Yep, it's usually one of three or four trips because they just fancy a few days away at half term. £10k later...

Ozanj · 14/10/2024 08:08

When people say that they’re usually being racist. More and more wealthy people Indian and Nigerian origin are going skiing now.

RampantIvy · 14/10/2024 08:08

RosesAndHellebores · 14/10/2024 06:47

The thing about ski-ing is that it's rarely the main or only annual holiday.

I agree. For many years we could only afford to go away once a year.
A holiday in the Med was a far more enticing option than a week's skiing.

I eventually did get to try skiing one afternoon when we did a winter holiday to Lapland. I'm glad that I didn't have a whole week of it.

blackteaplease · 14/10/2024 08:06

Timeforaglassofwine · 14/10/2024 06:52

It's a sport. Learning to ski isn't expensive, going skiing though is. When my kids were young we lived near a dry ski slope. Every school holidays the slope ran day camps, so for £40 a day for the two of them they got a couple of ski lessons plus a hot lunch and activities. They can both ski pretty well. Scout and schools run ski trips, at a cost of about £1,500.

Definitely this. If you live near a dry slope, indoor snow place or actual ski resort in Scotland its pretty cheap to learn. Going abroad skiing is costly but can be cheaper if you self cater, avoid the French alps and drive. I do know families that only go skiing on holiday and don't take a summer holiday for various reasons.

lamiconds · 14/10/2024 08:04

lamiconds · 14/10/2024 06:50

The thing with skiing is that it's a signal of multiple generational wealth

Almost no one takes up skiing as an adult - I said "almost" not none to be clear for the pedants - because as an adult, it's a lot of money to spend on a holiday that you might not like and where there are few other options if you don't like it

So it's a signal that you are from a wealthy family because you went skiing as a child and so did your parents etc etc

The other thing, thinking about it, that I would add to this is that it gets more fun the more you do it and the better that you are. It's not especially fun to do as a one off.

So that's another way it self selects for multi generational wealth - most skiers have been able to afford to do it multiple times in their childhood, and their parents did it often enough in their childhood too etc etc

Ginmonkeyagain · 14/10/2024 08:02

I have never been skiing as I grew in a fairly low income family - holidays were few days Norfolk or Wales, or staying with family.

these days I have the money, but I don't like being cold or falling over - so why would I spend money on a holiday that seems to involve both of those things? (Also I secretly think everyone there will be awful)

xxSideshowAuntSallyxx · 14/10/2024 08:01

I don't think it's posh, or elite or any more expensive than an AI somewhere but people would rather go AI to the Caribbean or Disney or Dubai than skiing. It has an image of being posh because the Royals do it, the wealthy do it but so can Joe Bloggs down the road. My friends do it and they're not wealthy, they're your average Joe.

Different people have different preferences to a holiday. For me I'd choose skiing over Disney or an AI for two weeks. I'd get bored stiff sat by a pool for longer than a day, I need to be doing something. I'd rather be in the mountains than on a beach anyway.

I went when I was 10 and would love to go again.

Doingmybest12 · 14/10/2024 08:00

Only fairly recently has skiiing become something that a more average family would consider or could afford.
If you don't have family who've been and know the etiquette it can be daunting
If you have one holiday a year you might prefer guaranteed sun in the summer.
When I was at school the ski trip was for a handful of well off families.
My daughter and son went with school and it cost an arm and a leg. Definitely a considered extra.
I didn't learn as a child, I don't feel like I can learn now and would be out of my comfort zone.
Etc etc, it's really worrying when people don't grasp why some things that are exclusive even for some families who might have the money to go once.